Classic girly names that aren’t too common

[HayDiscoFever]

DC2 due in 2 weeks and not 100% on any names.
Surname begins with D and is 2 syllables, would really like May as a middle name in memory of my mum.
Currently considering Tabitha (Tabby) but unsure if that sounds a bit ‘posh’ or Harriet (Hattie).
Any similar suggestions please?

Eliza
Violet
Annabel
Xanthe
Genevieve
Cecily
Francesca
Gabriella

Imogen
India
Eloise
Florence

Felicity
Verity
Constance
Emmeline
Elizabeth
Annaliese
Madeleine
Rosalind
Miranda

Miranda

Alexandra

Rosalind

Helena

Honor

Eleanor

@MojoJojo71

Great minds… @RickOShay

Miriam

Jemima
Imogen
Eloise
Samantha
Letitia

Would you call her May? It's v popular as a middle name or hyphenated with something else in front of it but it seems less often used as a first name in its own right?

Ah I love the name Harriet, it’s lovely.
Some off the top of my head, Lydia, Felicity, Georgina, Josephine, Imogen, Cressida, Beatrice.

Veronica
Rowena
Eleanor
Rebecca
Josephine
Tessa

I do like May but think prefer it as a middle name.
Great suggestions thank you.
Do people think Tabitha is a bit ‘posh’?!

I love Tabitha and Harriet.

Also

Nancy
Charlotte
Bethany
Beatrice
Matilda
Penny

Minnie
Annabelle
Violet
Eliza
Lucy
Martha
Bonnie
Charity
Eleanor
Lara

Catherine, Elizabeth, Mary, Martha, Victoria

Susanna
Sophy ( English spelling)
Georgia

Caroline

Elsie

Annie
Camilla
Emily
Felicity
Georgia
Honour
Margot
Nell
Penelope
Sienna
Tess
Ursula
Verity

Love Georgia, Penelope and Madeleine!

Tabitha is a beautiful name, classy, definitely not overly 'posh'

I don't think Tabitha is too posh at all to be honest. It's just a lovely normal name. Just wondering, what to you mean by not too common. You said you liked Penelope, but that was 41st most popular name in in England and Wales last year. For me, that would be too popular, but I'm nor sure where your cut off point it. Just a side note the Darkgreener website is great for quickly checking a name's popularity and quickly seeing if it is on an upward trajectory. Here are names you might like, all out of the top 300.
Camilla
Cecilia
Claudia
Isadora
Jessamine
Louisa
Mirabelle
Ramona
Rosemary
Susanna
Vita

Georgiana
Eloise
Amelia

Abigail
Hannah
Alicia
Serena

Was going to say Hannah, previous poster beat me to it