Emma, Anna & ?

[Sensibly]

My DH and I have 2 daughters, we are now expecting a 3rd child rather unexpectedly and finding names impossible. Alot of the names we love have been used by other relatives or aren't useable. Our girls are -
Emma Felicity Jane Lloyd and Anna Eleanor May Lloyd.
Names we like and can't use are
Lucy (Lucy Lloyd seems a bit much)
Katie (niece)
Sophie (family friends child)
Beth
Alice
Lydia (Lydia Lloyd seems L, Y, D heavy)
We like but don't love Zara and Mary but we could use these (my mum is Mary but would be nice tribute and MILs name is one of the girls middle names already)

Sam (Nephew)
Liam
Daniel
William
Edward
Henry
Lucas
Oscar
Oliver
George
All unusable

We like Harry and James, potentially useable (in the family but not close)

Any ideas? We like more timeless, unlikely to date names and matching them with longer middle names which have good meaning then a family names, ideally the first name is no more than 5 letters, 2 syllables.
Any ideas?

I think
Mary Catherine Faye or Zara Catherine May are perfectly lovely but DH isn't convinced.
James Anthony George is lovely too in my opinion.

I was going to say Sophie after reading your daughters names, I wouldn't let a family friends child having it stop me either but understand why you might.
Sophie and Emily were my top girls choices, but Emily is too close to Emma to have in the same house I think! (I do love Emma too but that's my best friends name and I wouldn't give her the satisfaction!)

I also quite like Eliza, Aida, Eleanor, Louisa

Boys I love Thomas, Elijah, Ethan, Matthew, Jonathan, James, Nate (nn)

Dora Mary?

How about Isla or Lila?

Tessa fits the pattern of your other names. I think Otto does for a boy.

Girls;
Tessa
Rosa
Zara
Clara
Bella

Catherine Mary are nice as middle names.

Boys:
Otto
Alex
Leo
Leon
Theo

Rosa is gorgeous
Harriet or Jack

Not read the whole thread but Emma and Anna are famous eponymous literary heroines (ala the Austen novel and Anna Karenina) as well as being very pretty, simple and classic/timeless, so I'd personally look for something similar, especially for another girl.

Mary works well (so many great literary namesakes!) but maybe slightly old fashioned compared to still popular Anna and Emma? Zara works well in sound with Anna and Emma (repeated letters/number of syllables) but possibly a bit modern sounding compared to her sisters names.

My pick would be similar but slightly more classic Lara (Dr Zhivago and fits very well in sound with Anna and Emma)
But there's also Tess (D'Urbervilles)?
Charlotte (Bronte/the Webb) is possibly too long?
Jane (Austen/Eyre) great match but bit old fashioned again?
Nina (Bawden) - less popular but good match in sound?

Shame you can't have William for a boy (ultimate author name!) or Samuel (lots of writers too) or Oliver (Twist). But I think your suggestion of James (Joyce/or the Giant Peach) is a really great match to timeless Anna and Emma. Other classic alternatives:

Adam (Bede) if you don't mind the same initial as Anna?
Or Charles (Dickens/ or the Chocolate Factory)?

Panna

I like alliterative names btw so I don't think Lara Lloyd is too much (so I think Lydia Lloyd is lovely too! I've just never been that keen on the name Lucy 😂)

Emma, Anna and Otto
Emma, Anna and Ulla

I actually know 3 sisters called Emma, Anna and Lucy which I think goes nicely

Sorry posted without reading the full intro. Lucy Lloyd sounds lovely imp

Emma Felicity Jane, Anna Eleanor May and ..

Bridget Mary Catherine
Charlotte Mary Catherine
Sophie Rose Catherine
Skye Rosemary Catherine
Rosa Mary Catherine
Harriet Rose Rebecca
Mary Scarlett Louise
Fergus George Antony
James Alexander George
Cedric James Dominic
Louis James David
Cecil Antony George
Charles Alister James
Hugh Nicholas Barry

Your daughters have lovely names!

Not going to lie I spent entirely too much time on this and had entirely too much fun lol

Ideas for Emma Felicity Jane Lloyd, Anna Eleanor May Lloyd and...

Thea Mary Quinn
Haley Catherine Eve
Eden Elizabeth Faye
Lena Anne Marie
Maeve Josette June
Sarah Cassidy Claire
Stella Catherine Rose
Tess Annelise Fleur
Ivy Abigail Faye
Mia Nicolette Faye
Hope Whitney Jane
Willa Mary Catherine
Kara Catherine Ivy nn KC/Casey if she likes
Meg Madalyn Faye
Renee Isabelle Sloane

Evan Jasper George
Sean William Rhys
Holden George Grant
Dean Benedict George
Wells Alexander James
Adam Anthony Reid
Neil Hawthorne Phillip
Lance Warren James
Clark Cedric James
(Quin) Quentin Taylor James
Cole Sebastian George
Jay Sterling Isaac
Ryan Bellamy Grant

Olivia
Sophie
Grace

I used to work in a company where there were 3 girls in one office, Anna, Emma & Suzanne.

SO that's my suggestion!

I thought Belle. I have a James Sebastian and Luke Dennis and a Daisy Jayne. Mary, Oliver, Benjamin and Maximilian were also high up the list

Sarah
Flora
Stella
Clara
Sophie
Rebecca
Phoebe
Frances
Claudia
Charlotte
Caroline

Catherine Mary Victoria
Christopher Andrew James

Virginia
Esther
Catherine
Sophia
Claudia
Charlotte
Rosa(mund)
Daisy
Polly
Posy

Flora, Clara, Rosa or Eliza.

Naomi

Before even reading your main post I thought of Lucy! I think Lucy Lloyd sounds amazing, and if anyone can pull it off.... it's the third child.

Lucy my first thought on seeing the girls names or Jane

Thomas or James for a boy

My first thought was Emma, Anna and Louisa.

For a boy I like Emma, Anna and Spencer

I also think Lucy is lovely and Lucy Lloyd sounds great!
Naomi is gorgeous. I hadn’t thought of that one.
I like Imogen and Natasha as well.

Stella