Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?

467 replies

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:17

I'm American, DH is British and we've lived in England for nearly 10 years now, we came back after Trump, I am from Georgia, which has now turned blue!! We do plan to go back once all children are finished with education/at university. All 3 of our children were born in the states, have dual citizenship so can go to university in either country.

Our eldest DS is due to start university next September, although he's still undecided whether to go straight away or take a gap year. He's interested in Economics and Maths and has applied to several universities through UCAS, choosing slightly different courses at each but all along those lines. He's already had offers from most of them and is currently preparing for his Cambridge interview.As he's our eldest, we've never been through any of this before. I've only really started looking into student finance over the last couple of years, especially with all the news about Plan 2 loans, interest, repayment thresholds and people wanting loans written off.

DH and I have been going back and forth about whether to let him take out a student loan or just pay the tuition fees ourselves. DH is on the fence but leans towards letting him take the loan, as his argument is that most people never pay the whole thing back anyway, so why spend the money when it might eventually get written off? I'm looking at it quite differently, probably because I'm American. I actually came to university in the UK myself because my parents worked out that even paying international student fees here was cheaper than going to an American university.

When I told my parents how much home student fees are here, they genuinely couldn't believe it. To them it's pennies, I do understand that is a privilege. They've now said they would happily just pay the tuition fees for all our children themselves rather than have them take out loans.For context, my brother's children go to a private day school in America where fees are approaching $100k each per year, and he's already planning for them to come to university in the UK because of how much cheaper it is.

I've also spoken to a few parents at DS's school and some seem to be planning on paying their children's fees outright, some are undecided. One mum I spoke to has an eldest son who finished university about seven years ago. She said she wishes they'd just paid his fees at the time rather than let him take out SFE. He's got a decent job straight out of university, and she said seeing how much was coming out of his salary between tax, NI and student loan repayments was quite an eye opener. His parents eventually decided to pay off the remaining loan for him.

I do understand that student loans here aren't like normal loans and that plenty of people never pay them off in full. But if you can afford to pay the fees without it affecting your finances, surely that makes more sense, even more so now. DH thinks I'm looking at this through my American upbringing and not understanding how the UK system works. Maybe he's right!

Would you pay your child's tuition fees upfront if you had the money, or would you let them take out the loan and use that money elsewhere?
Interested to hear from people who've actually been through this, especially those with older children who've graduated and you either paid or took our the tuition fees loans?

OP posts:
4939 · Yesterday 10:15

We haven’t but we did fund living expenses (so no maintenance loan taken) and now a large mortgage deposit. They can pay the tuition fees loans themselves. If we paid all of those we wouldn't have been able to do the mortgage deposit which is a chunk of money you need upfront as opposed to smallish monthly payments to pay tuition loan off.
Paying say 30-50k over 3-4 years for university seems a bit like money for nothing but 30-50k house deposit means they can get a house and lower mortgage and yiu need the money all at once for that. You also don’t know ahead of uni whether indeed the graduate will get a job that pays enough to make payments or indeed pay it all off before 35 years but if they have got a property and a smaller mortgage then that is a big support.
If we had had more funds we might have paid the loans also but the way we have done it worked best for us.

Stowickthevast · Yesterday 10:16

@DearCrab you just have to look at any uni FB group or the higher education boards on here to see that people are genuinely struggling with this. There's a thread at the moment about how more kids are commuting to university as they can't afford to live out. I know several people who have EU passports who are looking c at European unis as the fees are either non-existent or far cheaper - think £1,000-3,000 a year. I also know several people who are considering whether their children can afford to go to uni at all.

The accruing interest on loans is scary and a change from when I was at uni (90s) when the first loans started. Those were fixed at a low interest rate -2% pa I think - and were much smaller as we only paid a tiny amount in fees.

ShanghaiDiva · Yesterday 10:16

mondaytosunday · Yesterday 10:10

Most students WILL pay off their loans with Plan 5, and a fair chunk will be interest which starts from day one. The argument has been take the loan and if you have the money put it aside to be an eventual house deposit. But if you can afford both, pay the fees.
Im asset rich but cash poor. My DD gets a bursary tied to her SFE amount. So it made sense for her to take the loans, plus her eventual career is not likely to be particularly remunerative. I know some who are on quite good salaries that pay hundreds a month.
Its true fees here are small compared to the US. But it’s not the norm here to save for your children’s university, as until relatively recently there were no fees at all, so a number have been caught without the wherewithal to help with the costs.

Agree it’s not usual to start a uni fund when DCs are born. I went to uni in the 80s when it was free and I had a full grant that covered all my living expenses. Cost to my parents £0.

FunPartyIdeas · Yesterday 10:17

I'm 46 and still paying off my bloody student loan!! My parents couldn't afford to just pay it, unfortunately. We won't be able to for our kids either.

Herewegoagain127 · Yesterday 10:18

Are you sure it’s cheaper?

if he’s Cambridge material many Ivy leagues are means tested, you don’t pay a cent if you earn less than $100k, and then it’s a sliding scale contribution above that.

that’s accommodation, food, everything.

in state tuition is also often cheap. I think the state my dc is in it’s £10k- and even if you aren’t in state after the first year you can claim in state fees. Obviously that is negated by cost of living, the extra degree year etc, but then if they are US citizens they may be eligible for scholarships and aid, which isn’t really a thing here.

4939 · Yesterday 10:21

ignore I see OP is living in UK

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?
Kaybee50 · Yesterday 10:21

My teenager has just started university and has sadly had no choice to take out both the loan for Uni fees and a maintenance loan which doesn’t even cover their rent. I’m doing my best to cover rent and given them a monthly allowance. Very sadly I can’t support them financially in any other way. It’s not ‘small change’ for lots of families.

ColinOfficeTrolley · Yesterday 10:21

The title of your post is rather offensive.

You might think they are, but for working class families. It's certainly not cheap!!!

I would love to pay dd's fees in full for her so she left debt free.

As it is, she is entitled to minimum maintenance loan which doesn't even touch accommodation costs.

We will hopefully scrape together accommodation fees - which btw are higher than our mortgage, but she will have to live off the maintenance loan and leave with the debt of tuition fees.

So yes, it might be cheap to you, and by all means, if you have the privilege to pay all the fees, do it!!!!! Why wouldn't you?

But please do not think it's the same for everyone.

noramoo · Yesterday 10:22

Oh come on now OP 🙄not entirely sure if this is some kind of thinly veiled humble brag but anyway... Yes, if you can just pay the fees. As several PP have said, often it is not "just" the £9kpa fees to take into account but also maintenance loans, meaning the total per child could hit £50k for a 3 year degree. For a lot of families, particularly with more than one child, this is unattainable. This could easily be one year's entire salary pre-tax per child. Hope this helps you contextualise.

Crocsarentslippers · Yesterday 10:22

This is quite a funny post, so crass it's come out of the other end of being offensive and is just a bit embarrassing!.

OP, you obviously have so much old deep south family money ( let's not talk about how that was accrued) , that UK University fees are pennies to you.

The answer to your question is obvious - nobody takes out a loan if they don't need it, even one on reasonably favourable terms like a tuition and maintenance fee one.

However, four reasons to take the loans from a UK perspective :

  1. Repayments only start when a graduate hits a certain income bracket.
  2. Repayments are low and not designed to be a burden to a graduate.
  3. Student Loans are not counted as debt when applying for a mortgage, so it doesn't affect a credit score.
  4. If the debt isn't paid off in 30 years, or before a student reaches retirement age, it is written off.

I hope that helps you understand why loans are beneficial for all us poor people.

DearCrab · Yesterday 10:23

Herewegoagain127 · Yesterday 10:18

Are you sure it’s cheaper?

if he’s Cambridge material many Ivy leagues are means tested, you don’t pay a cent if you earn less than $100k, and then it’s a sliding scale contribution above that.

that’s accommodation, food, everything.

in state tuition is also often cheap. I think the state my dc is in it’s £10k- and even if you aren’t in state after the first year you can claim in state fees. Obviously that is negated by cost of living, the extra degree year etc, but then if they are US citizens they may be eligible for scholarships and aid, which isn’t really a thing here.

We do not know if he is Cambridge material. It is still at the interview stage, hasn't attended the interview yet and interview isn't a guarantee for an offer.
We wouldn't qualify for ivy league just for means testing even if he applied but we haven't looked into it, he wants to attend University here.

OP posts:
WaterlooBridge · Yesterday 10:23

4939 · Yesterday 10:21

ignore I see OP is living in UK

Edited

I was thinking the same. OP is likely fine but her brother’s children would be charged the overseas students tuition fee which is generally higher than US public colleges, cheaper than Ivy League.

Apricothairy · Yesterday 10:23

You are coming at this from an American lens and a wealthy one at that.

University education never used to be charged here in the UK and yet we still hold top place in the worldwide ranking. A lot of Americans and Chinese people study here for the quality and costs. A lot of families haven’t got a spare £9k for fees, I couldn’t simply pay that right now, then to add accommodation plus living costs.

BerryTwister · Yesterday 10:24

LancashireButterPie · Yesterday 10:11

This is one thing that really annoyed me about saint Martin Lewis.
Back in the day we took his advice re: "just take the loan, it's the cheapest loan they'll ever have and they probably won't pay it back".
Now DD is saddled with £73,000 of debt which continues to rise despite her paying £300 a month back.

With her younger siblings we were able to avoid this, one doing a degree apprenticeship and one doing an unusual course that attracted industry sponsorship. We paid their living costs ourselves.

If you can afford it, then absolutely pay his fees.

What I can't understand (and this has happened to a few of DCs friends) is parents paying for private education, then not paying for university costs. I'd do that that the other way around.

@LancashireButterPie I thought the repayments were only affected by income, not the size of the debt. That’s certainly what I’ve read. So the monthly payment is the same if your income stays the same, and only rises if your income rises, regardless of how big the debt becomes.

Tablesandchairs23 · Yesterday 10:24

Only cheap if you can afford it.

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Yesterday 10:25

With the way student loans are structured now, if you can afford to and are confident your child will go into a high paying role you are far better off paying the fees upfront than taking the loans. In the past taking the loans was a bit of a no-brainer as it was such cheap money, now it is pretty expensive.

normanstangersoninthebath · Yesterday 10:26

The fees will increase now they are losing the Middle Eastern students. The big company's and government sponsorship will no longer be paying for UK degrees due to cultural concerns. They are already heavily moving towards Germany and Holland instead.

JHound · Yesterday 10:28

[AIBU] In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?

Humble brag

WaterlooBridge · Yesterday 10:30

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Yesterday 10:25

With the way student loans are structured now, if you can afford to and are confident your child will go into a high paying role you are far better off paying the fees upfront than taking the loans. In the past taking the loans was a bit of a no-brainer as it was such cheap money, now it is pretty expensive.

Can you explain what you mean? Interest on Plan 5 current loans is RPI, so pegged to inflation. Yes a higher measure of inflation than CPI but it’s the same as it used to be when you say it was cheap money. Or maybe you mean inflation is now higher.

Or are you thinking of the old Plan 2 loans which are RPI plus up to 3%?

EasternStandard · Yesterday 10:32

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:26

Oh I haven't looked into maintenance loans. Think the fees are now at 10k, which is why we have been discussing this as they are now going up consistently after being stagnant on 9k/9250 for a while and the new plans aren't so good.

Do you mean you'll be paying these fees? Ie around 9k to 10k?

Dorisbonson · Yesterday 10:33

UK universities are in a culture war, not sure we would send our son to university here. If we don't emigrate we would pay for him to study in Australia, Eastern Europe or Cape Town.

SevenYellowHammers · Yesterday 10:34

“Cheap to those that can afford it. Very expensive to those who can’t.”

MyManinCaracas · Yesterday 10:35

I’m an American and know that the worst thing you can be on MN is a wealthy American, innocently asking about school or housing. 😆 You’re fine, OP, and as you have noted it’s a different cultural perspective. There’s nothing wrong with the points you are making or the questions you are asking.

oldwhyno · Yesterday 10:35

you're being unreasonable to think they're "so cheap" by UK economic standards, but you're not being unreasonable to pay them if you're so wealthy you can do so without affecting your finances.

It's a much more difficult decision if you have enough savings to do it, but it most definitely would affect your finances to some not insignificant degree.

DearCrab · Yesterday 10:38

Crocsarentslippers · Yesterday 10:22

This is quite a funny post, so crass it's come out of the other end of being offensive and is just a bit embarrassing!.

OP, you obviously have so much old deep south family money ( let's not talk about how that was accrued) , that UK University fees are pennies to you.

The answer to your question is obvious - nobody takes out a loan if they don't need it, even one on reasonably favourable terms like a tuition and maintenance fee one.

However, four reasons to take the loans from a UK perspective :

  1. Repayments only start when a graduate hits a certain income bracket.
  2. Repayments are low and not designed to be a burden to a graduate.
  3. Student Loans are not counted as debt when applying for a mortgage, so it doesn't affect a credit score.
  4. If the debt isn't paid off in 30 years, or before a student reaches retirement age, it is written off.

I hope that helps you understand why loans are beneficial for all us poor people.

Not sure I'd describe us as old money when my father, now in his 80s, was the second youngest of 12 children and grew up in a three-bedroom house in rural Georgia. It's the reason he has such a strong Southern accent about as Deep South as you can get! He barely had any formal schooling, let alone went to college. Neither of my parents came from money. They both grew up very poor, and whilst they're fortunate now that certainly wasn't always the case. My father has never worked an office job; he's always worked blue-collar jobs. If anything, I grew up new money, not old money, hated by the old money types in Georgia, if you know Georgia you will understand what I mean.

I've actually traced my family history In Georgia back to the 1700s, having grown up in the South and being interested in its history and studied History at university and was always interested in American history. When my ancestors were living in Georgia, the state itself had only recently been established. Georgia was formed in 1733. Many regular families were incredibly poor, and mine were certainly not plantation owners or wealthy landowners. If that's what you're insinuating you're making quite an assumption. I have traced my family history for a while yet no old money or plantation owners.

I think it's important not to make assumptions about someone's background or how family wealth is acquired simply based on where they're from. I didn't choose to be from Georgia and I'm very familiar with the history of my home state, including the history you're alluding to.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread