Please or to access all these features

Car seats

Confused about car seat regulations? Find baby car seat advice here. For Mumsnetter-approved essentials, sign up for Mumsnet Swears By emails here.

Three year old climbing out of car seat

27 replies

Inthedeepgreysea · Yesterday 16:04

She is in a Cybex Pallas and has been for well over a year now as she kept getting her arms out of the straps on standard car seats, but now she’s worked out how to wriggle out of it and get free.

I absolutely have to use the car with her in it. We live on and surrounded by country lanes with no pavements (or lighting at this time of year.) I have another child who is at school and she is at preschool three days a week while I work. None of these are optional, so I can’t say ‘we aren’t going to <fun activity> because of your behaviour.’

Is there anything I can do to contain her? I thought the Cybex was the safest option.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
BertieBotts · Yesterday 22:07

Yes do check whether the front fastening needs to be tightened. I actually think they are meant to be tightened every time the seat is used, they should engage the child's hips, that is part of the newer regulation for this type of seat. Is she sliding out under the shield or climbing out of the top of it? Check the manual anyway as it should say whether it's something you do each time.

TBH I have not used one of the newer type of these where you can tighten the strap directly. I had a seatbelt fitted one years ago for DS1 who is grown up now. The seatbelt fitted ones could be a problem for persistent escapees, because if DC pushed on the shield very slowly, the seatbelt would not lock and so they would create slack and be able to squeeze out that way. But most children were not that persistent so they did not work this out. DS never did.

Did you move to this kind of seat instead of a 5-point harness? The extra restraints you can add like the chest clip or the 5-point-plus (which is like a sort of mini jacket thing) work with a standard 5-point harness, they won't work with an impact shield. If you still have a 5 point harness seat or could borrow one, sometimes a change is good as it sort of distracts them from the fact they could escape because they don't know how to do it in that seat.

If she is hypermobile, that will also make it easier for her to escape. Some hypermobile children can escape any restraint. Does she have SEN at all or would she understand explanations about why she needs to stay in the seat?

The reward suggestions can be good, as sometimes children work out they can escape the seat, and then they just keep doing it because they can and because it gets them a load of attention for doing it, which they're not seeking out consciously, it's just that it makes their little toddler brain go "Zing! Whatever behaviour this is, it's powerful and worth repeating!". Obviously you can't ignore the behaviour, because it's unsafe for her to be unrestrained, so in terms of behaviourism, rewarding time spent in the seat without trying to escape is likely to be the most effective way to change this if she is doing it "just because". Something I read about rewards recently was vv helpful, it was something like "Rewards are not a prize for behaviour that is already happening, they are a tool you can use like a trail to start at a place DC is now and guide them to the place you want them to be".

You can try punishment like shouting or some kind of loss of a privilege but it's likely to be ineffective unless you pair it with the rewarding for the behaviour you want to see.

Other than this if you can try and understand why she doesn't want to be in the seat it might be you can solve the problem. Does she find the shield uncomfortable? Does the headrest need raising up to be at the right size for her? Is she bored in the car and finds car journeys too long? Does she need to have 5 mins to run around first before getting in the car? etc etc. Is she feeling travel sick or hot? Try less clothing or opening windows or keeping the air con vv cool in the car. It is tricky if they don't talk very much yet.

Inthedeepgreysea · Today 15:03

Thanks so much. It was actually embarrassingly straightforward to do and she now is trapped Smile

She has hit that threenager stage and I’m getting annoyed with her often encourages unwanted behaviour. Apart from this she isn’t too bad but just stroppy and defiant sometimes.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread