Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

Thoughts on Israeli elections?

120 replies

mids2019 · 18/10/2026 07:08

https://arabcenterdc.org/resource/israels-election-and-eisenkots-arab-coalition-dilemma/

With a very complicated Islraeli election about to take place there is some possibility that a new Israeli prime minister may have to form sort of coalition with Arab parties to form a government.

It will be interesting to see how all those that have the Israeli government in the anti Israel community will react to a government which may include those of Arab hertiage. Will the pro Palsstinains continue to hate the Israeli government or simply he Jews in part of it?

Israel’s Election and Eisenkot’s Arab Coalition Dilemma

Israelis are set to head to the polls on October 27, 2026, for what some have touted as the most consequential election in the country’s history. Gadi Eisenkot, the former Israel Defense Forces (IDF) chief of staff and leader of the Yashar (Straight) P...

https://arabcenterdc.org/resource/israels-election-and-eisenkots-arab-coalition-dilemma/

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 10:45

mids2019 · 28/10/2026 10:31

It looks like forming a government will be very difficult with a lot of horse trading to get something like a government. I don't know about the Arab parties and it feels like there would be tensions within government if they did enter that would be too large to overcome. If it can to a budget would the Arab parties simply put in motions to defund the IDF or not support budget measures for defence brining down the government?

I predict a fragile government but I don't know if that's a good thing at all.

Honestly, I don’t know much about the election system in Israel beyond it’s confusing and parties sometimes seem to have to form coalitions with unlikely partners.

Looking at them has put me right off PR in the UK which I used to support the idea of.

mids2019 · 28/10/2026 10:54

Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 10:45

Honestly, I don’t know much about the election system in Israel beyond it’s confusing and parties sometimes seem to have to form coalitions with unlikely partners.

Looking at them has put me right off PR in the UK which I used to support the idea of.

Good point but at least Israel is democratic. It feels like there will splintering of the main blocks to get some sort of government and how strong that will be I don't know. One thing that fascinates me is that this general election was held during war time (though with ceasefire). How many other countries would have contemplated elections at such a time? I wonder if Netanyahu may become the strong man in the chaos, declare himself winner whatever citing national interest. I suspect Israelis want strength and security at the moment and this election has delivered neither.

OP posts:
Gealach · 28/10/2026 11:19

mids2019 · 28/10/2026 10:04

Someone with more knowledge on Israeli politics enlighten me on this....

Israel is a democracy and it looks like Palestinian parties may have to be approached for coalition to govern. Now that would mean in future Palestinian/Arab politicians would be passing laws on such things as defence spending, defence policy and relationships with the Palestinian territories. Can the pro Palestine mobs in future pin the 'genocide of Palestinians' on an Israeli government which is held together by err........Paelstinians?

I am sort of assuming even if Palestinians hold the balance of power they won't vote their own country out of existence?

hopefully the Israeli elections will show pro Palestinians that politics is complicated and black and white narratives aren't the way forward.

By “mob” do you mean the ICJ or various states that will likely recognise this in the future?

But yes of course: Even if this government is held together by Arab parties who have Israeli citizenship but also identify as Palestinian, then they, as part of the Israeli government will be responsible for what happens in Gaza.

Such an odd question. Do you think that countries where the Green Party make up part of the government shouldn’t be held responsible for environmental issues?

Do you just find the idea of PR confusing maybe?

ThreeDeafMice · 28/10/2026 11:20

Martymcfly24 · 28/10/2026 08:54

@ThreeDeafMice You want to change the definition of war crimes ?

You seem to be discussing a completely different war time scenario of frenzied decisions and combat fighting than the reality of what is happening on the ground which is planned airstrikes and targeted drones.

There is so much in your post that is wrong .

1.Israel has targeted civilians especially children https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2026/06/israel-continues-commit-genocide-and-other-atrocity-crimes-deliberately They have blamed Hamas for their strikes (15 children killed queing for supplements?) but we know that they have lied many times about this.

2.Torture is a regular feature https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2026/oct/22/israel-us-made-electroshock-weapons-palestinian-detainees-axon-taser shocked that you "can't get worked up about that"

3.Rape : is it systemic:? well when it was caught on camera in Sde Teiman by soldiers the charges were dropped (with the support of public opinion)

4.Destruction: was 95% of farmland booby trapped too?what was the justification for that being destroyed?

5.Churches have been targeted https://www.anglicannews.org/news/2025/07/christian-leaders-appeal-for-an-end-to-the-destruction-of-churches-and-the-indigenous-christian-presence-in-gaza-and-occupied-west-bank.aspx

6.Food: Fourth Geneva Convention: Article 55 explicitly states that an occupying power has the duty to ensure the food and medical supplies of the population in occupied territory, and Article 59 notes that this obligation is unconditional. Israel is an occupying power.

7.Weapons: https://lieber.westpoint.edu/white-phosphorus-and-international-law/ Israel has used white phosphorus.

You can change the definition any way you want but it won't erase the facts.

Edited

The planned air strikes are against targeted individuals, and specific infrastructure. What’s the problem with that? I am glad that war has moved on from carpet bombing from 30,000 feet. Are you not?

It’s easy to pick out reports of individual cases (I also read The Daily Antisemite Guardian), but none of that justifies the shrill ululation of “war crimes war crimes” from people who’ve never fought in a war or needed to be protected from armed groups, unless we’re going to understand war crimes merely as obvious and inevitable consequences of armed conflict between a terror organization and a superior national armed force staged in civilian areas.

There was no mlilltary way for Israel to make itself safer from Hamas without the kind of damage that we have seen. Military action to make itself safer from Hamas was ethical, moral, lawful and required. Ergo there cannot be an indictment for unlawfulness based on the kind of damage we have seen.

That’s not to say that every single officer and soldier acted entirely correctly. That’s a standard no army can rise to, the British army included.

I also don’t agree I’m conflating Palestinian civilians with Palestinian combatants. If Palestinian combatants fight in areas full of Palestinian civilians then the damage caused to civilians is the fault of the Palestinian fighters, not Israel’s.

If any of this is “against the rules” then the rules are wrong.

More pertinent to this thread, I agree with whoever wrote that Israel’s experiences with PR should inform the British public. If we adopt the kind of pure PR that Israel has we will hand the balance of power to fringe parties and end up with some very extreme policies.

its an irony that a less “representative” system like constituency democracy such as we have at the moment leads to stable majorities and more moderate policies which (I think) are acceptable to a wider swath of the public.

mids2019 · 28/10/2026 11:43

Gealach · 28/10/2026 11:19

By “mob” do you mean the ICJ or various states that will likely recognise this in the future?

But yes of course: Even if this government is held together by Arab parties who have Israeli citizenship but also identify as Palestinian, then they, as part of the Israeli government will be responsible for what happens in Gaza.

Such an odd question. Do you think that countries where the Green Party make up part of the government shouldn’t be held responsible for environmental issues?

Do you just find the idea of PR confusing maybe?

It is just strange that a country that purportedly staged a 'vehicle's decided not to remove the vote from those it which to persecute first? There weren't any Jews in the governance of the third Reich and if you look through history genocide regimes are brutal against every member of a race it wishes to erase. To me it just casts doubt on any genocidal motivation of Israel especially given I can't think of many other democracies accused of this.

OP posts:
1dayatatime · 28/10/2026 12:17

Martymcfly24 · 28/10/2026 08:54

@ThreeDeafMice You want to change the definition of war crimes ?

You seem to be discussing a completely different war time scenario of frenzied decisions and combat fighting than the reality of what is happening on the ground which is planned airstrikes and targeted drones.

There is so much in your post that is wrong .

1.Israel has targeted civilians especially children https://www.ohchr.org/en/press-releases/2026/06/israel-continues-commit-genocide-and-other-atrocity-crimes-deliberately They have blamed Hamas for their strikes (15 children killed queing for supplements?) but we know that they have lied many times about this.

2.Torture is a regular feature https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/2026/oct/22/israel-us-made-electroshock-weapons-palestinian-detainees-axon-taser shocked that you "can't get worked up about that"

3.Rape : is it systemic:? well when it was caught on camera in Sde Teiman by soldiers the charges were dropped (with the support of public opinion)

4.Destruction: was 95% of farmland booby trapped too?what was the justification for that being destroyed?

5.Churches have been targeted https://www.anglicannews.org/news/2025/07/christian-leaders-appeal-for-an-end-to-the-destruction-of-churches-and-the-indigenous-christian-presence-in-gaza-and-occupied-west-bank.aspx

6.Food: Fourth Geneva Convention: Article 55 explicitly states that an occupying power has the duty to ensure the food and medical supplies of the population in occupied territory, and Article 59 notes that this obligation is unconditional. Israel is an occupying power.

7.Weapons: https://lieber.westpoint.edu/white-phosphorus-and-international-law/ Israel has used white phosphorus.

You can change the definition any way you want but it won't erase the facts.

Edited

The use of white phosphorus is not illegal and is widely used by all militaries across the world as a marking and smoke screening munition.

Even the report you cited confirms this:
"The use of white phosphorus munitions, even in an urban environment, would not violate international law per se."

"Instead, because there is no weapons control treaty that prohibits their use altogether, any use of the munitions would have to be evaluated against the law of armed conflict’s conduct of hostilities rules. In this case, Israel has denied reports that the IDF used white phosphorus munitions in Gaza. However, even if they had been used, the lawfulness of their use would depend on the facts and surrounding circumstances, as is the case with all attacks."

Gealach · 28/10/2026 12:24

@mids2019 genocide doesn’t have to kill or try to kill every member of the group. That’s why the definition includes “in whole or in part”

I’m not sure why you are comparing this to the Holocaust. Clearly Palestinians in the West Bank, in Gaza and those who are Israeli citizens- don’t all get the same treatment by Israel. The question is: Is Israel committing genocide of Palestinians in Gaza?

ThreeDeafMice · 28/10/2026 12:42

Gealach · 28/10/2026 12:24

@mids2019 genocide doesn’t have to kill or try to kill every member of the group. That’s why the definition includes “in whole or in part”

I’m not sure why you are comparing this to the Holocaust. Clearly Palestinians in the West Bank, in Gaza and those who are Israeli citizens- don’t all get the same treatment by Israel. The question is: Is Israel committing genocide of Palestinians in Gaza?

I’m not sure why you are comparing this to the Holocaust.

You know perfectly well why.

It’s because of the joy that antisemites and their fellow travellers get when they feel able to accuse the Jewish state of something of which Jews were the archetype victim. How satisfying it must feel to bring those surviving Jews down a peg!

Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 12:50

Back to the Israel election and I think this article from AFP sums it up well:

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and rival Gadi Eisenkot each vowed on Wednesday to form a government after both came up short in the first election since the October 7, 2023 attack traumatised the country.

Voters turned out Tuesday in the highest numbers in decades to give their verdict on the divisive rule of Netanyahu, Israel's longest-serving prime minister who has pushed the country sharply to the right and unleashed a wave of wars in response to the Hamas attack.

Exit polls showed Eisenkot, a former military chief and political novice, and his opposition bloc neck and neck with Netanyahu's hard-right camp and both well away from the threshold for a majority in parliament.

The strongest gains came from Arab Israeli parties whose voters turned out in soaring numbers against Netanyahu, who has relentlessly warned that the minority would dilute the Jewish nationalist direction in which he has taken Israel.

Netanyahu, greeting cheering supporters at a Jerusalem convention centre after 3:00 am (0100 GMT), called for a "strong government of the right" and said that the "Jewish and Zionist majority must unite".

