Please or to access all these features

Cancer

Find advice & support if you or someone you know has been diagnosed with cancer

Consultant putting Mum off investigations

67 replies

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 08:00

Is this usual?

Mum had a positive FIT test and referral to a gastro consultant.

He wasnt particularly nice anyway and was pretty blunt. He said about investigations but then asked if there was any point, as if it is cancer she isnt fit for surgery anyway due to other issues.

We said well theres pros and cons of knowing at least.

Then he started going on about how aggressive and risky colonoscopies are, how aggressive the prep is. She could end up with a stoma, internal bleeding, the prep is awful and she'd struggle etc.

She ended up opting for a virtual CT colonoscopy in the end which he wasnt happy about. Again asked what the point would be, if theres poo in the way it wouldnt show anything. I said surely some prep is given for that and he said no.

It genuinely felt like a "well youre old, if its cancer we wont do anything so why waste time" 😔

OP posts:
JustaSongAboutPingPong · 12/11/2026 12:06

Another here who thought that you were going to say that she was in her 90s with co-morbidities.

A relative of ours has just had surgery at 92 and she is in a wheelchair.

Absolutely go through PALS. The way he spoke to both of you is unacceptable and your DM would perhaps benefit from a second opinion.

museumum · 12/11/2026 12:12

Why is she not 'fit for surgery'? You say she has circulation issues and mobility - is this something vascular which means she wouldn't heal?
I think that given his attitude I'd want to know more about why he feels that surgery isn't an option at age 74, or is it just bowel surgery? or cancer surgery? what if she breaks a hip tomorrow; will they just leave it?

TrickyD · 12/11/2026 13:52

I had a CT colonoscopy on Tuesday. The prep stuff tasted horrible but chilling it and using a straw helps. The colonoscopy itself was absolutely fine. A bit undignified but not painful at all and you are only in the big tube for a very few minutes, repeated several times.
I’m 82 by the way, and it all resulted from a FIT test, no other symptoms,

Branleuse · 12/11/2026 13:57

I think doctors seem extremely keen to discourage people from further testing and surgeries all the time now. I actually don't trust most of them anymore. I would seek further advice and opinions and keep options open

TrickyD · 12/11/2026 14:20

I’ve just re-read the OP, and can’t believe the consultant said there was no prep involved with a CT colonoscopy. The first question the radiographer said to me was ‘Did you do the prep?’

EmeraldRoulette · 12/11/2026 14:35

I’ve just reread the OP and I missed a lot the first time

Sorry, my brain wasn’t working and I was doing some other stuff at the same time.

There is actually a whole list of things to complain about with this guy and he’s either made some drastic mistakes, or there have been some misunderstandings.

Now wondering if it actually was the consultant you saw @Purplecatshopaholic I was thinking that is unlikely just for a positive fit test

Definitely check who you saw…. it’s amazing how much these people like to pretend that they’re someone else as well. I had to ask one associate about seven times before they admitted that they actually weren’t a doctor!

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 14:58

Thanks again everyone ❤️ ive done a bit more reading on here and Reddit of experiences and something def. isnt adding up.

I saw theres some diseases that are treatable (and do often need treating before they get worse) that can cause a positive fit test, AND as you say pp that prep is needed for a CT colonoscopy, and theres not many health conditions that actually discount you from a standard colonoscopy.

He 100% was trying his best to put her off. He kept saying it was so aggressive, risky. When he said so what's the point i was really shocked.

I just keep going back to my FIL who by all accounts should have died about a year ago with all his ailments yet here he is, still hanging in there, generally and surprisingly ok considering, having surgery and bits cut off and out of him and stents shoved in places and various procedures for stuff. Theres never any question over his investigations. Mums a bit doddery but nowhere near as bad as him 😔

I do think a second opinion is fair, will push for that for sure.

OP posts:
BruFord · 12/11/2026 15:03

I've had a colonoscopy (I'm 52) and so has my DH. They're not that bad, I'm not sure why he'd suggest they're so awful. Unless it's a special type of colonoscopy?

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 15:20

The issue according to what OP said is that even if it is cancer, OP's mother isn't fit for surgery anyway due to other issues.

Not the same situation as lots of other people saying they had colonoscopies.

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 15:24

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 15:20

The issue according to what OP said is that even if it is cancer, OP's mother isn't fit for surgery anyway due to other issues.

Not the same situation as lots of other people saying they had colonoscopies.

Thats not the point. The point is it would be good to know what she/we're dealing with, regardless of whether shes fit for any surgery.

And to be honest, I think a second opinion would be reasonable about that given this consultants attitude.

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 16:31

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 15:24

Thats not the point. The point is it would be good to know what she/we're dealing with, regardless of whether shes fit for any surgery.

And to be honest, I think a second opinion would be reasonable about that given this consultants attitude.

Edited

Yes I agree a second opinion is reasonable just wanted to point out it's not just a simple case of a consultant putting an elderly woman off getting a colonoscopy.

If OP's mother has other issues that make surgery not suitable (not sure about that as it's not too clear what the mother's issues are that make the consultant feel she wouldn't be suitable for surgery)

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 17:02

Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 16:31

Yes I agree a second opinion is reasonable just wanted to point out it's not just a simple case of a consultant putting an elderly woman off getting a colonoscopy.

If OP's mother has other issues that make surgery not suitable (not sure about that as it's not too clear what the mother's issues are that make the consultant feel she wouldn't be suitable for surgery)

Again its not about the surgery, the consultant was putting mum off just the investigations to find out if whatever it is would even require any surgery.

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 12/11/2026 17:06

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 17:02

Again its not about the surgery, the consultant was putting mum off just the investigations to find out if whatever it is would even require any surgery.

