Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A jobless society…

51 replies

digimumworld · Today 04:44

Are we heading towards a jobless society. AIBU for being worried about this?

Or are there jobs but we all need to retrain in a field that controls AI or people facing public sector type roles.

So many people in my friendship circle have been made redundant over the past few months. It feels like every other person is looking for work, despite having years of experience. A friend said her whole team was made redundant as AI could do their work (around analysing).

I’ve personally worked part time for a little while, topped up with freelance gigs, feels like I’ve been looking for a full time role for a few years now - and I had a 10 year “office job” full time career before this, so it has been difficult for me to find something.

It just feels there is a much bigger crisis than youth unemployment. It’s general unemployment.

OP posts:
TheNoonBell · Today 15:07

OddBoots · Today 14:59

It certainly needs some international co-operation to tackle this issue.

All it takes is one country not to agree to "international cooperation" and that policy fails.

The balance we did have seemed to work well until Labour decided to get rid of non-dom status and then started to talk about exit taxes which pushed out the actually tax resident rich. Absolute stupidity which is going to cost the middle and working classes a lot to fund the ever growing non working class.

Meadowfinch · Today 15:11

AI is not going to replace any practical, manual work.

It can inform and improve that work, and in some cases robots will replace humans, but it cannot do most things that humans can do, as cheaply.

And AI will create lots of new jobs, just as PCs 40 years ago created the cyber security industry, online retail, cad, social media, cryptocurrency etc and all the support and management functions that those entail.

Nellodee · Today 15:48

No jobs isn’t the problem. No taxes is. We really need to start taxing wealth rather than income, because otherwise, governments will have no money and we will rely on the generosity of trillionaires.

EmeraldRoulette · Today 16:00

Walikota · Today 11:01

I think older people will require far more care and attention in sustaining useful healthy lives as the birthrate goes down in many countries and demographics mass shift to older age groups......so I m over in Taiwan doing a Biotechnology degree.Fingers crossed.

Could you explain exactly what you mean by this please? And how it relates to jobs?

@digimumworld yes I’ve been saying to my mum for ages now - okay it feels like ages certainly a few years - there’s going to be an awful lot of spare humans around and I don’t know what we’re going to do with them or how we are supposed to survive. UBI I suppose.

Badbadbunny · Today 16:04

EmeraldRoulette · Today 16:00

Could you explain exactly what you mean by this please? And how it relates to jobs?

@digimumworld yes I’ve been saying to my mum for ages now - okay it feels like ages certainly a few years - there’s going to be an awful lot of spare humans around and I don’t know what we’re going to do with them or how we are supposed to survive. UBI I suppose.

UBI is unaffordable and impractical. It's one of those "good in theory" ideas for sixth form debating societies but scratch the surface and it just won't work.

Badbadbunny · Today 16:04

EmeraldRoulette · Today 16:00

Could you explain exactly what you mean by this please? And how it relates to jobs?

@digimumworld yes I’ve been saying to my mum for ages now - okay it feels like ages certainly a few years - there’s going to be an awful lot of spare humans around and I don’t know what we’re going to do with them or how we are supposed to survive. UBI I suppose.

UBI is unaffordable and impractical. It's one of those "good in theory" ideas for sixth form debating societies but scratch the surface and it just won't work.

ThePeppyOpalScroller · Today 16:21

Meadowfinch · Today 15:11

AI is not going to replace any practical, manual work.

It can inform and improve that work, and in some cases robots will replace humans, but it cannot do most things that humans can do, as cheaply.

And AI will create lots of new jobs, just as PCs 40 years ago created the cyber security industry, online retail, cad, social media, cryptocurrency etc and all the support and management functions that those entail.

If AI creates a "new" job, then it can also do that new job.

MellowSubmarine · Today 16:38

Badbadbunny · Today 11:41

I think we need to embrace "localism" and turn our backs on the big internationals. We also need to spend on manufacturing in the UK, farming in the UK, etc - why should we buy stuff from abroad, giving foreigners the jobs, whilst we pay ever increasing amounts in benefits to our unemployed in the UK. Makes no sense. We need to divert some of the costs of unemployment (not just benefits but also crime, etc), into manufacturing and farming to create jobs in the UK. We need to dial back and bring back small businesses after decades of embracing big supermarkets, foreign suppliers, Amazon etc.

As others have said, "white collar" jobs are probably dead in the water with AI and other technology, so we have to look at what else we can do, and that comes down to manual skilled/trades work. AI will never replace the plumber coming to replace your boiler or your gardener or the electrician to wire in your new wall lamps or re wallpaper your living room. We need to get back to people being taught to do things rather than shuffle paper and press keys on the keyboard.

You’re right about the gardener and the decorator and the electrician doing new lamps not being replaceable by AI. But who is paying to have those things done if there is mass unemployment?

Emergency electrical or plumbing work, yes. But not new wallpaper or a new bathroom.

Plus of course far more people going into those jobs as other options become unavailable will drive down prices.

EmeraldRoulette · Today 16:43

Badbadbunny · Today 16:04

UBI is unaffordable and impractical. It's one of those "good in theory" ideas for sixth form debating societies but scratch the surface and it just won't work.

I agree

I just think it’s one of those things that might get tried when the powers that be realise how many jobs have gone.

As much as I don’t like it, I was thinking about it and I thought, the landscape I imagine in my worst case scenario… there might be something like it except it wouldn’t be universal. So we might just be headed for higher taxes and more benefits.

OriginalTomboy · Today 16:48

In the late 70s early 80s we were told at school that the rise of computers and our manufacturing industries disappearing would mean fewer jobs, more leisure time, blah, blah.. Service industries took a lot of the slack up, now its those industries under fire, something else will probably rise. no idea what but back in those days we didn't conceive that it would be service industries either.

Abhannmor · Today 17:13

Nellodee · Today 15:48

No jobs isn’t the problem. No taxes is. We really need to start taxing wealth rather than income, because otherwise, governments will have no money and we will rely on the generosity of trillionaires.

💯. Work and productivity is taxed. Living on rents or investments is much easier. Why is investment income not treated the same as a salary?
Similarly land banks and empty property should be taxed.

But the 1% know this is not sustainable. Hence the back up plans , the super yachts , the compound in New Zealand or some remote island etc. And presumably the well paid security...

Abhannmor · Today 17:16

OriginalTomboy · Today 16:48

In the late 70s early 80s we were told at school that the rise of computers and our manufacturing industries disappearing would mean fewer jobs, more leisure time, blah, blah.. Service industries took a lot of the slack up, now its those industries under fire, something else will probably rise. no idea what but back in those days we didn't conceive that it would be service industries either.

I recall one teacher predicted that plumbing would be safer from the cull than most occupations. Even Robbie the Robot doesn't fancy sticking his arm around the U bend lol 💩

EmeraldRoulette · Today 17:26

@Abhannmor “Why is investment income not treated the same as a salary?”

it is, isn’t it?

In fact, landlords are paying higher taxes on rental income. Unless they’ve set themselves up as a company, I think.

DeflectionAndWhataboutery · Today 17:31

TheNoonBell · Today 14:40

Pity we have taxed most of the previously UK resident ones out of the country.

One single billionaire left the country last year and that lost us £330 million in taxes.

The last thing the country needs is billionaires dictating policy based on the threat they will leave. Look at the state of the US.

I know a lot of HNW people. They want to live in the UK and have enough money that tax rises are a minor inconvenience. They are who we need, not selfish billionaires.

Dragonscaledaisy · Today 17:33

EmeraldRoulette · Today 16:00

Could you explain exactly what you mean by this please? And how it relates to jobs?

@digimumworld yes I’ve been saying to my mum for ages now - okay it feels like ages certainly a few years - there’s going to be an awful lot of spare humans around and I don’t know what we’re going to do with them or how we are supposed to survive. UBI I suppose.

UBI will never be introduced - where would the money come from to pay it?

sausageth · Today 17:34

kirbykirby · Today 10:32

Yep, AI seems to be really speeding up. I think we're going to see massive changes in society over the next few years.

Yes this. I'm not sure a jobless society is what we're looking at, but more a society demanding different types of jobs.

Dragonscaledaisy · Today 17:35

Abhannmor · Today 17:16

I recall one teacher predicted that plumbing would be safer from the cull than most occupations. Even Robbie the Robot doesn't fancy sticking his arm around the U bend lol 💩

The problem with all trades is that no one will be able to afford to or would want to pay them - it's an easy thing to learn when money's tight.

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · Today 17:40

I don’t think it’s just the billionaires that are the problem- we want everything now, and better and faster etc etc etc. there’s an ai post at the moment with people saying what tools they use to eg take minutes and what caught my eye was someone saying a human would never get them done as well. I thought: Congratulations, you’ve just cut one of someone’s tasks for the day. A few more and you’ve made them redundant. One day her own job may be gone and I’ll bet she won’t connect the dots.

specialmintapplecranberrysauce · Today 17:43

Dragonscaledaisy · Today 17:35

The problem with all trades is that no one will be able to afford to or would want to pay them - it's an easy thing to learn when money's tight.

At least if there are more plumbers and electricians their prices will have to be more competitive.

I'm sick of paying £65/£75 call outs when they are in my house for less than 10 minutes.

We only pay it now because getting a plumber out within a week is virtually impossible.

Douglasmummy · Today 17:45

MellowSubmarine · Today 16:38

You’re right about the gardener and the decorator and the electrician doing new lamps not being replaceable by AI. But who is paying to have those things done if there is mass unemployment?

Emergency electrical or plumbing work, yes. But not new wallpaper or a new bathroom.

Plus of course far more people going into those jobs as other options become unavailable will drive down prices.

Agree. It's fine saying ' no one can replace plumbers but someone needs to pay the plumbers to do the work. The economy relies on people being able to pay for stuff they need. During COVID people were learning basic plumbing skills from YouTube. If people don't have jobs and loads of time they aren't going to pay other people to do these jobs.

Dragonscaledaisy · Today 17:46

specialmintapplecranberrysauce · Today 17:43

At least if there are more plumbers and electricians their prices will have to be more competitive.

I'm sick of paying £65/£75 call outs when they are in my house for less than 10 minutes.

We only pay it now because getting a plumber out within a week is virtually impossible.

It will, you're right. I've learnt to do all kinds of work myself and I've saved thousands over the years - if I can do it, any one can. 😂Give it a go.

specialmintapplecranberrysauce · Today 17:50

Dragonscaledaisy · Today 17:46

It will, you're right. I've learnt to do all kinds of work myself and I've saved thousands over the years - if I can do it, any one can. 😂Give it a go.

I have learnt loads of new things over time. I can change taps, glaze windows, simple wiring etc. But if the fuse box or boiler needs attention it has to be a professional as I am scared of gas and electrocution - and they have magic screwdrivers and things 😄

Douglasmummy · Today 17:51

@Autumnalhibernationisthedream yes. It's the same with all the ' billionnaire' talk. Jeff Bezos didn't become a billionaire by himself, and those high street shops didn't shut by themselves. They shut because millions of people made millions of decisions not to bother going to shops and bought stuff on Amazon instead. There was a survey of people who bought crap on Shein and Temu and the vast majority were people spending £££ every week on tat. So not people living hand to mouth who couldn't afford clothes so had no choice. Just people with a shopping addiction.

RikthePoet · Today 18:03

Badbadbunny · Today 13:45

That's not capitalism though. Capitalism worked perfectly well on a small scale when we had generally smaller businesses and fewer billionaires with all the power. It's the way capitalism has morphed into globalisation that is the problem. We need to get back to smaller businesses with less influence.

But late-stage capitalism is an inevitable part of the system. Economies of scale encourage business conglomeration. Smaller businesses can't compete. You can't put the genie back in the bottle.

TheNimbleCoralBear · Today 18:09

In my view AI is the emperor's new clothes. I review documents for a living, mainly heavy duty commercial agreements which are critical to the company I work for. This is one of the things the AI creators have thrown money at so all the main AI's claim expertise at document review and it is supposed to be a core skill. I routinely get sent emails from my management where they have obviously put the document through some AI and have copy and pasted its output and they tell me what the key clauses of the document say. Some are clearly better prompters than others, but I can always tell and 100% of the time the AI had missed some things or got it wrong, sometimes laughably wrong.

This is in an area which is supposed to be a core AI skill. I'm pensionable age so I don't care if they make me redundant. I could go tomorrow but I absolutely guarantee the people in management will be convinced AI is giving them everything they need when actually it is crap. I do point mistakes out, but I'm sure it falls on deaf ears. I use AI myself sometimes, especially to speed up reviews when I have lots of documents or for transactions in another language, but the point is I have the skills to say when it is wrong, and it's wrong a lot.

Sometimes it completely hallucinates what is in agreements and what clauses mean. I know the standard response is don't worry it will get better, but I disagree. I know documentation review has absolutely been a focus for the various AI manufacturers. I've tested all the big ones. They are supposed to be excellent. They are not. They also can't cope with real world negotiations, even the ones plugged into our systems so they see our emails and know our payment terms.

I have a family member whose job is largely unique software coding. She says the same about AI coding. Looks great until you find it actually doesn't work. Much egg on face on front of your client.

Sooner or later there will be a realisation that AI is just a tool which has been massively overhyped so the creators can make money. It can speed up some jobs, but it needs to be closely watched and crucially it needs to be reviewed by someone who already knows what the answer should be. If you need to exercise any discretion in your role, AI cannot do that for you.