Please or to access all these features

Car seats

Confused about car seat regulations? Find baby car seat advice here. For Mumsnetter-approved essentials, sign up for Mumsnet Swears By emails here.

Three year old climbing out of car seat

26 replies

Inthedeepgreysea · Yesterday 16:04

She is in a Cybex Pallas and has been for well over a year now as she kept getting her arms out of the straps on standard car seats, but now she’s worked out how to wriggle out of it and get free.

I absolutely have to use the car with her in it. We live on and surrounded by country lanes with no pavements (or lighting at this time of year.) I have another child who is at school and she is at preschool three days a week while I work. None of these are optional, so I can’t say ‘we aren’t going to <fun activity> because of your behaviour.’

Is there anything I can do to contain her? I thought the Cybex was the safest option.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
maggisimpson · Yesterday 16:04

Pull over and go absolutely ballistic at her.

Inthedeepgreysea · Yesterday 16:06

@maggisimpson it isn’t possible or safe to pull over and she doesn’t care anyway … she might cry but then five minutes later she does it again. I really don’t need critique of parenting here, I need actual suggestions as to how to stop her doing this as in products not screaming until I’m hoarse for her to do the same thing again in minutes.

OP posts:
chirrupybird · Yesterday 16:15

I just screamed at mine when I saw she had undone her harness in the car seat, just total terror on my part. She was very proud of herself and was laughing until then, after I'd stopped the car and calmed down and done it up again I did tell her it was very clever but never, ever to do it again because it's dangerous and frightened mummy and she didn't. Not recommending the screaming part.

Can you reason with her, explain it's dangerous to get out, at that age they do understand a lot.

BunfightBetty · Yesterday 16:16

I don’t think that was a critique of your parenting. More that practical options are limited and in any case, if she doesn’t listen in general you probably have a bigger issue, though I appreciate this is concerning right now.

Is there no way you can do a dummy run journey, where you don’t need to be anywhere particular but you tell her she’s going to get an ice cream or something she values, and you can wait until she does it and then go fully nuclear? She needs to understand it’s an absolute no-no, that you won’t tolerate it and things won’t go well for her if she keeps doing it. Sometimes a hard shock works where nothing else has. It’s a pity and doesn’t feel good as the parent, but worth it for safety issues IMO.

The only other thing is to try and strap her in to a seat so tightly she can’t wriggle. One that has a button that’s hard to undo. We had an Axkid that DD couldn’t open. Then if she complains about being straitjacketed in you can say ‘well this is because you keep being really naughty and undoing your seat buckle. Until you can behave like a big girl I’m afraid we’ll have to keep strapping you in tightly’. She might learn it’s better for her to behave herself.

Inthedeepgreysea · Yesterday 16:17

So I have tried telling her and shouting etc but she either laughs or gets upset but does the same thing moments later. Yesterday she was thrown forwards and got hurt and I was hopeful it would make her realise it was dangerous but she’s still doing it.

I am wondering if there’s anything I can buy or even a different car seat to restrain her a bit better - don’t know if anyone has any ideas.

OP posts:
Inthedeepgreysea · Yesterday 16:24

Possibly @BunfightBetty but in all honesty I think she would find that a really amusing game to make the car stop and start at her whim if you like. So I don’t really want to do that especially given it isn’t always possible to stop straightaway.

OP posts:
BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 16:27

Does she respond to rewards?

Shalalaa · Yesterday 16:27

I bought a chest clip. Escape me not. Or Houdini. £1 off Vinted. Neither baby or toddler can get out their seats now, they were roaming around the car while I was on the motorway

maggisimpson · Yesterday 16:28

Not sure how you read that as a critique of your parenting 🤔

Inthedeepgreysea · Yesterday 16:29

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 16:27

Does she respond to rewards?

I could try although I am not totally sure how well it would work at this age. I’ve tried giving her a coveted snack but it only contains her for as long as the snack lasts.

@maggisimpson i guess because I posted in car seats as opposed to parenting? But I am sorry if I was defensive.

OP posts:
Thickasabrick89 · Yesterday 16:29

So I used to have this. We put additional harnesses on the straps so it was almost like a straight jacket in the end.

If she was upset or angry she would fight the car seat. It doesn't sound like you have this issue but if she went in the car seat calm, she would stay in the seat. If she went in the car seat angry and screaming, she would roll around the parcel shelf/foot well before I have a chance to stop the car safely.

They grow out of it but the restraining with additional straps was the only way we managed it in the short term.

moominontherun · Yesterday 16:30

There are specialist car seats that are more aimed at children with ASN but those are quite expensive. I can’t really add much more as the going ballistic thing worked for both of mine. I’m not a shouty parent generally so when I absolutely bellowed, I mean a guttural noise that came from my soul, they were dumbfounded and never did it again. I presume you tried the BeSafe belt collector when she was in the previous seat? If not, you could try put that seat back in with the belt collector if you still have it.

