Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SAHM and decided to leave my DP.

505 replies

Feedingmybaby · Today 12:17

I have decided to leave my DP after Christmas. I’m a SAHM to a baby and two pre-schoolers and have had enough. DP covers everything financially but makes no effort to be involved in family life and I am practically a single parent.

There is no arguing between us, but I am fed up of biting my tongue and pussyfooting around him due to his mood swings and sensitivity.

Looking for advice on how I can start to get prepared and what people advise going forwards. DP is a fairly high earner and I estimate that child maintenance will be around the £1500-£2000 mark as he earns above the threshold that CMS takes into account.

I anticipate that I will have near enough full time care of the children as DPs job involved lots of overnight travel and I just don’t think he would push for anything else really.

OP posts:
Allmychickenscometoroost · Today 15:35

Glowingup · Today 15:28

I get it but I think many on here downplay the immense psychological toll of being in an unhappy relationship, especially one where you feel you are walking on eggshells for fear of upsetting the other person, which the OP is. I would much rather be financially struggling a bit than be in a miserable relationship, even if he is rich. There are multiple posts jumping to the DP's defence, saying that it can't be that bad because surely otherwise the OP wouldn't have had three kids with him (oh yeah because that NEVER happens, right), accusing the OP of using her DP to have kids. Lots of posts saying that life as a single parent is so unbelievably tough and she needs to stay in the relationship. Whereas anecdotally, most single mums I know say their lives are better and easier post-split, especially where they were in relationships like the one the OP describes. Besides, she would be entitled to universal credit and would get CMS (yes, her DH might be an arse about paying or want 50/50 but the OP says this is unlikely). So realistically, she probably will be okay, albeit not wealthy and in time she can work on getting back to work.

would get CMS (yes, her DH might be an arse about paying or want 50/50 but the OP says this is unlikely

This is the thing, she has no way of knowing how he will be regarding CMS at all. There are stories galore, on and off Mumsnet, of previously decent men who became extremely difficult and devious re cms. Then there's the possibility that he could have other relationships and further children. I think most people are wisely telling her to be cautious.

Ophy83 · Today 15:35

I'd have thought it would be easier to get your career back on track now while he can pay for nursery, and then if things are still bad leave when you have a settled income.

However, if you are sure you can't continue any longer then maybe have a think about essential financial outlay over the next year or so and buy what you can now e.g. clothes/shoes for the kids in the next size up.

HowDoYouSolveAProblemLikeMyRear · Today 15:36

So many couples find that their marriage is least happy during the period when they have young children.

For the sale of your children, and remembering your vows, please consider giving it longer.

My parents had several not very happy years. They stayed together, and had so, so many more happy years after that.

I've known so many friends who've been unhappy together for a few years. The vast majority of those who stayed together ended up very glad that they did.

If nothing else, since he's uninvolved rather than abusive, and you're out of love with him rather than in love with someone else, your current situation, with children, the security of a home, and mostly getting the place to yourself and your children, sounds manageable.

OneHazelBird · Today 15:37

Don’t underestimate a man who is hurt not to try fuck you over.

Is he SE?
If so, getting that money out of him maybe but more difficult.

It is very unlikely you will get UC on top of that maintenance, so use that amount as your base and work out costs from there.

You need to think about where you’re going to live as the main priority.
Divorcing him and selling the house takes a lot of time and so you can’t rely on that.

Do you have family you can stay with until the house is sold?

Instead of renting and pouring your money away, I would then buy a small 1/2 bed flat somewhere cheap and then once you’re back at work you can look into buying somewhere better.

ItalianoSl · Today 15:40

Allmychickenscometoroost · Today 15:35

would get CMS (yes, her DH might be an arse about paying or want 50/50 but the OP says this is unlikely

This is the thing, she has no way of knowing how he will be regarding CMS at all. There are stories galore, on and off Mumsnet, of previously decent men who became extremely difficult and devious re cms. Then there's the possibility that he could have other relationships and further children. I think most people are wisely telling her to be cautious.

I have a friend - 4 kids. Dad has buggered off to new wife and life.
He (quite rightly) is supporting the family home and his kids very well. She is also able to claim UC. They're doing fine.

I get barely any support from my ex. I work. On the surface she seems a lot more comfortable than me, with a lot more free time (she is a p/t TA).

I am happier being financially independent, but there are times when I feel the weight of responsibility.

EppingIsFun · Today 15:40

I suspect ragebait, surely nobody's this ignorant in real life... OK perhaps they are 😂

Unmarried stay at home mother to three kids? And he's not a bad man, just 'not what you want'?

Hope you enjoy living on the breadline in temporary accommodation with your kids. If you're lucky, it won't be a B&B. And I say this not to be nasty, but to open your eyes to what you are about to do.

Glowingup · Today 15:40

Allmychickenscometoroost · Today 15:35

would get CMS (yes, her DH might be an arse about paying or want 50/50 but the OP says this is unlikely

This is the thing, she has no way of knowing how he will be regarding CMS at all. There are stories galore, on and off Mumsnet, of previously decent men who became extremely difficult and devious re cms. Then there's the possibility that he could have other relationships and further children. I think most people are wisely telling her to be cautious.

Well, no, there is never a guarantee is it but does that mean that women should remain in miserable relationships (and I'm sorry but my standards are higher than wanting to tiptoe around someone's moods and getting no help whatsoever with childcare) because there is a chance that their children's father might try to evade maintenance payments? No. If he is employed, there are also various enforcement mechanisms and it's actually fairly difficult to just 'not pay'. The point about him having more kids with someone else, so bloody what? For a start, it won't drastically reduce the OP's maintenance (the reduction is fairly small) and again, should women remain in miserable relationships for fear that their exes might have more children in the future?

CrazyMidget · Today 15:42

YRGAM · Today 12:42

You're not a single parent already because in addition to arranging care for their children, single parents are also responsible for paying the bills and supporting the family (maintenance is not enough for this btw). This is an area of life you have abdicated responsibility for to your partner. I'd think carefully about this before you go any further.

I agree with this. OP, I cannot imagine that leaving him is going to solve all your problems. With the situation you describe, you're just going to create a ton of new problems for yourself. Your kids are really young. I think you're far better off in your current situation for the foreseeable future. You can use the next few years to work towards greater financial independence. In the meantime, try to talk calmly with him and explain that you want to be more of a family unit. Try to water the grass in your own back garden, basically, and think about what you want to do when the children are older. Do you want to retrain? Start your own business? I think this is the time for planning, not leaving, imho.

Glowingup · Today 15:43

OneHazelBird · Today 15:37

Don’t underestimate a man who is hurt not to try fuck you over.

Is he SE?
If so, getting that money out of him maybe but more difficult.

It is very unlikely you will get UC on top of that maintenance, so use that amount as your base and work out costs from there.

You need to think about where you’re going to live as the main priority.
Divorcing him and selling the house takes a lot of time and so you can’t rely on that.

Do you have family you can stay with until the house is sold?

Instead of renting and pouring your money away, I would then buy a small 1/2 bed flat somewhere cheap and then once you’re back at work you can look into buying somewhere better.

That's rubbish, sorry. UC is not reduced pound by pound by child maintenance and OP has a young baby. She will get UC.

OneHazelBird · Today 15:44

EppingIsFun · Today 15:40

I suspect ragebait, surely nobody's this ignorant in real life... OK perhaps they are 😂

Unmarried stay at home mother to three kids? And he's not a bad man, just 'not what you want'?

Hope you enjoy living on the breadline in temporary accommodation with your kids. If you're lucky, it won't be a B&B. And I say this not to be nasty, but to open your eyes to what you are about to do.

You’re not wrong but I wouldn’t have the stomach to stay with a man who doesn’t bother parenting his own children.

CrazyMidget · Today 15:45

Glowingup · Today 15:40

Well, no, there is never a guarantee is it but does that mean that women should remain in miserable relationships (and I'm sorry but my standards are higher than wanting to tiptoe around someone's moods and getting no help whatsoever with childcare) because there is a chance that their children's father might try to evade maintenance payments? No. If he is employed, there are also various enforcement mechanisms and it's actually fairly difficult to just 'not pay'. The point about him having more kids with someone else, so bloody what? For a start, it won't drastically reduce the OP's maintenance (the reduction is fairly small) and again, should women remain in miserable relationships for fear that their exes might have more children in the future?

Standards are expensive. If you have three very young children and no income, you can't afford standards! I jest, but you know what I mean. OP is better off cultivating a return to work and getting her own income up rather than leaving in the next few months, imo.

OneHazelBird · Today 15:46

Glowingup · Today 15:43

That's rubbish, sorry. UC is not reduced pound by pound by child maintenance and OP has a young baby. She will get UC.

This must have changed then or I was told wrong.

When I applied for it they asked me how much maintenance I received and as it was zero then they said it didn’t affect my claim.

I’m really pleased to hear that as I’ve always thought that was so unfair.

Lilactimes · Today 15:47

Hi @Feedingmybaby
i have read all your posts but not all the responses.

I agree that if you are in a harmful controlling god forbid violent relationship then you need out.

If you are in a relationship with a lazy guy who is a rubbish dad and not helping you practically BUT is a high earner and supporting you (alongside paying bills and some house admin eg insurance/ cars etc) then you really aren't a single parent. It's just being split in a way that's exhausting for you but he may think he's more than doing his share.

If you aren't in danger - can you buy yourself some time out of the exhaustion? Do you have an allowance or access to the whole
salary? If so, use some for a mothers help or up cleaners hours. Get a break and get some real understanding of being a single mother and whether that is truly preferable to any benefits of your current life?
can you talk to a therapist to begin with Too?

good luck with whatever you decide to do x

CrazyMidget · Today 15:47

Glowingup · Today 15:40

Well, no, there is never a guarantee is it but does that mean that women should remain in miserable relationships (and I'm sorry but my standards are higher than wanting to tiptoe around someone's moods and getting no help whatsoever with childcare) because there is a chance that their children's father might try to evade maintenance payments? No. If he is employed, there are also various enforcement mechanisms and it's actually fairly difficult to just 'not pay'. The point about him having more kids with someone else, so bloody what? For a start, it won't drastically reduce the OP's maintenance (the reduction is fairly small) and again, should women remain in miserable relationships for fear that their exes might have more children in the future?

No one's saying that OP needs to stay indefinitely. But she needs to plan.

Glowingup · Today 15:50

CrazyMidget · Today 15:45

Standards are expensive. If you have three very young children and no income, you can't afford standards! I jest, but you know what I mean. OP is better off cultivating a return to work and getting her own income up rather than leaving in the next few months, imo.

How is she meant to cultivate her return to work when her DP completely opts out of parenting (I would say this in itself is bordering on abusive behaviour and sets a dreadful example to the kids) and she's tip-toeing around his mood swings? Does he strike you as the type who would happily let the OP go back to work, step in to help with the kids and pay for childcare? Does he fuck. If she stays, it carries on like this. If she leaves, she's dependent on benefits rather than this man and at least she has some mental peace. People make so many assumptions, that the OP chose this, she chose to be a SAHM, she was happy with the relationship else she wouldn't have had kids, she must have been happy with the division of labour. Shows such a lack of understanding of relationships like this.

Glowingup · Today 15:51

OneHazelBird · Today 15:46

This must have changed then or I was told wrong.

When I applied for it they asked me how much maintenance I received and as it was zero then they said it didn’t affect my claim.

I’m really pleased to hear that as I’ve always thought that was so unfair.

That must have been quite a while ago or you might be referring to spousal maintenance. Spousal maintenance does reduce benefits pound by pound but child maintenance does not.

Newversion2FINAL · Today 15:52

FramboiseFraise · Today 12:43

Not going to shoot you down. I agree entirely.
Especially as his job requires a lot of travel, I cannot see how he was ever going to be a particularly present father.

I agree also. I also have three kids of a similar age, and it's about to be four. I'm not a single parent in a relationship, but I do know how damn hard it is to be responsible for everything.

I think leaving him is jumping the gun, especially as you've seemingly not even talked about it, just a lot of tiptoeing around. I mean, that's exhausting. It's better to have it out.

If you are in a relationship with a lazy guy who is a rubbish dad and not helping you practically BUT is a high earner and supporting you (alongside paying bills and some house admin eg insurance/ cars etc) then you really aren't a single parent. It's just being split in a way that's exhausting for you but he may think he's more than doing his share.
Exactly this.

Please reconsider breaking up your family.

slowthisbirddown · Today 15:52

BlueFahrenheit · Today 13:41

I presume OP is not married?

You should have married and anchored yourself to his finances.

What even if she doesn't love him?

Chinscratches · Today 15:56

This thread is reminiscent of a lot of other odd threads recently

Giving you the benefit of the doubt ... Don't do anything till you are well established in a decent job

Because, at best he will be a decent man and pay on time for a while. But then he will meet a new woman and she will want to have a baby and they will decide that it makes most financial sense for him to be a SAHD for a while....

CrazyMidget · Today 15:59

Glowingup · Today 15:50

How is she meant to cultivate her return to work when her DP completely opts out of parenting (I would say this in itself is bordering on abusive behaviour and sets a dreadful example to the kids) and she's tip-toeing around his mood swings? Does he strike you as the type who would happily let the OP go back to work, step in to help with the kids and pay for childcare? Does he fuck. If she stays, it carries on like this. If she leaves, she's dependent on benefits rather than this man and at least she has some mental peace. People make so many assumptions, that the OP chose this, she chose to be a SAHM, she was happy with the relationship else she wouldn't have had kids, she must have been happy with the division of labour. Shows such a lack of understanding of relationships like this.

When you have children as young as OP's, leaving is likely to be a medium/longterm plan. When the youngest is in nursery, she could retrain. In the meantime, she could sell stuff on ebay, whether it's stuff she thrifts or makes, depending on what her talents are. For example, if I could paint or sew, I would sell my paintings or, say, baby clothes. And we don't know that her DP wouldn't facilitate her return to work/retraining. That's an assumption. I agree that the relationship doesn't sound very good, but PP are right that there are various ways he could get out of paying CM, and then she'd be well and truly buggered. I don't think leaving now is wise. OP needs to plan and save, imo.

Glowingup · Today 16:00

Chinscratches · Today 15:56

This thread is reminiscent of a lot of other odd threads recently

Giving you the benefit of the doubt ... Don't do anything till you are well established in a decent job

Because, at best he will be a decent man and pay on time for a while. But then he will meet a new woman and she will want to have a baby and they will decide that it makes most financial sense for him to be a SAHD for a while....

That is completely ludicrous. Yeah, he really seems like the type to want to become a SAHD. I can pretty confidently say that, as with most men but particularly sexist twats in high earning careers who think childcare is women's work and that they have the right to opt out of parenting, this guy will never decide to become a SAHD.

Glowingup · Today 16:05

CrazyMidget · Today 15:59

When you have children as young as OP's, leaving is likely to be a medium/longterm plan. When the youngest is in nursery, she could retrain. In the meantime, she could sell stuff on ebay, whether it's stuff she thrifts or makes, depending on what her talents are. For example, if I could paint or sew, I would sell my paintings or, say, baby clothes. And we don't know that her DP wouldn't facilitate her return to work/retraining. That's an assumption. I agree that the relationship doesn't sound very good, but PP are right that there are various ways he could get out of paying CM, and then she'd be well and truly buggered. I don't think leaving now is wise. OP needs to plan and save, imo.

These sorts of relationships are financially abusive. He's not well-meaning but thick, he knows he is opting out of parenting and he thinks that is okay because he sees it as the OP's job. He knows the OP is not in work (and if they're not married, he knows that too) and that she is financially vulnerable. He just doesn't give a shit about that because this arrangement suits him pretty well. It is almost certain that he's not going to be bending over backwards to arrange the sort of childcare needed for the OP to get back to work. And that happening would also mean that he would need to parent his own children, which he has decided already is not his job. So no, I don't think the OP will be able to walk into a job where she can financially support herself and allow her to leave this relationship. If she stays with him, it will be in her current role, ie child carer and home maker.

CrazyMidget · Today 16:10

Glowingup · Today 16:05

These sorts of relationships are financially abusive. He's not well-meaning but thick, he knows he is opting out of parenting and he thinks that is okay because he sees it as the OP's job. He knows the OP is not in work (and if they're not married, he knows that too) and that she is financially vulnerable. He just doesn't give a shit about that because this arrangement suits him pretty well. It is almost certain that he's not going to be bending over backwards to arrange the sort of childcare needed for the OP to get back to work. And that happening would also mean that he would need to parent his own children, which he has decided already is not his job. So no, I don't think the OP will be able to walk into a job where she can financially support herself and allow her to leave this relationship. If she stays with him, it will be in her current role, ie child carer and home maker.

I don't think it's almost certain, but even if you're right, he can't stop OP retraining or getting a job once the youngest is in nursery or starts school.

ItalianoSl · Today 16:10

Glowingup · Today 16:05

These sorts of relationships are financially abusive. He's not well-meaning but thick, he knows he is opting out of parenting and he thinks that is okay because he sees it as the OP's job. He knows the OP is not in work (and if they're not married, he knows that too) and that she is financially vulnerable. He just doesn't give a shit about that because this arrangement suits him pretty well. It is almost certain that he's not going to be bending over backwards to arrange the sort of childcare needed for the OP to get back to work. And that happening would also mean that he would need to parent his own children, which he has decided already is not his job. So no, I don't think the OP will be able to walk into a job where she can financially support herself and allow her to leave this relationship. If she stays with him, it will be in her current role, ie child carer and home maker.

You are making rather a lot of assumptions there.
I don't think OP has indicated how they manage their finances.

Triphazardsareus · Today 16:10

Feedingmybaby · Today 12:26

Because I want my children to have a nice Christmas in their home.

I don’t think he would try and get out of paying for them. He isn’t a horrible person, he’s just not what I want.

He's not what you want but you went on to have 2 more children after you realised he was a bystander parent?