Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School massively cocked up. What do I do

217 replies

Washingforweeks · Today 12:07

My son is y11 struggling a lot with his mental health. He’s in councilling and I’ve also contacted school to let them know and asked if he can see the MG nurse there. He’s expressed feeling suicidal.

yesterday school called me and said they were concerned as my son had spoken with the nurse and he’d signed himself out and left school premises.
I called him couldn’t get hold of him and I called school back, they said they had searched school and he was no where. So obviously I panicked like mad, rang the police to file missing person, we couldn’t find him anywhere.

about half hour later my son messaged and said I can’t answer. I said answer now it’s urgent where the hell are you. He called me a few minutes later he was sat in his English class!! I asked him to put the teacher on the phone so I could verify this and in the background I heard her talking to another teacher saying how on earth have wires got so crossed. The teacher was very apologetic and said she can only assume another child signed out pretending to be my son. I questioned how on earth a child can just sign them selves out and leave school premises any way with out a teacher knowing, she said she had been very busy with an emergency and unfortunately my son would of flown under the radar and just walked out. (Which we now know he didn’t). I’ve asked them to review cctv find out what happened etc.
getting that phone call frightened me to death. I honestly thought I was going to have heart attack.

do I just leave it now or do I need to insist the school has stricter protocols, if so how do I do this?

any advice please

OP posts:
Washingforweeks · Today 13:45

The school have just phoned me and said that another student in my sons form with the same initials has signed out and clicked my sons name by mistake. I completely understand these things can happen.
however, it’s the lying- which they did lie as they had stated they had searched for him and couldn’t find him. All they would have to of done is check what lesson he should have been in and they’d of seen him! I also asked how long his appointment was yesterday with the mh nurse and whether it was just a basic how can we help initial appointment. This never happened!! He has had that appointment today. So for school to call me and say he had a mh appointment then discharged him self is completely inaccurate, he never even had that appointment.

previously if my son has had a reason to leave school early ie an orthodontist appointment, he has never been able to just leave. I’ve had to go to reception to let them know I’ve collected him, so for him to just be able to sign himself out isn’t their usual protocol.

for those saying my annoyance should be aimed at my son- for what exactly?? He was sat in his English class non the wiser, going about his day!

OP posts:
Washingforweeks · Today 13:45

helpfulperson · Today 13:39

What CCTV? Are you saying that classrooms have CCTV in them, because I've never heard of that.

I believe there is cctv on the entrances to the school

OP posts:
MotherofPufflings · Today 13:47

Rather than lying, do you not think that they possibly didn't even think to check his class and assumed that if he was there he was hiding in the toilets/in the grounds? What would be their motivation for lying to you?

nomas · Today 13:47

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Today 13:37

The school have told the OP that they messed up. Why do you seem to think that they didn’t ?

No, they haven't, she "said she can only assume another child signed out pretending to be my son."

This doesn't yet tell us what has actually happened.

ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 13:48

helpfulperson · Today 13:39

What CCTV? Are you saying that classrooms have CCTV in them, because I've never heard of that.

No I’m not, OP said she’d asked them to check CCTV of entrances.

CasperGutman · Today 13:48

It seems like an unfortunate mistake, and one that merits a review of how they could have handled things differently, but I can see how it would happen without anyone needing to "lie" as such.

A member of staff - in our school most likely the duty deputy head, plus other SLT and pastoral staff available - will have been tasked to search the school for a missing pupil. They'll have looked in the places a missing pupil might be - toilets, corridors, behind the tree at the bottom of the playground, etc. They won't have looked in the classroom, perhaps because in 99% of cases where a pupil is "missing" it's because the class teacher has noted that they're not there when they should be.

As I said, unfortunate - and especially scary for you @Washingforweeks given the backstory - but an honest mistake. The information you were given was inaccurate and misleading, but to me calling it a lie implies the person who said it knew it to be untrue and intended to mislead you.

Make a complaint with a view to the school improving procedures and especially internal communication if similar situations arise in future. Don't go in all guns blazing accusing people of telling lies because this is very unlikely to be true and won't get a productive response.

Specialneedsnightmare · Today 13:48

The lying is disgraceful , and I wouldn't be able to let that go. In your shoes, I would have to make a formal complaint to the head, stating my concerns and loss of confidence in the school that they would state he was at a mental health appointment which he clearly wasn't , and also state that they had searched for him when that clearly wasn't the case either.

Washingforweeks · Today 13:48

MotherofPufflings · Today 13:47

Rather than lying, do you not think that they possibly didn't even think to check his class and assumed that if he was there he was hiding in the toilets/in the grounds? What would be their motivation for lying to you?

Edited

No I spoke to them on 2 seperate occasions and she was adamant he wasn’t on school premises at all. I’ve also just posted an update of another lie

OP posts:
ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 13:48

nomas · Today 13:47

No, they haven't, she "said she can only assume another child signed out pretending to be my son."

This doesn't yet tell us what has actually happened.

She said more than that. And she’s updated further since, they clearly messed up.

nomas · Today 13:49

Washingforweeks · Today 13:45

The school have just phoned me and said that another student in my sons form with the same initials has signed out and clicked my sons name by mistake. I completely understand these things can happen.
however, it’s the lying- which they did lie as they had stated they had searched for him and couldn’t find him. All they would have to of done is check what lesson he should have been in and they’d of seen him! I also asked how long his appointment was yesterday with the mh nurse and whether it was just a basic how can we help initial appointment. This never happened!! He has had that appointment today. So for school to call me and say he had a mh appointment then discharged him self is completely inaccurate, he never even had that appointment.

previously if my son has had a reason to leave school early ie an orthodontist appointment, he has never been able to just leave. I’ve had to go to reception to let them know I’ve collected him, so for him to just be able to sign himself out isn’t their usual protocol.

for those saying my annoyance should be aimed at my son- for what exactly?? He was sat in his English class non the wiser, going about his day!

So it was just a misunderstanding, as suspected.

I doubt they lied, he could have been somewhere they didn't look.

nomas · Today 13:49

ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 13:48

She said more than that. And she’s updated further since, they clearly messed up.

Another child messed up, it was a mistake, why blame that on the school?

And she’s updated further since

It was a cross post, OP posted a couple of minutes before I did.

nomas · Today 13:50

Washingforweeks · Today 13:48

No I spoke to them on 2 seperate occasions and she was adamant he wasn’t on school premises at all. I’ve also just posted an update of another lie

If she can't find him, it's better she says that, rather than pretending she knows where he is.

MotherofPufflings · Today 13:51

Washingforweeks · Today 13:48

No I spoke to them on 2 seperate occasions and she was adamant he wasn’t on school premises at all. I’ve also just posted an update of another lie

That doesn't sound like a lie, more likely a communication mix up.

Washingforweeks · Today 13:52

CasperGutman · Today 13:48

It seems like an unfortunate mistake, and one that merits a review of how they could have handled things differently, but I can see how it would happen without anyone needing to "lie" as such.

A member of staff - in our school most likely the duty deputy head, plus other SLT and pastoral staff available - will have been tasked to search the school for a missing pupil. They'll have looked in the places a missing pupil might be - toilets, corridors, behind the tree at the bottom of the playground, etc. They won't have looked in the classroom, perhaps because in 99% of cases where a pupil is "missing" it's because the class teacher has noted that they're not there when they should be.

As I said, unfortunate - and especially scary for you @Washingforweeks given the backstory - but an honest mistake. The information you were given was inaccurate and misleading, but to me calling it a lie implies the person who said it knew it to be untrue and intended to mislead you.

Make a complaint with a view to the school improving procedures and especially internal communication if similar situations arise in future. Don't go in all guns blazing accusing people of telling lies because this is very unlikely to be true and won't get a productive response.

