Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

Is serving leftovers to new guest on Boxing Day OK?

43 replies

gingerbreadandlemonade · Yesterday 18:48

Self-explanatory title really but a bit more context - my parents split up a few years ago. Have so far managed (just) to be in the same room together at Christmas as long as a neutral ground (mine or my sister’s house). Dad now has a new girlfriend and my mother does not want to be in the same room as either of them.
to keep the peace, me and my sister will see each other on Christmas Eve with our respective children. Food = simple, probably buffet, probably sausages, whatever the kids want.
Xmas day, I’ll have mum, she will have dad and his GF, and then Boxing Day we’ll swap. So everyone gets to see the people they want to.
We usually serve some sort of curry or other leftover dish on Boxing Day, but usually we have guests who ate the food the first time round.
is it rude to serve my dad and his girlfriend leftover turkey pie/ curry etc? When it will clearly be leftovers and the first time we’ve seen them at Christmas?
Further context - they have cooked for us before, lovely food (but tbf didn’t have half a turkey sitting in the fridge). I don’t know if I can face making another fancy meal but I don’t think the leftovers will go down well!

OP posts:
AuroraBloom · Yesterday 18:50

It will be fine. I wouldn't give it a second thought tbh.

Helga55 · Yesterday 18:52

If I were the parent with partner, I’d be quite happy with leftovers served up another way, curry/pie etc, as I’m usually still stuffed and wouldn’t want to face another Xmas meal! But I guess it depends if your parent & partner are the type to expect another full on meal with trimmings or if they’re quite easy going, have you asked if they’d be happy with a ‘twist’ on Xmas dinner? If, going forward you have one parent one year, your sister has the other and you swop each year, it might become a sort of tradition?

BillieWiper · Yesterday 18:53

Yes. That's what's on the menu on boxing day. Leftover turkey, roasties, Yorkshires, stuffing, veg and gravy. All usually served hot. Whether that's a food hygiene nightmare or not I've never had any deaths!

If the person doesn't like that I'd ask them to bring something. Or just eat cheese and crackers and nibbley things.

But I'd definitely have no intention of doing a separate cooked meal. Xmas dinner is pretty stressful and I do it every single year. I deserve the next couple of days off at least!

readingmakesmehappy · Yesterday 18:53

Some people prefer the leftovers anyway!

ExpensiveDecorations · Yesterday 18:54

Yes, if that’s what you usually do then that’s what’s on offer, they will have had a Christmas dinner the day before so leftovers are normal.

MyKindHiker · Yesterday 18:56

I'll put it a different way - if I went to someone's house on Boxing Day and it wasn't leftovers I'd be gutted. Leftovers in the form of turkey curry, turkey and ham pie, fried up roast potatoes etc etc is part of the festival tradition! I'd feel robbed if they kept all those yummy things for another time and gave me something new!

JustAMiddleAgedDirtBagBaby · Yesterday 18:56

Leftovers are the best bit of Christmas - partly because they're delicious, and partly because it means no-one has to cook after the marathon of Christmas dinner prep.

I'd be astonished (and a bit disappointed) if I went to someone's house on Boxing Day and wasn't fed leftovers and mince pies.

nocoolnamesleft · Yesterday 18:59

I, too, would be extremely disappointed in Boxing Day did not feature yummy leftovers.

TwistedOrange · Yesterday 18:59

It wouldn’t even occur to me it could be a problem, we’ve got my in laws Xmas day this year, and my family boxing day who will be having leftovers. Although my family are very easy going - but I’m sure reversed the in laws would be fine with it too.

I’d just do what you were planning and expect your guests to be grateful regardless!

Bandbros · Yesterday 19:01

Interesting. Usually I'd say of course everyone knows you have leftovers on Boxing Day, but in your situation I'm not sure I'd serve your Dad and new GF leftovers of a meal originally cooked for his Ex.

That said, leftovers to me is cold meat and bubble and squeak. I don't think a freshly cooked turkey curry or pie is leftovers, even if it was made fron leftover turkey iyswim.

mondaytosunday · Yesterday 19:06

It’s sounds perfect! They’ll have had the turkey at your sisters and if leftover dish is the norm for Boxing Day then it seems exactly what you should serve.

honeylulu · Yesterday 19:19

I'd be disappointed not to have some cold turkey on Boxing Day. If we have guests, that's what we serve - cold turkey, pigs in blankets and stuffing balls with warm baguettes, salad, mayonnaise/mustard etc. I'll do a hot soup as well (posh carton not home made) and one extra side dish, usually prawn cocktail and yule log for pudding. Never had a single complaint!

honeylulu · Yesterday 19:19

I'd be disappointed not to have some cold turkey on Boxing Day. If we have guests, that's what we serve - cold turkey, pigs in blankets and stuffing balls with warm baguettes, salad, mayonnaise/mustard etc. I'll do a hot soup as well (posh carton not home made) and one extra side dish, usually prawn cocktail and yule log for pudding. Never had a single complaint!

Favouritefruits · Yesterday 19:22

I think that’s absolutely fine, nobody wants Christmas dinner twice in a row! What’s your sister making? I’d be tempted to make the same dish

HmmmIAmPondering · Yesterday 19:36

Yum, Boxing Day leftovers are the best. I make a leftovers pie. Mushroom sauce: white sauce with a little nutmeg, sauted mushrooms with thyme and a little garlic, and add chopped turkey, pigs in blankets and stuffing, with some ready rolled puff pasty on top. Served with fresh veg.
It's always a hit and doesn't feel like leftovers. Very easy too!

MyOtherCarIsASatsuma · Yesterday 19:43

Completely fine. You and your sister sound so lovely, you're really putting yourselves out to make this all work for your parents.

ExpensiveDecorations · Yesterday 19:48

I’m one of the rare ones that really doesn’t want leftovers on Boxing Day, I’d far rather have something completely different, but I wouldn’t mind at all if I was served them because it is what a lot of people do. Same as any other visit, you what you are given. It would be bonus points from me if you dished up a chilli or something instead though.

PressedThistle · Yesterday 19:52

Leftovers are fine, but why is the new girlfriend (how new?) involved with your family Christmas at all? Who would she normally be spending it with? It's probably too late now but I think it's really cheeky of your dad to bring her along and upset all the arrangements.

Westfacing · Yesterday 19:55

I love leftovers on Boxing Day but wouldn’t serve them to guests

Not quite right somehow

PamPamPamPambaconandPam · Yesterday 20:00

Anyone with any sense is going to know that there is a high likelihood of being served leftover turkey in one form or another when you go visiting on Boxing Day!

Dragonscaledaisy · Yesterday 20:04

ExpensiveDecorations · Yesterday 19:48

I’m one of the rare ones that really doesn’t want leftovers on Boxing Day, I’d far rather have something completely different, but I wouldn’t mind at all if I was served them because it is what a lot of people do. Same as any other visit, you what you are given. It would be bonus points from me if you dished up a chilli or something instead though.

I'm the same. I can't think of anything worse then Christmas day leftovers. I would always be polite and eat whatever I was offered as a guest though because I appreciate the effort my host has made.

Hatty65 · Yesterday 20:05

Absolutely. I always cook a ham on Christmas Eve and do a buffet, then a traditional Christmas Dinner on the Day itself.

Boxing Day is my day off. I usually shove a turkey leg into a pan with veg and make home made soup in the morning because everyone likes it, but apart from that it is cold ham, cold turkey and salad bits. Help yourself.

I would not cook for anyone on Boxing Day, and I certainly wouldn't do (or want) another whole roast dinner.

PurpleThistle7 · Yesterday 20:12

PressedThistle · Yesterday 19:52

Leftovers are fine, but why is the new girlfriend (how new?) involved with your family Christmas at all? Who would she normally be spending it with? It's probably too late now but I think it's really cheeky of your dad to bring her along and upset all the arrangements.

It sounds like it hasn’t been the easiest for a while now as she said they just about manage a day on neutral ground so I’m guessing there will be some level of relief to move on from that experiment.

I think that you and your sister sound really kind. Personally I think Boxing Day should be for nibbles and too much cheese at odd times of the day but your plans sound lovely.

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Yesterday 20:19

It’s fine as long as you have some unopened bits to pad it out and a fresh dessert. I think this is extremely normal.

Egilsay · Yesterday 20:27

I usually have family over on Boxing Day, and they absolutely get leftovers. I do generally add fresh and apparently (but not) fancy salads, there's usually a cheeseboard (more leftovers, fresh cucumber or grapes or whatever garnish) and a couple of new desserts (but only because I like baking). Nobody has complained so far, and truthfully, after I've entertained a houseful on Christmas Eve, and at least two family members on Christmas Day, any moaning would get very short shrift.

Swipe left for the next trending thread