Please or to access all these features

Carers

Caring for elderly relatives? Supercarers can help

An impossible situation, is there anyone out there that has been through similar, or even just has any input? :(

83 replies

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 15:01

Hi, I’m wondering if there’s anyone else out there in a similar situation. This is a long one!

My friend is a carer for her family member who has multiple genetic conditions that have gone on to cause agoraphobia, germaphobia & extreme anxiety too. They need daily care surrounding all aspects of life, so my friend & her mum provide it. They have tried extensively researching the conditions, got psychologists, therapy, but nothing made any difference. The mental issues have hugely increased in severity since COVID. This person hasn’t left the house, AT ALL, since lockdown began in 2020, and as their carers, my friend & her mum can’t really either. Shopping delivered, no dentist/hair/any other appointments ever etc. Her only freedom is a 1 week holiday per year (only when/if she can afford it), which she must isolate after. Her mum has no freedom at all.

I speak (online) to her daily, ask if I can do anything, have visited their street & stood social distancing so that we can still see each other to wish happy birthday/Christmas & drop off presents on the doorstep. I am not allowed in the house or near them, think of lockdown restrictions - that’s how they’re living, only even more restricting.

Now, we’ve dreamed about holidaying together, but I couldn’t afford to join her previously. Last year I’d finally saved enough, and we planned & booked one. We were both ecstatic - until this week, 3 months before we’re due to go, the family member became very distressed about her travelling ‘in flu season’, so she can’t go (the holiday is booked for January). It’s been booked since March, we’ve really looked forward to it as it took so long to plan, and it’d be the first time in 7 YEARS that we could properly spend together. (It was booked for Jan as flights to the location are only available in Winter, and the activities we’d like to do are too, late Jan being the best option to avoid Christmas crowds. We specifically chose somewhere remote and safe, and activities that are outdoors-y and distanced from people, and she was I going to isolate afterwards anyway.)

I’m devastated, but more importantly I’m concerned for her. I could still go, albeit alone, but is that right? She can’t do anything, she can’t have a day out, go to the cinema, go for a meal, because she has to isolate for 7 days if leaving the house, to keep the person’s mind at ease, and it’s obviously not worth it for single/few-day trips. The holiday is her only escape, and my only chance to spend time with her. She’s trying her best to be accommodating for them, but she’s losing her life in the process and as her friend I’m heartbroken seeing this.

She’s devoted to her family and is so selfless, but is now facing the fact that she will never be able to move out, have a partner, have kids, go places, literally anything. She can’t bare the thought of them ending up in care, as she’s heard ‘horror stories’ regarding severely disabled people’s treatment in such places. They also can’t have a paid carer in, as this creates massive stress over contamination etc - so they have no help. When her mum eventually passes, she will be left to cope alone.

I’m disabled myself, I get their situation and of course have no hatred or judgement towards the person.. The family have tried everything. Managing the current needs is all that can be done. There’s no cures/successful therapies for any of the conditions, but they’re not life threatening, so they will likely live a full (but awful) life, and as there’s only a ~10yr age difference, caring for them will likely take up the rest of my friend’s life. She began caring & living this restricted at 16, we’ll soon be 23.

I guess I’m just hoping she’s not alone, are there others out there in a similar situation? Is there anyone in my situation as the friend? Am I wrong to be upset about the holiday, & would I be wrong to go alone? I’m worried that with my own health issues this might be my only chance before it declines further. Is that selfish? It’s also not fully refundable so I’d lose hundreds if I were to cancel. I love her & her family so much, this is such a difficult situation and she has lost every friend but me. I’ve had someone in my family with agoraphobia so I get that part of it, but that didn’t restrict their carer from going out, this is truly ‘next level’.

