Critique my boys list please

[cantdecide123]

Please let me know your thoughts on my shortlist....

Freddie
Joel
Max
Elliot
Jack
Leo

Already have DS1 called Isaac

I like Joel and Leo the best with Isaac

Joel ... love it
Followed by Leo

My 16wo is called Leo so this is clearly my fave by far!
Not a huge fan of Joel, I dont know why but sounds a bit wishy-washy to me.
Max always makes me think of a dog.
I thiink Isaac and Elliot go nicely together

Love Isaac.
I like Max, Leo and Jack - in that order.
I don't like Elliot
Really, really dislike Freddie and Joel.

Isaac is lovely, I'd go for Joel or Elliot.

I like Max and Jack best, they’re on my list too. Joel and Leo are also nice.

Joel or Leo

Joel goes lovely with Isaac.

I do like Jack aswell.

Lovely list of names OP. The only one I don't like is Freddie. My favourites are Max and Elliot.

Youve essentially listed my child’s classmates

Absolutely nothing wrong with any of them, but I I would consider all of them fairly popular. If that matters to you

joel or leo

Another vote for Joel

Another vote for Joel or Leo

Thanks everyone finding it much harder to decide this time round so it's great to have others' views

Leo! So lovely xx

My DS is Max but i liked Elliot too

Freddie - love
Joel -dislike
Max - love
Elliot - love
Jack - love
Leo -love

Elliot or Joel. Both lovely.

Joel is lovely. I like Elliot as well.

Love max and jack, Leo and Freddie both very over used

Leo and Joel are my favourites for Isaac's brother.

Freddie is Krueger to me so a definite no.

Other than that in order from best to worst:
Max
Elliot
Joel
Leo
Jack

Actively like the first three, the last two I'm less keen on, but I don't know if that's just that the two together make me think of Titanic (Jack, played by Leo)

I'm also not so keen on Jack with Isaac because of them both ending in the same sound.

I think Joel probably goes best with Isaac

I’m not going with the others, I love Leo and I love Freddie. Don’t like Joel, but that’s a personal reason :)

You could go Old Testament to find a match for Isaac - maybe not Hezekiah or Job - but on your list Leo is the standout for me! It works for a cuddly baby, a gangly teen and a serious grown up too.

I think you should discount jack and max as when you say the 2 boys names they're a bit rhymey.

Isaac and jack
Isaac and max

Just sounds a bit odd!

Isaac and Joel
Isaac and Leo

These sound better!

I don't like Freddie, it's too popular.