Which suits her better? 2 names!

[user1497628977]

We had a girl (we didn't know the sex!) and have 2 names. Madison and Scarlet. We know that Maddison and Scarlett are more popular, but I do prefer the original spelling of Madison and the colour spelling of Scarlet.

Which suits her better? Surname is double-barrelled.

Thanks!

Scarlet

So beautiful, congratulations!

Madison nn Maddie I think really suits her. Please not another Scarlet, so many around at the moment and it does sound quite tacky, nn 'scar' puts me off completely

Scarlet goes way better with Juliana than Maddison!

Maddison has too many syllables to flow with it.

She looks like a Madison. She's gorgeous. Congratulations!

Definitely Scarlet. I don't think it matters that you have a noun in your surname as I gather it is not Pimpernel (not a nature word).
She is absolutely beautiful, OP

She is absolutely beautiful She looks just like a Scarlet to me.