Also if there’s a key worker at nursery who she’s attached to, you could ask them to raise it with her. Auntie Annie at our nursery (one of the older ladies who has been there for years) can get children to do all sorts they wouldn’t do when asked by a parent!

NellietheNumpty · Yesterday 16:32

I would stop the car and get the child out and explain it is the law of the car and the land only strapped in people can ride in a car. I was in a crash with my children in the car both in appropriate car seats. They both suffered minor injuries and I had concussion. No shouting required but the seriousness of the matter should be clear and non negotiable.

BirdLandedonmyHead · Yesterday 16:33

Inthedeepgreysea · Yesterday 16:29

I could try although I am not totally sure how well it would work at this age. I’ve tried giving her a coveted snack but it only contains her for as long as the snack lasts.

@maggisimpson i guess because I posted in car seats as opposed to parenting? But I am sorry if I was defensive.

I eas thinking on the lines of a reward chart. With growing rewards for number of safe journeys in a row. Same for your other child so theres a demo going on.

Plus, apologies if its really obvious... is the seat properly fitted, and is she wearing thin tight layers as opposed to puffy, compressable ones?

Ive also seen putting their coat on backwards over the starps, but that can be a danger if you need to get them out quickly in an accident (but safer than an escapee in accident)

Koalaslippers · Yesterday 16:37

Is the pallas cushion thing tight enough around her or is she undoing it? I'm concerned that if she is wriggling out that it isn't secure enough for her.

What worked for mine was pulling over every single time and a short sharp 'no! You must stay in your seat'. It was tedious but it did eventually work. I do appreciate that journeys take longer in the meantime but the issue with using other products is that it doesn't address the behaviour so the child then tries to figure it out again and again.

OP posts:
IwillrunIwillfly · Yesterday 16:46

With traditional car seat straps we found the besafe belt collector worked amazingly to stop my son escaping from the straps. I dont think they make the same one anymore (it was such a simple piece of plastic that gathered the straps together!) but for my youngest we have the HOMYBABY anti escape chest clip from amazon and its the exact same as the besafe one.

I think the cybex one you have is the one with the big strap across the lap isn't it? If it is, how is she getting out? Is she pressing the button to release the seatbelt or sliding out? If shes sliding out I'd be worried it might not be a good fit and might be worth getting a fit check from where you got it? If she's undoing the seatbelt clip, you can buy things that cover the press button on them to make it harder to undo. Theyre generally not recommended because in an emergancy it might make it harder to get the child out of the seat, but might be worth considering if the risk is compared to her escaping and not being restrained at all?

Inthedeepgreysea · Yesterday 16:48

Thanks. She is sliding out; I’ll have to see if I can fit it better although I am not totally sure how. Hopefully there’s a YouTube video!

OP posts:
Koalaslippers · Yesterday 17:02

Are you pulling the strap on the cushion thing to tighten it?

IwillrunIwillfly · Yesterday 17:28

It might be worth going back to a 5 point harness seat if shes sliding out? Is she wearing thick jackets or anything? Did it come with any inserts that you're not using?

Liverpoolxxx · Yesterday 18:49

5 point harness abd the Cossatto anti-escape addition.

ChirpyBlueCat · Yesterday 20:00

You’d be best off getting a new seat for her, specifically an extended rear facing seat. Once she’s fitted in it correctly she shouldn’t be able to escape. At 3, children’s bodies aren’t developed enough to be safe forward facing in a car crash. Join the Bump to Booster car safety group on FB or have a look on their website, they’re super helpful and can give advice on the best seat for her age/height/weight.
https://www.bumptobooster.co.uk/why-rear-facing

Inthedeepgreysea · Yesterday 20:02

Thanks all. No inserts or anything and she never wears a coat or anything. I probably do need to tighten the front fastening.

OP posts:
Greenteaandbiscuits · Yesterday 21:48

Our cybex came with both straps and an impact sheild.

Our daughter worked out how to get out of the straps at age 2, so we tried the impact shield instead, worked a treat! Lasted till age 4 when she was old enough to know better and moved to a booster seat instead.

If you can get a seat with an impact sheild instead I recommend giving out a try!

I feel for you though. Nothing worse than looking in the mirror and seeing a toddler loose in the car with nowhere safe to stop 🙈

Inthedeepgreysea · Yesterday 21:50

It does have an impact shield Smile she is wriggling out of it. It was pitch black when we got in but tomorrow I will try to work out how to tighten it. It’s frustrating as it’s supposed to be one of the safest models.

OP posts: