Please or to access all these features

Carers

Caring for elderly relatives? Supercarers can help

An impossible situation, is there anyone out there that has been through similar, or even just has any input? :(

83 replies

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 15:01

Hi, I’m wondering if there’s anyone else out there in a similar situation. This is a long one!

My friend is a carer for her family member who has multiple genetic conditions that have gone on to cause agoraphobia, germaphobia & extreme anxiety too. They need daily care surrounding all aspects of life, so my friend & her mum provide it. They have tried extensively researching the conditions, got psychologists, therapy, but nothing made any difference. The mental issues have hugely increased in severity since COVID. This person hasn’t left the house, AT ALL, since lockdown began in 2020, and as their carers, my friend & her mum can’t really either. Shopping delivered, no dentist/hair/any other appointments ever etc. Her only freedom is a 1 week holiday per year (only when/if she can afford it), which she must isolate after. Her mum has no freedom at all.

I speak (online) to her daily, ask if I can do anything, have visited their street & stood social distancing so that we can still see each other to wish happy birthday/Christmas & drop off presents on the doorstep. I am not allowed in the house or near them, think of lockdown restrictions - that’s how they’re living, only even more restricting.

Now, we’ve dreamed about holidaying together, but I couldn’t afford to join her previously. Last year I’d finally saved enough, and we planned & booked one. We were both ecstatic - until this week, 3 months before we’re due to go, the family member became very distressed about her travelling ‘in flu season’, so she can’t go (the holiday is booked for January). It’s been booked since March, we’ve really looked forward to it as it took so long to plan, and it’d be the first time in 7 YEARS that we could properly spend together. (It was booked for Jan as flights to the location are only available in Winter, and the activities we’d like to do are too, late Jan being the best option to avoid Christmas crowds. We specifically chose somewhere remote and safe, and activities that are outdoors-y and distanced from people, and she was I going to isolate afterwards anyway.)

I’m devastated, but more importantly I’m concerned for her. I could still go, albeit alone, but is that right? She can’t do anything, she can’t have a day out, go to the cinema, go for a meal, because she has to isolate for 7 days if leaving the house, to keep the person’s mind at ease, and it’s obviously not worth it for single/few-day trips. The holiday is her only escape, and my only chance to spend time with her. She’s trying her best to be accommodating for them, but she’s losing her life in the process and as her friend I’m heartbroken seeing this.

She’s devoted to her family and is so selfless, but is now facing the fact that she will never be able to move out, have a partner, have kids, go places, literally anything. She can’t bare the thought of them ending up in care, as she’s heard ‘horror stories’ regarding severely disabled people’s treatment in such places. They also can’t have a paid carer in, as this creates massive stress over contamination etc - so they have no help. When her mum eventually passes, she will be left to cope alone.

I’m disabled myself, I get their situation and of course have no hatred or judgement towards the person.. The family have tried everything. Managing the current needs is all that can be done. There’s no cures/successful therapies for any of the conditions, but they’re not life threatening, so they will likely live a full (but awful) life, and as there’s only a ~10yr age difference, caring for them will likely take up the rest of my friend’s life. She began caring & living this restricted at 16, we’ll soon be 23.

I guess I’m just hoping she’s not alone, are there others out there in a similar situation? Is there anyone in my situation as the friend? Am I wrong to be upset about the holiday, & would I be wrong to go alone? I’m worried that with my own health issues this might be my only chance before it declines further. Is that selfish? It’s also not fully refundable so I’d lose hundreds if I were to cancel. I love her & her family so much, this is such a difficult situation and she has lost every friend but me. I’ve had someone in my family with agoraphobia so I get that part of it, but that didn’t restrict their carer from going out, this is truly ‘next level’.

Thank you for reading this far, any input is much appreciated ❤️

Further context regarding the disabilities:
The conditions affect the immune system, sight, gut, skin, sensory processing, mental capacity, amongst other stuff. They have long names that I cannot remember, and are all rare hence the lack of research/help.
Her mum has said this can’t go on forever, they will have to eventually find care, but my friend is terrified of letting this happen and is trading her life to make the family member’s easier, She is so strong and a beautiful human, but I am so concerned. This causes constant tension between the family as you could imagine, it’s such a tricky situation.

OP posts:
TemporarilyCantDoMyself · 25/10/2026 15:20

Oh my goodness I'm so sorry.

My immediate thought is that your friend, who you say is so selfless, needs to become selfish. She is literally sacrificing her life for another person. I can't work out from what you said whether this is all mental health conditions or there's also an element of immune conditions dictating her behaviour, but either way I really question the wisdom of her being so completely self-sacrificial. But I recognise that none of this is remotely easy. Ok I've read it again and it seems there certainly is a real immunological element.

Yes I think you should take the holiday. But I think your friend should too. If at all possible. No-one really should sacrifice their life in this way, with the possible exceptions of parents for their children. Without knowing the exact relationship it's hard to comment further @alp1002. You're a good friend to her.

JLou08 · 25/10/2026 15:29

I can't believe her own mother has let her live this way since 16. It's absolutely awful. Yes, you hear some horror stories about care but on the whole it's safe, it also opens doors to specialist support. Why does the disabled person's needs trump your friends. What a miserable life for her. I've a disabled child an another without additional needs, there is no way I would take away the opportunities for the non-disabled child by having them live like your friend is to meet the needs of the disabled.
You sound lovely and a lot more understanding than I am. I just find it awful that her mother is allowing this.

saveforthat · 25/10/2026 15:32

This is absolutely ridiculous. Surely the best thing would be for your friend to move out permanently.

TheGirlattheBack · 25/10/2026 15:39

Your poor friend. I also have an immune compromised relative in the household, it does not stop us going out and living our lives but we do self isolate at home if we catch something. Would that be an option to help ease the situation, could she self isolate at home for 2-3 days on her return from your holiday to see if anything is brewing?

Presumably the relative’s condition is made worse by infections? If not and this is an OCD thing then standard psychology advice is not to play along with the OCD routines, rituals and beliefs. Your friend neeeeeeeds a holiday.

Watchoutfortheslowaraf · 25/10/2026 15:44

Your friend and her mum need to really stop pandering so much. Self isolating for a week, no holidays anywhere or time the family member declare not acceptable? Never leaving the house? It’s absolutely insane that they are letting their family member dictate their lives so much. Caring is one thing but sacrificing everything in their lives is way too much.

Topseyt123 · 25/10/2026 15:46

This is utterly ludicrous and unacceptable.

Your friend and her mother need to stop some of this selflessness (doormats??) and start taking back control here. I would have lost patience with this bullshit years ago. I would just have no time for it at all.

Your friend should realise that she matters too, should stop putting up with this bollocks and go on the holiday. Relative should be told they cannot dictate the lives of others.

If your friend won't go on the holiday then you invite another family member or friend and still go. I'd make my irritation clear though.

Trallers · 25/10/2026 15:48

This family dynamic sounds incredibly toxic (although not necessarily intentionally, more like they've all fallen into these roles and then just continued them).

It's the sort of thing you'd do for a close family member going through an acute illness or treatment (e.g. chemo) but really isn't the answer for a lifetime condition.

I'd say your friend needs to start with some therapy of some sort to process her approach to the entire situation. I doubt a sudden ditching of the set-up would help her get her life on track as it sounds like there's some complicated mental gymnastics that have got her enmeshed with this in the first place.

As for the holiday -cant she do the 7 day isolation afterwards rather than cancel?

Brickiscool · 25/10/2026 15:49

If she doesn't isolate does it pose a genuine physical threat to this person or just a mental threat. I'm not saying a mental threat isn't bad. But suppose she just went out? What could this person actually do about it? As their mental health seems so bad, would it really worse if they didn't pander to it? And realistically if they had carers or went into care. They wouldn't have people isolating before seeing them

malefields · 25/10/2026 15:51

This is absurd. Is there any actual reason that your friend can’t have a normal, average holiday, or do you think it’s purely to appease that person’s anxieties and germophobia?

Because if it’s the latter… what they don’t know won’t hurt them. Just saying.

2chocolateoranges · 25/10/2026 15:54

As a parent I wouldn’t be allowing my 23 yr old to sacrifice their own life like this.

our lives are so short as it is and I would be supporting and encouraging my 23 year old to get out and about.

this person she helps care for needs real help as they are stunting other people from thriving.

EverlastingPeace · 25/10/2026 15:55

Would flu jabs be considered worthwhile for all parties?

Your friend and her mother are enabling the family member's behaviour and keeping them wrapped up in their own existence with not a single thought about anyone else's needs

BobbleBear · 25/10/2026 15:56

OMG, this is abusive.

Your friend is not being allowed to live a normal life and has been conditioned by her mum to accept this as her lot. That is so so wrong.

Her mother needs to step up and force the daughter to move out and start living a normal independent life.

I also think the mother needs to stop pandering to the other sibling as it’s all learnt behaviours and can be changed but only if she’s prepared to push through.

HeyUpDuckie · 25/10/2026 15:57

They need to stop enabling this behaviour. The sooner they start going out and the person sees they won't catch something the better. Stop playing into their hands.

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 16:00

JLou08 · 25/10/2026 15:29

I can't believe her own mother has let her live this way since 16. It's absolutely awful. Yes, you hear some horror stories about care but on the whole it's safe, it also opens doors to specialist support. Why does the disabled person's needs trump your friends. What a miserable life for her. I've a disabled child an another without additional needs, there is no way I would take away the opportunities for the non-disabled child by having them live like your friend is to meet the needs of the disabled.
You sound lovely and a lot more understanding than I am. I just find it awful that her mother is allowing this.

The person is her uncle, he was cared for by her grandma (his mum) previously, but she then passed leaving the care to my friend & her mum. Her aunt (sister of mum & disabled uncle) is also disabled and they care for her too, though she doesn’t have as extreme needs. Such an insane amount of responsibility. He used to go out (with help obviously) and could visit a few places, but the stress of lockdown completely ruined everything. I completely agree, I have mild support needs due to being autistic and often need mild physical help due to chronic health issues, which can put strain on my partner, but we talk regularly about it and his needs are placed equally to mine. Of course more extreme needs require more sacrifice but I’m glad that I’m not alone in thinking this is insane! :( Her mum quit her job to care for them full time, and my friend decided she would too, as we finished school as lockdown began. Neither thought it would stay this bad, as it never used to be before lockdown :(

OP posts:
alp1002 · 25/10/2026 16:09

TemporarilyCantDoMyself · 25/10/2026 15:20

Oh my goodness I'm so sorry.

My immediate thought is that your friend, who you say is so selfless, needs to become selfish. She is literally sacrificing her life for another person. I can't work out from what you said whether this is all mental health conditions or there's also an element of immune conditions dictating her behaviour, but either way I really question the wisdom of her being so completely self-sacrificial. But I recognise that none of this is remotely easy. Ok I've read it again and it seems there certainly is a real immunological element.

Yes I think you should take the holiday. But I think your friend should too. If at all possible. No-one really should sacrifice their life in this way, with the possible exceptions of parents for their children. Without knowing the exact relationship it's hard to comment further @alp1002. You're a good friend to her.

Thank you so much, the family member is her uncle, previously cared for by her grandma (mum of him & friend’s mum). During lockdown her grandma passed leaving the care to her & her mum, her mum quit her job to care full time, & my friend had just finished school so automatically decided to too. He is immunocompromised and I’m assuming the extreme anxiety has come from this, however there’s always been flus and viruses and it was never this extreme before lockdown. Her mum has lost all of her friends, and I’m the last remaining to my friend, truly awful for everyone. I’d wait a lifetime to spend time with her, I’m hoping she can be selfish for her own sake but if not I’ll be head for her always. I think I will still go, I would hate for her to have the guilt of me also missing out!

OP posts:
JanFebAndOnwards · 25/10/2026 16:12

What HCPs are involved with the patient? Do social services know about the situation??

It cannot be validated by any professional, surely. It’s virtually an adult safeguarding situation - ie for your friend and her mum!

What do they live on, are they all
claiming benefits?

carers UK might be a starting point.

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 16:15

TheGirlattheBack · 25/10/2026 15:39

Your poor friend. I also have an immune compromised relative in the household, it does not stop us going out and living our lives but we do self isolate at home if we catch something. Would that be an option to help ease the situation, could she self isolate at home for 2-3 days on her return from your holiday to see if anything is brewing?

Presumably the relative’s condition is made worse by infections? If not and this is an OCD thing then standard psychology advice is not to play along with the OCD routines, rituals and beliefs. Your friend neeeeeeeds a holiday.

Thank you, that was already the plan and what she usually does. Unfortunately she got ill on her holiday this year which didn’t show until the last day of her isolation, and I fear that’s increased the person’s anxiety.

I think it’s both, if they get ill they’re more likely to end up in hospital from smaller things (hence why COVID was so stressful), but because they’re also mentally disabled the stress of lockdown seems to have lead them to develop contamination OCD out of genuine fear. They’ve tried exposure therapy as well as a bunch of other recommendations from psychologists but it’s never improved! :(

OP posts:
Justaquestionplease · 25/10/2026 16:17

This is just ridiculous. Giving up your entire life for an uncle...I've never heard such madness and her mother facilitating it. It's absolutely horrific. A care home would absolutely be the best option by the sounds of it.

I'd have to say this to my friend. The idea that she would give up her entire life and future is just insane. I'd tell her straight to be honest.

haggingtime · 25/10/2026 16:27

If this was my friend I’d tell her she must absolutely move away from home as soon as possible.

I can’t believe her mum doesn’t insist on this.

AnnaBelIa · 25/10/2026 16:32

I really hope she can eventually see that caring for someone doesn't mean giving up her entire future, and that there are other options for her uncle too. And yes, I think you should still go on the holiday if she can't, especially if it means you can come back and have something positive to share with her. x

Linnende · 25/10/2026 16:37

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 15:01

Hi, I’m wondering if there’s anyone else out there in a similar situation. This is a long one!

My friend is a carer for her family member who has multiple genetic conditions that have gone on to cause agoraphobia, germaphobia & extreme anxiety too. They need daily care surrounding all aspects of life, so my friend & her mum provide it. They have tried extensively researching the conditions, got psychologists, therapy, but nothing made any difference. The mental issues have hugely increased in severity since COVID. This person hasn’t left the house, AT ALL, since lockdown began in 2020, and as their carers, my friend & her mum can’t really either. Shopping delivered, no dentist/hair/any other appointments ever etc. Her only freedom is a 1 week holiday per year (only when/if she can afford it), which she must isolate after. Her mum has no freedom at all.

I speak (online) to her daily, ask if I can do anything, have visited their street & stood social distancing so that we can still see each other to wish happy birthday/Christmas & drop off presents on the doorstep. I am not allowed in the house or near them, think of lockdown restrictions - that’s how they’re living, only even more restricting.

Now, we’ve dreamed about holidaying together, but I couldn’t afford to join her previously. Last year I’d finally saved enough, and we planned & booked one. We were both ecstatic - until this week, 3 months before we’re due to go, the family member became very distressed about her travelling ‘in flu season’, so she can’t go (the holiday is booked for January). It’s been booked since March, we’ve really looked forward to it as it took so long to plan, and it’d be the first time in 7 YEARS that we could properly spend together. (It was booked for Jan as flights to the location are only available in Winter, and the activities we’d like to do are too, late Jan being the best option to avoid Christmas crowds. We specifically chose somewhere remote and safe, and activities that are outdoors-y and distanced from people, and she was I going to isolate afterwards anyway.)

I’m devastated, but more importantly I’m concerned for her. I could still go, albeit alone, but is that right? She can’t do anything, she can’t have a day out, go to the cinema, go for a meal, because she has to isolate for 7 days if leaving the house, to keep the person’s mind at ease, and it’s obviously not worth it for single/few-day trips. The holiday is her only escape, and my only chance to spend time with her. She’s trying her best to be accommodating for them, but she’s losing her life in the process and as her friend I’m heartbroken seeing this.

She’s devoted to her family and is so selfless, but is now facing the fact that she will never be able to move out, have a partner, have kids, go places, literally anything. She can’t bare the thought of them ending up in care, as she’s heard ‘horror stories’ regarding severely disabled people’s treatment in such places. They also can’t have a paid carer in, as this creates massive stress over contamination etc - so they have no help. When her mum eventually passes, she will be left to cope alone.

I’m disabled myself, I get their situation and of course have no hatred or judgement towards the person.. The family have tried everything. Managing the current needs is all that can be done. There’s no cures/successful therapies for any of the conditions, but they’re not life threatening, so they will likely live a full (but awful) life, and as there’s only a ~10yr age difference, caring for them will likely take up the rest of my friend’s life. She began caring & living this restricted at 16, we’ll soon be 23.

I guess I’m just hoping she’s not alone, are there others out there in a similar situation? Is there anyone in my situation as the friend? Am I wrong to be upset about the holiday, & would I be wrong to go alone? I’m worried that with my own health issues this might be my only chance before it declines further. Is that selfish? It’s also not fully refundable so I’d lose hundreds if I were to cancel. I love her & her family so much, this is such a difficult situation and she has lost every friend but me. I’ve had someone in my family with agoraphobia so I get that part of it, but that didn’t restrict their carer from going out, this is truly ‘next level’.

Thank you for reading this far, any input is much appreciated ❤️

Further context regarding the disabilities:
The conditions affect the immune system, sight, gut, skin, sensory processing, mental capacity, amongst other stuff. They have long names that I cannot remember, and are all rare hence the lack of research/help.
Her mum has said this can’t go on forever, they will have to eventually find care, but my friend is terrified of letting this happen and is trading her life to make the family member’s easier, She is so strong and a beautiful human, but I am so concerned. This causes constant tension between the family as you could imagine, it’s such a tricky situation.

She needs specialist care. Your friend can't carry on like this as she will never get the chance to live her own life. Only she can make the this decision. I think eventually, she will become resentful of a life she is missing. You should still go on holiday. Is there anyone else you can go with? Be there for your friend, but don't make any future plans that involve her!

BillieWiper · 25/10/2026 16:41

She needs to stop enabling someone's mental illness. No she doesn't need to isolate and the person is mentally ill. Not physically. Not immunocompromised. They have severe health anxiety. The things they expect are not reasonable and by abiding by them your friends are not helping her or themselves.

Sprogonthetyne · 25/10/2026 16:47

It's an awful situation for the whole family, but I'm absolutely appalled that her mum would allow a 16yo to give up her entire life like that. She should definitely go on the holiday, but more importantly, she needs to move out.

Living this life from such a young age, it's likly she has become so acclimatised, like the proverbial frog in boiling water, and genuinely cannot see how extreme the situation is.

Is there any chance she could live with you for say 6 months, to actually experience life, then make a more informed decision as to if she actually want to give up her future.

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 17:00

Trallers · 25/10/2026 15:48

This family dynamic sounds incredibly toxic (although not necessarily intentionally, more like they've all fallen into these roles and then just continued them).

It's the sort of thing you'd do for a close family member going through an acute illness or treatment (e.g. chemo) but really isn't the answer for a lifetime condition.

I'd say your friend needs to start with some therapy of some sort to process her approach to the entire situation. I doubt a sudden ditching of the set-up would help her get her life on track as it sounds like there's some complicated mental gymnastics that have got her enmeshed with this in the first place.

As for the holiday -cant she do the 7 day isolation afterwards rather than cancel?

Thank you so much, that’s a great suggestion! Her mum is on the same page as me in terms of this cannot continue forever, of course when they both began caring neither thought it would become this extreme of a situation. All of us are autistic and because of that it can be very difficult to recognise at what point something has gone ‘too far’, and on top of that her morals are so strong that she would easily place the happiness & safety of the person over her own. As an outsider viewing it I recognise that it’s not okay for anyone, I’ll definitely start talking a out therapy with them, thank you.

Yes that was the original plan anyway, to isolate, the issue is travelling in ‘flu season’ is risky as she could get ill, then possibly chronically ill etc, which is causing the disabled member immense stress from obsessing over it all. Unfortunately I became chronically ill from COVID, as did. one of my parents, which they’re aware of and this won’t help the anxiety. I was previously perfectly healthy so for someone already immunocompromised you can imagine the fear of what could happen to them. The fear of my friend never being able to live her life outweighs this to me though!

OP posts:
alp1002 · 25/10/2026 17:13

Brickiscool · 25/10/2026 15:49

If she doesn't isolate does it pose a genuine physical threat to this person or just a mental threat. I'm not saying a mental threat isn't bad. But suppose she just went out? What could this person actually do about it? As their mental health seems so bad, would it really worse if they didn't pander to it? And realistically if they had carers or went into care. They wouldn't have people isolating before seeing them

Both, the person is immunocompromised so things such as colds could put them in hospital, and because of this and the stress from COVID, it’s really exacerbated their fears of contamination and developed into this extreme situation. Unfortunately, I became chronically ill from covid (they’re aware of this) and I was previously healthy, so this also added to the anxiety of what ‘could’ happen to them. Because the person’s mental capacity isn’t great, rational explanations, exposure therapy, literally everything they’ve tried hasn't made any difference. But this does make me question that too, what would happen if they just stopped doing this? Extreme meltdowns & stress, but it couldn’t continue forever surely. Nobody knows the answer and I think that’s why my friend & her mum have carried on this way for this long.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread