Yes, I do agree that people post those sorts of irritatingly irrelevant replies on all sorts of threads.
eg
OP: 'I've got relatives coming on Sunday and I want to do a roast. If you were cooking meat for 15 people, what meat would you buy?'
First reply: 'I'm vegan so I'd do cauliflower steaks.'
OP: 'Hubby and I were out shopping yesterday and went into a well-known chain of coffee shops. While we were having our coffees a man starting shouting racist abuse at us. Hubby told him to stop and then the man punched him in the face. AIBU to think we should go to the police?'
First reply: 'YABU for saying 'hubby.'
Second reply: 'Coffee shops are a waste of money, just make a coffee at home and take a flask out with you'
Third reply: 'I never go shopping with my husband lol he just moans all the time!!!'
Fourth reply: 'Is there a reason you haven't included the name of the coffee shop?'
I think the difference with the childfree board in particular is just the degree to which some people are so invested in defending their own choice to have kids, as if they either a) take someone else's decision to be childfree as a negative judgement on anyone who chooses to be a parent, or b) are absolutely desperate to change your mind because they somehow know better than you what you would enjoy.
OP: 'What's your reason for not having kids? Mine is just that I think it would really restrict my freedom. I like spontaneous travel, backpacking and being able to do whatever I want when I want and that wouldn't be easy with a baby. Also I'm incredibly squeamish and the thought of changing nappies and clearing up baby sick makes me nauseous.'
First reply: 'What nonsense, I have triplets and I just popped them in a sling and trekked round Nepal with them, now they're all 8 year olds and I can assure you I still lead a very full life, how dare you suggest that I don't?'
Second reply: 'Oooooh, no, OP, you're missing out!!! I thought I'd hate nappies and sick too but you'll feel differently when you have your own!!! Being covered in regurgitated milk while having scrummy cuddles with your gorgeous little one is honestly one of the best things about having a baby and now that my two are strapping young men who excel at rugby, I really miss the smell of their lovely baby shit'