Down to 2 names...

[Nham123]

Think we have finally whittled name choices down to two girls names and would appreciate opinions please! :) we already have a daughter called Isla so would like it to go with her name too.

So.. Poppy or Imogen? What do you think?

[NotYoda]

Imogen

[BoboBunnyH0p]

Imogen, I think the Imogen and Isla sound find together, just make sure they have different middle initial so they don't mix up post.

[Agadooo]

Poppy-no Prob with two 'I' names if you really like Imogen though. How's about Ava?

[CPtart]

Imogen.

[Sparklingsky]

Imagen does sound classic. However - if you remove cultural references and listen to the actual sounds IMHO Imagen doesn't fair well - unlike Isla. Poppy is better in this regard. Ava is even better.

[Sparklingsky]

Imogen

[crayfish]

Imogen by a million miles.

[nectarini1983]

Poppy

[pleasethankyouthankyouplease]

Poppy. Knew a dreadful Imogen....clods my view of the name!

[pleasethankyouthankyouplease]

No, doesn't clod. That's what I am. It clouds-CLOUDS my view

[1horatio]

Imogen :)

[WineCheeseSleep]

I love both but I'll vote for Imogen. I think it sounds lovely with Isla too.

[JugglingFromHereToThere]

Poppy - I like flower names and they are such cheerful flowers, such a gorgeous colour. And something a child can relate to from a young age which I think is lovely - "I called you Poppy after this beautiful red flower" - as you walk through fields of gold together
All blessings to you all whichever you decide

[Sophronia]

Definitely Imogen. Poppy just makes me think of 'popping' things.

[BertrandRussell]

Imogen.

Imo is a lovely shortening. And so is Immie.

Poppy is a name for a cat.

[LowAMH]

Imogen

[Bellasima20]

100% Poppy - can not stand Imogen, just twee and pretentious.

[Scattymere]

Another vote for Poppy. Also adore flower names. Imogen sound clunky and boring, but know a few mums who chose it because they think it sounds really classy. It doesn't (to me anyway). Imy is also most sickly nn I've heard arrggh!!

[squoosh]

Poppy is WAY more twee than Imogen.

[Dixxie]

Both lovely names

[lizziet123]

Imogen.

IMHO Isla and Imogen flow better than Isla and poppy. Both lovely names tho. Congratulations! X

[LadyAntonella]

Poppy

[Pipilangstrumpf]

I wouldn't have two same gender siblings with the same initial (can get confusing when mail is addressed to Miss I. Surname).

But I don't like Poppy at all.

[TeradelFuego]

If either of these names could be said to be 'twee' it is quite obviously Poppy!

[OliveOrTwist]

Another vote for Imogen here. One of my favourite girls names!