Girls name to match Eve

[Evmamai]

Hi all, we have a toddler named Eve and are expecting a second baby girl in March. We found picking Eve’s name super easy and even now she suits it’s so well. Her full name is Eve Alexandra.
Our shortlist right now is

• Zara
• May
• Isla
• Grace

However none feel quite right, I love May but DH worries that two single syllable 3 letter names is a bitch match. I also love Isla but it is very popular. DH loves Grace but I went to school with. Girl who was cruelly nicknamed “Greasy Grace” and now I hear grease when ever I hear Grace. Zara is another of my preferences but DH says it makes him think of the shop!

So any ideas or suggestions? Our surname is McManus.

Eve and Ava Elizabeth
Eve and Willow Charlotte
Eve and Wren Louise
Eve and May Elizabeth
Eve and Lucy Anne
Eve and Maya Elizabeth

I would personally look for names similar to your list

So Isla could be Ailsa
May could be Maya
Grace could be Greta

Jane/Jayne
Tess
Clara

Lia/Leah?

Yes I like that

My very horrible next door neighbours have two daughters, Eve is the elder and Grace the younger.

I don't like Zara (agree with your husband), and the other two names are rather blah.

I'd suggest Stella, or perhaps a virtue name such as Mercy or Charity. All would work well with McManus.

My favourites are Zara 10/10 and Grace 9/10.
Other ideas..
Eve Alexandra and ..

Sara Isobel
Grace Belinda
Lila Grace
Skye Eloise
Sarah Elizabeth