It's a girl! Shortlist decided but just can't choose.

[BooStar]

We finally have a shortlist of 3 names for our little girl due in a few weeks:

India
Claudia
Merryn

Middle name is most likely going to be Fay (my mother's name)

I really love all of them but my reservations are:
India - a bit too leftfield?
Claudia - a bit harsh/stuffy?
Merryn - a bit plain?

These are only little niggles so really struggling to choose!
I just need some opinions! No holds barred :)

Merryn is a beautiful name. I'm not keen on the others.

Congratulations!

They are all nice, but Merryn is my favourite.

Claudia for me. Beautiful and underused.

Won't be harsh or stuffy unless your family is which I'm assuming not since you're concerned about it.

Merry is my favourite by far.

Merryn for me too.

I have a Claudia - so clearly my favourite!

They are all quite different types of names though imo. Just an observation

I like them all! Fab names

Merryn. Not keen on India, sorry.

I love Merryn, like Claudia and find India a bit irritating.

I love Claudia and think it will sound best with Fay. Wishing you a happy birth

I have a Claudia right now asleep in my arms. I don't find it stuffy or harsh at all. If anything I was drawn to it because it feels like such a luxurious name if that makes sense! I also love India too but DP struck that one off the list early on. Merryn is pretty as well.

Forgot to say, why not just wait and see which name she suits when she arrives. It's easier when they are here to put a name to a face I found. You have a short list so just try them out. Sometimes it is obvious.

I love Merryn the most, closely followed by Claudia.

I am not too keen on India though. I don't think it's leftfield. (Leftfield can be good )

I really like Claudia. Pretty and underused. Only possible hang-up for me is the meaning, but presumably you're not too worried about that.

Merryn, then Claudia, but I think you'll know when you meet her.

My little dainty DD1 would have made a perfect Merryn, but not a Claudia. Claudia would have suited DD2.

I like India, but it has to feel right to you. We're to middle of the road for an India.

In order of preference:

Merryn
Claudia

India

Though it's a close call between the first two!

Another vote for Merryn.

I love india.

Not India. The other two are gorgeous. Probably Claudia for me.

What about Indiana, instead of India?
I like Merryn, and also Meredith.

I love India.
But agree with what others have said - keep all 3 for when she's born and see what suits

Merryn is my fave of the choices too.

India is a country!!!

Claudia is lovely.

I love India, but Claudia nearly as much.