Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

Violence against women and girls in Gaza.....

353 replies

mids2019 · 23/09/2026 23:01

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

Even if you are in a war torn environment there is no excuse for alarming rates of sexual violence against women in Gaza. I think this highlights the fact that women suffer the most in Islamist governed territories like Gaza where women's rights have been historically removed. Hamas as a government aren't preventing this (weirdly enough) so what can be done. (Maybe a march?)

A file photo showing a Palestinian woman inspecting her damaged home after an Israeli strike on a nearby mosque, in Gaza City (29 July 2026)

Reports of violence against women in Gaza surge, UN agency finds

The UN Population Fund also says there has been a "severe escalation" in the number of early and forced marriages.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c94gm7dp40y0o

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 13:32

Nothing to see here it seems - no problems with rape victims forced to marry their rapists to avoid shame and scandal.

Early or child marriage involving girls as young as 12.

Nothing to say about the survey dairy debris posted - violence against women in Gaza conducted by the Women’s Affairs Center in 2001 that revealed that 46.7 percent of the 670 women interviewed reported that their husbands used “force and brutality” during sexual intercourse; 17.4 percent reported that their husbands beat them to have sex; and 35.9 percent said that their husbands threatened and intimidated them into submission."

It's all just an "average" problem apparently, a global issue that we don't need to condemn Palestinian men for. Though somehow - despite it being a global issue it's also still Israel's fault.

I'm disappointed but not surprised on page 12 of this thread that it confirms what I predicted on page 1 "Shocking details in that report that you won’t see widespread condemnation of. Even from those usually vocal about Gaza."

dairydebris · 14/11/2026 14:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

FacetiousFace · 14/11/2026 14:15

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 13:32

Nothing to see here it seems - no problems with rape victims forced to marry their rapists to avoid shame and scandal.

Early or child marriage involving girls as young as 12.

Nothing to say about the survey dairy debris posted - violence against women in Gaza conducted by the Women’s Affairs Center in 2001 that revealed that 46.7 percent of the 670 women interviewed reported that their husbands used “force and brutality” during sexual intercourse; 17.4 percent reported that their husbands beat them to have sex; and 35.9 percent said that their husbands threatened and intimidated them into submission."

It's all just an "average" problem apparently, a global issue that we don't need to condemn Palestinian men for. Though somehow - despite it being a global issue it's also still Israel's fault.

I'm disappointed but not surprised on page 12 of this thread that it confirms what I predicted on page 1 "Shocking details in that report that you won’t see widespread condemnation of. Even from those usually vocal about Gaza."

What do you suggest is done to tackle that while people are living in flooded tents, terrified of bombs, suffering from malnutrion and deprived of medical care? Honestly how do you even begin?

Surely you start at the beginning and tackle what you can, get those people homes, food, medical care, allow them jobs and dignity in their lives then you move on from there. All of these things we can do if Israel let's us.

What do you hope to achieve by condemning predatory Palestinian men? What would that do? It's always the same with pro Israel posters 'condemn, condemn, condemn' but no appetite to actually do anything meaningful that will actually effect change.

You know as well as anyone else that the biggest single thing that could be done to effect change is end the occupation and allow Palestinians to live in dignity. Yet for some reason want to talk about anything but the single biggest thing that would effect change. Why? Because you know that to effect change the West has to turn on Israel, sanctions have to happen, trade partnerships have to end and Israel has to suffer the consequences for what they have done until they learn to abide by the law. And pro Israel people don't want that. It's as simple as that. Israel before Palestinians at any cost.

FacetiousFace · 14/11/2026 14:23

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 13:32

Nothing to see here it seems - no problems with rape victims forced to marry their rapists to avoid shame and scandal.

Early or child marriage involving girls as young as 12.

Nothing to say about the survey dairy debris posted - violence against women in Gaza conducted by the Women’s Affairs Center in 2001 that revealed that 46.7 percent of the 670 women interviewed reported that their husbands used “force and brutality” during sexual intercourse; 17.4 percent reported that their husbands beat them to have sex; and 35.9 percent said that their husbands threatened and intimidated them into submission."

It's all just an "average" problem apparently, a global issue that we don't need to condemn Palestinian men for. Though somehow - despite it being a global issue it's also still Israel's fault.

I'm disappointed but not surprised on page 12 of this thread that it confirms what I predicted on page 1 "Shocking details in that report that you won’t see widespread condemnation of. Even from those usually vocal about Gaza."

If I remember right you were even on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine, correct me if I am wrong?! And now you want women and girls protected? So what is it you want to happen other than see people 'condemn' Palestinians? How do you see change actually occurring for these women and girls if aid agencies aren't even allowed proper entry?

It's a lot of hot air as usual designed to demonise Palestinians as uniquely awful when what is happening there is far from unique, in fact it is a recognised consequence of occupation of which Palestinians have been living under for almost 60 years.

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 14:40

FacetiousFace · 14/11/2026 14:23

If I remember right you were even on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine, correct me if I am wrong?! And now you want women and girls protected? So what is it you want to happen other than see people 'condemn' Palestinians? How do you see change actually occurring for these women and girls if aid agencies aren't even allowed proper entry?

It's a lot of hot air as usual designed to demonise Palestinians as uniquely awful when what is happening there is far from unique, in fact it is a recognised consequence of occupation of which Palestinians have been living under for almost 60 years.

You're wrong about that.

Emilesgran · 14/11/2026 15:00

FacetiousFace · 14/11/2026 14:23

If I remember right you were even on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine, correct me if I am wrong?! And now you want women and girls protected? So what is it you want to happen other than see people 'condemn' Palestinians? How do you see change actually occurring for these women and girls if aid agencies aren't even allowed proper entry?

It's a lot of hot air as usual designed to demonise Palestinians as uniquely awful when what is happening there is far from unique, in fact it is a recognised consequence of occupation of which Palestinians have been living under for almost 60 years.

there is far from unique, in fact it is a recognised consequence of occupation of which Palestinians have been living under for almost 60 years

So it's just "par for the course" level violence, but also Israel's fault. How on earth does that work?
🤔

Squeezingwildoranges · 14/11/2026 15:07

@FacetiousFace, "It's a lot of hot air as usual designed to demonise Palestinians as uniquely awful when what is happening there is far from unique, in fact it is a recognised consequence of occupation of which Palestinians have been living under for almost 60 years."

I agree with you entirely. I do not believe for one minute this thread has anything to do with concern for Palestinian women and girls. Rather, as you said, it is an attempt to demonise Palestinian men, to paint them as amoral, uncivilised, savages. To the majority of people in the world, Israel's actions are indefensible so the tactic now is the best form of defence is attack.

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 15:17

Squeezingwildoranges · 14/11/2026 15:07

@FacetiousFace, "It's a lot of hot air as usual designed to demonise Palestinians as uniquely awful when what is happening there is far from unique, in fact it is a recognised consequence of occupation of which Palestinians have been living under for almost 60 years."

I agree with you entirely. I do not believe for one minute this thread has anything to do with concern for Palestinian women and girls. Rather, as you said, it is an attempt to demonise Palestinian men, to paint them as amoral, uncivilised, savages. To the majority of people in the world, Israel's actions are indefensible so the tactic now is the best form of defence is attack.

How is it an attempt to demonise Palestinian men when it is being openly discussed that Israel is also part of the problem re the occupation and then the war.

Why is it ok to criticise Israeli men when they deserve it but not Palestinian men when they deserve it? Both groups have a part to play in the violence that women and girls suffer in Gaza.

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 15:24

@FacetiousFace if you are going to accuse me of being "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine" then show some evidence. I believe you have me mixed up with someone else, or you are misinterpreting what I said. Show me an example rather than throw out a hostile statement without proof, and we will discuss. Otherwise, I call bullshit.

In fact, I have on several occasions criticised the Israel government from blocking humanitarian aid. My position is consistent that I have nothing but sympathy for innocent Palestinians caught between a rock and a hard place with Hamas and the Israel government.

Squeezingwildoranges · 14/11/2026 15:38

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 15:17

How is it an attempt to demonise Palestinian men when it is being openly discussed that Israel is also part of the problem re the occupation and then the war.

Why is it ok to criticise Israeli men when they deserve it but not Palestinian men when they deserve it? Both groups have a part to play in the violence that women and girls suffer in Gaza.

I absolutely agree that rapists are to blame for their actions. No question about that. The point is, without the dire humanitarian crisis and the lack of any form of law and order results in the rapists being emboldened.

FacetiousFace · 14/11/2026 15:45

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 15:24

@FacetiousFace if you are going to accuse me of being "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine" then show some evidence. I believe you have me mixed up with someone else, or you are misinterpreting what I said. Show me an example rather than throw out a hostile statement without proof, and we will discuss. Otherwise, I call bullshit.

In fact, I have on several occasions criticised the Israel government from blocking humanitarian aid. My position is consistent that I have nothing but sympathy for innocent Palestinians caught between a rock and a hard place with Hamas and the Israel government.

I said correct me if I am wrong. You did. I haven't said anything further on it.

If you want to use that as a reason not to discuss my very valid points about the reason people want anything but the immediate issues that can solved spoken about then go for it. I stand by what I said.

You know as well as anyone else that the biggest single thing that could be done to effect change is end the occupation and allow Palestinians to live in dignity. Yet for some reason want to talk about anything but the single biggest thing that would effect change. Why? Because you know that to effect change the West has to turn on Israel, sanctions have to happen, trade partnerships have to end and Israel has to suffer the consequences for what they have done until they learn to abide by the law. And pro Israel people don't want that. It's as simple as that. Israel before Palestinians at any cost.

FacetiousFace · 14/11/2026 15:52

Squeezingwildoranges · 14/11/2026 15:07

@FacetiousFace, "It's a lot of hot air as usual designed to demonise Palestinians as uniquely awful when what is happening there is far from unique, in fact it is a recognised consequence of occupation of which Palestinians have been living under for almost 60 years."

I agree with you entirely. I do not believe for one minute this thread has anything to do with concern for Palestinian women and girls. Rather, as you said, it is an attempt to demonise Palestinian men, to paint them as amoral, uncivilised, savages. To the majority of people in the world, Israel's actions are indefensible so the tactic now is the best form of defence is attack.

Precisely. We all know that preditary men take advantage of vulnerable women, that happens everywhere even in our western 'civilised' societies. If you want to reduce this then reduce the amount of vulnerable women. Let them have homes, let them have schools, universities, clean water, food, medical care, jobs, all of this can be done by the International community now if they actually cared about Palestinian women and girls.

Palestinian men are no more or no less preditary than any other man the difference is when women and girls are forced to live in extreme poverty in the flooded streets these preditary men have more opportunities to act on it.

Look at any conflict, any occupation and the same thing happens the world over. So end the conflict, end the occupation and give women and girls a chance.

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 16:11

FacetiousFace · 14/11/2026 15:45

I said correct me if I am wrong. You did. I haven't said anything further on it.

If you want to use that as a reason not to discuss my very valid points about the reason people want anything but the immediate issues that can solved spoken about then go for it. I stand by what I said.

You know as well as anyone else that the biggest single thing that could be done to effect change is end the occupation and allow Palestinians to live in dignity. Yet for some reason want to talk about anything but the single biggest thing that would effect change. Why? Because you know that to effect change the West has to turn on Israel, sanctions have to happen, trade partnerships have to end and Israel has to suffer the consequences for what they have done until they learn to abide by the law. And pro Israel people don't want that. It's as simple as that. Israel before Palestinians at any cost.

It was an extremely offensive comment. It's not ok to go around throwing horrible accusations at people and say "correct me if I'm wrong".

I don't want to engage with you any further. Or God knows what you would be accusing me of next. So please stop tagging me and I'll do the same.

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 16:33

Squeezingwildoranges · 14/11/2026 15:38

I absolutely agree that rapists are to blame for their actions. No question about that. The point is, without the dire humanitarian crisis and the lack of any form of law and order results in the rapists being emboldened.

You didn't answer the question: How is it an attempt to demonise Palestinian men when it is being openly discussed that Israel is also part of the problem re the occupation and then the war?

Both sides are being blamed so how is that attempting to demonise Palestinian men?

Squeezingwildoranges · 14/11/2026 17:24

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 16:33

You didn't answer the question: How is it an attempt to demonise Palestinian men when it is being openly discussed that Israel is also part of the problem re the occupation and then the war?

Both sides are being blamed so how is that attempting to demonise Palestinian men?