Thank you for reading this far, any input is much appreciated ❤️

Further context regarding the disabilities:
The conditions affect the immune system, sight, gut, skin, sensory processing, mental capacity, amongst other stuff. They have long names that I cannot remember, and are all rare hence the lack of research/help.
Her mum has said this can’t go on forever, they will have to eventually find care, but my friend is terrified of letting this happen and is trading her life to make the family member’s easier, She is so strong and a beautiful human, but I am so concerned. This causes constant tension between the family as you could imagine, it’s such a tricky situation.

OP posts:
alp1002 · 25/10/2026 17:21

malefields · 25/10/2026 15:51

This is absurd. Is there any actual reason that your friend can’t have a normal, average holiday, or do you think it’s purely to appease that person’s anxieties and germophobia?

Because if it’s the latter… what they don’t know won’t hurt them. Just saying.

There is a genuine risk that she could catch something and therefore pass it on to them, the person is immunocompromised so if they were to get a cold etc that could land them in hospital, hence the extreme anxiety. Most things are visible after a week so isolating should eliminate the fears, but this hasn’t calmed them at all knowing this as their mental capacity isn’t enough to be rational. I became chronically ill from covid myself (and was previously perfectly healthy) so them knowing that has made the fear even worse :(
I’ve said the same, I don’t think she could disappear for a week without them noticing but I agree with that, there’s no issue being safe but not actually leaving at all isn’t fair.

OP posts:
malefields · 25/10/2026 17:23

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 17:21

There is a genuine risk that she could catch something and therefore pass it on to them, the person is immunocompromised so if they were to get a cold etc that could land them in hospital, hence the extreme anxiety. Most things are visible after a week so isolating should eliminate the fears, but this hasn’t calmed them at all knowing this as their mental capacity isn’t enough to be rational. I became chronically ill from covid myself (and was previously perfectly healthy) so them knowing that has made the fear even worse :(
I’ve said the same, I don’t think she could disappear for a week without them noticing but I agree with that, there’s no issue being safe but not actually leaving at all isn’t fair.

I get that they’re immunocompromised, but is the fear proportional to risk? Only asking because DD is also immunocompromised but not to a point where she needs to fear every outing etc

Flapjak · 25/10/2026 17:25

I would say this is a really unhealthy and unsustainable situation and your friend sounds like she has been conditioned/psychologically abused so that she accepts these rules - if her relative has such a compromised immune system , they need to live in a plastic bubble / sterile room whilst others can live their lives freely- this sounds utterly controlling and unfortunately a situation which will not end well for anyone. I think your friend needs to speak to women's aid or social services as she has been forced to become a prisoner in her own home- obviously it is awful that the uncles behaviour is so extreme that this is the only way he feels safe - what happens if they do go out what is he going to do about it ? Behave violently , threaten to harm himself or lock them out ?

BeethovenNinth · 25/10/2026 17:25

Your friend has given up her life for her uncle.

she should walk away

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 17:30

BobbleBear · 25/10/2026 15:56

OMG, this is abusive.

Your friend is not being allowed to live a normal life and has been conditioned by her mum to accept this as her lot. That is so so wrong.

Her mother needs to step up and force the daughter to move out and start living a normal independent life.

I also think the mother needs to stop pandering to the other sibling as it’s all learnt behaviours and can be changed but only if she’s prepared to push through.

The person in question is her uncle, the mum’s brother. He was cared for by my friend’s grandma, until crisis hit in covid and it fell on friend’s mum to care for him. She quit her job to do this, myself & my friend finished school that year so she naturally chose to be a carer too. Before covid, his needs were still extensive but manageable, so when taking this on neither knew how bad it would become.
He was born severely mentally & physically disabled and the conditions are genetic, they have tried endless amounts of therapy, psychologist visits, exposure etc and nothing has helped at all.
Because the threat is real (if he catches a cold etc he will end up severely ill & in hospital), the fears of contamination are genuine. I definitely think my friend needs to look into therapy to view the situation differently, her mum is on the same page as me and knows this isn’t acceptable. Hopefully a better arrangement can happen even if it involves stress, such an awful situation for all involved.

