Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

Netanyahu must win today. Israel can’t afford a weak leader right now.

267 replies

IsraelNeedsBibi · 27/10/2026 01:27

It’s crazy how much pure hatred gets thrown at Netanyahu from every direction, more than any other current leader even Putin, but the idea that Israel must get rid of him to rebuild its standing in the international community is absurd IMO.

You can't run a country surrounded by hostile Arab states, who hope for your annihilation, by trying to be politically correct or try to please Western governments (to appease their own electorates) who have no idea what Israel has to deal with. They only understand strength, not weakness.

Say what you want about his politics but the guy has serious balls and does not back down.

No other leader in Israel, or any other world leader for that matter, has his level of experience when it comes to dealing with terrorism and national security. He’s been managing these existential threats for decades while other politicians just talk.

If you actually research the corruption charges it's obvious they are a politically motivated stitch-up by a left wing establishment that invented a bizarre legal theory about "media coverage" just to oust a leader they couldn't beat in elections.

It's exactly why he needs to stay in power and finish the job. He is the only one who refuses to fall for the fantasy of a 2 state solution, which is completely dead in the water after Oct 7th. Any backing down to the Palestinians now would be absolute suicide.

He literally built Israel's massive tech economy and proved with the Abraham Accords that strength gets results.

My genuine worry if he loses today is that whoever takes over will be way too soft and cave to international pressure on a Palestinian State and on Iran.

If Israel softens its stance, the pressure on Iran and Hamas drops completely and it leaves ordinary Iranian and Gazan people trapped with zero hope.

In a brutal neighborhood you need a strong, tested leader.

As Golda Meir said - "If we have to have a choice between being dead and pitied, and being alive with a bad image, we’d rather be alive and have the bad image."
.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
golosh · 09/11/2026 15:22

HopefulYankee · 08/11/2026 22:09

Anything Israel did after Oct 7 is acceptable? Why don’t we just kill them all. Fgs 🙄

Exactly. This would all be easier if all the Muslims could just move out of gaza, west bank, and bits of lebanon and jordan, kindly please thank you.

jupiter2000 · 09/11/2026 16:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

JaneJeffer · 09/11/2026 17:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Especially the ones who talk to themselves

Twiglets1 · 09/11/2026 17:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Bit of an offensive comment don't you think? How would you like it if I said "they are sick in the head these Palestinian supporters".

JaneJeffer · 09/11/2026 19:56

https://www.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1650261766748145&id=PlsOlive&seo_visit=1
Imagine thinking it’s acceptable to murder all these children

jupiter2000 · 09/11/2026 21:34

Twiglets1 · 09/11/2026 17:14

Bit of an offensive comment don't you think? How would you like it if I said "they are sick in the head these Palestinian supporters".

I was called all sorts on the thread re Ireland's footballers wearing armbands.

Twiglets1 · 09/11/2026 21:39

jupiter2000 · 09/11/2026 21:34

I was called all sorts on the thread re Ireland's footballers wearing armbands.

That doesn’t answer my question about it being an offensive comment.

golosh · 10/11/2026 01:08

Twiglets1 · 09/11/2026 17:14

Bit of an offensive comment don't you think? How would you like it if I said "they are sick in the head these Palestinian supporters".

That’s pretty tame in comparison to what I’ve heard people say about ‘pro pallys’.

The issue is the sheer numbers of people killed in this war. In comparison to October 7th, which was committed by terrorists in cold blood, Israel (a democratic state) has killed 70,000 people - thousands more are in the rubble and thousands more are dying from a lack of aid and medical supplies.

There are arrest warrants out. There are sufficient grounds to investigate genocide. Our, Jewish, foreign secretary has called it ethnic cleansing. That in itself should give people pause to think, is Israel really conducting itself in the best way?

It takes a LOT of mental gymnastics and dehumanisation of the Other to then say the killing of so many innocent individuals is acceptable or necessary or unavoidable or just disposable collateral.

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 06:22

golosh · 10/11/2026 01:08

That’s pretty tame in comparison to what I’ve heard people say about ‘pro pallys’.

The issue is the sheer numbers of people killed in this war. In comparison to October 7th, which was committed by terrorists in cold blood, Israel (a democratic state) has killed 70,000 people - thousands more are in the rubble and thousands more are dying from a lack of aid and medical supplies.

There are arrest warrants out. There are sufficient grounds to investigate genocide. Our, Jewish, foreign secretary has called it ethnic cleansing. That in itself should give people pause to think, is Israel really conducting itself in the best way?

It takes a LOT of mental gymnastics and dehumanisation of the Other to then say the killing of so many innocent individuals is acceptable or necessary or unavoidable or just disposable collateral.

It’s not ok to make offensive comments towards people that support Israel.

Disagree with them - yes. Say they are “sick in the head” - no.

We can all have our private thoughts about others, but to throw insults on MN achieves nothing.

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 06:32

@golosh @jupiter2000 if you feel people have insulted you on other threads, challenge them on those threads or report them. Don’t lump all pro Israel supporters into one big group as if we are identical in our views and all “sick in the head”.

That is what is “dehumanising of the Other” to quote golosh. It’s dangerous thinking to not only dehumanise Israelis but by association even those from other groups that dare to support Israel.

golosh · 10/11/2026 07:24

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 06:32

@golosh @jupiter2000 if you feel people have insulted you on other threads, challenge them on those threads or report them. Don’t lump all pro Israel supporters into one big group as if we are identical in our views and all “sick in the head”.

That is what is “dehumanising of the Other” to quote golosh. It’s dangerous thinking to not only dehumanise Israelis but by association even those from other groups that dare to support Israel.

If you read the thread, the reply was to someone who said all Israeli action since October 7th was acceptable. That is kind of sick if you think about what the Israeli government has done.

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 07:36

golosh · 10/11/2026 07:24

If you read the thread, the reply was to someone who said all Israeli action since October 7th was acceptable. That is kind of sick if you think about what the Israeli government has done.

That comment was challenged, which is fair enough.

What was not fair was the assumption that all Israel supporters are the same and all "sick in the head".

The poster was clearly upset talking about Israel women being kidnapped and held in tunnels, raped and murdered. Children and babies murdered. The fact that Gazan citizens danced and clapped on October 7.

Yet even that poster did not go so far as to say that anyone who supports Palestinians must be "sick in the head". It's a highly emotive issue with blame on both sides but there is really no need to throw childish insults around.

1dayatatime · 10/11/2026 08:21

golosh · 10/11/2026 01:08

That’s pretty tame in comparison to what I’ve heard people say about ‘pro pallys’.

The issue is the sheer numbers of people killed in this war. In comparison to October 7th, which was committed by terrorists in cold blood, Israel (a democratic state) has killed 70,000 people - thousands more are in the rubble and thousands more are dying from a lack of aid and medical supplies.

There are arrest warrants out. There are sufficient grounds to investigate genocide. Our, Jewish, foreign secretary has called it ethnic cleansing. That in itself should give people pause to think, is Israel really conducting itself in the best way?

It takes a LOT of mental gymnastics and dehumanisation of the Other to then say the killing of so many innocent individuals is acceptable or necessary or unavoidable or just disposable collateral.

I think you've identified the key issue of proportionality in war, the moral standpoint of one side killing more people than the other and actually how this ties in to left wing politics.

So starting with the politics, left wing politics since Marx focuses on the oppressors vs oppressed, rich vs poor, strong vs weak or in Marx's words bourgeoisie vs proletariat.

As Israel (by any measure) has killed more Gazans than the number killed on 7th October terrorist attack, through a left wing lens Israel would be the oppressor.

What I struggle with is that in other conflicts this logic doesn't seem to apply, which makes me think that other factors must be at play which makes the Israel / Hamas conflict different.

For example Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022 and since then Ukraine has killed some 500,000 Russians, yet no one criticises Ukraine for this.
The United States suffered 2,400 deaths at Pearl Harbour (comparable to 7th October deaths) yet went on to inflict 2.5 to 3 million Japanese deaths. But the US was certainly not criticised for this. And the Korean War had the highest civilian to military death ratio at 74%.

Because the West has avoided a major conflict involving significant civilian casualties for 80 years, this has created an illusion that wars can be fought surgically with minimal civilian casualties. Unfortunately this is certainly not the case in urban built up conflicts such as Gaza where combatants and civilians are living in such close proximity.

Newbutoldfather · 10/11/2026 08:31

@1dayatatime ,

I agree with some of what you post, but not all of it.

I think the numbers game by itself is not that informative. You are right, killing more people in a defensive war doesn’t make you morally wrong. There is no virtue in risking your own soldiers’ lives unnecessarily.

However, was this war really a defensive war beyond a certain point? And, did Israel minimise harm to civilians or merely pay lip service to doing so?

And, ultimately, what are Israel’s war aims? They did seem to change from destroying Hamas and making Israel safe, which I wholly concurred with, to reshaping the map of the Middle East through expansion into Gaza, settling the West Bank, and even into Lebanon. They have never stated that they aren’t trying to seize and permanently hold territory.

If they are ethnically cleansing, which seems hard to dispute, this is clearly wrong and they should be sanctioned for it.

If Israel wants to change (and I really hope Eisenkot will do so), they need to stop E1, gradually pull out of Gaza and Lebanon and at least open the way towards negotiations to create a two state solution.

golosh · 10/11/2026 10:23

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 07:36

That comment was challenged, which is fair enough.

What was not fair was the assumption that all Israel supporters are the same and all "sick in the head".

The poster was clearly upset talking about Israel women being kidnapped and held in tunnels, raped and murdered. Children and babies murdered. The fact that Gazan citizens danced and clapped on October 7.

Yet even that poster did not go so far as to say that anyone who supports Palestinians must be "sick in the head". It's a highly emotive issue with blame on both sides but there is really no need to throw childish insults around.

I think you’re clutching at straws here Twiglet sorry. Firstly you’re responding to the wrong person, I didn’t say all pro-Israelis are sick in the head. I am pro Israeli, in that I think it is important that Jews have a state to belong to, of course. I also bear witness to the senseless crimes the Israeli state has committed, and I don’t think we should excuse war crimes, or say they are ‘acceptable’ as the previous poster had said.

It is perfectly possible for the human brain to be appalled by the events of October 7, yet say ‘actually maybe killing innocents on a much larger scale is not going to help’.

Twiglets1 · 10/11/2026 12:40

golosh · 10/11/2026 10:23

I think you’re clutching at straws here Twiglet sorry. Firstly you’re responding to the wrong person, I didn’t say all pro-Israelis are sick in the head. I am pro Israeli, in that I think it is important that Jews have a state to belong to, of course. I also bear witness to the senseless crimes the Israeli state has committed, and I don’t think we should excuse war crimes, or say they are ‘acceptable’ as the previous poster had said.

It is perfectly possible for the human brain to be appalled by the events of October 7, yet say ‘actually maybe killing innocents on a much larger scale is not going to help’.

I’m responding to you because you decided to tag me and start a dialogue with me despite I was talking to @jupiter2000 not you.

golosh · 10/11/2026 13:43

1dayatatime · 10/11/2026 08:21

I think you've identified the key issue of proportionality in war, the moral standpoint of one side killing more people than the other and actually how this ties in to left wing politics.

So starting with the politics, left wing politics since Marx focuses on the oppressors vs oppressed, rich vs poor, strong vs weak or in Marx's words bourgeoisie vs proletariat.

As Israel (by any measure) has killed more Gazans than the number killed on 7th October terrorist attack, through a left wing lens Israel would be the oppressor.

What I struggle with is that in other conflicts this logic doesn't seem to apply, which makes me think that other factors must be at play which makes the Israel / Hamas conflict different.

For example Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022 and since then Ukraine has killed some 500,000 Russians, yet no one criticises Ukraine for this.
The United States suffered 2,400 deaths at Pearl Harbour (comparable to 7th October deaths) yet went on to inflict 2.5 to 3 million Japanese deaths. But the US was certainly not criticised for this. And the Korean War had the highest civilian to military death ratio at 74%.

Because the West has avoided a major conflict involving significant civilian casualties for 80 years, this has created an illusion that wars can be fought surgically with minimal civilian casualties. Unfortunately this is certainly not the case in urban built up conflicts such as Gaza where combatants and civilians are living in such close proximity.

I think you’ll find many many people have raised objection to what the Ukrainians are doing, just read the Guardian report on the leaked death data. And there are many who have deep generational trauma about what the US did after Pearl Harbor. I am as it happens in Japan right now, and I can guarantee you that.

’Collateral damage’ cannot explain:
Emptying 335 bullets at close range on to a six year old
Bombing aid workers
Using starvation as a method of warfare (ICC report)
Repeated attacks on hospitals, schools and universities
Children arriving in hospitals with direct gunshot wounds, which a UN commission reported as indicating direct targeting

These require answers about specific actions that cannot be provided by comparing death tolls with other wars.

Also, legal proportionality isn’t about comparing numbers of deaths, it’s about excessive civilian harm from an attack- excessive relative to the military advantage. Israels actions have been excessive in the legal sense.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread