Classic girly names that aren’t too common

[HayDiscoFever]

DC2 due in 2 weeks and not 100% on any names.
Surname begins with D and is 2 syllables, would really like May as a middle name in memory of my mum.
Currently considering Tabitha (Tabby) but unsure if that sounds a bit ‘posh’ or Harriet (Hattie).
Any similar suggestions please?

Darcey
Jennifer
Therese /Tessa
Natalie
Charlotte
Catherine /Cora

Tallulah nn Tully
Eunice
Jocelyn
Cassandra
Alyssa
Lucinda

If you like Hattie what about Hettie as a nickname for either Henrietta or Hester?

I love Chloe and Sophie.

Tabitha's lovely, it is a bit posh but I don't think there's anything wrong with having a posh name
Maeve could be a potential?

What does it matter if it’s “posh”? What difference does it make?

Bella
Bessie
Philippa
Stephanie
Louisa
Maria
Martha

Clarissa
Corinna
Jessica
Marguerite
Miranda
Dulcie
Delphine
Regina

Antonia?

Alexandra
Henrietta
Rosalind
Hester
Serena

I wouldn't have associated Tabitha with posh at all! I actually think of the witch of the same name from bewitched (1970's, US comedy).

Julia
Julieann
Matilda
Rochelle
Daniella/ Danielle
Elizabeth
Melinda
Belinda
Izella
Kristen
Kirsten
Fleur
Stella

Cecile
Violet
Constance known as Connie
Iris
Mary
Charlotte- but is quite popular
Florence
Philippa
Rosalind
Honor
Lucy
Elodie
Fiona

Tabitha isn't posh in the least It's great on a cat, but horrid (and weird) on a human.

Harriet/Hattie is really nice.

Jennifer May
Catherine May
Sarah May
Victoria May
Alexandra May
Francesca May
Rachel May
Elizabeth May

Rebecca May
Laura May
Erin May
Hannah May
Joanna May

Eileen

Rebecca May
Rosalind May
Rowena May
Henrietta May
Susannah May
Tallulah May
Phillipa May
Edwina May
Evelyn May
Georgiana May
Hermione May
Yvonne May
Gillian May

Veronica
Alison
Judith
Lisa
Bethany

Emma May

Tabitha and Harriet are lovely. (I don't see Tabitha as posh).
I would go with one of those - they exactly meet your criteria.
So do:
Miranda
Constance
Cecily
Cecilia
Eleanor (though a bit more popular?)
Rowena
Susannah
Jemima
Henrietta

Penelope and Margot would have met the criteria a few years ago but are zooming up the popularity charts.

Prefer Harriet to Tabitha, but neither seem too ‘posh’ to me.

Philippa (Pippa)
Meredith
Arabella (Bella)
Beatrice
Cassandra (Cassie)
Helena
Cecilia
Delphine
Hermione
Rosalind
Constance (Connie)
Virginia (Ginny)

Tabitha is my favourite girls name ever. I had boys but if I’d had a DD she would 100% have been Tabitha.

I have a teenage Georgia and you hardly hear anyone else called it . She’s now just called George .

Outside the top 100 (E&W):

Juliet
Rosa
Leah
Verity
Serena
Cassia
Cassandra
Victoria
Sarah
Gabriella
Naomi
Amy
Alicia
Georgina
Josephine
Helena
Rosalie/Rosanna/Rosalind/Rosemary
Phillipa
Emmeline
Jennifer
Evangeline
Natalie
Frances
Louisa
Henrietta
Adele
Seraphina
Larissa

I like Tabitha. I don't see it as a posh name at all. I also like Harriet with the nickname Hattie, I think that's very cute.

Other ideas -
Constance (Connie)
Josephine (Josie)
Emmeline
Lydia
Martha
Anastasia
Gabriella
Bethany
Esther
Frances