Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

How do I play this...(Dd's Christmas wishlist)?

229 replies

hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · 15/11/2026 05:20

DD5's Christmas list for FC includes

  • a real unicorn
  • nuts that when you open them have fairies, sweets, magic, or whatever you want in them
  • an identical toy to a random one she found at the charity shop but in v specific different colours
  • water skis
  • wallpaper for her (very recently decorated) bedroom

There was something else on the same wavelength but I can't remember what it was!

None of the above is happening. I've bought her bits I think she'll like from me/the family. But FC usually brings the most coveted gift and I don't currently have any ideas of what that could/should be. . . Or how to steer her there even if I did have an idea. I mean, who can beat a real unicorn 🤣

What's my next move?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
20
hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · 15/11/2026 08:52

BendyAndTired · 15/11/2026 08:43

How would any of those fit in a stocking?

Seriously, this is one of the reasons we have a few small gifts from Santa in a stocking; a book, some chocolate, a small novelty toy, Christmas socks, etc and all bigger presents are wrapped and from real people. Her wish list is so unrealistic because you’ve allowed her to think there’s no limit to what she can ask for.

It might be time to modify your Santa system and explain to her gently that it has to fit into certain criteria.

Can see how you might have got there but respectfully I disagree. In our house FC brings the stocking (which isn't huge) and one gift (which is a toy/something you arguably play with). So far the FC gifts have been:

  • a doll pram (age 3)
  • a walking talking doll (age 4)

She didn't write to the north pole till 3 so we've only had 2 Father Christmas presents so far. This year she's gone wild with possibilities! And I'm tempering her expectations, she's not expecting a unicorn anymore (for the reasons many people have said, though I wish I'd thought about poo on the sleigh, that was great!) was looking for ideas on how to steer her in a more reasonable direction, whilst keeping some magic. The responses here have been wonderfully helpful. I'm very grateful and glad I asked!

DS7 has previously received:

  • a remote control car (age 4)
  • invisible ink pens (age 6)
  • a scaletrix set (age 5)
  • a golf club set (age 3)

All of which I managed to get secondhand (other than the pens) and he was thrilled. They put two or three things on the list and he brings one, as well as the stocking.

But after the 5th Christmas he did say he would ask for all of father Christmas's magic and that was going to be all he put on his list so it would be the one he got 😅🤣....maybe theres something about the wild imaginations of 5 year olds!

OP posts:
TalcandSandMagic · 15/11/2026 08:53

When DD was a little older she asked for snow for Christmas or her (January) birthday. I made a box of white pom poms (don't melt) snow balls for under the tree and they come out every Christmas for an indoor snow ball fight.
It did snow on her birthday- once it had gone dark- cherry on the cake 😀.

DS's wish for dragons was sayisfied by some spectacular playmobil dragons (mostly from ebay)!

hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · 15/11/2026 08:54

TalcandSandMagic · 15/11/2026 08:53

When DD was a little older she asked for snow for Christmas or her (January) birthday. I made a box of white pom poms (don't melt) snow balls for under the tree and they come out every Christmas for an indoor snow ball fight.
It did snow on her birthday- once it had gone dark- cherry on the cake 😀.

DS's wish for dragons was sayisfied by some spectacular playmobil dragons (mostly from ebay)!

Omg that's so cute! I bet that's such a stand out memory and lovely tradition.

I might do it even though noone has asked for snow 🤣 annual snowball fight sounds super fun

OP posts:
Bushmillsbabe · 15/11/2026 08:55

hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · 15/11/2026 06:35

🤣 thanks!

@Bjorkdidit She is very imaginative indeed! Switched on too sadly, I think she'd recognise a horse dressed up in a snap.

@Gingerbreadseasoniscoming Have explained father Christmas brings toys not live creatures and also wouldn't bring 'sticks that help you dance on the water' (that would be the skis) to someone who can't yet swim properly. She said she'd keep thinking and that's when the nuts came out.

Oh boy!

@Zapx I think this might have to be the plan. We genuinely never take her anywhere near shops other than occasionally the charity shop so I guess she doesn't know what's actually in existence.

Oh I've remembered the other one...an Alexa! I bought her a cd player last year (we're quite a low tech household) but wants one she can talk to in her bedroom. Just not personally something I want in the house.

The Alexa dot is actually very child friendly. It doesn't allow then to play anything which isn't child appropriate, it shuts off at anytime you chose and tells them 'your parents want us to play tomorrow as it too late now'. We are pretty low tech too - our oldest (11) doesn't have a phone, no ipads, 1 household laptop for school work only. But the dot has been great for our 7 year old - tells her stories and plays songs.

EatingHealthy · 15/11/2026 08:56

hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · 15/11/2026 07:04

Never was a bit hyperbolic. Apologies.

I usually do the food shop whilst she's at school, so she rarely comes to a supermarket. When she does we have a peruse of the toys but she doesn't often ask for anything. Weekends we're usually out on walks, visiting playgrounds or if the weather is bad we visit family, do indoor activities (like swimming for example) or tuck up at home with Blue Planet or play board games.

Our local town centre is pretty small, doesn't have a toy shop or Argos or anything like that. It has a nice weekend market, lots of charity shops, a book shop, bakeries, a smattering of independent clothes places and a few 'posh' chain stores. We really rarely have reason go to town so I was guessing that's why she's not got much of an idea on what's on offer. I've never been the type to just walk around shops browsing so not something we really do. Can't even bring home the Argos catalogue these days like we used to back in the 90's 🤣

I picked up an Argos catalogue from my local Sainsbury's a couple of weeks ago.It doesn't contain everything they sell any more, it's specifically Christmas gift focused - and very toy focussed - so may be worth checking if they've got them if you have a Sainsbury's near by.

hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · 15/11/2026 08:56

Bushmillsbabe · 15/11/2026 08:55

The Alexa dot is actually very child friendly. It doesn't allow then to play anything which isn't child appropriate, it shuts off at anytime you chose and tells them 'your parents want us to play tomorrow as it too late now'. We are pretty low tech too - our oldest (11) doesn't have a phone, no ipads, 1 household laptop for school work only. But the dot has been great for our 7 year old - tells her stories and plays songs.

I didn't know that, thank you, will look into it.

I'd be sad the cd player plan didn't last though. Thought that would be a good one for the years...! Nostalgia clouding my judgement 🫢

OP posts:
PomPomChatton · 15/11/2026 08:57

randomname72 · 15/11/2026 07:44

I may be a little off beam but can you write a letter from the North Pole Elves and explain the problems FC is having about wild animals, fariea, extreme sports and wallpaper? For the beanie babies- say it is rare and most unusual unlike the more common spotted tiger but FC trying hard to source it. I’m sure chat gpt could write a very convincing sounding one and I am sure a 5 year old won’t detect AI. And ChatGpt could make it look “authentic”.

I was going to say the same. One year Santa had to write a letter to my DD to explain he didn't have the plans to make exactly what she wanted, so the elves made something he thought she'd love instead. The toy was forgotten about a few months later, but the letter from Santa was talked about for years!

User573359 · 15/11/2026 09:05

This is a brilliant list 😂. My eldest used to have similar request, quite an imagination. But I was very against her looking at catalogues so I suppose she didn't know what there was either. But what I did used to do is put videos on the TV of toys I think she'd like and I was happy to buy without her knowing I'd curated it and that did the trick! Or I would make a Pinterest board of toys for her to look at. She would certainly ask for them. If you don't want to open her world to ALL the tat available my advice is to do similar, and source and leave catalogues of things you wouldn't mind her knowing exist, Sylvanian, Lego and Playmobil used to do their own catalogues. Let her look at toy websites that you have pre approved, or make your own catalogue on Pinterest.

CurlewKate · 15/11/2026 09:07

Surely whoever wrote it down for her should have moderated her wishes? Talked it over with her?

PointsScore · 15/11/2026 09:07

@hangonwhilstioverthinkthis

I mean, who can beat a real unicorn

Not necessarily beat it, but as others have shared, Harry Potter threw up a few.

My DS asked Santa for a broom - but one that ‘ can really fly’. This was early December so far too late for witches brooms left over from Halloween.

This request followed a year where he asked for a crystal ball. Again, ‘one that really works, I want to see what happens next’…

Nevergoingthereagain · 15/11/2026 09:07

Hi there
I will be honest I haven’t read all the responses so this may have been suggested - I would go for the first one! I think a carefully crafted letter from FC explaining why Unicorns can’t be owned by people however they can be adopted (like endangered animals) and then a good old Google search to creat adoption papers etc and pics of her Unicorn - keep it going for as many years as you like - it will be a great story for when she grows up.
Good luck - sounds like a fabulous little girl

ITSSSSCHRISTMASSS · 15/11/2026 09:13

What about a unicorn wall sticker for her room? Or posters she can choose where to put them?

https://www.iconwallstickers.co.uk/pink-rainbow-unicorn-wall-sticker?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=Magento%20Top%20100%20Wall%20Stickers&utm_term=&utm_content=&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=22849095598&gbraid=0AAAAADhB0Y1xWHsYGPjMn4q0ZSFpP9kuA&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIkdzvus2JmAMVk4BQBh2c5zphEAQYAyABEgJzz_D_BwE#attr=2496997,212536,213463,213569,213703,214021

I can’t tell if the cat is a beanie boo or one of the similar brands, technically a tiger is a cat. You might have some luck in toy shops. Also charity shops are great, my DDs went through a beanie boo phase and loved scouring the charity shops for them.

Not exactly water sticks or walking on water but how about a trip to a festive ice skating rink?

Do you have any gift shops near you. We have these teeny tiny little fairy’s I picked up on holiday once from a gift shop in what ever town we were visiting. They would be perfect to hide in walnut shells.

My youngest DD has had a fairy garden for about 6 years, she’s loosing interest now. It started on a tiny bit of dirt in the garden then DH built some potting boxs and we turned them into a big fairy village, used coloured fish tank pebbles to build roads, lots of fairy garden accessories, fairies, mini mushrooms, houses. It looks more like a ghost town now though, but dd loved it for years.

SofiaAmes · 15/11/2026 09:14

You could get unicorn removable wall paper/decals like this

FluffMagnet · 15/11/2026 09:14

The elves make everything in their workshop, so no live animals or magic or anything that isn't a toy? Plus Father Christmas cannot afford to give everyone exactly what they want, a list is only a guide to give him an idea of the things you like.

jupiter2000 · 15/11/2026 09:15

I remember my dd wanting a flying unicorn when she was about 5. She ended up getting a magic toy one with a wand but it didn't fly and she wasn't happy 😆 5 years later she recently explained that a unicycle was what she had actually wanted that year. I said to her 'but that doesn't fly either' she said ' I know but that's what I wanted ' 🤣

TheEighthDwarf · 15/11/2026 09:17

Good luck on securing the account for next year’s John Lewis Christmas ad😀

MrMarkhamsFanClub · 15/11/2026 09:22

I once asked DH for a unicorn for mmy birthday - joking, obvs! as I couldn't think of anything at the time.
He called my bluff and bought me one of those unicorn eggs thst 'hatch' in water. There's loads on Amazon, might this help?

CannabisAlchemist · 15/11/2026 09:23

hangonwhilstioverthinkthis · 15/11/2026 07:04

Never was a bit hyperbolic. Apologies.

I usually do the food shop whilst she's at school, so she rarely comes to a supermarket. When she does we have a peruse of the toys but she doesn't often ask for anything. Weekends we're usually out on walks, visiting playgrounds or if the weather is bad we visit family, do indoor activities (like swimming for example) or tuck up at home with Blue Planet or play board games.

Our local town centre is pretty small, doesn't have a toy shop or Argos or anything like that. It has a nice weekend market, lots of charity shops, a book shop, bakeries, a smattering of independent clothes places and a few 'posh' chain stores. We really rarely have reason go to town so I was guessing that's why she's not got much of an idea on what's on offer. I've never been the type to just walk around shops browsing so not something we really do. Can't even bring home the Argos catalogue these days like we used to back in the 90's 🤣

@hangonwhilstioverthinkthis You know Argos have brought their physical catalogue back 🎉

BellaVida · 15/11/2026 09:24

What’s a fabulous list! Mine are all older now and I miss the magic of it all and the challenge of finding the wonderfully elusive things they’d put on theirs!!

One of nieces asked for a unicorn a couple of years ago and they got her a second hand ride on one similar to this- https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/278414698932?_ul=GB&campid=5339075985&mkcid=1&mkevt=1&mkrid=710-53481-19255-0&rb_itemId=278414698932&rb_pgeo=GB&toolid=10044&var=0&ff=11

You can get empty walnut shells on Etsy and fill them with little surprises, gems, sweets, little teddies etc or pre-filled ones like these/ https://www.waldorfshop.eu/en/p/surprise-nuts_4349200_19144?ReferrerID=15&srsltid=AYCX9vLes7z2T0CESAz-GIHbxTBGMSTQmwUPOrj4kPkUO3z6fL1gay_XRzQ

Instead of the waterskis maybe something like this? https://www.amazon.co.uk/PLAYMOBIL-70906-Starter-Scooter-Children/dp/B09JSHP49L/ref=asc_df_B09JSHP49L?mcid=81a55fd7353f32e5963b827d102a9196&tag=googshopuk-21&linkCode=df0&hvadid=697244016634&hvpos=&hvnetw=g&hvrand=10996062533841262237&hvpone=&hvptwo=&hvqmt=&hvdev=m&hvdvcmdl=&hvlocint=&hvlocphy=9196409&hvtargid=pla-1665117057532&psc=1&hvocijid=10996062533841262237-B09JSHP49L-&hvexpln=0&gad_source=1

For wallpaper, if you’re not happy to redecorate her own room so soon, you could get pads of craft paper from Hobbycraft or B&M, or some samples in B&Q , then she could decorate a room in a shoebox or bigger cardboard box- if you put it upside down and cut of one of the sides, it gives her 3 walls and a floor to decorate. Then buy a cheap toy wooden bedroom set- I think they had some in Aldi.

Surprise nuts | Waldorfshop

Surprise nuts 10 pieces filled with gems for the advent calendar and for birthdays. Buy gifts for kids now at Waldorfshop!

https://www.waldorfshop.eu/en/p/surprise-nuts_4349200_19144?ReferrerID=15&srsltid=AYCX9vLes7z2T0CESAz-GIHbxTBGMSTQmwUPOrj4kPkUO3z6fL1gay_XRzQ

Uniqueusername3 · 15/11/2026 09:25

I letter from FC saying he's not trying to get on mummies naughty list by bringing a huge mythical animal into her house/redecorating/getting her into dangerous sports without mums permission. Etc.

The toy, if you take a picture of it, Google search for ones for sale on eBay, vinted etc.

You could have him send the letter in advance asking her to choose a normal toy, or on Christmas day explaining that he chose something he thought she'd like.

We actually don't do Santa lists, we just buy presents.

Fast800goingforit · 15/11/2026 09:27

This reminds me of when a family member wanted a wand like a Harry Potter one, but one that worked. Would she enjoy Flower Fairy books and the like?

timoteigirl · 15/11/2026 09:29

I would get her a doll's house if she doesn't already have one and those items for the dolls so she can use her imagination to make unicorn live etc. and let her do the wallpaper etc.