Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

Is serving leftovers to new guest on Boxing Day OK?

43 replies

gingerbreadandlemonade · 16/11/2026 18:48

Self-explanatory title really but a bit more context - my parents split up a few years ago. Have so far managed (just) to be in the same room together at Christmas as long as a neutral ground (mine or my sister’s house). Dad now has a new girlfriend and my mother does not want to be in the same room as either of them.
to keep the peace, me and my sister will see each other on Christmas Eve with our respective children. Food = simple, probably buffet, probably sausages, whatever the kids want.
Xmas day, I’ll have mum, she will have dad and his GF, and then Boxing Day we’ll swap. So everyone gets to see the people they want to.
We usually serve some sort of curry or other leftover dish on Boxing Day, but usually we have guests who ate the food the first time round.
is it rude to serve my dad and his girlfriend leftover turkey pie/ curry etc? When it will clearly be leftovers and the first time we’ve seen them at Christmas?
Further context - they have cooked for us before, lovely food (but tbf didn’t have half a turkey sitting in the fridge). I don’t know if I can face making another fancy meal but I don’t think the leftovers will go down well!

OP posts:
optionsavailable · 16/11/2026 20:30

Unless your dad’s new partner is unusual then I think she will be fine with leftovers and be accustomed to similar. I imagine she’s just happy to be invited and will be more nervous about the new dynamic than critiquing the food. I’d just speak to your dad ahead and ask if she’s good with curry or would turkey sandwich and chips be better etc. I’d say you’re overthinking it.
your mams being a bit awkward mind, she’ll tolerate your dad but a new woman that’s decades later she won’t be in a room with 🤦🏼‍♀️

Howwillaknow · 16/11/2026 20:31

Personally I would make the effort to make something fresh for guests. The thought of eating other people's leftovers turns my stomach unless it's close family in which your case it's your parents so maybe ok. Still personally I'd cook from fresh.

That aside I hope it all goes well. You and your sister are doing something very nice for your parents.

optionsavailable · 16/11/2026 20:33

HmmmIAmPondering · 16/11/2026 19:36

Yum, Boxing Day leftovers are the best. I make a leftovers pie. Mushroom sauce: white sauce with a little nutmeg, sauted mushrooms with thyme and a little garlic, and add chopped turkey, pigs in blankets and stuffing, with some ready rolled puff pasty on top. Served with fresh veg.
It's always a hit and doesn't feel like leftovers. Very easy too!

This sounds awful for me 😬

I’d check dads partner likes mushrooms before doing this.

nocoolnamesleft · 16/11/2026 20:35

optionsavailable · 16/11/2026 20:33

This sounds awful for me 😬

I’d check dads partner likes mushrooms before doing this.

Yeah. Mushrooms? What a way to wreck quality leftovers!

Uniqueusername3 · 16/11/2026 20:36

Yeah it'll be fine, it's not a half picked at turkey plonked on the table.

pinkdyno · 16/11/2026 20:37

Boxing Day is leftovers. Perfect. BUT you are way ahead in the curry and pie here 🫣😂we would be on cold meats, bubble and squeak, cheese, pate, biscuits, no cooking of effort style.

curry and pie are later in month, then the soup. And If you are like my MIl pie is New Year’s Day. Questionable hangover 😵 cure

optionsavailable · 16/11/2026 20:38

nocoolnamesleft · 16/11/2026 20:35

Yeah. Mushrooms? What a way to wreck quality leftovers!

Yeah I think people either love them or hate them and I’m in the the camp (and know a few others). I even hate the smell!

usually if I do mushrooms I split the dishes last minute, add the mushrooms and let them both cook seperate

slimy horrible stinky things 😂

WinterGhost · 16/11/2026 20:38

Sounds fine but I would get a new dessert in so that there’s a fancy new dessert for all of you to have together.

blueskiesandsun · 16/11/2026 20:53

If it was me I’d make a turkey, leek, ham and tarragon pie with store bought puff pastry. So still using leftovers and less faff but feels like a new meal taste wise. And serve with any style of potatoes and some green veg, either leftovers or not, or a mix. Followed by a nice fresh chilled dessert, maybe something lemony.

TheLastSilverSaint · 16/11/2026 21:18

If I was invited to someone’s house for lunch on Boxing Day, leftovers is exactly what I’d assume they were going to serve.

mindutopia · 16/11/2026 22:01

Totally fine, we are having the whole family on Boxing Day (we’re on our own for Christmas Day) and everyone will be having microwaved plates of leftovers plus some cheese, biscuits and chocolate. That’s the whole point of Boxing Day, surely.

AnnaQuayRules · Yesterday 01:10

Boxing Day lunch is ALWAYS leftovers. It's the best meal of Christmas I think.

YourJoyousDenimExpert · Yesterday 01:44

We have cold turkey and ham with jacket potatoes and salad and pickles on Boxing Day and I would serve this to a new set of guests. It’s Christmas after all!

Chickadee26 · Yesterday 02:13

I love a turkey, stuffing cranberry sandwich. Or turkey tetrazzini ❤I love using turkey leftovers for both of those. Mushrooms and all!

gingerbreadandlemonade · Yesterday 06:09

PressedThistle · 16/11/2026 19:52

Leftovers are fine, but why is the new girlfriend (how new?) involved with your family Christmas at all? Who would she normally be spending it with? It's probably too late now but I think it's really cheeky of your dad to bring her along and upset all the arrangements.

just over a year. And I 100% agree, I think it’s odd. Gets odder because she also has 2 children within a few hours drive - but apparently they’re both so besotted they need to spend it together. I’m keeping my eyes peeled over on AIBU for someone’s “my mums spending Xmas with some rando she’s just met and his family” type post…

OP posts:
speakout · Yesterday 06:44

I can see from this thread that leftovers are popular, I'm not a big fan,and would probably make something else for new guests.
I do eat leftover pigs in blankets next morning in a breakfast roll maybe some sliced meat in a sandwich, but I'm not a fan of leftover roast pootatoes or day old sprouts.
I would probably do a ham, some salad crusty bread, homemade soup from the freezer, new potatoes etc.
But that's just me, and maybe that would be disappointing to some.

ExpensiveDecorations · Yesterday 06:50

We cook to minimise leftovers because none of us want them so it would be something different here (probably chilli cooked the week before and frozen) but I totally accept that leftovers are normal and would eat then at someone else's house. I'd prefer them cooked into a pie or similar to sandwiches and grazing. But I really would just eat whatever's on offer.

MyOtherCarIsASatsuma · Yesterday 08:21

I think leftovers is a bit of a misnomer for having things like turkey and ham for a few days after Christmas. It's not scraps or pickings it's a beautifully tended joint or bird that has been cooked intentionally to serve over a few days. It may not be how absolutely everyone plans their meals round Christmas time but it's a very normal, mainstream choice.

We invited ILs down for Christmas dinner to save elderly MIL from cooking a turkey. She still bought a humongous one and cooked it on Christmas Eve!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread