Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?

467 replies

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:17

I'm American, DH is British and we've lived in England for nearly 10 years now, we came back after Trump, I am from Georgia, which has now turned blue!! We do plan to go back once all children are finished with education/at university. All 3 of our children were born in the states, have dual citizenship so can go to university in either country.

Our eldest DS is due to start university next September, although he's still undecided whether to go straight away or take a gap year. He's interested in Economics and Maths and has applied to several universities through UCAS, choosing slightly different courses at each but all along those lines. He's already had offers from most of them and is currently preparing for his Cambridge interview.As he's our eldest, we've never been through any of this before. I've only really started looking into student finance over the last couple of years, especially with all the news about Plan 2 loans, interest, repayment thresholds and people wanting loans written off.

DH and I have been going back and forth about whether to let him take out a student loan or just pay the tuition fees ourselves. DH is on the fence but leans towards letting him take the loan, as his argument is that most people never pay the whole thing back anyway, so why spend the money when it might eventually get written off? I'm looking at it quite differently, probably because I'm American. I actually came to university in the UK myself because my parents worked out that even paying international student fees here was cheaper than going to an American university.

When I told my parents how much home student fees are here, they genuinely couldn't believe it. To them it's pennies, I do understand that is a privilege. They've now said they would happily just pay the tuition fees for all our children themselves rather than have them take out loans.For context, my brother's children go to a private day school in America where fees are approaching $100k each per year, and he's already planning for them to come to university in the UK because of how much cheaper it is.

I've also spoken to a few parents at DS's school and some seem to be planning on paying their children's fees outright, some are undecided. One mum I spoke to has an eldest son who finished university about seven years ago. She said she wishes they'd just paid his fees at the time rather than let him take out SFE. He's got a decent job straight out of university, and she said seeing how much was coming out of his salary between tax, NI and student loan repayments was quite an eye opener. His parents eventually decided to pay off the remaining loan for him.

I do understand that student loans here aren't like normal loans and that plenty of people never pay them off in full. But if you can afford to pay the fees without it affecting your finances, surely that makes more sense, even more so now. DH thinks I'm looking at this through my American upbringing and not understanding how the UK system works. Maybe he's right!

Would you pay your child's tuition fees upfront if you had the money, or would you let them take out the loan and use that money elsewhere?
Interested to hear from people who've actually been through this, especially those with older children who've graduated and you either paid or took our the tuition fees loans?

OP posts:
DearCrab · Yesterday 11:03

TallagallaPenguin · Yesterday 10:54

And do you think $100k / year school fees are normal for most people in the US? Your family’s wealth isn’t the norm, even in the US. Certainly not here. We get that it’s cheap at uni here compared to what you’re used to, but it’s not cheap compared to what most people are used to.

Would be good for you to actually reflect on that because you don’t seem to have done that at all so far. You’ve explained why it seems cheap to you, but not reflected on how it might not be cheap for most other people.

I don't think I have said everyone in the states can afford that. I was just stating that that is a norm and the fees for higher education in the states are very high, ie here you can study medicine for 10k that is not the case for the states That is not me stating that every single America can afford to do pay the fees in the states or here its just a start difference and for a lot of middle class families in the states they would see UK fees as relatively cheap. Middle class families have higher incomes in the states that is just a fact. I am not stating these to absolutes but I am stating that higher education is FAR more expensive in the states than it is here. There is a difference between the average vs the median as well as that professional salaries here are much higher in the US for the same job. Say for instance Nursing, my sister in law in the states is a nurse and the wage difference is very stark, her and my brother can afford to send their children to private schools. In the UK that is not as common for nurses (as an example) a graduate nurse earns about 60k in the states, here its in the 30s. She has been a nurse for 20 years. This is just an example, I am not saying every single person in the states is high earning but the salaries for the same job differ massively.

OP posts:
Thirteenblackcats · Yesterday 11:04

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:23

Weren't the fees £9/9250k per year ? That would still be under 30k for 3 years. How did it get to 50k straight out of University, unless you mean a few years after, when it accrued interest, I am assuming that is Plan 2

Fees and maintenance loan I’m presuming

Circe7 · Yesterday 11:06

I wouldn’t personally unless money was no object. I think usually it doesn’t make financial sense to.

I think it’s preferable to give money for a house deposit or further graduate training (which might not be funded) or even for travel or similar. This is imo much more likely to make a difference to your child’s future than paying off a loan which they may never pay back anyway. And anything can happen that may mean your child won’t be able to repay it - serious health issues, AI decimating the area they wanted to go into etc.

Student loans aren’t debt in the usual sense as repayment is conditional on income and no one can come after you if you don’t pay.