OP posts:
tsmainsqueeze · 25/10/2026 17:37

Absolutely ridiculous !
And unless the uncle has learning difficulties which affect his understanding of how his behaviour restricts everyone else then regardless of his problems he is an extremely selfish man .
No one should be living like this .

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 17:43

JanFebAndOnwards · 25/10/2026 16:12

What HCPs are involved with the patient? Do social services know about the situation??

It cannot be validated by any professional, surely. It’s virtually an adult safeguarding situation - ie for your friend and her mum!

What do they live on, are they all
claiming benefits?

carers UK might be a starting point.

There’s definitely somebody involved but I couldn’t tell you who/what, I’m sure social services are aware as I’ve heard it mentioned before. Unfortunately I’m new to ‘adulting’ am trying to learn everything & catch up with the info! Will gently ask my friend as much as possible. My own mum is aware and is working to find help too as she is equally concerned.

Friend & her mum are on carer’s allowance/UC, friend also makes some money from a little business that she runs from home (declared of course). Disabled individual receives PIP, not sure if anything else. All are physically catered for and safe, but as you say mentally this is not okay!

OP posts:
alp1002 · 25/10/2026 17:49

Justaquestionplease · 25/10/2026 16:17

This is just ridiculous. Giving up your entire life for an uncle...I've never heard such madness and her mother facilitating it. It's absolutely horrific. A care home would absolutely be the best option by the sounds of it.

I'd have to say this to my friend. The idea that she would give up her entire life and future is just insane. I'd tell her straight to be honest.

Thank you, I definitely have to say something and I’ve stepped in to express my concern gently. I completely get wanting to be there for a family member but for someone with this extreme amount of needs a professional environment that they can visit whenever would make the most sense imo. Her mum is on the same page as me and is working towards this for when she can no longer manage, I’m just thinking of how much longer that would be. There’s no issue making little sacrifices but as you say this is far beyond that.
in the time this has been going on I’ve found a partner, bought a house, my other friends have been to uni etc, granted you can do this at any age but she shouldn’t have to wait for a time that may never come. I feel that stepping in now before we get any older is crucial!

OP posts:
alp1002 · 25/10/2026 17:58

Linnende · 25/10/2026 16:37

She needs specialist care. Your friend can't carry on like this as she will never get the chance to live her own life. Only she can make the this decision. I think eventually, she will become resentful of a life she is missing. You should still go on holiday. Is there anyone else you can go with? Be there for your friend, but don't make any future plans that involve her!

I completely agree, I know she wants the best for the family member but that shouldn’t come at her expense to this extent.
I’ve asked my boyfriend if he thinks we could afford for him to go instead, hopefully he can and is able to get the time off! If not I think I’ll go anyway, it’s a wonderful opportunity and I don’t want to give it up! Absolutely, I always make sure she knows she’s invited to everything (group activities) and will never leave her out, but won’t plan 1-1 things as realistically I know there’s no point. Hopefully in time she’ll have a better arrangement, and I’ll be here throughout support her.

OP posts:
alp1002 · 25/10/2026 18:06

BillieWiper · 25/10/2026 16:41

She needs to stop enabling someone's mental illness. No she doesn't need to isolate and the person is mentally ill. Not physically. Not immunocompromised. They have severe health anxiety. The things they expect are not reasonable and by abiding by them your friends are not helping her or themselves.

The person is genuinely physically disabled, as well as having learning disabilities, neurological disabilities and several genetic diseases. The last time they caught a cold they ended up in hospital, hence lead them to develop health anxiety on top of everything else because of genuine fears of it happening again/something worse happening. A very unfortunate circumstance. Because of the learning disabilities, they don’t understand and aren’t able to rationalise like we can. Hoping my friend is able to find a better solution for their care than the current situation.

OP posts:
alp1002 · 25/10/2026 18:18

Sprogonthetyne · 25/10/2026 16:47

It's an awful situation for the whole family, but I'm absolutely appalled that her mum would allow a 16yo to give up her entire life like that. She should definitely go on the holiday, but more importantly, she needs to move out.

Living this life from such a young age, it's likly she has become so acclimatised, like the proverbial frog in boiling water, and genuinely cannot see how extreme the situation is.

Is there any chance she could live with you for say 6 months, to actually experience life, then make a more informed decision as to if she actually want to give up her future.

Thank you, that’s a very good suggestion and something I’ll bring up, even for a few weeks just something to help her live like a 23yo should be. I live with my boyfriend and we’d be happy to have her at our house, we’re just figuring out life too and that’s what she should be doing!

I completely agree, it’s as if she’s so used to it that she’s happy to do it, and while I get that she loves her family member, putting her own life on hold potentially forever is not okay. It’s one thing for her mum as she’s in her 50s (still a sad situation) but for someone our age to not even have a chance at life is horrific. Her mum thinks the same as is attempting to gently start conversations about it, which causes a lot of tension and upset but they need to happen.

OP posts:
alp1002 · 25/10/2026 18:26

malefields · 25/10/2026 17:23

I get that they’re immunocompromised, but is the fear proportional to risk? Only asking because DD is also immunocompromised but not to a point where she needs to fear every outing etc

I definitely think the fear has surpassed the risk, I’ve been asking them this myself because the longer you leave these things usually the worse they get. The family have had weekly sessions with a psychologist to try and understand why the fear is so persistent & why usual therapies haven’t worked but no answers so far!

OP posts:
Gazelda · 25/10/2026 18:33

Your friend needs some support for herself. She’s not going to be able to just walk away from a life she’s been conditioned to. Can you suggest she gets a carers assessment via her GP? Or calls Carers Uk for advice. I suspect she’d benefit from some good therapy for herself rather than as an offshoot of uncle’s needs.

it must be heartbreaking for you to see this happening to your friend. from what you’ve posted, it reads like an abusive situation.

She’s lucky you love her and are wanting to find the right solution for her.

BillieWiper · 25/10/2026 18:35

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 18:06

The person is genuinely physically disabled, as well as having learning disabilities, neurological disabilities and several genetic diseases. The last time they caught a cold they ended up in hospital, hence lead them to develop health anxiety on top of everything else because of genuine fears of it happening again/something worse happening. A very unfortunate circumstance. Because of the learning disabilities, they don’t understand and aren’t able to rationalise like we can. Hoping my friend is able to find a better solution for their care than the current situation.

Ah ok so there is more to it. They definitely need professionals to help. It's not fair on your friend and her mum to do it all.

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 18:36

Flapjak · 25/10/2026 17:25

I would say this is a really unhealthy and unsustainable situation and your friend sounds like she has been conditioned/psychologically abused so that she accepts these rules - if her relative has such a compromised immune system , they need to live in a plastic bubble / sterile room whilst others can live their lives freely- this sounds utterly controlling and unfortunately a situation which will not end well for anyone. I think your friend needs to speak to women's aid or social services as she has been forced to become a prisoner in her own home- obviously it is awful that the uncles behaviour is so extreme that this is the only way he feels safe - what happens if they do go out what is he going to do about it ? Behave violently , threaten to harm himself or lock them out ?

Thank you, definitely a situation that nobody expected and now seem to be stuck in. He’s never shown any violence towards anyone but realistically nobody knows what could happen, especially if after 7 years nothing has gotten better. I’ve become involved as I love the family dearly, and am actively involving my own mum as I’m still young and don’t know enough about care to give proper help! Trying to get my friend to understand that this isn’t healthy is the first step, her mum is on the same page as me and is actively trying to change the situation too.

OP posts:
alp1002 · 25/10/2026 18:44

tsmainsqueeze · 25/10/2026 17:37

Absolutely ridiculous !
And unless the uncle has learning difficulties which affect his understanding of how his behaviour restricts everyone else then regardless of his problems he is an extremely selfish man .
No one should be living like this .

Unfortunately he does have learning disabilities which is what makes the whole thing even more complex, he genuinely has no understanding of the issues he’s unintentionally causing :(
Agreed, putting your life in hold for a year or two to help a loved one is one thing, but permanently is another.

OP posts:
Liverpoolxxx · 25/10/2026 18:56

She should go on the holiday and then move in with you until she can find a place of her own. She’ll need an awful lot of support.

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 19:01

Gazelda · 25/10/2026 18:33

Your friend needs some support for herself. She’s not going to be able to just walk away from a life she’s been conditioned to. Can you suggest she gets a carers assessment via her GP? Or calls Carers Uk for advice. I suspect she’d benefit from some good therapy for herself rather than as an offshoot of uncle’s needs.

it must be heartbreaking for you to see this happening to your friend. from what you’ve posted, it reads like an abusive situation.

She’s lucky you love her and are wanting to find the right solution for her.

Edited

Thank you!

Myself, my friend and her mum are all (low support needs) autistic so getting them to understand how bad this has gotten and how important it is to have boundaries is so difficult, I’d be the same if I was in their position hence why I care so deeply, and as an outsider I can look at it logically without the intense emotional aspects. They try so much to accommodate him because they know what it’s like to not be accommodated, which is lovely but not at the expense of their freedom. Of course during lockdown everything suddenly changed, but for their family it never changed back.

I’ll pass all of this advice on & be there throughout, thank you so much

OP posts:
Keepingongoing · 25/10/2026 19:06

What an awful situation, I’d go as far as to say tragic. You sound like a lovely friend hanging in there and trying to support your friend, she must be very dear to you.

Ultimately it’s an unsustainable situation, what happens if your friend or her mum need medical attention? Or a repair needs doing at the house? But also it’s utterly, utterly wrong that the uncle’s anxieties dictate your friend and her mum’s behaviour to this extent.

I think you can support your friend best by showing her how wrong it is, and by showing her that she has a right to all the things that people normally do when they’re her age. Unfortunately some people are very ready to sacrifice themselves, and when young, this sacrifice can be very extreme.

It would be so so good for her to have that holiday with you, and whilst I wouldn’t normally recommend giving in to another person’s anxieties to a greater extent, perhaps in the case of the holiday it would be worth more concessions if it got her away from this situation for a week. Could she do a few extra days isolation afterwards, wear a mask on the plane (the higher spec one which protects you from other people) and get a flu jab beforehand.

My gut feeling is that giving her a short break away from this awful situation might start to give her a different perspective . I wonder also if talking to an organisation like Carers UK would be helpful ( there is a helpline) and there are charities supporting young carers in many areas too.

Boreded · 25/10/2026 19:18

I hope you’ll forgive me for the AI aspect of my reply, I wanted to get the right contact details for the support networks that could be relied on. The rest of the response is mine, but the contacts are AI.

I think you should get in touch with adult safeguarding and raise your concerns about your friend…she is a vulnerable adult.

  • Adult Social Care / Adult Safeguarding: Contact their local council. They can assess the situation, investigate safeguarding concerns and look at alternative care arrangements. Find the council at www.gov.uk/find-local-council.

Hopefully then your friend will be able to access one of these services:

  • Carers UK: 0808 808 7777 or www.carersuk.org. They can advise on your friend’s rights, carers’ assessments, respite and support.
  • Carers Trust: www.carers.org. They can help identify local services offering practical support and breaks from caring.

Your friend and her mum can also request separate carers’ assessments through Adult Social Care, regardless of whether the family member agrees to outside carers.

I really wouldn’t wait until the situation reaches crisis point. There are professionals who can help them explore alternatives, and your friend deserves the opportunity to have a life outside her caring responsibilities. You will be doing her a massive favour if you do step in and help, even if she doesn’t believe it in the first instance. Her uncle needs more than she and her mum can offer him.

