Please or to access all these features

Christmas

From present ideas to party food, find all your Christmas inspiration here.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Christmas possibly without extended family - Should I stay or should I go (away?)

9 replies

TheAquaViper · 08/10/2026 14:57

Hi,
My first post ever here, and I'm not sure that I'm posting on the right sub, but here goes!

Long story short: My mother has refused to see or speak to me (and by extension, my children - 11, 9) for two months following a disagreement that originated between my brother and I. (My brother and I are now fine and have been since shortly after the incident). To be honest, I've come to terms with her not having contact with me. It is sad, but probably for the best right now. The thing that makes me sad is that my children have now had no relationship with her for 2 months. During this time, my Mother-in-Law has passed away. It was not unexpected, as she had been very frail and in and out of hospital for many months. My mother had been aware of her condition - I'm not sure if she's aware that she had died, but it had been imminent. So now my children seem to have no grandmothers, which really breaks my heart.

A big concern of mine is that we are now approaching Christmas. Normally, my husband, children and I spend Christmas day itself at home, just the four of us. Then we spend one day at my in-laws and one day at my parents. The in-laws visit is usually a very quiet one, even before my MiL became unwell. They don't really do games, films, music, just a modest roast dinner with us and my husbands parents and present opening for the children. My parents' gathering is much more lively - I have 3 siblings (one who lives overseas) with their spouses and a niece and nephew. We play card or board games, video games and the dinner is much more of a special meal. My children really look forward to this gathering.

This year, I am facing the prospect that me and my little family will not be welcome to the full Christmas gathering on my side. Additionally, my husband's side of the family is now just his dad. I still want Christmas to be special for my children. I was considering the idea of going away for a short break somewhere (If it's not too late to book!) so we still have something fun to look forward to over Christmas. But then, that would leave my father-in-law on his own. We could take him, but he is about to turn 80 and I'm not sure what kind of trip would appease both the elderly and the active youngsters!

Do I hang about and hope that the relationship between my mother and I has healed by Christmas time? Do I book a trip away for just us but make sure we see FiL over Christmas? Do I continue trying to find somewhere to go that would work for both DC and FiL? Do I just accept that this Christmas will be a different one and roll with the punches?

Thank you for any advice or similar stories! Family alienation is new to me

OP posts:
LilyMumsnet · 08/10/2026 17:13

Hi OP

Welcome to Mumsnet! Flowers

We're just going to move your thread over to the Christmas topic. We think you're likely to get support and advice from other users who may be experiencing similar.

Laptopbop · 08/10/2026 17:21

Could you host a day for your family - everyone invited and your mother can turn in down if she wants.
Or have you friends you can visit and that is the ‘family fun’ fix.

Your kids will have a great time either way - school is full of festive fun in Dec so they won’t be missing out

Ponderingwindow · 08/10/2026 17:28

You can have a fun Christmas with just your small family if you don’t want the hassle of travel.

Whoops75 · 08/10/2026 17:30

I would definitely look at starting new traditions something ye can enjoy as your family gets older.
As it’s FIL first Christmas as a widow DH should see what other family members are doing and ye can book a time to see him and exchange gifts. How close do ye live to him, maybe the new tradition is ye stay in a hotel when ye visit or do a Panto the evening ye stay with him.

As for your family, would you ring your mother and tell her you what you’re thinking? If she refuses to back down invite your siblings to your house so the cousins can exchange gifts or go to a nice restaurant for a meal and exchange gifts there.

TheAquaViper · 08/10/2026 23:30

Thanks for the replies.

We do tend to do our own things as a small family as well, but obviously we will miss out on the big family christmas, which is kind of the point of christmas isn't it? We don't really have friends and not a huge house to host, but could arrange a festive meal out and extend an invite to my mum.

OP posts:
Elieza · 09/10/2026 08:55

is your brother your ally in this now the problem is resolved? would he help you sort this? if so..

i’d speak to my brother and both of you go to your mums house and say “how about we bury the hatchet, the argument us siblings had is over, so there’s no reason for us and the children to be all split up not speaking. Im sorry all of that happened can we get back to normal again now”.

amd see what happens.

Billybagpuss · 09/10/2026 09:11

Have you contacted her recently? What does she do when you try?

why don’t you have a quiet Christmas Day with fil then take the kids away for new year somewhere with fireworks etc we did centreparcs in Holland one year, much cheaper than the uk a great all you can eat buffet new year fireworks and morning dip in the lake.

TheSandgroper · 09/10/2026 10:46

I would go away and take FIL with you. Almost 80 is almost spring chicken to my DF - he has been coming away with us until recently and he’s in his 90’s. Just little holidays to a cabin somewhere but he gets fed, watered and etc at his elbow. What’s not to like?

Next year can take care of itself.

Stompythedinosaur · 09/10/2026 11:03

How hurtful!

Could you have a separate get together with siblings and cousins?

I don't think the big get together is the main point of Christmas. I think (staying at home or going away) that you can have a lovely time with your close family.

But, decide now, don't let your happiness be dependant on your mother's choices.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page