Emma, Anna & ?

[Sensibly]

My DH and I have 2 daughters, we are now expecting a 3rd child rather unexpectedly and finding names impossible. Alot of the names we love have been used by other relatives or aren't useable. Our girls are -
Emma Felicity Jane Lloyd and Anna Eleanor May Lloyd.
Names we like and can't use are
Lucy (Lucy Lloyd seems a bit much)
Katie (niece)
Sophie (family friends child)
Beth
Alice
Lydia (Lydia Lloyd seems L, Y, D heavy)
We like but don't love Zara and Mary but we could use these (my mum is Mary but would be nice tribute and MILs name is one of the girls middle names already)

Sam (Nephew)
Liam
Daniel
William
Edward
Henry
Lucas
Oscar
Oliver
George
All unusable

We like Harry and James, potentially useable (in the family but not close)

Any ideas? We like more timeless, unlikely to date names and matching them with longer middle names which have good meaning then a family names, ideally the first name is no more than 5 letters, 2 syllables.
Any ideas?

I think
Mary Catherine Faye or Zara Catherine May are perfectly lovely but DH isn't convinced.
James Anthony George is lovely too in my opinion.

Otto
Bob
Asa

Ada
Ava
Eve

I think Clara Catherine Mary or Sarah Catherine Mary would work well with Emma and Anna.

I like Kieran for a boy, Emma, Anna and Kieran.

Alexandra
Claire or Clara
Amelia
Sophie
Ella
Isabella
Delilah

Oscar
William
Noah
Albert
George
Joseph
Theodore
Wiliam
Anthony

A lot of criteria OP.

I wouldn’t go with another ending in an A sound.

Emma, Anna and Kate
Emma, Anna and Ruby
Emma, Anna and Phoebe
Emma, Anna and Tess

Emma, Anna and Richard
Emma, Anna and Benjamin
Emma, Anna and Fraser
Emma, Anna and Caleb
Emma, Anna and Joseph

Rebecca.

My sisters, cousins, daughter and I already account for a lot of names on your "like" or "already have" list. Rebecca is the main one you are missing!

Frances

What about Lara?

I like James

What about Lara?

I like James

Juliet/ Julia

I like the idea of another name ending in a. Fortunately there are lots, so some of them must be usable.

I know a Mora, and I think it’s a lovely name. Also Cara, Ida, Laura, Rosa - all fairly traditional names that go ok with Emma and Anna.

It’s a bit harder to find names ending in a for a boy, but there are some e.g. Luca or Dara.

Oh I do like Rosa, Rosa Catherine Faye Lloyd, I like that!!

My daughter is Rosa! So obviously I think it's the best name. We get lots of compliments on it. Came here to say Rosa, or perhaps a one syllable name like Rose, Faye as first name, or Maeve

Alba

i like Lydia Lloyd too

Tess

Nell

Georgia

jasmine

rose

Rosa Mary Lloyd

Mary or Daniel I think would go with your current names. I particularly love Mary and it never gets used despite it being a classic

You need to ask MN to edit the name Lloyd out of your OP, as well as the middle names. Your children could easily be recognized as the OP stands currently.

Una Mary Catherine Lloyd or
Robyn Olivia Mary Lloyd

James Anthony George Lloyd or
Max Christopher James Lloyd

If it's a boy please call him Otto 🙏

I have the same name as one of your daughters and my two sisters both have names on your like but not using list, that’s really tickled me 😁

Emma Anna and Samantha - are my cousins

So that is the only name I can add!

Samantha Lloyd would work?

Thea or Harriet x

I don't think you should reuse any middle name.

Marina Catherine Faye
Maya Catherine Faye (pr My-ah)
Maria Catherine Faye
Mara Catherine Faye
Vita Catherine Faye
Grace Catherine Faye
Keira Catherine Faye
Cora Catherine Faye
Rosa Catherine Faye
Sara Catherine Faye

Eloise?