Edited

Yes I agree, the teacher implied that who ever had used his name would be sanctioned but I did say well I don’t think that’s right it could have been a genuine mistake.

this is why I’ve posted, I am concerned that if it had happened my son could have just sauntered out of school. However I know that because there’s an element of major panic due to what’s going on with him mentally atm I can’t see a way to communicate it with out the emotions. I just feel abit upside down and disappointed, but then I also know it was a genuine mistake. However the lies weren’t x

OP posts:
ElBandito · Today 13:52

They need to establish if the student who signed out intentionally gave the wrong name or if the admins has made an error. Potentially there is actually a student missing. Most secondary schools these days the kids have ID cards, really you should have to show that to sign out.

twinkletwinkleatthebar · Today 13:53

nomas · Today 13:50

If she can't find him, it's better she says that, rather than pretending she knows where he is.

The OP has just posted an update about the MH nurse apt being today not yesterday. There has been a HUGE communication error (or rather multiple errors) which need to be investigated.

CasperGutman · Today 13:53

"they did lie as they had stated they had searched for him and couldn’t find him"

Respectfully, their statement was inaccurate and their search inadequate, but that doesn't mean they lied.

ObliviousCoalmine · Today 13:54

Not quite compatible, but I very regularly used to get a text/call at about 10am saying my daughter hadn’t registered that morning, wasn’t in school and wasn’t in her lesson. I could see on Life360 she was in school and every single time I used to have to send them back to where her lesson was to “check again” and magically she’d appear.

It is a safeguarding issue, particularly because of the things you’ve flagged to the school about his MH.

MotherofPufflings · Today 13:54

Have they apologised at all?

Doseofreality · Today 13:54

And this is a perfect example of why kids should be allowed to have their phones on them whilst in school.
I’ve had two separate occasions when schools aha contacted me asking where my child was, on both occasions their form teacher has mismarked the register.
OP, that must have been so worrying for you. It’s not a nice call to receive. I would be lodging an official safeguarding complaint.

CasperGutman · Today 13:54

If a year 11 pupil is determined to leave school premises then I don't think any school will prevent them. Certainly not a mainstream school. They might instruct them that they need to stay, but they won't physically restrain them from leaving.

Crazybigtoe · Today 13:56

nomas · Today 13:49

Another child messed up, it was a mistake, why blame that on the school?

And she’s updated further since

It was a cross post, OP posted a couple of minutes before I did.

Edited

The school need to know where students are. The other child signing out as OPs son is an issue.

But what's also of issue is the incorrect updates that the OP received re the whereabouts of her child.

  1. he didn't attend the MH appointment
  2. he was on site and in his classroom but they said he wasnt

With any child the above is problematic. With a child who has MH issues and spoken about suicide, this adds an extra dimension.

ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 13:56

nomas · Today 13:49

Another child messed up, it was a mistake, why blame that on the school?

And she’s updated further since

It was a cross post, OP posted a couple of minutes before I did.

Edited

You and intentionally missing the point and not reading the posts properly

BePeachNewt · Today 13:57

Washingforweeks · Today 13:45

The school have just phoned me and said that another student in my sons form with the same initials has signed out and clicked my sons name by mistake. I completely understand these things can happen.
however, it’s the lying- which they did lie as they had stated they had searched for him and couldn’t find him. All they would have to of done is check what lesson he should have been in and they’d of seen him! I also asked how long his appointment was yesterday with the mh nurse and whether it was just a basic how can we help initial appointment. This never happened!! He has had that appointment today. So for school to call me and say he had a mh appointment then discharged him self is completely inaccurate, he never even had that appointment.

previously if my son has had a reason to leave school early ie an orthodontist appointment, he has never been able to just leave. I’ve had to go to reception to let them know I’ve collected him, so for him to just be able to sign himself out isn’t their usual protocol.

for those saying my annoyance should be aimed at my son- for what exactly?? He was sat in his English class non the wiser, going about his day!

But if they thought he’d signed out and left the building, why would they go and check the classroom he was supposed to be in? Surely they’d be searching outside instead?

BerryTwister · Today 14:00

Would your son agree to having “find my phone” or some sort of tracking app? It would make life easier.