I knew it was popular when we chose it, but we had such trouble finiding a boys name we agreed on at all, that when dp suggested it after months of suggesting silly names just to be a pita (Jarvis? Zadock? Cruz?) it just seemed right. He was almost called Jude, which seems so so wrong for him now!!!
And really, kids don't mind having popular names that much. In our class in school there were 5 Steven/Stephen's. Every one was called something different, a nickname, a surname etc Not one of them minded, they were all close friends!