Please or to access all these features

Education

Join the discussion on our Education forum.

How can I help my Year 10 daughter engage with homework / revision

77 replies

Divebar2021 · 20/09/2026 22:11

Gosh I don’t even know how to describe this. My DD14 is at a pretty academic girls school - it’s non selective but punches above its weight as far as exam success goes. MyDD was always middle of the bunch at primary school and although settled well at this school has never really shone academically. Her teachers all seem to like her but her results are average to below average. She had a phase of school refusal and anxieties about school which they were responsive to and she sees someone from the pastoral team once a week to discuss her issues. ( things have been much better )
At the moment we are having battles to get her to do homework. She would rather lie around on her phone so as we are now in year 10 I have become more directive. She has a composition to write for English and I’m at a loss to know how to move her forward from her “stuck” position of “ i don’t know what to write”. She was supposed to have done a plan and she has a broad idea of a story but no actually clue what happens. I told her to get on and she spent 40 minutes doing hair and make up. Gave her a bit of a talking to and left her to it for a hour or so and when I came back she’d done nothing. She doesn’t know what to write. I then sat with her for 20 minutes to brainstorm some ideas and did a kind of mind map of prompts but she wasn’t taking it seriously so I left her to it. I find it upsetting that she sees my attempts to help as a joke. After this she sat at her desk for 2 hours and produced 2 sentences. The mind map was in front of her… she knows how to string a sentence together and she’s very eloquent. I’ve told her the sentences can be rubbish but just write something and it can be edited. She goes into a spiral and becomes very passive. Both DH and I have frustration that she won’t be proactive and ask for help but will sit there. What the hell do I do? She’s not stupid but she’s failing English and maths. I’m definitely not a helicopter parent but I feel if I do not step up she is going to bomb her GCSEs. ( she had a tutor for maths last year and still failed. ) Am I missing something.

OP posts:
HelpfulHelena · 21/09/2026 07:38

My dd is in y11 at a similar school. She finds it extremely hard to allow me to help her with schoolwork and so typically I don’t. I helped with one situation where dd got completely blocked in one subject and just couldn’t face tackling her home learning assignments for a few months.

You’ve done all the sensible things and she is still resisting. Have you asked her how she feels about this subject compared to the rest? Is she anxious, frustrated, bored, overwhelmed, feeling incompetent, scared she’s fallen so far behind she can’t catch up? Does she WANT to get a passing mark in English and if yes, what is her plan?

Does her school have a lunchtime drop-in for English so she could go and talk to the teacher about how hard she’s finding it? Or maybe a homework club so she could stay behind after school for 30 mins and force herself to do three paragraphs

DeftGoldHedgehog · 21/09/2026 07:43

DD2 was like this with all her homework from Y7, after getting on with it quite well at primary school. Secondary school was just too much in general. She was diagnosed with ASD and ADHD at 13. She passed her Maths and English GCSEs at home with tuition and independent study. Tried college but it was too much like school. She is doing well working in a restaurant though and passed her driving test.

Divebar2021 · 21/09/2026 07:48

TeenToTwenties · 21/09/2026 07:36

OP any issues with

  • fine or gross motor skills
  • organisation
  • spelling
  • general problem solving (eg can't reach something - what does she do)
  • sitting still
  • focus in day to day life
  • motivation at weekends

Organisation is poor. She couldn’t put her papers into a folder yesterday. She just looked at them.

Spelling is not great ( vocabulary is good)

She can lie around for hours if she’s on her phone. She’s not restless.

Fine motor skills … maybe a bit clumsy. She does do activities… kickboxing , riding and swimming. She can draw if she puts her mind to it.

motivation quite low id say. She has started to go out more at weekends with her friends but has always been quite passive in organising things. She was kicked out of one friendship group for being too quiet but she has a nice group of friends now.

Motivation for school work is low. she tends to give in at the first hurdle - “ I can’t do this “ “ we haven’t been taught this”. Shes always running out of time in class.

OP posts:
TeenToTwenties · 21/09/2026 07:49

I'd get her seen by a private Ed Psych if you can afford it.

MaeshoweDragon · 21/09/2026 07:51

Next step is a soft version of tough love... a bit of eye opening to the future.

What does she want to do with her life. Does she understand that even this essay is one step further on, that education is non-negotiable, get on, get done...

Does she have any other non-negotiables in her life - from the simple brushing teeth, cleaning room, through laundry, kitchen chores, helping in the garden? How much exercise does she do, what do you do as a family for fun, for health?
Ours did homework because it was an expected aspect of life. Non-negotiable. Not doing homework didn't mean being nagged, being pushed and getting stressed- or even going to comfort entertainment on the phone, game system or telly, it meant helping the family by cleaning the oven, scrubbing the bath, walking the dog.

It worked in 2 ways, homework or hard work... homework got CHOSEN. And if hard work or walking the dog got chosen, it usually served to clear the mind.

Approached it by just saying "OK, you don't want to do homework, I don't want to clean the bath, it still has to be done, so come help..."

NullaEffugium · 21/09/2026 07:52

Divebar2021 · 21/09/2026 07:38

I guess I don’t know enough about ADHD to identify it. But definitely paralysis.

I have ADHD and a lot sounds similar. I was doodling, daydreaming, sometimes my mind would go blank and I’d be watching a sunbeam for hours that felt like a timelapse video of 2 mins.

Might want to pay for private assessment. Any tutor would need to be trained in ADHD as well.

Plus you sound a wonderful mum and have gone to great lengths to help in ways that would help a neurotypical child, all to no avail. Mind maps for example are no good to me or my DC (also ND). My dyslexic & autistic child struggles to write, so she learned by watching educational videos like GCSE bite size and doing oral work in place of written work.

Divebar2021 · 21/09/2026 07:53

unlikelychump · 21/09/2026 06:52

Hmmm. My daughter is similar. I am here hoping for the solution. I am wary of making it worse by pushing.

I definitely think I made it worse and I’m really sad I did that but I so want her to do ok. Not top marks just ok.

OP posts:
NullaEffugium · 21/09/2026 07:55

DeftGoldHedgehog · 21/09/2026 07:43

DD2 was like this with all her homework from Y7, after getting on with it quite well at primary school. Secondary school was just too much in general. She was diagnosed with ASD and ADHD at 13. She passed her Maths and English GCSEs at home with tuition and independent study. Tried college but it was too much like school. She is doing well working in a restaurant though and passed her driving test.

Yes, years 10-12 are when the wheels fall off a bright child that has ND. They can’t compensate for the ND learning difficulties with their intelligence any more.

Divebar2021 · 21/09/2026 07:55

NullaEffugium · 21/09/2026 07:52

I have ADHD and a lot sounds similar. I was doodling, daydreaming, sometimes my mind would go blank and I’d be watching a sunbeam for hours that felt like a timelapse video of 2 mins.

Might want to pay for private assessment. Any tutor would need to be trained in ADHD as well.

Plus you sound a wonderful mum and have gone to great lengths to help in ways that would help a neurotypical child, all to no avail. Mind maps for example are no good to me or my DC (also ND). My dyslexic & autistic child struggles to write, so she learned by watching educational videos like GCSE bite size and doing oral work in place of written work.

Edited

Thanks for your comment that’s very kind. A friend of mine is a psychiatrist ( obviously not a specialist in this area) but she has suggested ADHD. I think we might need to look at that now.

OP posts:
Rainallnight · 21/09/2026 08:03

You need an ADHD and Ed Psych assessment.

Supperlite · 21/09/2026 08:06

OP the phone needs to go. She can have it for one hour a day at weekends and half an hour of an evening after homework is done. Be RUTHLESS. Our children are the first generation to be less intelligent than their parents. Phones are just dopamine injectors and we wonder why children then can’t concentrate without a dopamine rush every ten seconds.

I am sorry to be direct but it sounds like she struggles with low self worth and getting royally pissed off wont help that. I think you need a two pronged approach;

Firstly - Make it FUN and by that I mean YOU get stuck in. Wear a colander for a hat, use a whisk as a wand, she can make a potion in a tea cosy, and narrate. Engage her imagination like when she was little. Make it up as you go along, “The witches gathered together in their… is it a house or a forest? Look around what do you see?! A forest! Are the trees tall or stubby? Quick let’s write it down! Then what happens, are they having a cuppa or brewing a potion? What’s it for?!”

The point of this is to engage her whimsy. Humans are naturally playful but Phones have caused children to become even more embarrassed and conscious of social cues which means they struggle to learn because they don’t engage with the trial and error stage of play. If you can show her that being playful and creative is fun for adults too, and it will help with her problem solving skills. Nothing is failure, it’s just a question that hasn’t been solved yet.

Secondly, help her analyse mark schemes so she understands what the question is asking for. I am dyslexic and I was failing at some subjects because I didn’t understand what the questions were asking me. I realised I needed to interpret the questions. E.g “Explain” means to show them how something works, “describe” means to talk about physical attributes, etc etc.
Help her to learn how to analyse data so she can ascertain the REAL question that is being asked of her.

Really praise the small steps, particularly around applying herself rather than the result. The academic result is secondary, what we really need is a young woman who is tenacious and will give any problem a good crack at solving because that is what will enable her to succeed in home and the work place as an adult.

Badbadbunny · 21/09/2026 08:07

“School” simply doesn’t work for some kids so she needs to find ways to get through it as best she can. It’s hard for some parents and even teachers to understand if they were successful and enjoyed their own school years. Coping strategies are needed rather than just whingeing at them to just do it.

I remember hating English as I had no imagination and couldn’t write creative writing or poems. No amount of telling me to do it worked - obviously it wouldn’t, it was like telling a fish to climb a tree. What DID work was a different teacher telling me to plan just one generic story, he told me how to do it, told me to choose my own subject and get back to him with the plan of the core basic plot, when I was ready, whether that was a day, week or month. With the pressure off, and freedom to choose my own subject, I did it that same evening and took the plan in the next day! Then he told me to pad out the plan - turn bullet points into sentences. Again, done that evening for the next day. Then he said put the sentences together into paragraphs and add more detail, ie the senses and descriptives. I went home and finished the story that night! I was so pleased with myself. The key had been no pressure, freedom to write about what I wanted to, etc. He then gave me the best advice ever, which I passed to my son - he told me how to use that same story line for virtually any story as in exams they’re usually very open ended questions for creative writing stories, ie a story about a city at night or something like it must end with “if I knew then what I know know I wouldn’t have done it” - he gave me some pointers as to how to use the introduction and conclusion to wrap around my own story so I could reuse the bare bones of it to answer virtually any question. My confidence went through the roof! Yes, it was a “fudge” but what worked was that it was a coping strategy. It gave me confidence in myself and it opened the floodgates to other writing, just knowing I had a back up plan, but also knowing how to tweak it rather than obsessing about the detail of the question asked and getting bogged down.

notquitethesame · 21/09/2026 08:09

My youngest was quite similar. He was very motivated for things that actually interested him though (school work didn't, other than one or 2 subjects). Does she have anything in her life that she is really motivated about, even if it's a sport/art/hair and make-up/travel etc?
At around that stage we had lots of sensible discussions with DS about career paths. It sounds like your DD's school will probably be pushing a very academic path. This is certainly what DS thought was probably expected from him and I can see that was not helpful for a child who didn't excel in or enjoy that. Once we had some discussions and identified a more practical career path that he was really interested in we found his general motivation improved. When we found a practical post 16 course that he was really keen to do it changed a lot of things. He also learned that if he passed GCSE English and Maths he would not have to ever study these again, whereas if he didn't he would need to retake them alongside the course he actually wanted to do. This gave him more of a push than anything I could have tried and was the reason that he (grudgingly) agreed to do a lot of work on maths and English with me.

We did have to break down the tasks at first, to sort of teach him how to approach a question etc. Almost starting as if he had been taught nothing about this and building from scratch, so a tutor may be helpful if you think this approach might help you.

Justbrieme · 21/09/2026 08:16

DS is autistic and he just cannot initiate work. At the moment my focus is on learning not results so we get him to the point of just past initiation and off he goes.

In your DDs case that is actually writing that first sentence.

I don’t know what we will do about exams though, that will be its own problem.

Your DD sounds like she has serious executive function issues.

Bringemout · 21/09/2026 08:22

Have you tried saying no phone and you sit at the kitchen table until it’s done? she was able to do her hair and make-up and doom-scroll when left to her own devices so she didn’t just switch off and do nothing.