Find your local council - GOV.UK

Find your local authority in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland

http://www.gov.uk/find-local-council.

PoisedOliveRobin · 25/10/2026 19:27

I'm going to post my thoughts which are probably going to be controversial. I think your friend should be encouraged to go on holiday with you. If, when she returns home, she has a cold etc which she passes on to her uncle then it's not the end of the world. If he ends up in hospital then he will have ready access to professionals who can see what his problems are, and hopefully provide the right support. If the hospital want to discharge him then your friend and her mum can refuse to have him home. There must be somewhere where he could be looked after where he can be helped. What's the saying? Put on your own oxygen mask before you help others.

YouDoYouDo · 25/10/2026 19:36

The thing is, everyone on this thread can offer their thoughts on what your friend should do, and what the friend’s mother should do but in reality, this is all completely outside your control OP. You can offer advice but in all honesty they sound so entrenched and divorced from the world that I doubt you will get far. I think what’s really important here is what you are going to do.

I find it quite worrying that you are questioning whether it would be wrong for you to still go on the holiday. It is VITAL that you still go on the holiday. Enough people are already sacrificing their own lives unnecessarily. Don’t become another one. You have your own challenges and you need to prioritise yourself.

I also think it would be a much better example to your friend to say “I think you should come on this trip and I’ll do what I can to help you be able to come, but if you decide not to, no way am I missing it. You’re only young once and I’m going to go and enjoy myself” than to give up your own holiday essentially because of her uncle.

It would be more helpful to your friend to show her that actually she does have a choice here, and could choose to not always put her uncle first, than to go along with the idea that she has no choice.

You sound like a really lovely, caring, loyal friend, but there may not that much you are able to do to help your friend other than continuing to be her friend until she is ready to change her life. But please don’t you make any sacrifices in the meantime. You don’t need to do so to be a good friend, and the best example you can show your friend is by making the most of your own life.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 25/10/2026 19:47

alp1002 · 25/10/2026 18:26

I definitely think the fear has surpassed the risk, I’ve been asking them this myself because the longer you leave these things usually the worse they get. The family have had weekly sessions with a psychologist to try and understand why the fear is so persistent & why usual therapies haven’t worked but no answers so far!

I appreciate we only know what you've said here, but it really sounds like it's so persistent and therapies haven't worked because your friend and her mum are effectively reinforcing it by complying with the demands and making them 'normal'. Then the next demand comes, and that's absorbed into 'normal' too.

Imagine if they'd just said 'no' when e.g. the demand to not go outside first came along. They would have gone for a walk outside, come home, and nothing bad would have happened. Eventually so many walks outside would have happened with nothing bad at all coming of it that her uncle would not have been scared of it anymore and going outside would have been the 'normal' instead. But by treating it as though there is something to be scared of they're making it seem like a legitimate fear and a reasonable demand and it is absolutely not. It is abusive, even if the person doesn't have the capacity to understand it.

Just the same as if someone is punching their carers in the face, even if the person doesn't understand what he's doing, the carer still has a broken nose, it's not ok.

Foundress · 25/10/2026 19:58

You sound like a loyal and good friend @alp1002 Unfortunately your friend and her DM are being abused by their Uncle. Just because a person has learning disabilities doesn’t mean they are incapable of abusing other people. Presumably this man (I knew it would be a man) must have some intellectual ability? How would he come up with these infection theories otherwise? He is manipulating your friend and her DM. Whether that is consciously or not who knows? Unless someone makes a referral to adult social services nothing will change. Even if SS got involved it would probably be very difficult to convince your friend and her DM they are abuse victims.

Ilikewinter · 25/10/2026 20:07

Is there a cultural expectation that the females in the family will look after the uncle by any chance?. And if no-one in the house hold is working who is paying the bills etc?. Yes your friend needs to live her own life but that is clearly never going to happen.