I think I have narrowed it down to two names any opinions please?

[Dirtydishesmakemesad]

well actually the name i wanted was Tamsin Eloise but dh hates that so our names we have agreed on are:

Elsie May or Georgia May

is there any hideous reason not to use these which is the nicest?

our other children are Jessica, Jacob, Bethan and Emily

I like Georgia May.

Elizabeth May - nn Elsie.
Or Georgina. I think a full name like Elizabeth or Georgina fits the sibset beautifully. I am not keen on Georgia (but like Georgina)
I would choose Elsie over Georgia though.

Hmm that's a shame - I like Tamsin a lot. I would go with Georgia May - very pretty.

Georgia May.

I prefer Elsie but Georgia goes with your other names.

Georgia May.

If you go for Elizabeth May with nn Elsie then she'll not get called Elsie but Liz, so you might as well go for Elsie.

But Georgia is prettier.

Georgia does fit nicely with the other names doesnt it!
I keep imagining introducing the children "ah yes here is my son jacob and my daughters Jessica, Bethan, Emily and Georgia" it does seem to roll off the tongue better than Elsie

I prefer Georgia, Emily and Elsie sound quite similar.

I prefer Georgia but sounds too similar to Jessica to me. Elizabeth is too close to Bethan. Elouise is much nicer.

I like Georgiana May

I know you weren't offering that as an option

Georgia is better with your set and sounds nicer, IMO.

Isn't there a Jagger daughter called Georgia May? Doesn't matter anyway, I really like it.

Elsie.

Elsie is the name my DH uses whenever he does his "old lady" impersonation. Can't get past that I'm afraid!

Georgia is lovely and works very well with your other names.

I prefer Elsie but Georgia's a better fit iyswim.

Lydia, I know 4 Elizabeths, none called Liz. They are Elizabeth (never shortened), Libby, Beth and Eliza.

I prefer Georgia and it fits better with the other names.

Georgia May is beautiful and goes with the other names you've got.

There are loads of Georgias here, I can think of 4 instantly and they are all awful and almost as awful as the Michael Bolton song the name reminds me of...sorry.

Elsie, no, there's only one Elsie Tanner

Another vote here for Elsie being too close to Emily - I'd go for Georgia.

oh I like Tamsin, but Georgia if I have to choose.

I think they are both lovely - but will Emily and Bethan feel left out if everyone else begins with a 'j' sound?

Yep, Georgia May Jagger is a model.

Well i had a scan today and we got a really good look at her little face and this will sound really stupid now but she doesnt look like a Georgia OR an Elsie (and i am prepared to admit that i may be overthinking a scan photo but she just doesnt!). If i had to give her a name from the picture i immediatly thought of my mums name since my mum had the exact same look to her cheeks i cant use that as i think it would upset my family too much!. My dh looked at me like this .

Georgia May. I know two old lady Elsies and neither of them like it-one keeps it a dark secret and goes by a completely different nickname.