Even if you do have the money, you’re probably best investing it and paying off the loan once it becomes clear your child will make enough to have to repay it or giving them the choice of taking a lump sum instead.

Wooli · Yesterday 11:06

But either way OP, you grew up with money. The average HOUSEHOLD income in the UK is £39,000 ($51,000). The average household income in the USA is $87,000. Yet housing costs broadly the same in both countries (£17,000 per year/$22,000).

Only rich families could ever earn enough to save enough to pay tuition fees and all other associated costs. The average British person saves £147 a month. Millions can’t afford any savings at all. The average cost of putting a child through uni for three years outside London is £70,000. It would take forty years for the average person to save enough for one child, or 60 years if the child goes to uni in London.

Even when fees were free, it was only wealthy families that could afford to send children to uni. We don’t want to return to a time when bright working class children were written off because education was out of their financial reach.

But yes, I agree that if a family is in a position to have hundreds of thousands in savings, they should pay their children’s fees. If you could prevent them being saddled with debt for their working lives, why wouldn’t you? Unfortunately the vast majority of people couldn’t even dream of it. Just contributing to their rent is a struggle.

museumum · Yesterday 11:11

If I had enough money to pay their maintenance and enough for a house deposit for them, without affecting our retirement income or our ability to buy ourselves any elderly care we need, only then I'd consider it.

But that would require about a quarter of a million pounds in cash that I don't have on top of the savings we already do have, so no.

Scarcityvarcity · Yesterday 11:11

I think quite a lot of parents do pay the fees and maintenance. My DCs went to universities with a lot of ex private school students and I think few of them took out loans. I wish I could do it for my children.

Wadsworthy · Yesterday 11:14

Thirteenblackcats · Yesterday 09:20

My colleague graduated in 2020 with £50000 debt. Sure cheap if you can afford it

Tuition fees are £9,700 pa. A lot of your colleague's debt will be a loan for living expenses. Those are within a student's control.

Universities currently make a loss on most domestic undergrad students - a loss of somewhere between £1,000-£2,000 per student per year. The shortfall is made up by international students, who generally pay at least twice the amount that home students pay in tuition fees. And then academic staff do hours & hours per week of unpaid overtime or annual leave foregone, as well as bringing in external funds to pay for research, research students, and research facilities.

KitsyWitsy · Yesterday 11:15

Last time I looked my student loans were at 86k. I can’t say I ever think about it.

ChocolateApples · Yesterday 11:16

I guess the logical approach is to make a spreadsheet and see how things stack up. Don't forget there's an opportunity cost if you pay the fees. I think the current interest is 4.1% on a Plan 5 loan, based on RPI. You could probably earn more investing that money. But would you put that exact sum aside in an investment account for the child?

Plus it is pretty rubbish to graduate and then lose that extra money, so it would be very nice not to have to and have more money for a pension/flat deposit etc. It sounds like you will be handing over a fair amount of cash to your kids as young adults so I'd probably just consider it as part of that.

WaterlooBridge · Yesterday 11:16

Scarcityvarcity · Yesterday 11:11

I think quite a lot of parents do pay the fees and maintenance. My DCs went to universities with a lot of ex private school students and I think few of them took out loans. I wish I could do it for my children.

There were stats published on this recently at Russell Group universities.

About 5% of English students do not take a maintenance loan or tuition fee loan, so no student finance debt.

About a third don’t take out the maintenance loan.

claphamjunction123 · Yesterday 11:18

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:31

Sorry I did not mean for it to come off tone deaf. My parents are in their 80s, they will never spend majority of their money and want to help their grandchildren. They are coming at this from an American angle, higher education is very expensive in the states so to them 10k a year is nothing in the grand scheme of things. Not trying to be tone deaf, just stating how they view it and how I view it based on the states that is all

What a ghastly person you are.

Ilovedettol · Yesterday 11:19

We are paying tuition and accommodation fees when DS goes next year, so around £20k pa. He has taken a gap year and is working to save money to finance the rest. He already has decent savings as he’s had a part time job since he was 15 which he will come back to work in during uni holidays.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 11:20

Thirteenblackcats · Yesterday 09:20

My colleague graduated in 2020 with £50000 debt. Sure cheap if you can afford it

American university fees are enormous and can saddle a graduate with enormous debt for life esp for medicine and law. But UK fees are not cheap compared with much of the rest of Europe and Scotland, where university education is 'free'. I would much prefer to go back to maintenance grants and fees paid (the government still pays most fees anyway) with fewer people going to university.

user001236547 · Yesterday 11:21

We're also American. We paid their fees. Two of ours ended up going back to the US for uni and we paid for them too. I think it's great that it's more reasonable here, and I know it's out of reach for many families, but why saddle your child with debt if it's within your means not to?

Ilovedettol · Yesterday 11:21

claphamjunction123 · Yesterday 11:18

What a ghastly person you are.

Why? I can’t see that op is “ghastly” in any way.

Schoolchoicesucks · Yesterday 11:21

Your OP is misleading because you actually seem to be asking if your parents should pay the fees for their grandchildren. And you missed the "relatively" cheap.

In your circumstances then yes, please do get your wealthy elderly loud southern parents to pay £150k to the UK's economy.

For everyone else on the thread, whether you should pay depends. On your financial circumstances and your children's expected earning trajectory. If paying fees would stretch you financially or means you couldn't support them with a house deposit, the loans probably make sense.

Grammarnut · Yesterday 11:21

claphamjunction123 · Yesterday 11:18

What a ghastly person you are.

She's not ghastly, just tone deaf and ignorant.

IzzyLeng · Yesterday 11:23

Do remember you will have to top them up for living costs as well. With multiple kids especially if there may be some timeframe overlap that can add up.

So dd gets the minimum loan due to our income, think she gets under 5k a year maintenance. So we pay her rent which is 1k a month. She was meant to live off the loan but couldn't so I am also topping her up £140 a month plus paying for spotify, netflix, phone, contact lenses. It adds up!

Are your kids planning on staying in the uk or might they go the the USA? I know if they move abroad they are supposed to come to an arrangement to set up a direct debit and pay money back every month. But it can't be taken out their wages like it is in the UK and I don't know how enforceable this is? How can they trace someone in the USA who is no longer using an NI number, etc? Obviously that's a moral issue but from a practical pov I suspect you can drop out of view and never pay it back.

DearCrab · Yesterday 11:24

claphamjunction123 · Yesterday 11:18

What a ghastly person you are.

I don't think I have said anything nasty or cruel towards anyone. Maybe I am misunderstanding what ghastly means

OP posts:
reluctantbrit · Yesterday 11:24

We pay for DD, tuition fee and maintenance. But we put money away since she is 3 when her nursery fees came down due to free hours. Over 15 years we managed to save a decent sum.
We also managed to be mortgage free a year prior to her starting so all extra money is now funnelled into savings as well, for us and for her uni pot.

She had the tuition fee loan in the first year but when we saw how interest was already accruing we paid it off and now fund her.
She will do a masters and we decided to see how much money is left for that, she may take the loan and we supplement.

Plenty of people say „save for a house deposit“ but how many undergrads/postgrads settle down immediately long-term, plenty of them only get short term contracts.

JuliaAgrippina · Yesterday 11:24

Would you pay your child's tuition fees upfront if you had the money, or would you let them take out the loan and use that money elsewhere?

If we could I'd pay it upfront and then not have the amount taken off when they start to earn.

Can't so have to hope it's not to bad a burden in adult life and terms do not change under them.

Chenecinquantecinq · Yesterday 11:25

pay it for them

Ilovedettol · Yesterday 11:27

Grammarnut · Yesterday 11:21

She's not ghastly, just tone deaf and ignorant.

Or actually, factually correct? Compared to America, University fees in the UK are much cheaper. That is just a fact. We have friends in the USA putting their children through university and the costs are staggering.
Someone having more money than you, either their own or family money in no way makes them “ghastly”, “tone deaf” or “ignorant”.

DearCrab · Yesterday 11:28

I think people are taking an offence to my post. I haven't come here to boast, just to hear other parents views as at our children's school it seems as though most parents just pay it, granted they are at an independent school. I do recognise the privilege. There's a lot of assumptions about me, my take is from someone who grew up in the states, my parents offered me the opportunity to come to the uk to study because to them it was cheaper to pay international fees here than it was back home. Its not to upset anyone, I am aware that others might be struggling that is not the aim of the post, if my post has been offensive towards anyone I do apologise and you have every right to disengage from the post. I can only speak from my own experience and I know it is a privilege to be in this position.

OP posts:
JuliaAgrippina · Yesterday 11:29

DearCrab · Yesterday 11:24

I don't think I have said anything nasty or cruel towards anyone. Maybe I am misunderstanding what ghastly means

I think they are ignoring you are from US where fees and costs are just ridulous and you may not be aware many here got degrees when there was no tution fees and still some grant.

Jobs here without degree few and low paid - with better options even with debt. Apprenticeships are harder to get on than degree courses. Also we are not providing house deposits - we did save from birth and they have that which is a buffer on tip of loans and they may get something from DGP when they die - but house depoist are outside our scope.

I do think you need to look down at the figures but if you can pay it's one less bill in adulthood for them to cope with.