Imogen or Autumn?

[Newday1]

Just that really.
Which would you choose?
Thanks

I like both but I would and did pick Imogen.
Just checking you like any of the following nn: Immie, Idgy, Imz, Iggy and Mog.

@Newday1 husband got his way "Charlotte" in the end and to be honest I regretted not pushing for one of my choices harder but she's nearly 2 now and she has grown into her name. I also loved Aria and Elizabeth.

icecreamsundae32 my husbands favourite name is Charlotte, looks like we have similar taste. But as my name is Charlotte that was a no go. I love my name and only ever got compliments so think it's a fab choice.

Really like Aria as well

@icecreamsundae32 Charlotte is a gorgeous name! I’m the same though- let my husband cajole me into a name I wasn’t sure of!!

Imogen is my favourite, but I am biased as that is my daughters name! They're both great names though x

Imogen

Imogen.

I really like the name Autumn. But to echo a bit of an MN obsession: it doesn't seem to nickname well at all? I have no idea how it would shorten....
With that in mind I'd say Imogen but only by a small margin!
Both good choices imo

Imogen. I’m not keen on season names.

Both gorgeous

There will be approximately three Imogens in your child’s class at school (I’m teacher and drowning in Isabellas, Evies, Darcys, Islas and Tillys).

However I would also be careful about Autumn dating quickly.

Tricky choice.

Autumn Charlotte plus your surname. That works well, this way you're honoured as her birth mother. Plus you get the first name that you like.

I really like both!

Imogen is one of my favourite girls names. Autumn is pretty but I wouldn’t like to introduce myself as that though it would be fine as a second name.

When is baby due? A February baby called autumn seems odd. Not keen on Imogen really.

I like both very much.
My DB had a classmate in the early '90s called Autumn and she was the most beautiful girl I'd ever seen

@Newday1 imogen has actually been declining in popularity since 2010 when it reached it peak

Whilst a couple of years ago I can see there may have been more than 1 imogen in a class, that’s statistically very unlikely now @thunderthighsohwoe

In fact imogen looks set to leave the top 50 names soon

Look at the graph showing the Uk statistics if you want proof

names.darkgreener.com/#imogen

Imogen! Dd is Imogen and is the only one in her school. As a teacher I’ve only ever taught 1 Imogen in 10 years so in don’t think it’s that popular depending on where you live.

Personally, I prefer Imogen. But i think it is whatever you prefer really!

What are you thinking now @Newday1 ? Which name?

Imogen.
Autumn seems a bit Instagram for me.

Imogen

Love both
Imogen Autumn would be fab.
Of the two I think if I had to choose the one though it would be Imogen.

Depends if you want an option to shorten the name. Immy/Imi works. Aut doesn't.

Thanks everyone for your posts!
I thought Imogen would be far more popular due to it being a bit more mainstream so I am pleasantly surprised to see it really is 50/50.

Currently we are leaning towards Autumn as I like the slightly more unusual factor.

I'm not sure if Autumn Imogen works as a first and second name. Bit of a mouthful! And it doesn't seem any names we like work with Autumn.

For example:

• Autumn Charlotte (DH fav name is Charlotte/my first name)
• Autumn Faith
• Autumn Sienna
• Autumn Imogen

Feel like it's impossible.

Any thoughts? x