Max, Hugo and...?

[Sharksandfishes]

Girl this time. We have:
Annabelle
Nancy
Florence
Lydia
Mabel

We have the most common surname (have name changed for this). And we live in Australia (not sure why that matters!)

If anyone is interested, we went with Clara in the end!

Anna (not Annabelle). Annabel if you must, but Anna is more classic and goes so well with Max and Hugo.

Oh, Clara is nice!

Congrats.

Lydia or Nancy

Other suggestions:
Clara
Mary

I immediately thought of Louise/a or Flora, tbh...

1. Lydia
2. Annabelle
3. Florence
4. Nancy

1. Mabel

I personally dislike Mabel but your other names are lovely.

Florence
Ariadne
Millicent

With a plain surname you can afford to go a little fancier with the first name. I think Nancy is too plain in this case. Mabel is awful, no matter the surname, in my opinion. I like Lydia, but Annabelle (prefer Annabel) and Florence are nice too.

Annalise

Annabelle

Clara is gorgeous! Congratulations op!!

Bakewell Farts - I LOVE Ariadne - and Antigone.

How about:

Lucinda
Juliet

Oh - just scrolled up, I love Clara. Hugo and Max are brilliant too, Guy if you have another boy.

I thought Lawrence when I saw Max and Hugo...so I’d say Florence 😁

From your list Nancy, I also thought Alice would go well with your other names.

Florence in Australia at the moment is quite the bachelorette apparently (it’s not as popular there as here in general as a name)