A sister for Sylvie

[MrsCantthinkofaname]

Really want a pretty, vintage name to go with Sylvie that is underused but not too out there. We’ve finally agreed on the below shortlist so just wanted some help to pick a favourite.

Pearl
Olive
April
Clementine (Clemmie)
Etta (Ettie)
Theodora - (Dot, Dora, Teddy etc - love the variety of nicknames for this)
Mabel

Would love to hear people’s thoughts.
Thanks!

Pearl!

Clementine or Etta. I like the matchy nicknames.
Aurelie
Marguerite or Margot
Aimee
Amelie
Sophie

Avril rather than April

We have a Sylvie too!!

I like most of your names. Clemmie and Etta would be my favourites of those two. I also like Cleo.

Congrats on your pregnancy

Xxx

Clementine is my favourite.

Pearl or Margot.

Mabel or Etta

Just realised Margot isn't on your list, got muddled up with other suggestions. Out of your list I like Pearl, although all are lovely!

Olive!!

Otherwise Etta, congrats

You’ve literally just listed some of my DREAM girls names @MrsCantthinkofaname - what a stunning list!

Pearl - LOVE
Olive - LOVE
April - LOVE
Clementine (Clemmie) - LOVE
Etta (Ettie) - LOVE
Theodora - (Dot, Dora, Teddy etc - love the variety of nicknames for this) - LOVE
Mabel - LOVE

HA! Was going to try and be constructive with my comments but I just adore all of them. Favourites Olive, Etta, Clemmie and Mabel I think

Love Clementine and Theodora!

Theodora

Mabel. Or Edith. Or Marnie - I love Marnie at the mo!

The only one I don’t like is clementine - only because it get shortens to Clemmie or clem and it reminds me of phlegm!

Mabel

Etta or Theadora, love both!

Really dislike Clementine because of Clem/Phlegm Clemmie/Phlegmie - obviously I’m not the only one

I love them all! Clementine, Etta and Pearl are probably my favourites with Sylvie. I love Theodora too but it’s quite different in style to me, even though the nicknames are all gorgeous. Mabel also goes beautifully!

Pearl, April and Clementine would go well.

Theodora (or Polydora?) and Mabel, but also love the suggestion of Margot (or Margaux).

Olive ...definitely my favourite!

I like Pearl, April, Clementine and Mabel. April is my fav I think.

Pearl is lovely but seems to be quite a popular choice where I live - there are 4 spread out in 3 toddler groups we go to.

What about Opal?

All pretty names though Theodora is my favourite. My Mother was a Sylvia and her sister’s name was Margot.