I'm not going to get into a cherry picking competition about who said what and where. The gist of your comments, to me, and I'd like to think a few other posters would agree, seem to minimize the fact that the societal breakdown in Gaza has resulted in a massive spike in GBV. Of course Palestinian rapists who are taking advantage of the chaos are absolutely vile but as I said, I feel you are minimizing the effect that the inhumane conditions has on the statistics in order to demonise Palestinian men in general. Perhaps that is not your intention but that is how it comes across.

climbintheback · 14/11/2026 17:29

There must be some decent men in Gaza to protect them? The ones that end up here are pretty dodgy!

FacetiousFace · 14/11/2026 17:41

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 16:11

It was an extremely offensive comment. It's not ok to go around throwing horrible accusations at people and say "correct me if I'm wrong".

I don't want to engage with you any further. Or God knows what you would be accusing me of next. So please stop tagging me and I'll do the same.

Haha, cool 😉 Like I said if you don't want to discuss the reasons people here want anything but the immediate issues that can solved spoken about then go for it. It's pretty clear why that is anyway.

I just hope that one day governments do get their arses in line and start sanctioning illegal occupiers all over the world, everyone including the women and girls that posters claim to care so very much about will be a lot safer for it.

FacetiousFace · 14/11/2026 17:47

Squeezingwildoranges · 14/11/2026 17:24

I'm not going to get into a cherry picking competition about who said what and where. The gist of your comments, to me, and I'd like to think a few other posters would agree, seem to minimize the fact that the societal breakdown in Gaza has resulted in a massive spike in GBV. Of course Palestinian rapists who are taking advantage of the chaos are absolutely vile but as I said, I feel you are minimizing the effect that the inhumane conditions has on the statistics in order to demonise Palestinian men in general. Perhaps that is not your intention but that is how it comes across.

Exactly. On a thread about gbv posters want to do everything but talk about what can be done to minimise it and you would have to wonder why? If someone had the answer to stopping predators then that would be fantastic, I think there would be a well deserved Nobel prize in their future.

Unfortunately there isnt a single place on earth free from predatory men, we can do things to help protect women from them though, like preventing societal breakdowns, preventing man made humanitarian catastrophes and not supporting countries who purposefully impose these conditions on others.

Twiglets1 · 14/11/2026 17:50

Squeezingwildoranges · 14/11/2026 17:24

I'm not going to get into a cherry picking competition about who said what and where. The gist of your comments, to me, and I'd like to think a few other posters would agree, seem to minimize the fact that the societal breakdown in Gaza has resulted in a massive spike in GBV. Of course Palestinian rapists who are taking advantage of the chaos are absolutely vile but as I said, I feel you are minimizing the effect that the inhumane conditions has on the statistics in order to demonise Palestinian men in general. Perhaps that is not your intention but that is how it comes across.

How am I minimising the effect that the living conditions have on the statistics?

I accept the analysis of the UN Special Rapporteur’s report on violence against women in 2005, which found 2 main reasons for the high Gender based violence level in Palestine.

The stress of living under occupation and “traditional patriarchal norms and values”.

That report doesn't minimise the stress of living under occupation and neither do I. That doesn't mean it's the only contributory factor though.

FacetiousFace · 14/11/2026 17:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Icanthinkformyselfthanks · 14/11/2026 19:26

@Squeezingwildoranges , why is this worse? Surely Arab and Isreali women are deserving of the same concern?

golosh · 15/11/2026 03:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Twiglets1 · 15/11/2026 07:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

This shows how my words were misrepresented to suggest that I was "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine."

The tiny detail was excluded that the only agencies I said I could understand* *Israel blocking are the ones who wouldn't comply with new rules requiring NGOS to provide basic staff information for security reasons.

Even Everexpanding referred to UNRWA being infiltrated by Hamas.

As I said on that thread, an unbiased outlook would understand why Israel wouldn't want to continue working with organisations that employ staff openly hostile to them. Grounds for rejection included:

Denying the existence of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state
Denying the Holocaust or the Hamas-led attacks on Israel on 7 October 2023
Supporting an armed struggle against Israel by an enemy state or terrorist organisation
Promoting "delegitimisation campaigns" against Israel
Calling for a boycott of Israel or committing to participate in one
Supporting the prosecution of Israeli security forces in foreign or international courts

I pointed out that all the organisations together who will be unable to operate in Gaza in 60 days only represent 1% of the aid currently coming into Gaza.

I made the point that it would be better if no organisations had to pull out but ultimately that is the choice they made by not providing the information required.

