Judge my shortlist!

[Charlotte2020]

We've whittled down to:
Ivy
Astrid
Imogen
Freya
Eva

I can't decide which one!

Imogen or Freya.

They're all lovely names!

Astrid
Imogen
Freya

Are my favourites, have you any ideas for a middle name? Try saying the entire name with your surname does any go better?

I like them all but every other female toddler seems to be a version of Eva, Ava so I wouldn't go for Eva because of that.

In order of preference:
1=Ivy
1=Eva

1. Freya
2. Imogen
3. Astrid

Nice list! Not useful but like them all! Which go better with surname?

Love Astrid then Ivy.

Eva and Freya are too popular and will get lost among the many similar ‘a’ ending names.
Don’t really like Imogen.

Ivy absolutely! DS had a teacher called Ivy and I always thought what a lovely name it was. Beautifully simple but (in my neck of the woods anyway) pretty uncommon.

Ivy - ok, don’t love it
Astrid - really don’t like this name, think it just doesn’t sound nice at all
Imogen - nice as well, I know a small one who is called Immy
Freya - really nice, not too popular but not outlandish
Eva - popular if that bothers you but a lovely, simple and pretty name

I like them all! Imogen, Freyja and Ivy are on my list. I prefer Eve (on my list) to Eva. Like Astrid and indeed many Scandi names but I’m not sure on the ass- start, prefer Ingrid (also on my list).

1. Astrid - lovely, up and coming but not very much used right now

Joint 1. Freya - am liking the Scandie theme! Lovely name - very popular a while ago, but less common now I think (check on darkgreener if it bothers you).

1. Ivy - I like it but it is becoming v popular
2. Imogen - I don’t love it personally but it’s a nice name and not super popular
3. Eva - lovely but there are SO many Eve/Eva/Ava/Evelyns I would avoid unless it’s the only name you like

Ivy - 4/10
Astrid - 1/10
Imogen - 3/10
Freya - 6/10
Eva - 8/10

Imogen

Ivy then Imogen.
The others seem very of the moment which is fine if you like them.

Imogen

My preference:
Imogen
Freya
Astrid
Ivy
Eva

I spent all day yesterday ripping ivy off trees and now can’t remember why I ever thought Ivy was a nice name, horrible parasitic plant, and Eva is lovely but so so popular.

They are all lovely names!
I think Astrid is possibly my favourite though.
Great choices OP.

My top two would be (in no particular order) :
Freya
Eva

A great list
Imogen is my favourite
So underused these days and descending in the charts every year, which is a good sign if that sort of thing matters to you

Ivy.

Imogen, Eva and Freya far too popular and Astrid I just don't really like, but Ivy is pretty but unfussy.

Freya

Astrid is my favourite on this list. Imogen next.

I know lots of baby / toddler Ivy, Freya, And Eva.

Ivy - don't like
Astrid - like but it's popular
Imogen - fine but I don't like Immy
Freya - overused so a bit meh, Frey isn't very nice
Eva - overused and I don't like it

Ivy - ok, but indistinct from all of the Evies and Avas and Islas
Astrid - really like Astrid, by far my favourite on this list. It’s strong and consonant heavy. Very refreshing
Imogen - it’s nice. I know several Imogens my age
Freya - overused and dull
Eva - similar to Ivy, though I do prefer Eva

Ivy - Really like this. Sounds very whimsical and pretty. Not common either.

Astrid - My favourite. Love it.

Imogen - Nice but a bit plain.

Freya - Boring. Overused.

Eva - As above. There seems to be a million Eva, Eve, Evelyn, Ella's around.