Has there ever been any consequences for not doing work? What has happened in the past when she hasn’t wanted to complete what she’s supposed to? It sounds like she just waits for things to be done for her, if it’s always been like that then it’s a hard ship to turn around. Is she a perfectionist in other areas of life? Sometimes perfectionists don’t even want to attempt something incase they mess it up.

Honest opinion let her fail (for the moment) she’s basically trying to get you to do it for her and you can’t. She’s just started this term so theres time to pull this back but if she doesn’t turn work in it’s on her.

Divebar2021 · 21/09/2026 08:22

notquitethesame · 21/09/2026 08:09

My youngest was quite similar. He was very motivated for things that actually interested him though (school work didn't, other than one or 2 subjects). Does she have anything in her life that she is really motivated about, even if it's a sport/art/hair and make-up/travel etc?
At around that stage we had lots of sensible discussions with DS about career paths. It sounds like your DD's school will probably be pushing a very academic path. This is certainly what DS thought was probably expected from him and I can see that was not helpful for a child who didn't excel in or enjoy that. Once we had some discussions and identified a more practical career path that he was really interested in we found his general motivation improved. When we found a practical post 16 course that he was really keen to do it changed a lot of things. He also learned that if he passed GCSE English and Maths he would not have to ever study these again, whereas if he didn't he would need to retake them alongside the course he actually wanted to do. This gave him more of a push than anything I could have tried and was the reason that he (grudgingly) agreed to do a lot of work on maths and English with me.

We did have to break down the tasks at first, to sort of teach him how to approach a question etc. Almost starting as if he had been taught nothing about this and building from scratch, so a tutor may be helpful if you think this approach might help you.

She is very motivated by horses and horse care and volunteered in stables for 18 months and really grafted. She also volunteered at a gymnastics club for her DoE and really liked helping the little kids. They really loved her at the club and wanted to stay on. She likes hair and beauty and had a phase of being interested in special effects make up on herself and friends. We’re very happy for her to go down a vocational route so there’s no pressure coming from us to go to University or enter a profession. She doesn’t know yet what she wants to do but I know we’ve got time.

(She does have academic subjects that she’s been interested in. She was particularly interested in the holocaust which was a bit startling when she announced that. Overall she likes history and does ok at it. )

OP posts:
notquitethesame · 21/09/2026 09:59

Divebar2021 · 21/09/2026 08:22

She is very motivated by horses and horse care and volunteered in stables for 18 months and really grafted. She also volunteered at a gymnastics club for her DoE and really liked helping the little kids. They really loved her at the club and wanted to stay on. She likes hair and beauty and had a phase of being interested in special effects make up on herself and friends. We’re very happy for her to go down a vocational route so there’s no pressure coming from us to go to University or enter a profession. She doesn’t know yet what she wants to do but I know we’ve got time.

(She does have academic subjects that she’s been interested in. She was particularly interested in the holocaust which was a bit startling when she announced that. Overall she likes history and does ok at it. )

That sounds uncannily like DS (but with different vocational interests). For us it really helped when we took him to open days and did a lot of research on college courses/apprenticeships etc. There was a light bulb moment when one of the college tutors told him that a course he was interested in would be 3 days vocational training per week and students who don't have their GCSE maths and English have at least a day a week on those subjects whereas anyone who has passed them already has free time. After that he didn't like accepting help with maths and English but grudgingly accepted that it was better than having to face another year of it.

Mischance · 21/09/2026 10:07

Just leave her to it.

Honestly I know that sounds hard hearted, but what is your involvement achieving? ... two things: no progress on the homework and a worsening relationship with your DD.

Tell her: "You are nearly an adult now and I cannot keep trying to get you to work. You know I am here for you if you need any help or have any questions, but from now on I am just going to have to trust you to do what is needed, just as you trust me to do my work."

I can honestly say that my assortment of DDs were just left to get on with their homework and to take the consequences if it was not done. They knew I would help if asked.

XelaM · 21/09/2026 10:39

TeenToTwenties · 21/09/2026 07:04

How is she going to pass Eng Lang GCSE if she does this?

If you were on the Y11 thread of those kids who just finished their GCSEs you would know that some English teachers actually advise to use AI to help pre-prep stories etc.

GCSE exams are about working smart and being able to answer questions to the exact specification. It's not about becoming a Pulitzer prize winner.

Badbadbunny · 21/09/2026 10:55

XelaM · 21/09/2026 10:39

If you were on the Y11 thread of those kids who just finished their GCSEs you would know that some English teachers actually advise to use AI to help pre-prep stories etc.

GCSE exams are about working smart and being able to answer questions to the exact specification. It's not about becoming a Pulitzer prize winner.

Edited

Nail on the head there. GCSEs are stepping stones for further education/careers etc., so what matters most is to get the best grades possible, not to become an expert in the subjects taken. They can choose their favourite subjects to study in depth at A level, University or later in life for fun (rather than exam grades). If using AI helps motivate them to actually do something that's a win in my book. Especially when a parent moaning and threatening them with sanctions hasn't worked.

postitnot · 21/09/2026 18:03

My dd struggled with motivation all the way through school til suddenly it seemed to kick in around year 10. But maybe a bit later on when the teachers started putting pressure on?
She still hated maths so we'd do a 'quick 20 mins' every evening we'd set the timer and do as much as possible then stop. Seemed to help her stay motivated. She got a 6! I was so pleased and so was she.

independentfriend · 21/09/2026 18:46

I might try encouraging her to work for 15 mins and then to stop. By the time she's sitting for two hours and producing two sentences it's very unproductive and she's better stopping and doing something else.

Would she work better in companionable silence near you with you working on your own thing? - look up 'body doubling'. Don't introduce this as punishment for not having done any work.

It can be very hard to motivate yourself if you're thinking that no matter what you do it won't be good enough - I wonder if that kind of perfectionism is part of where she is.

Can you / her talk to her personal tutor or equivalent together re her feeling stupid?

MMUmum · 21/09/2026 18:55

Divebar2021 · 20/09/2026 22:11

Gosh I don’t even know how to describe this. My DD14 is at a pretty academic girls school - it’s non selective but punches above its weight as far as exam success goes. MyDD was always middle of the bunch at primary school and although settled well at this school has never really shone academically. Her teachers all seem to like her but her results are average to below average. She had a phase of school refusal and anxieties about school which they were responsive to and she sees someone from the pastoral team once a week to discuss her issues. ( things have been much better )
At the moment we are having battles to get her to do homework. She would rather lie around on her phone so as we are now in year 10 I have become more directive. She has a composition to write for English and I’m at a loss to know how to move her forward from her “stuck” position of “ i don’t know what to write”. She was supposed to have done a plan and she has a broad idea of a story but no actually clue what happens. I told her to get on and she spent 40 minutes doing hair and make up. Gave her a bit of a talking to and left her to it for a hour or so and when I came back she’d done nothing. She doesn’t know what to write. I then sat with her for 20 minutes to brainstorm some ideas and did a kind of mind map of prompts but she wasn’t taking it seriously so I left her to it. I find it upsetting that she sees my attempts to help as a joke. After this she sat at her desk for 2 hours and produced 2 sentences. The mind map was in front of her… she knows how to string a sentence together and she’s very eloquent. I’ve told her the sentences can be rubbish but just write something and it can be edited. She goes into a spiral and becomes very passive. Both DH and I have frustration that she won’t be proactive and ask for help but will sit there. What the hell do I do? She’s not stupid but she’s failing English and maths. I’m definitely not a helicopter parent but I feel if I do not step up she is going to bomb her GCSEs. ( she had a tutor for maths last year and still failed. ) Am I missing something.

Not what you want to hear Op, but I think you need to leave her to it and let her suffer the consequences. You cannot physically make her complete her assignments and you can't be in the exam room with her, better she learns a lesson about failing now rather than in her GCSE years

SchoolMum66 · 21/09/2026 19:05

XelaM · 21/09/2026 02:23

Can she not ask ChatGPT for ideas if she's completely stuck and then just rephrase those?

What???!!! That's exactly what she shouldn't do. The school is trying to teach her to think for herself, not have AI do it!

Badbadbunny · 21/09/2026 19:07

SchoolMum66 · 21/09/2026 19:05

What???!!! That's exactly what she shouldn't do. The school is trying to teach her to think for herself, not have AI do it!

AI isn't a perfect answer but neither is a child spending hours staring into space achieving nothing. AI may help kick start her to actually do something.