The 77-year-old prime minister was unusually brief and did not directly claim victory.

Instead, he listed leaders Israel has killed under his orders and again hinted that he was ready for a third bombing campaign against Iran alongside US President Donald Trump, his close ally.

"Israel has a unique opportunity with our partner President Trump to forever eliminate the existential threat of Iran," Netanyahu said.

Eisenkot, speaking to his own supporters in Tel Aviv, issued a veiled warning to Netanyahu, who observers say could use a war to push for a unity government.
"Netanyahu, don't you dare use Israel's security for your political needs," Eisenkot said.

Addressing Israel's security establishment, Eisenkot said that they served the state and not Netanyahu, calling him "a caretaker prime minister, without a mandate or the people’s trust".

Eisenkot shares many of Netanyahu's views on security and has backed the Gaza offensive following October 7 that has reduced the territory to rubble.

But Eisenkot has vowed to create a more inclusive atmosphere inside Israel and to rein in extremist settlers in the West Bank who have attacked Palestinians with virtual impunity.

After turnout of nearly 78 percent, the highest since 1999, Eisenkot said it would be a mistake to hold a second election and vowed to work "swiftly" to form a government.

"The public has voted for change," Eisenkot said. "A worthy leader would accept the people's vote of no confidence and announce his retirement from political life today."

The three mainstream Israeli television networks in exit polls gave the two blocs each around 51 seats well below the 61 needed to govern after initially giving an edge to the opposition.

Israeli Arab lists were projected to win 17 to 18 seats, a sharp gain, with some Israeli Arab communities reporting near-universal turnout driven by outrage to often derogatory rhetoric against them by Netanyahu's far-right allies.

Key Israeli Arab leader Mansour Abbas said he believed the right had "suffered a major loss" and was open to working with Eisenkot.

But Eisenkot said during the campaign he would not govern with Israeli Arab lawmakers -- and Netanyahu again suggested that a government relying on Arab votes would lack legitimacy.

Arab lawmakers could give Eisenkot support in parliamentary votes to maintain a minority government without joining a coalition. If not, Israel could head to new elections.

Itamar Ben Gvir, a far-right firebrand who according to exit polls did not gain as much as many expected, warned Netanyahu against another option -- a unity government with Eisenkot.

"It would be a terrible mistake," said Ben Gvir, who champions the expulsion of Palestinians and would likely be excluded from any unity government.

www.afp.com/en/netanyahu-and-rival-each-claim-mandate-after-tight-israel-election

Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 13:03

The third option mentioned in the above article - a unity government with Netanyahu and Eisenkot - has been categorically and very recently ruled out by Eisenkot.

Martymcfly24 · 28/10/2026 14:55

ThreeDeafMice · 28/10/2026 11:20

The planned air strikes are against targeted individuals, and specific infrastructure. What’s the problem with that? I am glad that war has moved on from carpet bombing from 30,000 feet. Are you not?

It’s easy to pick out reports of individual cases (I also read The Daily Antisemite Guardian), but none of that justifies the shrill ululation of “war crimes war crimes” from people who’ve never fought in a war or needed to be protected from armed groups, unless we’re going to understand war crimes merely as obvious and inevitable consequences of armed conflict between a terror organization and a superior national armed force staged in civilian areas.

There was no mlilltary way for Israel to make itself safer from Hamas without the kind of damage that we have seen. Military action to make itself safer from Hamas was ethical, moral, lawful and required. Ergo there cannot be an indictment for unlawfulness based on the kind of damage we have seen.

That’s not to say that every single officer and soldier acted entirely correctly. That’s a standard no army can rise to, the British army included.

I also don’t agree I’m conflating Palestinian civilians with Palestinian combatants. If Palestinian combatants fight in areas full of Palestinian civilians then the damage caused to civilians is the fault of the Palestinian fighters, not Israel’s.

If any of this is “against the rules” then the rules are wrong.

More pertinent to this thread, I agree with whoever wrote that Israel’s experiences with PR should inform the British public. If we adopt the kind of pure PR that Israel has we will hand the balance of power to fringe parties and end up with some very extreme policies.

its an irony that a less “representative” system like constituency democracy such as we have at the moment leads to stable majorities and more moderate policies which (I think) are acceptable to a wider swath of the public.

Edited

Thank you for your post. I wont derail further in case the thread police turn up.
It's interesting to see opinions like this . I didn't think people would think like that but obviously I'll acknowledge your real life combat experience.

I live in a country with PR, not a problem because there is a lack of fringe extremist parties. So the issue probably lies with Israeli views and not it's form of democracy.

ThreeDeafMice · 28/10/2026 15:12

Martymcfly24 · 28/10/2026 14:55

Thank you for your post. I wont derail further in case the thread police turn up.
It's interesting to see opinions like this . I didn't think people would think like that but obviously I'll acknowledge your real life combat experience.

I live in a country with PR, not a problem because there is a lack of fringe extremist parties. So the issue probably lies with Israeli views and not it's form of democracy.

So the issue probably lies with Israeli views

Israeli views are shaped by Israeli history and the reality of living in Israel. That's why I give Israeli views latitude and and am slow to judge them. There's nothing special about being Israeli that means you and I wouldn't feel and act the same as they do, if we grew up and lived there. Walk a mile in someone else's shoes, as the saying goes. "If you prick us, do we not bleed?" - that was someone else famous too, making a point as relevant today, as it was when it was written in 1596.

Moving on, my concern is that whatever country you live in (and I'm glad to hear about the lack of extremists there) Britain does have a significant number of fringe extremist parties, who until now have had little direct influence over government. I don't want to see that change.

OpheliaWasntMad · 28/10/2026 15:14

ThreeDeafMice · 28/10/2026 11:20

The planned air strikes are against targeted individuals, and specific infrastructure. What’s the problem with that? I am glad that war has moved on from carpet bombing from 30,000 feet. Are you not?

It’s easy to pick out reports of individual cases (I also read The Daily Antisemite Guardian), but none of that justifies the shrill ululation of “war crimes war crimes” from people who’ve never fought in a war or needed to be protected from armed groups, unless we’re going to understand war crimes merely as obvious and inevitable consequences of armed conflict between a terror organization and a superior national armed force staged in civilian areas.

There was no mlilltary way for Israel to make itself safer from Hamas without the kind of damage that we have seen. Military action to make itself safer from Hamas was ethical, moral, lawful and required. Ergo there cannot be an indictment for unlawfulness based on the kind of damage we have seen.

That’s not to say that every single officer and soldier acted entirely correctly. That’s a standard no army can rise to, the British army included.

I also don’t agree I’m conflating Palestinian civilians with Palestinian combatants. If Palestinian combatants fight in areas full of Palestinian civilians then the damage caused to civilians is the fault of the Palestinian fighters, not Israel’s.

If any of this is “against the rules” then the rules are wrong.

More pertinent to this thread, I agree with whoever wrote that Israel’s experiences with PR should inform the British public. If we adopt the kind of pure PR that Israel has we will hand the balance of power to fringe parties and end up with some very extreme policies.

its an irony that a less “representative” system like constituency democracy such as we have at the moment leads to stable majorities and more moderate policies which (I think) are acceptable to a wider swath of the public.

Edited

At what point will Israel feel they are militarily “safe from Hamas”?

Edited to add - there is a danger that Netanyahu is using this conflict for his own ends - eg comment above
"Netanyahu, don't you dare use Israel's security for your political needs," Eisenkot said.
So who decides when Israel is safe from Hamas?

I completely agree with your comment on PR and the irony that a less representative system is more like to bring stability and moderation in politics. PR favours the fringe extremists as you have said .

1dayatatime · 28/10/2026 15:38

Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 12:50

Back to the Israel election and I think this article from AFP sums it up well:

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and rival Gadi Eisenkot each vowed on Wednesday to form a government after both came up short in the first election since the October 7, 2023 attack traumatised the country.

Voters turned out Tuesday in the highest numbers in decades to give their verdict on the divisive rule of Netanyahu, Israel's longest-serving prime minister who has pushed the country sharply to the right and unleashed a wave of wars in response to the Hamas attack.

Exit polls showed Eisenkot, a former military chief and political novice, and his opposition bloc neck and neck with Netanyahu's hard-right camp and both well away from the threshold for a majority in parliament.

The strongest gains came from Arab Israeli parties whose voters turned out in soaring numbers against Netanyahu, who has relentlessly warned that the minority would dilute the Jewish nationalist direction in which he has taken Israel.

Netanyahu, greeting cheering supporters at a Jerusalem convention centre after 3:00 am (0100 GMT), called for a "strong government of the right" and said that the "Jewish and Zionist majority must unite".

The 77-year-old prime minister was unusually brief and did not directly claim victory.

Instead, he listed leaders Israel has killed under his orders and again hinted that he was ready for a third bombing campaign against Iran alongside US President Donald Trump, his close ally.

"Israel has a unique opportunity with our partner President Trump to forever eliminate the existential threat of Iran," Netanyahu said.

Eisenkot, speaking to his own supporters in Tel Aviv, issued a veiled warning to Netanyahu, who observers say could use a war to push for a unity government.
"Netanyahu, don't you dare use Israel's security for your political needs," Eisenkot said.

Addressing Israel's security establishment, Eisenkot said that they served the state and not Netanyahu, calling him "a caretaker prime minister, without a mandate or the people’s trust".

Eisenkot shares many of Netanyahu's views on security and has backed the Gaza offensive following October 7 that has reduced the territory to rubble.

But Eisenkot has vowed to create a more inclusive atmosphere inside Israel and to rein in extremist settlers in the West Bank who have attacked Palestinians with virtual impunity.

After turnout of nearly 78 percent, the highest since 1999, Eisenkot said it would be a mistake to hold a second election and vowed to work "swiftly" to form a government.

"The public has voted for change," Eisenkot said. "A worthy leader would accept the people's vote of no confidence and announce his retirement from political life today."

The three mainstream Israeli television networks in exit polls gave the two blocs each around 51 seats well below the 61 needed to govern after initially giving an edge to the opposition.

Israeli Arab lists were projected to win 17 to 18 seats, a sharp gain, with some Israeli Arab communities reporting near-universal turnout driven by outrage to often derogatory rhetoric against them by Netanyahu's far-right allies.

Key Israeli Arab leader Mansour Abbas said he believed the right had "suffered a major loss" and was open to working with Eisenkot.

But Eisenkot said during the campaign he would not govern with Israeli Arab lawmakers -- and Netanyahu again suggested that a government relying on Arab votes would lack legitimacy.

Arab lawmakers could give Eisenkot support in parliamentary votes to maintain a minority government without joining a coalition. If not, Israel could head to new elections.

Itamar Ben Gvir, a far-right firebrand who according to exit polls did not gain as much as many expected, warned Netanyahu against another option -- a unity government with Eisenkot.

"It would be a terrible mistake," said Ben Gvir, who champions the expulsion of Palestinians and would likely be excluded from any unity government.

www.afp.com/en/netanyahu-and-rival-each-claim-mandate-after-tight-israel-election

How can there be strong gains from the Arab Israeli voters when I thought Israel was supposed to be an "apartheid state"?

I can see how that might have been the case in South Africa when black citizens didn't have the vote but in Israel, Arab Israelis do have the vote.

FacetiousFace · 28/10/2026 15:45

1dayatatime · 28/10/2026 15:38

How can there be strong gains from the Arab Israeli voters when I thought Israel was supposed to be an "apartheid state"?

I can see how that might have been the case in South Africa when black citizens didn't have the vote but in Israel, Arab Israelis do have the vote.

https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/07/19/world-court-finds-israel-responsible-apartheid

The International Court of Justice in The Hague, Netherlands, August 27, 2018.

World Court Finds Israel Responsible for Apartheid

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) issued an advisory opinion on July 19, 2024, with significant consequences for human rights protections in Palestine under Israel’s 57-year occupation. The opinion stems from a December 2022 request by the Unite...

https://www.hrw.org/news/2024/07/19/world-court-finds-israel-responsible-apartheid

ScrollingLeaves · 28/10/2026 15:53

Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 10:45

Honestly, I don’t know much about the election system in Israel beyond it’s confusing and parties sometimes seem to have to form coalitions with unlikely partners.

Looking at them has put me right off PR in the UK which I used to support the idea of.

Looking at them has put me right off PR in the UK which I used to support the idea of

Snap.

OnePeppyFatball · 28/10/2026 15:59

1dayatatime · 28/10/2026 15:38

How can there be strong gains from the Arab Israeli voters when I thought Israel was supposed to be an "apartheid state"?

I can see how that might have been the case in South Africa when black citizens didn't have the vote but in Israel, Arab Israelis do have the vote.

Israeli settlers living illegally on occupied Palestinian land in the West Bank can vote while Palestinians living in the same territory under Israeli military rule do not have the right to vote.

  • More than 750,000 Israeli settlers living on occupied Palestinian land in the West Bank in violation of international law enjoy the full rights and privileges of Israeli citizenship, including the right to vote. Meanwhile, some three million Palestinians in the West Bank and two million in Gaza who have lived under brutal Israeli military rule since 1967 are denied the right to vote or have any say in the government that controls their lives. In total, about 30% of the people living under Israel’s control are Palestinians who cannot vote in Israeli elections.

Fact Sheet: Israeli Settlements & International Law

Israeli settlements on occupied Palestinian land violate international law and have been condemned by the UN, ICJ, and human rights organizations.

https://imeu.org/resources/key-issues/fact-sheet-israeli-settlements-international-law/215

Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 16:02

ScrollingLeaves · 28/10/2026 15:53

Looking at them has put me right off PR in the UK which I used to support the idea of

Snap.

We have our share of parties with extreme views in the UK too - shudder to think of parties like Restore or Your Party for example forming a coalition government with a mainstream party.

ThreeDeafMice · 28/10/2026 16:06

OpheliaWasntMad · 28/10/2026 15:14

At what point will Israel feel they are militarily “safe from Hamas”?

Edited to add - there is a danger that Netanyahu is using this conflict for his own ends - eg comment above
"Netanyahu, don't you dare use Israel's security for your political needs," Eisenkot said.
So who decides when Israel is safe from Hamas?

I completely agree with your comment on PR and the irony that a less representative system is more like to bring stability and moderation in politics. PR favours the fringe extremists as you have said .

Edited

At what point will Israel feel they are militarily “safe from Hamas”?

Look more carefully at my post that you quoted; I didn't say "safe from Hamas".

So who decides when Israel is safe from Hamas?

The Israeli electorate is the one whose opinion on that counts the most.

there is a danger that Netanyahu is using this conflict for his own ends - eg comment above

That can be understood two ways. One way I agree with, and one way I don't. His point would be that his "ends" are what he firmly believes to be best for his country, one that he's served his whole life, in the army, and in government. If he feels this conflict will lead to a better future for Israel then it's appropriate for him to "use" it. But I don't accept the charge that Netanyahu has as his goal the detriment of his country for his own benefit.

"Netanyahu, don't you dare use Israel's security for your political needs," Eisenkot said.

There - that's Eisenkot "using" Israel's security for his own political needs. Do you see what I mean? That's what politicians do. They "use" current affairs to argue for their own view of the right course of action. It's not inappropriate.

ThreeDeafMice · 28/10/2026 16:09

Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 16:02

We have our share of parties with extreme views in the UK too - shudder to think of parties like Restore or Your Party for example forming a coalition government with a mainstream party.

You can get around this by "engineering" your version of PR to have different rules. But one must then acknowledge that one is then abandoning the idea of having "every vote count", the purpose of PR.

If Britain is to have a system of plebiscite in whch everyone gets a vote, and in which governments change when a broad swath of the electorate wills it - yet still produces government of broad consensus that is able to block out extreme positions, then the one we have isn't that bad.

Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 16:13

ThreeDeafMice · 28/10/2026 16:09

You can get around this by "engineering" your version of PR to have different rules. But one must then acknowledge that one is then abandoning the idea of having "every vote count", the purpose of PR.

If Britain is to have a system of plebiscite in whch everyone gets a vote, and in which governments change when a broad swath of the electorate wills it - yet still produces government of broad consensus that is able to block out extreme positions, then the one we have isn't that bad.

Interesting ... I think in the end the system we currently have isn't that bad.

ThreeDeafMice · 28/10/2026 16:17

Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 16:13

Interesting ... I think in the end the system we currently have isn't that bad.

It's the "worst except for all the other forms that have been tried from time to time"?

Twiglets1 · 28/10/2026 16:18

ThreeDeafMice · 28/10/2026 16:17

It's the "worst except for all the other forms that have been tried from time to time"?

Yes exactly 😂

Twiglets1 · 29/10/2026 17:54

With 99% counted, Israel’s election leaves parliament deadlocked

With 99% of votes counted, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s bloc is set to win 53 seats in the Knesset, leaving it short of a parliamentary majority, according to figures released Thursday by Israel’s Central Elections Committee.

The opposition bloc led by Gadi Eisenkot is set to win 48 seats, while the two Arab parties are set to secure a combined 19 seats.

The latest figures show no change in the balance between the main parliamentary blocs. Netanyahu’s Likud remains the largest party with 27 seats, followed by Eisenkot’s Yashar with 21 and Beyachad with 12.

The Joint List is projected to win 11 seats, while the Arab-led Ra’am party and the Democrats are each projected to receive eight. United Torah Judaism, Yisrael Beiteinu and Otzma Yehudit are each on seven seats. Shas and the joint Religious Zionism-Zehut list are each projected to win six.

The committee stressed that the figures remain provisional. Official results are scheduled to be published on Wednesday, November 4, following an additional review of election integrity.

www.calcalistech.com/ctechnews/article/bkkzoebtgl

OnePeppyFatball · 29/10/2026 21:53

What a surprise. When you haven’t got the result you want, start accusing the Arab Israelis of cheating. Typical. From the BBC:

“The main Israeli opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot and Arab-led party leaders have denounced Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for alleging foreign interference following the election which saw his coalition lose its majority.
Netanyahu's Likud accused Israel's Arab-led parties of "stealing" the election. Home security agency Shin Bet is investigating whether they received illegal funding from Qatar and Turkey. ”
“The main Israeli opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot and Arab-led party leaders have denounced Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu for alleging foreign interference following the election which saw his coalition lose its majority.
Netanyahu's Likud accused Israel's Arab-led parties of "stealing" the election. Home security agency Shin Bet is investigating whether they received illegal funding from Qatar and Turkey. ”

Excerpt From
“Israeli opposition accuses Netanyahu of trying to 'delegitimise' election”
BBC News
https://apple.news/A5ck7f8ZbTxitkiFLkW-AOw
This material may be protected by copyright.

Israeli opposition accuses Netanyahu of trying to 'delegitimise' election — BBC News

The PM's Likud party has alleged foreign interference and said Arab-led parties "stole" the election after his coalition lost its majority.

https://apple.news/A5ck7f8ZbTxitkiFLkW-AOw