Ok well we all seem to agree on a second opinion anyway, if your mum wants that.

AFigureWalks · 12/11/2026 18:05

Your mum needs an investigation so she can make an informed decision about treatment and her life.
An investigation with a clear result would give her peace of mind!
I am wondering whether that doctor would have behaved in the same way with a male patient and companion.
You should complain to PALS. Something sounds very wrong with him.
I hope your mum is ok.

EmeraldRoulette · 12/11/2026 18:16

@Peevedoff i’m sorry if this comes across as pushy
I just wanted to make sure you’ve seen posters, including me saying that it may not have been the consultant that was in the meeting. The more I think about it the more I think that is likely.

BunfightBetty · 12/11/2026 18:17

Please raise a concern about him - about both his zeal to direct your mum away from investigations, and his lack of bedside manner. Shushing you is absolutely as far away from acceptable as it gets.

Doing so will hopefully get your mum in a position where she gets the investigations she wants and needs - not those a possibly ageist and arrogant doctor has decided she deserves. It might also stop somebody else being treated so spectacularly rudely, with a lack of patient-centred concern.

The days of patriarchal medicine are meant to be over. Somebody needs to make sure this one got the memo.

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 18:31

EmeraldRoulette · 12/11/2026 18:16

@Peevedoff i’m sorry if this comes across as pushy
I just wanted to make sure you’ve seen posters, including me saying that it may not have been the consultant that was in the meeting. The more I think about it the more I think that is likely.

Not pushy at all sorry i did see those and theyve definitely fed into me thinking somethings off.

He looked, how can i put this, "senior" 😬 but I got the feeling he isnt based there. Im annoyed I didnt write his name down but id remember it if I saw it. Hes not on their directory ive just checked

OP posts:
Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 18:34

Again this is awkward to say, but without wishing to stereotype (but I accept I am) i think perhaps hes from a culture where (generally) women dont speak up/challenge men iyswim.

OP posts:
dontrunintothedark · 12/11/2026 18:34

That's not a normal way to be treated, no.

In my experience the ones who refuse to calmly give you the clinical reason for their proposed course of action or inaction are the ones who don't have a valid clinical reason.

Just imagine how he behaves towards women attending alone. Please make a complaint and see someone else.

EmeraldRoulette · 12/11/2026 18:39

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 18:34

Again this is awkward to say, but without wishing to stereotype (but I accept I am) i think perhaps hes from a culture where (generally) women dont speak up/challenge men iyswim.

Don’t worry, I guessed that.

I think all things considered it’s possible you saw a Locum or you saw one of these newfangled consultants who has come in on the new portfolio pathway (don’t get me started).

You can look him up on the GMC register if you can track down the name. You might get some more information there.

I presume this was a GP referral was it? I would definitely report to the GP. Because you’ve been told a whole bunch of stuff that was wrong and your mum was not treated with respect.

Pearlstillsinging · 12/11/2026 18:40

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 09:00

Shes 74, not massively frail as such but does have mobility issues. She has circulation problems but no serious conditions, shes not taking umpteen meds a day type thing just some blood pressure meds and painkillers.

I think for us the point of the investigation would be to get an answer so she can either be relieved, or pragmatic about it. And the rather jarring point about wasting resources on her is a bit irrelevant at this stage given they dont know what resources she'll need, which investigations would help shed light on.

I have heard the prep is brutal, have also heard people say its nowhere near as bad as people make out. Young and elderly. My FIL has had it at least 4 times and he has heart and kidney failure and about 2 sheets of A4 of conditions (I wonder what the difference could possibly be between them 🙄)

re: personal feelings - its my mum that would want to know what shes dealing with, or not.

It just felt really off. Especially now I have done a bit of research and have seen prep/colonoscopies, while harsher on older people, are still generally low risk.

He got quite angry with me at one point when I was asking for clear reasons for why he was so against investigations IF she is actually fit for those - and he didnt refute this - he just kept saying whats the point and wasnt listening when she told him why.

I would want a 2nd opinion. The Consultant sounds dreadful.
A 70 yr old friend had a colonoscopy and a gastroscopy recently and has since been very pleased to have the correct treatment for her condition, which didn't include surgery.

She takes blood pressure tablets and has a pace-maker and has one replacement hip, while waiting for another but it was never suggested that she shouldn't have the investigations

mysittingduck · 12/11/2026 18:47

SpamIAm · 12/11/2026 08:05

If they aren’t able to treat then it seems reasonable to point out that the potential harm caused by investigations will be for no benefit.

This. Colonoscopies can be painful and cause further problems. Not worth it unless likely to be followed by useful treatment.

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 18:50

mysittingduck · 12/11/2026 18:47

This. Colonoscopies can be painful and cause further problems. Not worth it unless likely to be followed by useful treatment.

She wants to know what shes facing, if anything.

Thats not unreasonable. Especially as it could be something else.

OP posts:
Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 18:51

EmeraldRoulette · 12/11/2026 18:39

Don’t worry, I guessed that.

I think all things considered it’s possible you saw a Locum or you saw one of these newfangled consultants who has come in on the new portfolio pathway (don’t get me started).

You can look him up on the GMC register if you can track down the name. You might get some more information there.

I presume this was a GP referral was it? I would definitely report to the GP. Because you’ve been told a whole bunch of stuff that was wrong and your mum was not treated with respect.

Yes gp referral under 2ww for a "specialist opinion"

OP posts:
mysittingduck · 12/11/2026 18:52

Peevedoff · 12/11/2026 18:50

She wants to know what shes facing, if anything.

Thats not unreasonable. Especially as it could be something else.

Then she should get a second opinion
as pp said.