Oxfam’s policy lead for Israel and the Palestinian territories said that many of the 37 groups on the list had already been blocked for months from bringing supplies into Gaza anyway, due to security concerns.

Multiple people made personal attacks towards me, to the extent that that MN had to intervene, asking people to behave with civility towards each other, even if you disagree on the matter in hand. Usernames change but other things stay the same.

I can imagine how hard some people were looking to try to find a thread to discredit me when I've said over and over again that I support more humanitarian aid coming into Gaza and have criticised Israel whenever they have blocked it. Apart from this one time when I said I could understand why Israel would block the NGOs who wouldn't comply with the new rules, on security grounds. That thread doesn't prove that I'm "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine" because the NGOs affected didn't need to stop working in Gaza, they chose to.

Because they were not prepared to work with Israel to ensure no staff were employed who had done things like deny the Holocaust or the Hamas-led attacks on Israel on 7 October 2023. Again, my stance was that it would be better if no organisations had to pull out but ultimately that is the choice they made by not providing the information required.

FacetiousFace · 15/11/2026 08:12

Twiglets1 · 15/11/2026 07:39

This shows how my words were misrepresented to suggest that I was "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine."

The tiny detail was excluded that the only agencies I said I could understand* *Israel blocking are the ones who wouldn't comply with new rules requiring NGOS to provide basic staff information for security reasons.

Even Everexpanding referred to UNRWA being infiltrated by Hamas.

As I said on that thread, an unbiased outlook would understand why Israel wouldn't want to continue working with organisations that employ staff openly hostile to them. Grounds for rejection included:

Denying the existence of Israel as a Jewish and democratic state
Denying the Holocaust or the Hamas-led attacks on Israel on 7 October 2023
Supporting an armed struggle against Israel by an enemy state or terrorist organisation
Promoting "delegitimisation campaigns" against Israel
Calling for a boycott of Israel or committing to participate in one
Supporting the prosecution of Israeli security forces in foreign or international courts

I pointed out that all the organisations together who will be unable to operate in Gaza in 60 days only represent 1% of the aid currently coming into Gaza.

I made the point that it would be better if no organisations had to pull out but ultimately that is the choice they made by not providing the information required.

Oxfam’s policy lead for Israel and the Palestinian territories said that many of the 37 groups on the list had already been blocked for months from bringing supplies into Gaza anyway, due to security concerns.

Multiple people made personal attacks towards me, to the extent that that MN had to intervene, asking people to behave with civility towards each other, even if you disagree on the matter in hand. Usernames change but other things stay the same.

I can imagine how hard some people were looking to try to find a thread to discredit me when I've said over and over again that I support more humanitarian aid coming into Gaza and have criticised Israel whenever they have blocked it. Apart from this one time when I said I could understand why Israel would block the NGOs who wouldn't comply with the new rules, on security grounds. That thread doesn't prove that I'm "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine" because the NGOs affected didn't need to stop working in Gaza, they chose to.

Because they were not prepared to work with Israel to ensure no staff were employed who had done things like deny the Holocaust or the Hamas-led attacks on Israel on 7 October 2023. Again, my stance was that it would be better if no organisations had to pull out but ultimately that is the choice they made by not providing the information required.

That's a lot of words to say that you agree with Israel blocking aid agencies entering Gaza. It would be better if Israel didn't block them but hey ho if they do. I mean what choice do they have?

It wasn't hard to find btw because I remembered you defending it. Literally Twiglets1 aid agencies blocked into advanced search and there it was 2nd result and you quite literally told me to - if you are going to accuse me of being "on board with Israel blocking aid agencies from working in Palestine" then show some evidence.

I post a whole thread and am then accused of a personal attack and trying to discredit you? Did you want evidence or not because it seemed very much like you did. You say yourself I've said over and over again that I support more humanitarian aid coming into Gaza and have criticised Israel whenever they have blocked it. Apart from this one time when I said I could understand why Israel would block the NGOs who wouldn't comply with the new rules, on security grounds.

So you admit that 'this one time' you were actually 'understanding' of Israel blocking aid agencies from entering Gaza exactly what I said you did because I remembered your endless understanding on that thread. That's not a personal attack, that's not discrediting you, that not being uncivil. I didn't call you any names for your views, I havent made judgements on you for your views just simply repeated them back to you.

golosh · 15/11/2026 09:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread