Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

SAHM and decided to leave my DP.

482 replies

Feedingmybaby · Today 12:17

I have decided to leave my DP after Christmas. I’m a SAHM to a baby and two pre-schoolers and have had enough. DP covers everything financially but makes no effort to be involved in family life and I am practically a single parent.

There is no arguing between us, but I am fed up of biting my tongue and pussyfooting around him due to his mood swings and sensitivity.

Looking for advice on how I can start to get prepared and what people advise going forwards. DP is a fairly high earner and I estimate that child maintenance will be around the £1500-£2000 mark as he earns above the threshold that CMS takes into account.

I anticipate that I will have near enough full time care of the children as DPs job involved lots of overnight travel and I just don’t think he would push for anything else really.

OP posts:
FunPartyIdeas · Today 14:39

Crushed23 · Today 14:34

I’m no expert on the benefit system, but this seems like a reasonable assumption? OP says CMS will be £1500-2000, then there’s child benefit x3, plus UC. I imagine this will be enough to live on?

And to pay rent etc?!
Why bother working in that case?
And if child arrangements go 50/50, no CMS. He can also claim CB for at least one of the kids too to take that away.

WilliamTopazMcGonagallPoorPoetFromDundeeBeItTold · Today 14:39

Glowingup · Today 14:19

Most people talk about their DH and DP on threads where said person has acted absolutely abominably so that means nothing.

True, but that tends to be the ones where they start with a trivial irritant that slowly leads to the uncovering of horrendous abuse, once the scales finally fall from her eyes.

This thread is different: OP doesn't seem to have any real issues with him - apart from wanting him to be around more to parent, as well as earning a massive salary that enables her to be the primary parent - it just sounds like she's thinking that she might be able to 'do better', but still relying on him to pay for everything after she's left and taken the children with her.

FairKoala · Today 14:40

Feedingmybaby · Today 12:27

The parenting won’t be any different for me. I am genuinely a single parent in regards to this. But I’m worried about how we’ll manage financially as he covers all of this.

Think about it that he might cover the cost of all the bills but you are covering the cost of childcare.
If you did return to work what exactly would the monthly bill be compared to your earnings . Would like me childcare costs outstrip what you could earn.

If he goes for 50/50 he is going to have to fork out for childcare himself out of his own pocket as well as getting dc to and from nursery on his days
I think he will go for EOW given his job
He might threaten 50/50 but no judge is going to give someone children when they have a job where he stays away every week

He is probably going to look at CM as an expense he sets up to pay on DD.
Whether he sees dc for an overnight stay EOW is something that will probably not happen after the initial interest. Or he gets his family members to do because he is exhausted from his Big Job and travelling

All the practical things that you do, he will have to take on as well as his job
If he thinks he is hard done by now he will certainly feel it intensely when he realises his life wasn’t so bad and didn’t justify the anger and moodiness.

What is your housing situation like.
Do you own or rent and who’s name is on the deeds.

If your name isn’t on the deeds you need to look at what financial input you have put into the house.

If your name is on the deeds and you feel safe then I wouldn’t move out. It is your house and you have every right to be there. The house most likely would need to be sold and the equity split. You might get more than 50% (unsure how not being married affects this but as you have to house 3 dc as well as your self virtually full time you might get a higher percentage.

You can claim UC as a single person if you are in the process of splitting up.
I would look initially at Entitled to website and answer honestly that you are living separately from your ex partner but still under the same roof / separate beds etc and see what you could get now.
Then do the same exercise as though the separation has occurred and use the postcode of a random rental property you think would be practical to live in via Rightmove to find out what you can realistically get.

Then If you have a chunk of money via the equity in the house and you bought, what would you get if that was the case.
I have had a few friends who bought 1 bed flats for themselves and their dc as that was what they could afford and whilst dc were still young they worked and saved and eventually climbed the property ladder to buy bigger and bigger places.

Do think that if your stbex is reasonable and pays you CM that is luck rather than design.

I know a lot of single mums. I don’t know any who have regular CM paid into their account. each month.
These deadbeat dads include high earners as well as those who flit from job to job and the self employed guy who says he earns only £10 per day from his cash business despite paying out £40,000 per year on his child’s school fees (apparently that money is borrowed from family members)

PuddleDuckling5 · Today 14:40

If you do decide to stay and work on the relationship (the only right decision in my view with three tiny kids and the circumstances you describe) please marry him!

Not in a coldly calculating way because you plan to eventually leave him and get your money’s worth, but because you are hugely vulnerable without marriage. What if he dies? What if he has an affair? Do you have any rights to the house or any joint savings and so on?

Why not stay, marry him, work on the relationship and make peace with what you can’t fix, and work towards your own financial independence over the next few years, if only to make you feel less trapped. Once you have a viable exit, you may well feel less desperate to use it.

FunPartyIdeas · Today 14:41

FairKoala · Today 14:40

Think about it that he might cover the cost of all the bills but you are covering the cost of childcare.
If you did return to work what exactly would the monthly bill be compared to your earnings . Would like me childcare costs outstrip what you could earn.

If he goes for 50/50 he is going to have to fork out for childcare himself out of his own pocket as well as getting dc to and from nursery on his days
I think he will go for EOW given his job
He might threaten 50/50 but no judge is going to give someone children when they have a job where he stays away every week

He is probably going to look at CM as an expense he sets up to pay on DD.
Whether he sees dc for an overnight stay EOW is something that will probably not happen after the initial interest. Or he gets his family members to do because he is exhausted from his Big Job and travelling

All the practical things that you do, he will have to take on as well as his job
If he thinks he is hard done by now he will certainly feel it intensely when he realises his life wasn’t so bad and didn’t justify the anger and moodiness.

What is your housing situation like.
Do you own or rent and who’s name is on the deeds.

If your name isn’t on the deeds you need to look at what financial input you have put into the house.

If your name is on the deeds and you feel safe then I wouldn’t move out. It is your house and you have every right to be there. The house most likely would need to be sold and the equity split. You might get more than 50% (unsure how not being married affects this but as you have to house 3 dc as well as your self virtually full time you might get a higher percentage.

You can claim UC as a single person if you are in the process of splitting up.
I would look initially at Entitled to website and answer honestly that you are living separately from your ex partner but still under the same roof / separate beds etc and see what you could get now.
Then do the same exercise as though the separation has occurred and use the postcode of a random rental property you think would be practical to live in via Rightmove to find out what you can realistically get.

Then If you have a chunk of money via the equity in the house and you bought, what would you get if that was the case.
I have had a few friends who bought 1 bed flats for themselves and their dc as that was what they could afford and whilst dc were still young they worked and saved and eventually climbed the property ladder to buy bigger and bigger places.

Do think that if your stbex is reasonable and pays you CM that is luck rather than design.

I know a lot of single mums. I don’t know any who have regular CM paid into their account. each month.
These deadbeat dads include high earners as well as those who flit from job to job and the self employed guy who says he earns only £10 per day from his cash business despite paying out £40,000 per year on his child’s school fees (apparently that money is borrowed from family members)

I could be wrong, but isn't the house rented?

Crushed23 · Today 14:42

FunPartyIdeas · Today 14:39

And to pay rent etc?!
Why bother working in that case?
And if child arrangements go 50/50, no CMS. He can also claim CB for at least one of the kids too to take that away.

Edited

I don’t know, isn’t there housing benefit available? I don’t live in the UK so I find these threads fascinating - either great advice to the OP on how to maximise benefits, or vehement disapproval of needing any state assistance. No middle ground!

MyCatChloe · Today 14:43

kittenswhiskas · Today 14:29

Good luck op, I do know a couple of friends that were in your situation and they said they were better off financially after splitting on benefits etc, they actually had more money

Well whoopee for them. Sod the hard-pressed taxpayer.

catornotcat · Today 14:43

There are lots of legal wheezes men can use to reduce child maintenance payments, so be aware of that.

SeniorSausage · Today 14:45

You might think you feel like a single parent but I promise that actually being a single parent is very different.

I love being a single parent but I had a decent career and some financial support from family to keep a roof over our heads.

You need a decent home for you and the kids and a reliable way to pay all the bills as a bare minimum.

MalateOxaloacetate · Today 14:45

BusyGreySnail · Today 13:44

I'm sorry this was hard for you and your family, but frankly I find it baffling that your DM was surprised she had to find part time work in this situation. I don't know how it has been normalised that a grown adult is able to rely on their ex for life and never be expected to financially support themselves. Same with OP. I would just never expect this.

This tbh. She worked part time with a school age child and for all that was able to live her life and have her child go to private school. Hardly poverty to work a few hours a week as a grown adult.

MyCatChloe · Today 14:45

Crushed23 · Today 14:34

I’m no expert on the benefit system, but this seems like a reasonable assumption? OP says CMS will be £1500-2000, then there’s child benefit x3, plus UC. I imagine this will be enough to live on?

She has no way of knowing what CMS will be. This is just her wildly optimistic assumption. I think she may be disappointed.

AInightingale · Today 14:46

If you leave him and the house is in joint names, you will get no UC whatsoever unless he agrees to buy you out (in which case you will have to live, pay rent etc from your share) or sell the house (men can be very reluctant to do either). This is a tricky, dodgy situation to be in - the court costs for forcing a sale can be colossal.

FunPartyIdeas · Today 14:46

Crushed23 · Today 14:42

I don’t know, isn’t there housing benefit available? I don’t live in the UK so I find these threads fascinating - either great advice to the OP on how to maximise benefits, or vehement disapproval of needing any state assistance. No middle ground!

Benefits shouldn't be a lifestyle choice.

LeedsLoiner · Today 14:48

Crushed23 · Today 14:34

I’m no expert on the benefit system, but this seems like a reasonable assumption? OP says CMS will be £1500-2000, then there’s child benefit x3, plus UC. I imagine this will be enough to live on?

It'll certainly be a lot more than a lot of people who work full time bring in...whilst the OP sits at home as a SAHM.

Crushed23 · Today 14:48

FunPartyIdeas · Today 14:46

Benefits shouldn't be a lifestyle choice.

I don’t disagree.

SeniorSausage · Today 14:49

MyCatChloe · Today 14:43

Well whoopee for them. Sod the hard-pressed taxpayer.

Sorry? Should these women stay living in an unhappy/difficult relationship to save the government money? Or perhaps they should hand back benefits that they are entitled to? Sod their poor kids. You have no idea what situations these women have come from nor what other contributions they might make to society.

ItalianoSl · Today 14:49

Crushed23 · Today 14:42

I don’t know, isn’t there housing benefit available? I don’t live in the UK so I find these threads fascinating - either great advice to the OP on how to maximise benefits, or vehement disapproval of needing any state assistance. No middle ground!

I don't think anyone begrudges people depending on benefits if they are fleeing abuse.
It seems OP is a bit fed up. She won't get housed in anything decent and long term if she makes herself voluntarily homeless.

MalateOxaloacetate · Today 14:50

Crushed23 · Today 14:42

I don’t know, isn’t there housing benefit available? I don’t live in the UK so I find these threads fascinating - either great advice to the OP on how to maximise benefits, or vehement disapproval of needing any state assistance. No middle ground!

There’s housing benefit but a major shortage of social housing. So she will either end up in emergency accommodation (a hotel or B&B room) for months or years or she will get a private property rented for her by the council… both are putting an enormous strain on the public purse which is struggling to keep up with supporting its population. Meanwhile she has a paid for life with a safe man that she planned to have 3 children with and who she only appears to be leaving because he isn’t as involved with the kids as she, the SAHM, would like.

People just wonder why people choose to leave a perfectly OK life to eek money from the taxpayer when it’s their own choices that have led to their lack of income. Of course this doesn’t apply to women fleeing abuse or unsafe homes or who have been widowed or something else outside of their control. But OP is none of that, she’s just fed up.

MalateOxaloacetate · Today 14:51

SeniorSausage · Today 14:49

Sorry? Should these women stay living in an unhappy/difficult relationship to save the government money? Or perhaps they should hand back benefits that they are entitled to? Sod their poor kids. You have no idea what situations these women have come from nor what other contributions they might make to society.

No, they should get a job and support themselves and their children when they leave their marriage…

ItalianoSl · Today 14:51

SeniorSausage · Today 14:49

Sorry? Should these women stay living in an unhappy/difficult relationship to save the government money? Or perhaps they should hand back benefits that they are entitled to? Sod their poor kids. You have no idea what situations these women have come from nor what other contributions they might make to society.

PP says she knows women in the same situation as OP - no abuse, just unhappy and feeling like they're doing everything. As other PP have said, maybe she needs to put some work into the relationship for the sake of them both and their children, before looking at the State to support her.

FunPartyIdeas · Today 14:51

ItalianoSl · Today 14:49

I don't think anyone begrudges people depending on benefits if they are fleeing abuse.
It seems OP is a bit fed up. She won't get housed in anything decent and long term if she makes herself voluntarily homeless.

Agreed, and to help them to get back on their feet and working again so they are self-reliant.

SeniorSausage · Today 14:51

AInightingale · Today 14:46

If you leave him and the house is in joint names, you will get no UC whatsoever unless he agrees to buy you out (in which case you will have to live, pay rent etc from your share) or sell the house (men can be very reluctant to do either). This is a tricky, dodgy situation to be in - the court costs for forcing a sale can be colossal.

That's not true? I claim UC and own my own home. We jointly owned when he moved out and its now completely in my name.

Amber995 · Today 14:52

I’ve been a single parent for a year. Husband walked out. I used to think I was a single parent with husband at home as he did very little, also a high earner and worked away all the time!
I now know I definitely wasn’t a single parent. Both kids are off school sick at the moment by the time they are back at school and I’m at work it will have been 10’days without seeing adult due to the bug. I would never chose to be a single mum it’s hard, relentless and lonely.
your kids are young, it’s tough! Try counselling together and individually work out what is best

catornotcat · Today 14:54

Feedingmybaby · Today 12:27

The parenting won’t be any different for me. I am genuinely a single parent in regards to this. But I’m worried about how we’ll manage financially as he covers all of this.

You probably won't.

£1500/ £2000 is nowhere near enough to live on.

And you probably won't even get that. A high earning man who has not married you has almost certainly made a deliberate decision not to marry you to protect himself financially. Why you think such a man will be financially obliging and generous to you when you leave him and take his children with you is beyond me. He can also afford a nanny whilst the children are with him, so don't bet on getting full custody either.

Whatever you do, your position is precarious as you are not married. Staying and building a career so you are better able to support yourself and your children, whether you stay or go, would be a better bet.

WhosGotTheKeysToMyBimma · Today 14:55

This is a very sad thread. If it's genuine I think OP is going to be in for a shock.

Life on benefits is not cushy and you'll be lucky if DP pays anywhere near what you think. CMS has no teeth to enforce and men know this.

He may go for 50/50 and then where will she be?