Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School massively cocked up. What do I do

217 replies

Washingforweeks · Today 12:07

My son is y11 struggling a lot with his mental health. He’s in councilling and I’ve also contacted school to let them know and asked if he can see the MG nurse there. He’s expressed feeling suicidal.

yesterday school called me and said they were concerned as my son had spoken with the nurse and he’d signed himself out and left school premises.
I called him couldn’t get hold of him and I called school back, they said they had searched school and he was no where. So obviously I panicked like mad, rang the police to file missing person, we couldn’t find him anywhere.

about half hour later my son messaged and said I can’t answer. I said answer now it’s urgent where the hell are you. He called me a few minutes later he was sat in his English class!! I asked him to put the teacher on the phone so I could verify this and in the background I heard her talking to another teacher saying how on earth have wires got so crossed. The teacher was very apologetic and said she can only assume another child signed out pretending to be my son. I questioned how on earth a child can just sign them selves out and leave school premises any way with out a teacher knowing, she said she had been very busy with an emergency and unfortunately my son would of flown under the radar and just walked out. (Which we now know he didn’t). I’ve asked them to review cctv find out what happened etc.
getting that phone call frightened me to death. I honestly thought I was going to have heart attack.

do I just leave it now or do I need to insist the school has stricter protocols, if so how do I do this?

any advice please

OP posts:
Comeinsideforacupoftea · Today 16:11

I understand that there's some additional complications with his mental health issues but the lad is almost an adult.... What do you think is going to happen once he's 18 and he no longer has to tell you his wherabouts 24/7?

Mapletree1985 · Today 16:13

ExtraOnions · Today 12:19

A child, with a similar name to yours, has legitimately signed out, in doing this they have selected the wrong name.

School thinking it’s your child, invoke the correct protocols, and informed you.

He was then located 30 minutes later in class.

Unfortunate, but nothing too dramatic. These things happen when you are managing 700 kids

Once I was called by my son's school to tell me he had dislocated his shoulder. I had to drop everything at work, drive for half an hour doing my best to observe safety, and walked breathlessly into the nurse's office. She directed me to the back room, where a child I'd never seen before was sitting on the cot cradling his sore arm. "Who are you?" I said, probably quite brusquely. "Who are you?" he shot back.

Turned out he was the only other kid in the school with the same rather unusual first name as my son.

AmnesiacDream · Today 16:16

nomas · Today 13:49

So it was just a misunderstanding, as suspected.

I doubt they lied, he could have been somewhere they didn't look.

For a child where there is a suicide or self harm concern - which is strongly implied by a MH appointment prompting an unplanned sign out - the search should have been extremely thorough. Given he wasn't hiding anywhere, this seems to be something they did mess up.

LondonPapa · Today 16:17

helpfulperson · Today 13:39

What CCTV? Are you saying that classrooms have CCTV in them, because I've never heard of that.

Schools have CCTV in hallways and entrances / exits. A lot have done since the early to mid-2000s. Some schools have audio recording too. All for safeguarding and yet they fail miserably as OP described.

AmnesiacDream · Today 16:17

Comeinsideforacupoftea · Today 16:11

I understand that there's some additional complications with his mental health issues but the lad is almost an adult.... What do you think is going to happen once he's 18 and he no longer has to tell you his wherabouts 24/7?

Edited

The same thing. He doesn't have to tell OP his whereabouts now. She's still going to be concerned and the school are still going to have a duty of care.

Dutch1e · Today 16:17

BluebellBeth · Today 15:56

Surely that would be the first place you'd check.

If a young person with mental health struggles signs out and time is critical, would you really look for them in the place they just signed out of?

I understand that the sign-out system at this school has a design flaw but they didn't know that and were working as swiftly as possible based on the information they had.

Edit for typo

NeverDropYourMooncup · Today 16:20

ColinISabirthdaycake · Today 15:49

Yes in some ways I'd expect his class to be the last place they'd look. But if registration happens electronically now, they should have seen he'd been registered.

