Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A jobless society…

50 replies

digimumworld · Today 04:44

Are we heading towards a jobless society. AIBU for being worried about this?

Or are there jobs but we all need to retrain in a field that controls AI or people facing public sector type roles.

So many people in my friendship circle have been made redundant over the past few months. It feels like every other person is looking for work, despite having years of experience. A friend said her whole team was made redundant as AI could do their work (around analysing).

I’ve personally worked part time for a little while, topped up with freelance gigs, feels like I’ve been looking for a full time role for a few years now - and I had a 10 year “office job” full time career before this, so it has been difficult for me to find something.

It just feels there is a much bigger crisis than youth unemployment. It’s general unemployment.

OP posts:
LaurieFairyCake · Today 08:16

Yes, the majority of us are going to lose our white collar jobs in the next decade.

the problem is there’s loads of people who’s thinking hasn’t caught up with this yet and are STILL saying stuff like:

“young people don’t want to work/they only want benefits/ there’s no such thing as ageism in job hunting for people over 50 or under 25/if you wanted a job you’d find one/work in a supermarket, take in ironing, move counties or countries/get on your bike”

I’ve seen every version of the above over the last couple of years and NO acknowledgement that the world of work has UTTERLY changed.

Just because YOU have a job right now doesn’t mean that you will have in 5 years.

Way too many people comfy in their ignorance. I know dozens of good graduates, children of clients and friends who cannot find an entry level job - and they have £40-£100k of graduate debt.

PaisleyElephant · Today 08:50

I think it varies by sector, but it doesn't make sense to say it will be a jobless society. That doesn't even make sense. You can't have AI and robots doing everything. Many roles need actual human beings. If everything is robots, no one will have a job to earn money to pay for robot/AI services.

I am sure the jobs market has changed, but people need to adapt and move with the times. People did this during COVID, when we all had to change our ways of working.

I do find it hard to believe about ageism as well. I am over 50 and was recently approached about a new employment opportunity, and my current job I was also approached and the only applicant. I have various part time roles but this is through choice to mix public and private sector income streams. I think it's more likely if people are being ageist they won't want women of child bearing age. Once you get to 50, this is less of a financial risk for business owners.

Public sector don't reveal age, ethnicity etc to shortlisted to prevent judgement on protected characteristics.

Of course, some jobs are lost/replaced by AI and some recruiters will be ageist, but I don't think it reflects the whole of society by a long shot.

I also think the quality of graduates has gone massively downhill. I have been recruiting people into graduate roles for 15 years and it's changed so much. Just basics like writing skills and reading the actual questions on the form/person spec/job description. So many are really low effort as well. The quality applicants really stand out and do well. I would wonder about the quality of the applications from those struggling to find work (for graduate level jobs).

kirbykirby · Today 10:32

Yep, AI seems to be really speeding up. I think we're going to see massive changes in society over the next few years.

Beenheredecadesnewnameneeded · Today 10:42

Yes probably.

I have been working as a ta for 10 years.

our numbers (obviously linked to birth rate) are dropping massively and will continue to do so for at least the next six years (although I can’t see it ever really picking up)

our long term plan is to merge classes over the next few years (thus halving the staff)

quite likely to be make redundant- unless I’m more willing to cover classes instead of using an expensive teacher (I do cover one afternoon a week and occasional sickness cover , but I only get paid an extra 38p per hour to do so and it’s hard work, so hence the reluctance)

the government have said it won’t prop up schools with the declining numbers, so I would expect schools to start merging eventually (although not an expert, just a poor TA at the bottom of a pile !)

  • side note it would be truly amazing if the government used this opportunity of spare classrooms to help support the sen crisis rather then taxi ing kids off side miles away - but what do I know !

obviously this will impact other sectors as the lack of children move through the system. Even though it may take another decade to realise.

DoYouSellBuckets · Today 10:47

I think there will be massive changes. But, businesses need customers. The state can't subsidise people being out of work if there aren't enough people to pay tax. So I think things will shift. Probably not quickly enough, though.

I sort of think the increasing of the tax-free 'side gig' allowance is part of encouraging this. As people have less spending money, I think there will inevitably be a lot of pain. But also, I hope more barter will start up. AI can't replace plumbers, sparkies, scaffolders, teachers, nurses. I think the under-paid caring roles that tech can't replace will have a re-adjustment. I hope people will trade skills - not in a gig-economy way but by starting up co-ops etc. For example community nurseries where people cover their kids' nursery fees by working there one day a week. Community pubs where people run them together. Allotment-holders swapping produce for hours spent helping. I think the circular economy will continue to grow - Vinted, eBay, CeX. Wasteful, flash culture is likely to see a decline.

I'm not an economist or philosopher (I work in tech so probably one of the first for the chopping block) but I think people have forgotten how recent the 'money comes in on payday and is spent on produce from large corporations' system is. There's a reason our grand-parents grow veg, knit clothes and own a sewing machine. They aren't just hobbies

Walikota · Today 11:01

I think older people will require far more care and attention in sustaining useful healthy lives as the birthrate goes down in many countries and demographics mass shift to older age groups......so I m over in Taiwan doing a Biotechnology degree.Fingers crossed.

Havanananana · Today 11:34

John Maynard Keynes predicted that by the year 2030, technological advancements would revolutionise the labour landscape to such an extent that individuals would only need to work 15-hour weeks. This has not happened. As millions of workers have already discovered, human labour is seen as an expensive overhead and the economic gains of technology have been used to cut costs and boost profits rather than being shared out amongst the workforce in the form of shorter working hours.

Thanks to technology and AI one person can do the work previously done by three people, so now one person works 45 hours but only gets paid about the same as before, while the other two people are discarded.
Then the right-wing invents two classes of people - the net contributors and the net-takers - and demonises the latter, removing the social safety net, whilst praising the former but threatening them that if they don't conform, they too can join the have-nots.

There comes a crunch point. The car factory owner who proudly showed the union reps his new robots asked the question, "How are you going to get these to go on strike?" To which the union rep replied, "How are you going to get them to buy your cars?"

Badbadbunny · Today 11:41

I think we need to embrace "localism" and turn our backs on the big internationals. We also need to spend on manufacturing in the UK, farming in the UK, etc - why should we buy stuff from abroad, giving foreigners the jobs, whilst we pay ever increasing amounts in benefits to our unemployed in the UK. Makes no sense. We need to divert some of the costs of unemployment (not just benefits but also crime, etc), into manufacturing and farming to create jobs in the UK. We need to dial back and bring back small businesses after decades of embracing big supermarkets, foreign suppliers, Amazon etc.

As others have said, "white collar" jobs are probably dead in the water with AI and other technology, so we have to look at what else we can do, and that comes down to manual skilled/trades work. AI will never replace the plumber coming to replace your boiler or your gardener or the electrician to wire in your new wall lamps or re wallpaper your living room. We need to get back to people being taught to do things rather than shuffle paper and press keys on the keyboard.

helpfulperson · Today 11:48

As the world always does it will sort itself out. This happened in the 80's 3 million unemployed. Computers fundamentally changed job roles and availabilty. Bosnian war, falklands war etc changed the politi al landscape. It took a while but things settled.

OddBoots · Today 12:03

It wouldn't be a problem if we hadn't let the billionaires hoard all the money.

Stompythedinosaur · Today 12:33

The problem really is capitalism - that the benefits of technology are going towards making a small minority richer which the rest of us are seen as disposable.

I don't really believe there'll be no jobs though. There are too many things AI can't do. I think the types of joins people train for will change. Healthcare, the creative arts, social care etc aren't easier going to disappear.

ThePeppyOpalScroller · Today 13:41

A jobless society isn't what you should be worried about. We are fucked long before we get to that point. When unemployment reaches 25%, the economy collapses. The UK is currently at just under 5%. If just one in four jobs gets lost to AI or the fallout from it, then everyone else goes with them. This is how close we are to the end. People need to wake up. Your job isn't safe because the redundancies are in a different department or there is a hiring freeze.

It isn't all jobs, it's just a quarter of them. That's the point of no return. That's the water over the bulkhead.

Badbadbunny · Today 13:45

Stompythedinosaur · Today 12:33

The problem really is capitalism - that the benefits of technology are going towards making a small minority richer which the rest of us are seen as disposable.

I don't really believe there'll be no jobs though. There are too many things AI can't do. I think the types of joins people train for will change. Healthcare, the creative arts, social care etc aren't easier going to disappear.

That's not capitalism though. Capitalism worked perfectly well on a small scale when we had generally smaller businesses and fewer billionaires with all the power. It's the way capitalism has morphed into globalisation that is the problem. We need to get back to smaller businesses with less influence.

Nevermind31 · Today 13:46

The nice white collar jobs that allow us to sit in an office and are highly paid are disappearing. Unfortunately, AI and robots are taking over the stuff we do like doing, leaving things that many people do not want to do. Yes, there will always be jobs in elder care. And other manual stuff. But many of us would rather not do those things, nor do we enjoy them. AI is enhancing profits for a minority of people, not quality of life for the rest of us. Only now it is affecting the higher earners

MasterGland · Today 14:01

Jobs will disappear but work won't. Jobs are really creations of the industrial revolution. We have always worked i.e cleaning your house, growing or hunting food etc.
Working class jobs in this country were primarily destroyed by deindustrialisation and then latterly by offshoring call centres etc.
AI has now come for the middle class jobs. It will be interesting to see how this impacts the conversation around 'feckless scroungers'.

notedbiscuits · Today 14:10

One many problems is the number of entry jobs that require experience. Where are these young people supposed to get experience when majority of jobs require experience?

Those no experience required jobs are usually scams or dodgy. A colleague went for one of these jobs 10/12 years ago and it was basically given a bag of crap to sell - keyrings, mobile phone cases etc and with someone going into offices etc. They dumped the bag of crap outside the place’s offices and didn’t return

MirrorClocks · Today 14:15

I think AI will take out many of the mid-range skilled jobs - leaving the unskilled and mainly manual jobs that a lot of people don’t want to do on the bottom tier and the highly-skilled and tech jobs on the top end.

We’re fast becoming a nation of Vinted sellers and delivery drivers.

notedbiscuits · Today 14:19

We need to encourage practical skills such as electricians, plumbers etc.

Those with practical skills who are not bright academically are looked down in schools.

We need vocational schools for those entering year 10. There are only 35 University Technical Colleges in the UK. If you live miles away from one - my nearest one is 45 miles away, no govt or council funding for travel and accommodation

PurpleThistle7 · Today 14:20

I think it will eventually settle and falling birthrates will help with this. But like the Great Depression where it took a while for the workforce to upskill etc, we are definitely in for a challenging time. My husband and I both work in university admin which is a sinking ship. The jobs I came up through (reception and filing and such) don’t exist anymore and it’s not clear to me what will replace them. Not a lot of ‘safe’ career options anymore.

TheNoonBell · Today 14:40

OddBoots · Today 12:03

It wouldn't be a problem if we hadn't let the billionaires hoard all the money.

Pity we have taxed most of the previously UK resident ones out of the country.

One single billionaire left the country last year and that lost us £330 million in taxes.

Boreded · Today 14:49

notedbiscuits · Today 14:19

We need to encourage practical skills such as electricians, plumbers etc.

Those with practical skills who are not bright academically are looked down in schools.

We need vocational schools for those entering year 10. There are only 35 University Technical Colleges in the UK. If you live miles away from one - my nearest one is 45 miles away, no govt or council funding for travel and accommodation

My son went to one of these, over an hour on the bus every morning and evening, he was leaving the house before 7am.

We could do with more of them, or for standard schools from year 10 to allow students to drop the non-STEM subjects (this is why he went to a UTC) in favour of the courses in engineering and and technology

Parkinbus · Today 14:59

people need to adapt and move with the times.

If technological advances and AI do away with 25% of existing jobs, there simply won't be enough jobs to go round, no matter how much you adapt. Businesses are always going to go with efficiency and money saving ahead of making sure people are employed.

OddBoots · Today 14:59

TheNoonBell · Today 14:40

Pity we have taxed most of the previously UK resident ones out of the country.

One single billionaire left the country last year and that lost us £330 million in taxes.

It certainly needs some international co-operation to tackle this issue.

KnickerlessParsons · Today 15:05

Our management are adamant that AI won’t result in redundancies but will allow us all to do our jobs quicker

Mumofamasingboys · Today 15:05

People need to wake up to this and politicians need to step in. Business leaders won’t as they are only in this to make themselves rich short term..