Please or to access all these features

Cancer

Find advice & support if you or someone you know has been diagnosed with cancer

Consultant putting Mum off investigations

67 replies

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 08:00

Is this usual?

Mum had a positive FIT test and referral to a gastro consultant.

He wasnt particularly nice anyway and was pretty blunt. He said about investigations but then asked if there was any point, as if it is cancer she isnt fit for surgery anyway due to other issues.

We said well theres pros and cons of knowing at least.

Then he started going on about how aggressive and risky colonoscopies are, how aggressive the prep is. She could end up with a stoma, internal bleeding, the prep is awful and she'd struggle etc.

She ended up opting for a virtual CT colonoscopy in the end which he wasnt happy about. Again asked what the point would be, if theres poo in the way it wouldnt show anything. I said surely some prep is given for that and he said no.

It genuinely felt like a "well youre old, if its cancer we wont do anything so why waste time" 😔

OP posts:
HowNowBrownCow33 · 12/11/2026 19:19

He sounds an absolute arse. Its quite reasonable to want to know if youve got cancer even if your not fit for surgery. For one the liklihood is she doesnt have it and the poor woman is going to be imagining some painful imminent death. And if she does have cancer she will need the diagnosis to access supportive care

I thought you were going to say shes 98 with severe dementia and on deaths door. Not 74. I would complain. Is she definitely not fit for surgery?

DrFoxtrot · 12/11/2026 19:31

I agree with getting a second opinion. I once had a patient in her 80s in the same situation. She ended up having surgery for cancer and it was curative.

seahorsessky · 12/11/2026 19:50

SootylovesSue · 12/11/2026 08:05

Can see why they might not want to do a colonoscopy (prep and procedure are tough going), but I don't think a CT colonoscopy is unreasonable. Even if your is mum not fit for surgery or chemo at least you would know cause which would help with symptom management/planning IF a cancer was found.

Edited

The virtual one still involves the prep though, or is that not so? And she could have an MRI, unless there's a particular problem with that, OP? I am aware that doesn't pick up everything, but it is still very good.
And what was the point in her having the FIT test if she wasn't going to get any further treatment if it was positive?

urghhh47 · 12/11/2026 20:02

Well my Dad has just had another colonoscopy to see if any further polyps had grown since last time and he's 83....the doctor sounds like a complete knob tbh. My eldest son has a colonoscopy once a year for his ulcerative colitis. Yes there can be complications but it's considered to be a very safe procedure now. Definitely get a second opinion and tbh I'd start with your Mum's GP.

TrickyD · 12/11/2026 22:24

@seahorsessky yes, the virtual CTcolonoscopy certainly does involve the prep.
Its taste is very unpleasant but I was determined to drink the lot rather than have my innards declared to be unsuitable and have to start again on a later day.

JustaSongAboutPingPong · 12/11/2026 22:27

Just wanted to add that my DSis had bowel prep recently and it was brutal. She is fit, did over 21,000 steps yesterday, but spent most of her time sat next to the toilet. She actually looked a little green. I don’t think it’s a very easy procedure at all.

I can totally understand you wanting to know OP.

Was the score of the FIT test explained at all? Was it unusually high? I know there is a cut off in England of 120 before you are referred. However I think that the test has an accuracy of 95% so it might be worth asking for the test result to be explained and the test possibly being repeated as a first step?

3D medical illustration of colorectal cancer highlighted in a human digestive system, showing GP Notebook TV logo in top left corner.

Faecal immunochemical test (FIT) in the detection of bowel cancer – GPnotebook

In the second video in a series on cancer in primary care, Dr Jim McMorran outlines the role of FIT in bowel cancer screening, in investigating patients with unexplained symptoms and in prioritising patients referred on the 2 week wait (2WW) pathway.

https://gpnotebook.com/tv/oncology/faecal-immunochemical-test-fit-in-the-detection-of-bowel-cancer

Sosorryaboutthis · 12/11/2026 22:59

DFIL was older than your Mum and tried to have a colonoscopy. He took the Meds which he found very hard, but he did do it. He became very disoriented before the procedure due to dehydration and low blood pressure. He was delirious by the time of the procedure and even though we got him to hospital they wouldn't do it. He fell going up his path on the way home, hit his head and died of a brain bleed within a couple of days. The prep and the procedure are incredibly taxing in older people

SootylovesSue · 13/11/2026 08:19

Plenty of 74 year olds have surgery for bowel cancer and many will also be given chemo. Unless significant medical issues she should definitely be investigated. I thought you were going to say she was 90 and near housebound.

Mischance · 13/11/2026 08:46

There are two aspects here, one to do with how patients are treated as people and the other to do with the medical issues.

Firstly this consultant was just plain rude. This is unforgivable. Complain to PALS. I did this about one consultant and they were on to it in an instant and made sure I never had to see him again. I believe this was because they knew him of old and had received other complaints - adding yours to the mix is grist to their mill to deal with this person.

Secondly, he may have a point about the relative ultimate value of investigation and treatment - BUT the patient should have choice. The pros and cons should be explained in a gentle and honest manner and choices offered. And time given to think about it.

I had a positive FIT a few months ago followed by a negative one. I have now been found to have anaemia. There is a moderate index of suspicion that there is something of concern in the gut. I am on anticoagulants (because of coronary artery stent and pacemaker) which could go some way to explaining the signs and symptoms, and am being referred on. My expectations of that referral are that the relative pros and cons of the next steps will be discussed with me in a measured and kind fashion. I am not a good candidate for surgery because of my underlying heart problems and I know that.

The risks of endoscopy do exist but are very small and the scare tactics of the consultant your mother saw are inappropriate - a sensible discussion of what those risks might be is what should have happened and what we are all entitled to.

I am in my 70s and female and have never got the impression that I am treated with any less respect and concern (except for the horrid shouty guy referred to in my PALS complaint!) and I have been offered and had some highly expensive heart treatments irrespective of my age or gender. And there were many older people in the beds around me!

Your local PALS do need to know how you have been treated and you are entitled to ask for a second opinion for your mother from a different consultant.

hyggetyggedotorg · 13/11/2026 09:11

I’m so sorry to hear how your mum was spoken to. At 74 with no significant health issues she could easily have another happy & healthy 20 years of life yet! Of course she wants to know if she has cancer, quite apart from anything else it’s useful for family to know too from a genetic point of view.

I would definitely ask for a second opinion, is there another hospital close by that mum’s GP could refer her to?

Of course I totally understand that the Consultant has to fully explain the risks of any procedure & will sometimes have to say no to treating a patient due to the risks outweighing the potential benefit. However, that is a harrowing conversation for the patient (I was with my mum when it was explained to her that further chemo wasn’t appropriate as her liver was failing), and it is essential that conversations like this are dealt with as kindly & gently as possible. She was only a few years younger than your mum OP and definitely wasn’t ready to die.

I’m actually really angry on your behalf. I work in the NHS & recently had a fairly frail 88 year old patient have a CT colonoscopy as a standard colonoscopy would not have been suitable for her. I can’t see why it would be too much for your mum to have the same?

Plastron · 13/11/2026 09:15

Ultimately, @Peevedoff, your DM has had a test producing results of concern, has progressed to the next stage of seeing a medical professional, and has then been blocked from getting a diagnosis by his brusque and obstructive manner. That doesn’t sound remotely acceptable.

I’d agree with contacting PALS asap and exploring a second opinion. Your DM still doesn’t have a satisfactory explanation of her positive FIT test. What was he really suggesting she should do - just forget about it? FFS.

Whattodo127845 · 13/11/2026 09:20

I am so sorry. I feel like the NHS do not care about our aging population.

My Dad had bowel cancel, he had surgery at age 70 (in fact days before his 71st birthday). He also had prostate cancer which they left for months.

Long story short, on his final day an intensive care nurse said there was 'no point bothering' with additional treatment such as a ventilator. I was livid with the lack of compassion.

Fight for your Mum. She could still have treatment.

Littlecrake · 13/11/2026 09:22

It’s sounds absolutely weird. 74 with no major health problems is completely normal for a colonoscopy. You do need prep for a CT colonoscopy. My friend had surgery for a rectal tumour at 86 (although her referral said, rather hilariously, “this biologically elite lady”). I’m not in favour of frail, elderly people being subjected to endless tests that won’t change management, or challenging “treatments” that leave them feeling dreadful in their last months but this doesn’t sound like it’s the case.

Mrcollinswave · 13/11/2026 10:34

This is awful!
even if she is elderly and too frail for treatments intended to cure, she will qualify for palliative care!!
I hope the virtual CT will give you some answers.

Piglet89 · 13/11/2026 10:36

I simply do not tolerate this kind of poor communication skills (AKA rudeness), superiority and poor medical risk management from consultants. The vast majority I have met do not like intelligent people (women) with extremely high analytical skills questioning them. I am a lawyer: I’m always shocked by how poor their attention to detail is and how much they dislike my attempts to manage my own medical risk, as I assess it (given the information they tell me, supported by my own independent research).

I’d probably write to the head of the Trust to complain.

Bluebellcove · 13/11/2026 10:48

I have a relative who is 82, who was in hospital for 3 nights just so they could do the prep for them in hospital and do a polyp removal. And they have cancer but didn’t say don’t do the procedure, but how can we help it be the most successful.

Sparrowsandbudgies · 13/11/2026 12:15

Freemefromic · 12/11/2026 09:08

This is totally unacceptable. Contact PALS and tell them exactly what happened at that appointment. Tell them your mum wants to see a different consultant.

Do not be fobbed off.

Yes, this.

I think 74 and reasonably healthy all things considered she should absolutely not be dismissed like this!

I am 46 and have very complex, rare health issues. I’m on 26 meds a day and on long term PIP etc - to give you an idea of how unwell I am. I was whisked through having a colonoscopy and then a CT scan (as they did struggle to see one part of my bowel). The prep wasn’t fun - especially as one of my conditions means acute laxatives etc can be potentially fatal for me (Addisons disease) but it was okay and I’d do it again if I had to. Thankfully it was all okay but I have a strong history of bowel cancer in my family so needed checking. Definitely complain and push for tests!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page