If the signing out comes either after the register has been taken, it shows that he's left. If it comes before the register is closed, it shows that he's already left and with a busy class, particularly after some form of incident, the teacher may have floodfilled and not realised that he was already marked absent and she'd have to go back, reopen the register and manually overwrite his entry.

What is notable is that as soon as they saw he had been signed out, they immediately reacted, rather than assume that it was probably for an appointment - possibly at the same time as seeing that somebody else hadn't arrived in class, so they checked Inventry/whatever system and saw another student had left.

Dutch1e · Today 16:20

OP, my heart absolutely breaks for you, you must have been in bits.

The advice about making your complaint outcome-focused is excellent, and my choice would be an overhaul of the sign-out system to ensure that parents and those brilliant, bloody dedicated, teachers all have the correct information to work from.

BluebellBeth · Today 16:26

Dutch1e · Today 16:17

If a young person with mental health struggles signs out and time is critical, would you really look for them in the place they just signed out of?

I understand that the sign-out system at this school has a design flaw but they didn't know that and were working as swiftly as possible based on the information they had.

Edit for typo

Edited

I don't actually disagree with you.

I was replying to someone who said it's obvious they'd search toilets etc etc before the classroom. If you decided to search in school, the class, class teacher and his mates would be the obvious place to start. I should perhaps have quoted @motherofpufflingsrather than @ColinISabirthdaycake

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 16:30

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Today 15:08

The DS has MH issues, has spoken about suicide then (allegedly) left school unexpectedly after a session with the MH nurse. How was the OPs response an overreaction?

Her overreaction is towards the school and their response who dealt with it appropriately - there is no complaint to be made

AmnesiacDream · Today 16:32

MotherofPufflings · Today 13:47

Rather than lying, do you not think that they possibly didn't even think to check his class and assumed that if he was there he was hiding in the toilets/in the grounds? What would be their motivation for lying to you?

Edited

The motivation for lying in most cases of a service or commercial provider talking to a user/customer is to stop the customer/user from going on about something and causing them work they don't want to do. It happens all the time. And would certainly be a possibility here.

Dutch1e · Today 16:33

BluebellBeth · Today 16:26

I don't actually disagree with you.

I was replying to someone who said it's obvious they'd search toilets etc etc before the classroom. If you decided to search in school, the class, class teacher and his mates would be the obvious place to start. I should perhaps have quoted @motherofpufflingsrather than @ColinISabirthdaycake

Oh I see what you mean. Then yes, that's a good point and I take back my comment.

Washingforweeks · Today 16:34

Comeinsideforacupoftea · Today 16:11

I understand that there's some additional complications with his mental health issues but the lad is almost an adult.... What do you think is going to happen once he's 18 and he no longer has to tell you his wherabouts 24/7?

Edited

He isn’t 18. He’s 16, and when he’s 18. 28, 58 etc I’ll still be here for him

OP posts:
MyArtfulGreySloth · Today 16:39

ExtraOnions · Today 12:19

A child, with a similar name to yours, has legitimately signed out, in doing this they have selected the wrong name.

School thinking it’s your child, invoke the correct protocols, and informed you.

He was then located 30 minutes later in class.

Unfortunate, but nothing too dramatic. These things happen when you are managing 700 kids

Yes I’m sure you’d be this blasé if it was your own child 🙄

Comeinsideforacupoftea · Today 16:40

Washingforweeks · Today 16:34

He isn’t 18. He’s 16, and when he’s 18. 28, 58 etc I’ll still be here for him

You can be there for him of course. But I would argue that it isn't realistic to expect any professional organisation that isn't a prison or a mental health facility to infalibly monitor the wherabouts of somebody who is almost an adult.

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Today 16:42

Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 16:30

Her overreaction is towards the school and their response who dealt with it appropriately - there is no complaint to be made

Well thankfully most people on here disagree with you. The school messed up at several points - incorrectly told the OP had seen the MH nurse so were concerned about his actions following this. He hadn’t seen the nurse neither had he walked out of school. Their actions lead to the police being called unnecessarily and a huge amount of stress to the OP. Lessons absolutely need to be learnt from this.

Endorewitch · Today 16:43

ExtraOnions · Today 12:19

A child, with a similar name to yours, has legitimately signed out, in doing this they have selected the wrong name.

School thinking it’s your child, invoke the correct protocols, and informed you.

He was then located 30 minutes later in class.

Unfortunate, but nothing too dramatic. These things happen when you are managing 700 kids

No they don't.If another child signed out for dentist etc ,how on earth could the school mistake him for OP son. This is not a mistake. This is someone not doing their job properly.

Slightyamusedandsilly · Today 16:47

ExtraOnions · Today 12:19

A child, with a similar name to yours, has legitimately signed out, in doing this they have selected the wrong name.

School thinking it’s your child, invoke the correct protocols, and informed you.

He was then located 30 minutes later in class.

Unfortunate, but nothing too dramatic. These things happen when you are managing 700 kids

It is quite dramatic that a child, a minor of 11, exhibiting suicide ideation is potentially allowed to leave school. Suppose it had been him and he'd killed himself? I think that can be categorised as the school neglecting their duty of care.

Zebedee999 · Today 16:54

ExtraOnions · Today 12:19

A child, with a similar name to yours, has legitimately signed out, in doing this they have selected the wrong name.

School thinking it’s your child, invoke the correct protocols, and informed you.

He was then located 30 minutes later in class.

Unfortunate, but nothing too dramatic. These things happen when you are managing 700 kids

Completely agree. But OP immediately goes down the complain (compo?) route instead of understanding the pressures of having hundreds of kids under your control as teachers do.

NeverDropYourMooncup · Today 17:05

Slightyamusedandsilly · Today 16:47

It is quite dramatic that a child, a minor of 11, exhibiting suicide ideation is potentially allowed to leave school. Suppose it had been him and he'd killed himself? I think that can be categorised as the school neglecting their duty of care.

Edited

It would be for an 11 year old to be allowed to leave. However, as per the first four words of the OP, 'My son is y11'.

Slightyamusedandsilly · Today 17:12

NeverDropYourMooncup · Today 17:05

It would be for an 11 year old to be allowed to leave. However, as per the first four words of the OP, 'My son is y11'.

Missed the Y!!!

However, if he'd left and killed himself, the school would face multi-agency safeguarding investigations, a coroner's inquest, and potential legal or regulatory liability (according to AI). And I suspect the head would be forced to resign.

So maybe not a small thing really.

AmnesiacDream · Today 17:12

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Today 16:42

Well thankfully most people on here disagree with you. The school messed up at several points - incorrectly told the OP had seen the MH nurse so were concerned about his actions following this. He hadn’t seen the nurse neither had he walked out of school. Their actions lead to the police being called unnecessarily and a huge amount of stress to the OP. Lessons absolutely need to be learnt from this.

More worryingly, I think, is that if someone did see the mental health nurse and sign themselves out using the wrong name, the school would not have notified the correct parent or had the correct vulnerable child being looked for.

While OP's situation was stressful and but ultimately no harm done, the real concern is how their systems could so easily miss identifying the correct child who is at risk and needs action.

diddl · Today 17:18

Presumably it's policy to inform parents when their child signs themselves out of school?

I think timings are also important.

Not sure how a child accidentally signing out with another's name can be 100% prevented.

Nearly50omg · Today 17:19

LeaveTheWorldBehind · Today 12:42

How do you know that they lied about looking for him?

He was in the class he was meant to be! All they had to do was walk along to the classroom and check!!!! Which they clearly didn’t! Just rang his mum to stress her out and left her to deal with the potential issue!!

BeLemonMoose · Today 17:29

ExtraOnions · Today 12:19

A child, with a similar name to yours, has legitimately signed out, in doing this they have selected the wrong name.

School thinking it’s your child, invoke the correct protocols, and informed you.

He was then located 30 minutes later in class.

Unfortunate, but nothing too dramatic. These things happen when you are managing 700 kids

I agree. I know it is worrying but no need for an official complaint