Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

How do I play this...(Dd's Christmas wishlist)?

229 replies

hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · 15/11/2026 05:20

DD5's Christmas list for FC includes

  • a real unicorn
  • nuts that when you open them have fairies, sweets, magic, or whatever you want in them
  • an identical toy to a random one she found at the charity shop but in v specific different colours
  • water skis
  • wallpaper for her (very recently decorated) bedroom

There was something else on the same wavelength but I can't remember what it was!

None of the above is happening. I've bought her bits I think she'll like from me/the family. But FC usually brings the most coveted gift and I don't currently have any ideas of what that could/should be. . . Or how to steer her there even if I did have an idea. I mean, who can beat a real unicorn 🤣

What's my next move?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
TheJoyousBiscuit · 15/11/2026 18:32

Tell her that unicorns aren’t real obviously in a kinder way then that but if their younger tell her that FC can’t magic up special creators like afires and undixprns they will reveal themselves to her when she’s ready or something like that. My kids never asked for stuff like that. I wonder why….?

Tinaforshort · 15/11/2026 20:07

Eastmeetswest1 · 15/11/2026 07:44

If any help we let our gang write Xmas lists (and post them off) but explained that Santa then chose 1 gift each to bring as he had to fit all the boys and girls gifts on the sleigh.

The ride on Unicorn - definitely look on Vinted or Facebook Marketplace as a friend got what looked like a brand new one for £40. It looks amazing!

Good luck - one of ours wanted a real crocodile one year - Santa brought a remote controlled one! 😂

When my almost 17yo DD (birthday 28/12) was 3 or 4 all she wanted was a ‘real life crocodile’ - it was going to live in our bath apparently 😂and a pink skateboard. Every year since we have given her something crocodile related - I have found all sorts over the years and for me, now their getting older, a lovely memory.

Sorry not much help OP but I wish you luck in your quest.

DiplomaticImNot · 15/11/2026 22:06

hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · 15/11/2026 07:21

This is the toy. She'd like one that's pink with white stripes so they can be sisters and travel in a little pet carry bag she has together.

How's this? The tiger is probably the closest. I miss this magical age

How do I play this...(Dd's Christmas wishlist)?
How do I play this...(Dd's Christmas wishlist)?
How do I play this...(Dd's Christmas wishlist)?
DiplomaticImNot · 15/11/2026 22:15

Bit different from a unicorn, of course, but I always wanted a dog for Christmas.

From about 3 to 4 years old upwards, I used to ask for a real dog every year, and when asked what else as FC didn't bring dogs, I would add dog bed, dog lead, dog toy, dog food, etc. Used to drive my parents' nuts 😂

Finally got my 1st dog for Christmas, but in September (as December isn't a good month to get a pet) when I was 15, after 3 years of walking several other people's dogs in all weathers for no money. Had him for 14 years, and I've had dogs ever since.

Itsthewoluff · 15/11/2026 22:56

FC never delivers animals.

LucyLoo1972 · 15/11/2026 22:57

hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · 15/11/2026 06:39

We've always said he brings toys, and so far that's always been what's requested. This level of request is....new!

We have explained each time why whatever she says isn't appropriate or possible and she takes it well but when the next thing feels even more outlandish. For example we started with the unicorn, explained no live animals and especially not magic creatures, so then it was the wallpaper (but we just decorated your room!) okay how about water skis (erm, you can't swim) well in that case I'd like some nuts which have whatever you wish for inside 🤣🤯

She should go into writing childrens books I think!

I love the idea of sticks that make you dance on the water!

Itsthewoluff · 15/11/2026 23:03

It was a lot easier in the days of the Argos catalogue 😂

DiplomaticImNot · 15/11/2026 23:34

When my dd was about 7, she wanted to see a real fairy, and used to write them letters.

We got her some fairy dust that she had to sprinkle in Nan's garden to help see them, and the next day we'd secretly added a little 'magic door' that appeared overnight in the base of a tree in my mum's garden, with a little pathway to it, etc, with a little note from the fairies saying they'd lose their magic if she saw them, but because she believed so hard, they'd decided to let her see their front door and they would be happy to exchange notes instead which she could leave by their door.

It worked a treat, and I still have the notes she wrote.

DiplomaticImNot · 15/11/2026 23:42

They have some nice ideas on here for woodland fairy hunts, building a fairy door, etc, etc.

www.woodlandtrust.org.uk/blog/how-to-make-fairy-doors/

XelaM · Yesterday 00:05

DiplomaticImNot · 15/11/2026 23:34

When my dd was about 7, she wanted to see a real fairy, and used to write them letters.

We got her some fairy dust that she had to sprinkle in Nan's garden to help see them, and the next day we'd secretly added a little 'magic door' that appeared overnight in the base of a tree in my mum's garden, with a little pathway to it, etc, with a little note from the fairies saying they'd lose their magic if she saw them, but because she believed so hard, they'd decided to let her see their front door and they would be happy to exchange notes instead which she could leave by their door.

It worked a treat, and I still have the notes she wrote.

This is so adorable 😍 How did you build the door and path?

Blondeshavemorefun · Yesterday 00:22

Is there a home bargains near you and have a wander down the toy aisle

we have a gigantic unicorn that we won when miniblondes was 2 at an oldies xmas fete. She is now almost 10 and still loves it - it was bigger then her once

Similar to this

https://ebay.io/m/Pu3RkX

snugglyblanket · Yesterday 00:31

She's at the perfect age to explain that Santa has certain rules about what he can deliver, nothing live/dangerous/age inappropriate, etc and that a Christmas list is just a list of ideas that he'll use to pick something he thinks she'll like. Santa only brings one gift & fills stockings in our house, so not too much expectation, but he always brought something they'd love and linked stocking theme to an interest, eg frog socks, frog pin, little metal frog, frog bookmark for DS's frog stage. Perhaps a unicorn themed stocking?

The fairies in nuts thing reminded me of DD's obsession with Hatchimals eggs! Don't think they make the original ones any more but they still pop up unopened on eBay. Kids love any sort of blind bags/box/egg so I'm sure she'll love whatever you come up with!

Would she like something different for her room? Fairy lights perhaps? Bunting? My DD has some sparkly disco ball type strips that run down the edge of her door so she sees it when she opens the door.

On a bit of a tangent, I'm certain we used to have a Playmobil boat with water skis. If she can't ski herself, maybe she'd like to play it instead? I don't see skis but Argos have a Playmobil x Barbie wakeboarding boat set.

DiplomaticImNot · Yesterday 08:18

XelaM · Yesterday 00:05

This is so adorable 😍 How did you build the door and path?

Edited

We used little glass flat stones from my old aquarium, with some sprinkled glitter and bits of moss from my mum's gardening stash, and some tiny fake flowers/mushrooms, etc.

The door was one my mum had bought from a local garden centre that you could fix to a tree trunk.
This was about 16 years ago now, and there's much more choice nowadays.

Ours was similar to this with the little pathway, some mushrooms, etc, but I think the door was green with a stone surround.

How do I play this...(Dd's Christmas wishlist)?
Isitchristmasyettt · Yesterday 08:35

Ponycycle unicorn!!!

DD wanted a horse when she was younger - we got a Ponycycle. Second hand I think I paid about £40 and it was like new. You can get them in different sizes - DD was about 9 when I got hers. I’d recommend getting one with brakes on it - we had the old style one without brakes and let’s just say it was like watching Evil Knieval interesting when it was sloped 😂

How do I play this...(Dd's Christmas wishlist)?
Anneleesa · Yesterday 08:41

There’s an app called Wonderlens that will created an augmented reality and show a unicorn in your living room. That might tick the box.

Then get her a playmobil set with some fairies and unicorns, and a box set of the Magic Faraway Tree.

I would riff on the theme of magic, ignore the sweets and go for other magical things…

Get her a colour transforming mug and some hot chocolate powder and mini marshmallows.

You could also buy some Flying Wish Paper - it’s quite magical because you write your wish on the paper, set the corner alight and it flies up into the air and vanishes. Brilliant in a darkened kitchen at Christmas with a few candles or fairy lights on in the background.

Colour-changing bubble bath.

A magic candle you can’t blow out.

Oh and maybe one of those cardboard Christmas trees you stand in water and it grows crystals all over it. They are kind of magical.

I would also try to divert her into “woodland magic” - something like Sylvanian families where she can enter an imaginary world.

FancyBiscuitsLevel · Yesterday 08:52

Actually @hangonwhilstioverthinkthis- this might be a test going on! When my DS wasn’t sure if Father Christmas was real, he asked for Lego sets that were discontinued, he’d seen them at a friends house and then said he knew we couldn’t get them but maybe father Christmas could. He also knew he didn’t get everything on his list so FC might bring something else etc. anyway, dh decided to massively over pay to get one of these discontinued sets from eBay (think paying £50 for a set that had been £10-15 new). DS was so shocked and excited on Christmas morning!

DS never told us he didn’t believe anymore, he’s the eldest so think played along for sibling, but this was I think his last hit of magic.

Long way of saying, try to make it work!

hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · Yesterday 09:26

FancyBiscuitsLevel · Yesterday 08:52

Actually @hangonwhilstioverthinkthis- this might be a test going on! When my DS wasn’t sure if Father Christmas was real, he asked for Lego sets that were discontinued, he’d seen them at a friends house and then said he knew we couldn’t get them but maybe father Christmas could. He also knew he didn’t get everything on his list so FC might bring something else etc. anyway, dh decided to massively over pay to get one of these discontinued sets from eBay (think paying £50 for a set that had been £10-15 new). DS was so shocked and excited on Christmas morning!

DS never told us he didn’t believe anymore, he’s the eldest so think played along for sibling, but this was I think his last hit of magic.

Long way of saying, try to make it work!

🤨 food for thought here!

I think we've had some great ideas from this thread. Feeling more confident now.

She also asked for Thing from the Addams family 🤣 and her brother found a roboalive zombie hand thing in Aldi which he's bought with his own pocket money 🥰 so at least these chats around the dinner table are sparking sibling love!

We tend to have chats at this point in the year and then the 'official' letter is written in time for the royal mail deadline, so have a few weeks to steer her in a more manageable direction yet. But feeling very prepped if these things stay firm I really like some of the ideas which encourage the magic without going back on the reasons we've already given for not having them 'for real life'.

Thanks you wonderful lot!

OP posts:
Thewonderfuldollypartonsbra · Yesterday 11:15

I remember when dd was about the same age and wanted either 'a baby sister or a bunny rabbit pet on a lead'

I wasn't having anymore babies but could I fuck find any rabbit,lead or not

Finally,as I was on the verge of giving up,asda came to the rescue (the rabbit on a lead had the same name as dd so that made ut even more special)

Overjoyed,I paid a silly amount of money for both toy and batteries,got it home,wrapped it up and waited for the big day

She unwrapped it and never played with the bloody thing-it went to the charity shop months later

I feel everyone's pain-i should have just got bloody pregnant and prayed for a girl

Periperinotsospicy · Yesterday 12:12

DD11 when she was 5 asked for similar things. Too much magic obviously in our house!

Fairies are real people and so you can't keep one as a pet. Real fairy magic is not just given to anyone! You have to be either a magical creature or lucky enough to meet one. And fairy magic isn't FCs to give away.

She did get a pets alive magical unicorn. She loved it. We did not. But we can't all get what we want!
Also glitter goes a long way. Maybe in a walnut shell?
And magic books. With spells. Although she might need to read for one of those.

XelaM · Yesterday 12:15

DiplomaticImNot · Yesterday 08:18

We used little glass flat stones from my old aquarium, with some sprinkled glitter and bits of moss from my mum's gardening stash, and some tiny fake flowers/mushrooms, etc.

The door was one my mum had bought from a local garden centre that you could fix to a tree trunk.
This was about 16 years ago now, and there's much more choice nowadays.

Ours was similar to this with the little pathway, some mushrooms, etc, but I think the door was green with a stone surround.

Thank you 😍 It's one of the most creative and adorable things I've read

Tulipsriver · Yesterday 13:27

I think I've actually created a foolproof system to prevent this scenario!

As Christmas approaches, the children can point out toys they might want in shops or adverts and I'll offer to take a photo. They also look through some catalogs for inspiration. Then, when it's time to make their list, I cut out toys they have said they'd like, along with photos of the things they've seen. Everything gets coded into star toys (most expensive), snowflake toys (medium) and rudolf toys (cheap bits). The elves deliver them a handy template list with room for however many star, snowflake, and rudolf toys. Then they choose from the photos and stick their choices down.

The elves do not give them pictures of live(or mythical) animals, or anything that is wildly impractical and we can't argue with them because they are the toy makers and know what's on offer this year 🤷‍♀️

Maybe the elves could deliver a letter explaining her current list doesn't meet regulations (unicorns would be very sad to be taken away from their family to live with humans) and ask her to do something similar?

Bigboldfont · Yesterday 14:41

she's 5. Tell her Santa brings toys, not wallpaper, not live animals, not dangerous things which waterskis would be for a 5 year old, and find something like a nut with a fairy doll, again, Santa doesn't bring live things, just toys.
or tell her Santa brings 1 toy and the rest is from relatives or mum and dad.

baftaagain · Yesterday 16:49

Bigboldfont · Yesterday 14:41

she's 5. Tell her Santa brings toys, not wallpaper, not live animals, not dangerous things which waterskis would be for a 5 year old, and find something like a nut with a fairy doll, again, Santa doesn't bring live things, just toys.
or tell her Santa brings 1 toy and the rest is from relatives or mum and dad.

Agree.

undergroundandoverground · Yesterday 18:37

If you look on somewhere like etsy lots of people make magical things in walnut shells! Little scenes, fairies, etc.

I'd get something like that as its small and unique.

I think its fab she doesnt have a long list of plastic tat she's hankering for! If you would like more realistic wants in future though, smyths toys do send catalogues in the post for that circling stuff in the toy catalogue feeling lol.

sandyrose · Yesterday 18:38

My daughter one put on her wish list that she wanted her brothers hea’d…to wear kind of like a hat! She also had something similar to a live unicorn on it. Years later we were laughing about the mad things on her list that year. She just shrugged and said she couldn’t think of anything she actually wanted so just put random stuff down.

She was really happy with everything she got - we usually get them things like craft kits (we like Sculpt’d), a hot water bottle, UNO, PJs, a oodie, and a soft toy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread