Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking that university fees in the UK are so cheap that we should just pay them for our children?

468 replies

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:17

I'm American, DH is British and we've lived in England for nearly 10 years now, we came back after Trump, I am from Georgia, which has now turned blue!! We do plan to go back once all children are finished with education/at university. All 3 of our children were born in the states, have dual citizenship so can go to university in either country.

Our eldest DS is due to start university next September, although he's still undecided whether to go straight away or take a gap year. He's interested in Economics and Maths and has applied to several universities through UCAS, choosing slightly different courses at each but all along those lines. He's already had offers from most of them and is currently preparing for his Cambridge interview.As he's our eldest, we've never been through any of this before. I've only really started looking into student finance over the last couple of years, especially with all the news about Plan 2 loans, interest, repayment thresholds and people wanting loans written off.

DH and I have been going back and forth about whether to let him take out a student loan or just pay the tuition fees ourselves. DH is on the fence but leans towards letting him take the loan, as his argument is that most people never pay the whole thing back anyway, so why spend the money when it might eventually get written off? I'm looking at it quite differently, probably because I'm American. I actually came to university in the UK myself because my parents worked out that even paying international student fees here was cheaper than going to an American university.

When I told my parents how much home student fees are here, they genuinely couldn't believe it. To them it's pennies, I do understand that is a privilege. They've now said they would happily just pay the tuition fees for all our children themselves rather than have them take out loans.For context, my brother's children go to a private day school in America where fees are approaching $100k each per year, and he's already planning for them to come to university in the UK because of how much cheaper it is.

I've also spoken to a few parents at DS's school and some seem to be planning on paying their children's fees outright, some are undecided. One mum I spoke to has an eldest son who finished university about seven years ago. She said she wishes they'd just paid his fees at the time rather than let him take out SFE. He's got a decent job straight out of university, and she said seeing how much was coming out of his salary between tax, NI and student loan repayments was quite an eye opener. His parents eventually decided to pay off the remaining loan for him.

I do understand that student loans here aren't like normal loans and that plenty of people never pay them off in full. But if you can afford to pay the fees without it affecting your finances, surely that makes more sense, even more so now. DH thinks I'm looking at this through my American upbringing and not understanding how the UK system works. Maybe he's right!

Would you pay your child's tuition fees upfront if you had the money, or would you let them take out the loan and use that money elsewhere?
Interested to hear from people who've actually been through this, especially those with older children who've graduated and you either paid or took our the tuition fees loans?

OP posts:
PoppetDog · Yesterday 13:09

deutschland83 · Yesterday 13:09

This thread is a massive ick.

Yes, it's so bad I'm tempted to think it's rage bait.

BunkBedsArePeopleShelves · Yesterday 13:09

10k a year seems a lot to me. We have free fees, so we pay just 3000 a year in charges. But the first two years were discounted in the Budget, and we get 500 grant towards it, so I paid 1000 a year for my DD and 2500 for 3rd and 4th year.

40k plus living costs seems like a huge amount

DearCrab · Yesterday 13:09

Toodaloos · Yesterday 12:54

You won’t get a medical degree for £10k. Medical degrees are at least 5 years, quite possibly 6, with a couple of years of supervised learning afterwards. You are looking at least £15,000 for fees best case scenario. Medical degrees are hard work and unlikely you will be able to take on part time work to support your living and so you’d need to look at additional loans to live off too if not funded by parents or some sort of external backing. Very easily £100,000 in the 5 years….

I did not mean 10k for 5 years?

Our daughter wants to study medicine, we have been looking into Universities as she started her A Levels this academic year. So far the tuition fees are 10k for home students per year that is very cheap compared to med schools in the states. I am focused on tuition fees. We have saved up for university living costs separate to their normal savings since all our children were babies. I am confused by the additional loans?

I have a friend in the states and her son is studying medicine at Ox, he is in his 5th year and paying international fees which is still cheaper that in the states for ivy league schools. The schools they looked in the states would have cost them over 70- 100k a year just on fees before living costs so the UK is far cheaper for higher education as a whole. Luckily our children are classed as home fee paying students, we have lived here for 10 years, their father is British and they are dual citizens.

OP posts:
DearCrab · Yesterday 13:11

PoppetDog · Yesterday 13:09

Yes, it's so bad I'm tempted to think it's rage bait.

You do not have to engage if that is what you think. I can only speak of my experiences, I wasn't born in England so have always known higher education to be very expensive then I came here and noticed the stark difference.

OP posts:
RampantIvy · Yesterday 13:11

DearCrab · Yesterday 09:31

Sorry I did not mean for it to come off tone deaf. My parents are in their 80s, they will never spend majority of their money and want to help their grandchildren. They are coming at this from an American angle, higher education is very expensive in the states so to them 10k a year is nothing in the grand scheme of things. Not trying to be tone deaf, just stating how they view it and how I view it based on the states that is all

I have just looked at what it would cost now for DD's halls when she did her undergrad degree.

Tuition fees £9790
Halls £7896
Food, travel and other living expenses ?

That's £53,058 for just tuition and a roof over your head for a three year degree. Students need to eat and socialise, travel home and have other sundry expenses.

Gonners · Yesterday 13:11

My (Brooklyn born) partner managed to get a PhD without paying any fees. He started out at a community college for his BA (no fees for people living within the borough) then moved to Columbia for MA and PhD. They gave him a grant to cover the MA fees and then, when he moved on to the PhD, they gave him a part-time job teaching English to foreign postgrad students. This meant that as a university employee, he was exempt from tuition fees AND paid enough to cover his living expenses. With the PhD under his belt, he got a job in Canada and never had a job in the US again. 😆

FatMrsHoot · Yesterday 13:12

I think if you can afford it, and you've thought about living costs etc as well, then I'd do it.

My parents paid my fees and I am very grateful to not have debt hanging over my head. This was when they were only £3k per year as well!

EasternStandard · Yesterday 13:12

DearCrab · Yesterday 13:09

I did not mean 10k for 5 years?

Our daughter wants to study medicine, we have been looking into Universities as she started her A Levels this academic year. So far the tuition fees are 10k for home students per year that is very cheap compared to med schools in the states. I am focused on tuition fees. We have saved up for university living costs separate to their normal savings since all our children were babies. I am confused by the additional loans?

I have a friend in the states and her son is studying medicine at Ox, he is in his 5th year and paying international fees which is still cheaper that in the states for ivy league schools. The schools they looked in the states would have cost them over 70- 100k a year just on fees before living costs so the UK is far cheaper for higher education as a whole. Luckily our children are classed as home fee paying students, we have lived here for 10 years, their father is British and they are dual citizens.

All this aside your dh saying you should do a loan because that's how it's done doesn't really make sense financially. You may as well pay for them if you have enough money for it not to make much of a dent.

DearCrab · Yesterday 13:15

Mumsnet isn't exclusive to one socioeconomic group. I haven't said anything offensive or uncouth to anyone and if you don't like the post, you're perfectly free to disengage. There are people from all sorts of socioeconomic backgrounds on here and I can only speak from my own experiences and perspective.

I've never denied that we're privileged. I absolutely recognise that we've been extremely fortunate and that our circumstances aren't representative of everyone. Some people seem to be putting words in my mouth and taking what I've said as something I never intended. Just because something isn't the experience of everyone doesn't mean it isn't a valid experience. We all come from different backgrounds have different circumstances and have different experiences. They're all equally valid. I wanted to see what others are doing because this has been a big discussion point, even in the news, lots of parents are considering just paying the fees, again I haven't said every parent. Same way it is just a fact that higher education is cheaper here than in America and that is the experience I am coming from.

OP posts:
shrodingersvaccine · Yesterday 13:16

I think you're comparing tuition fees in isolation rather than looking at the wider economics of the two countries. US university fees are higher, yes, but so are salaries in many professional occupations, and the earning potential after graduation is very different. You can't simply compare the headline cost of a degree without considering what graduates can realistically expect to earn afterwards, the cost of living, taxation, housing and purchasing power.

Your example of your sister is actually quite illustrative - you're using the financial circumstances of a very high-earning American family as the benchmark for judging why ordinary British families need student loans. Those are fundamentally different economic circumstances. A neurosurgeon earning $1.5–2 million in the US is operating in a completely different earning environment from a neurosurgeon working in the NHS. A UK consultant neurosurgeon will typically earn somewhere around £100,000–£140,000 in NHS base salary, depending on experience. That's an excellent salary by UK standards, but it is nowhere near the earning potential you've described for your sister. The financial return on investing in a medical education is therefore very different in the two countries.

You cannot take the American model of parental investment in education, where professional salaries can be extraordinarily high, and assume the same financial calculations apply to British families.

You also need to consider the average household's financial position here. Median UK household income was £39,200 in the financial year ending 2025, according to the ONS. That is household income, not individual income. Housing, energy, food, transport, childcare and other essential commitments have to be paid out of that. The average household expenditure was already around £623 a week in 2023/24. For many families, there simply isn't a substantial surplus left over to fund university tuition, let alone accommodation and living costs.

It's also worth distinguishing between having a good household income and having substantial accessible savings. Plenty of families are earning enough to get by comfortably month to month but don't have tens of thousands of pounds sitting in cash or investments that they can readily withdraw to pay university fees. They may have mortgages, pensions, other children to support and their own retirement to think about. Being able to afford £10,000 a year without compromising your financial security is a very different proposition from being able to afford it in theory.

That's precisely why student loans exist. They allow people to access higher education without requiring their parents to have accumulated significant wealth or savings beforehand. The income-contingent repayment system also means graduates repay according to what they earn, rather than having to meet a conventional fixed monthly loan repayment regardless of their circumstances. For someone whose family cannot afford to pay upfront, taking a loan isn't an irrational financial decision; it's often the only realistic route to university.

By your logic, I could ask why British students don't all go to India, Nigeria or the Balkans to study because tuition fees are considerably cheaper there. It's a meaningless comparison without considering local salaries, where graduates intend to work, professional accreditation, degree recognition, living costs and the wider economic circumstances.

There is a distinction between something being cheaper in absolute terms and being more affordable relative to local incomes. UK tuition fees may look extraordinarily cheap to someone accustomed to American university prices, and your parents may be entirely right that UK universities represent excellent value compared with the American system. That doesn't mean they are cheap for the average British family. On the opposite side, US tuition (and cost of living) blows Europeans minds because we just cannot comprehend earning enough to ever pay those costs - we just don't see wages that high in Europe.

I don't think anyone is disputing that having parents or grandparents who can pay tuition fees outright is a wonderful advantage. The point is that your family's financial circumstances, your parents' ability to fund education and your sister's earning potential are not representative of the financial circumstances of most British families, and you don't seem to understand that the two systems aren't comparable. That's why so many people take student loans, even if, from your family's perspective, paying the fees upfront seems like an obvious choice.

DearCrab · Yesterday 13:17

Gonners · Yesterday 13:11

My (Brooklyn born) partner managed to get a PhD without paying any fees. He started out at a community college for his BA (no fees for people living within the borough) then moved to Columbia for MA and PhD. They gave him a grant to cover the MA fees and then, when he moved on to the PhD, they gave him a part-time job teaching English to foreign postgrad students. This meant that as a university employee, he was exempt from tuition fees AND paid enough to cover his living expenses. With the PhD under his belt, he got a job in Canada and never had a job in the US again. 😆

Edited

Props to him!! I am 100% for free education and for everyone to have the opportunity to pursue higher education no matter their socioeconomic background but sadly its not free for all everywhere in the world

OP posts:
MyManinCaracas · Yesterday 13:18

In fairness to the OP her question would never cause so much vitriol with other Americans. She wouldn’t be seen as boasting or lol “ghastly” because we don’t have tall poppy syndrome. And Americans are largely unaware that there is vast poverty in the U.K. - it’s just lack of awareness, not anything evil or deliberately tone deaf.

Newbutoldfather · Yesterday 13:21

OP,

Your post is incredibly naive or incredibly crass (delete as appropriate).

I mean, yes, you are obviously right, but it is a fairly simple calculation. You look at the loan interest rate and you work out whether you can invest the same sum of money and pay off the loan and have any left over after taxes.

If the answer is yes, invest the money and give it to your children to pay the loan off. If the answer is no, pay the fees upfront.

Surely, you can either do this maths or ask your financial advisor.

On a parenting forum where many feel guilty about leaving their children in debt after uni and where many will never be able to save £50k, surely you see it is somewhat insensitive?

AbsentFriends · Yesterday 13:22

@shrodingersvaccine that is such a good reply, thank you for saying it all much better than I could!

Scarcityvarcity · Yesterday 13:22

DearCrab · Yesterday 13:15

Mumsnet isn't exclusive to one socioeconomic group. I haven't said anything offensive or uncouth to anyone and if you don't like the post, you're perfectly free to disengage. There are people from all sorts of socioeconomic backgrounds on here and I can only speak from my own experiences and perspective.

I've never denied that we're privileged. I absolutely recognise that we've been extremely fortunate and that our circumstances aren't representative of everyone. Some people seem to be putting words in my mouth and taking what I've said as something I never intended. Just because something isn't the experience of everyone doesn't mean it isn't a valid experience. We all come from different backgrounds have different circumstances and have different experiences. They're all equally valid. I wanted to see what others are doing because this has been a big discussion point, even in the news, lots of parents are considering just paying the fees, again I haven't said every parent. Same way it is just a fact that higher education is cheaper here than in America and that is the experience I am coming from.

I think it is an interesting discussion. I have only just realised how many of DC friends don't have loans. It is becoming increasingly common in UK I think as people have realised loans interest rates are extortionate. I feel bad I couldn't do it for my DC but that's life.

HelenHywater · Yesterday 13:23

I also think the OP perhaps hasn't really thought what she sounds like. You could have left all of the opinion out and just said your parents have offered to pay fees and what do people think

anyway, do what you will, but I don't know anyone (fairly wealthy parents) who has paid their children's fees. It may be that they pick them up when they leave university, but I'm not aware of anyone doing that.

You might like to think how that will set your children apart from the other children at university and possibly how existing on handouts from rich relatives isn't brilliant life experience and doesn't set them up to know how to budget, how to be in touch with real life and how to empathise with the reality for many people - something that it would be useful for a doctor to but then again, maybe you don't care about that.

Petalperfect · Yesterday 13:23

I think you worded the title incorrectly - you could just pay the fees. Many families could not afford to do the same particularly for multiple children. Plus there is a cost of living crisis. This is a privilege dilemma tbh. I think there may have been a lack of understanding of individual situations and financial differences from you op.

nicepotoftea · Yesterday 13:25

DearCrab · Yesterday 13:11

You do not have to engage if that is what you think. I can only speak of my experiences, I wasn't born in England so have always known higher education to be very expensive then I came here and noticed the stark difference.

DH is on the fence but leans towards letting him take the loan, as his argument is that most people never pay the whole thing back anyway, so why spend the money when it might eventually get written off?

This might have made sense when interest rates were lower and the write off period was shorter, but if you don't earn enough to pay off a substantial chunk, 'never paying the loan back' just means effectively paying extra tax, and you are also at the mercy of changes to the system.

pinkyredrose · Yesterday 13:27

What's the actual point of this thread, to stealth boast how much money you have?

Many people are struggling to heat thier homes right now and you're waffling on about how 'cheap' higher education is!

Newbutoldfather · Yesterday 13:30

@HelenHywater ,

I don’t know about that.

If you are lucky enough to be able to pay, all that does is put your children in the same position everyone was in 40 years ago, when fees were free and there was a means-tested accommodation grant.

I think it is sad how many students work term-time jobs now. Of course, getting work experience (and money) is great in the long hols, but uni should be about study, with a little bit of fun and widening your horizons.

Scarlettpixie · Yesterday 13:31

I don't think you are boasting OP but your post is tone deaf.

Most people in the UK can't afford to pay their children's tuition fees. In fact, many cannot afford to support their children to live away at Uni even with the tuition and maintenance loans as accommodation costs exceed the maintenance loan they are entitled to.

I saved for my son since he was small but only to the extent that when he was 18 there was enough for him to pay to learn to drive. I am a single mum (lawyer) earning just over 40K working full time. My son gets about 9K in maintenance loan plus the tuition fee loan so will leave uni with in excess of 50K in student debt. I pay for his phone and groceries and the loan covers his rent and other expenses. He is a one of the cheapest uni's for accomodation costs (under £6k). I take him on holidays.

If I could afford to pay for 20K per year, I would save that for his house deposit rather than paying for his student loans. If I could afford to do both, that would be different and I would do it gladly but very few are in your very fortunate position.

I earn above average for the UK and earn what I think is a decent wage but I have a mortgage and expenses and while I would love to help him more, it isn't possible. His dad pays nothing and has very little, he is self employed. There are no living grandparents. My inheritance went toward my house.

I am on a few forums for people who have children at Uni or are looking into them going to uni. Many parents struggle as the maintenance loan is means tested and they are already stretched yet their child only qualifies for minimum loan (about £5K) which in almost all cases will not even cover the rent (when we were looking £9K was not uncommon and it was certainly a factor to be considered when DS was making his choices - luckily his favourite was also one of the cheapest). Those children have to take a gap year to work and save or go to a local uni, limiting their options. Some just can't afford to go.

While the US has expensive fees, presumably people can afford to pay them as wages are so much higher in some roles. As someone else said, a neurosurgeon in the US can earn multiple times what one would earn here.

PinkBottle75 · Yesterday 13:32

OP you're getting a hard time as the average British person has no idea how expensive US college fees are. They are clueless.

You're absolutely right to look at courses in England and Ireland as better value than what is offered in the USA. I've often wondered why we don't get more students from America as even at £35k per year for international students, it's cheaper than what's on offer there. There is a rise in the number coming from what I've seen, looking at the research. Good arbitrage!

We have the money to pay fees for both our kids plus living costs.

However our first child has taken the loan and living cost allowance. Why?

For us, we've chosen to put the fee and living costs money into an index tracker.

Our view is that over the children's lifetime, a tracker will do better than the student loan value due to compounding over time.So this means approx £15k of our personal money goes into a stocks and shares ISA per year. It's put into something like S&P500 or VWRP and then left to sit there. As you are more than likely aware, S&P500 goes up average of 12% or so per year. So over time, the compounding effect means kids will be OK and actually do better.

There is the niggly question of the % payback if they go above £26k or whatever the sum is. That's something that will need to be addressed at the time, if and when it happens.

That's our plan at the moment. Maybe it will change.. not sure yet. If you're comfortable investing, which for sure many Americans are much more so than British counterparts, this is something you could consider.

Feel free also to pick holes in it too. I love feedback/criticism.

deutschland83 · Yesterday 13:33

DearCrab · Yesterday 13:09

I did not mean 10k for 5 years?

Our daughter wants to study medicine, we have been looking into Universities as she started her A Levels this academic year. So far the tuition fees are 10k for home students per year that is very cheap compared to med schools in the states. I am focused on tuition fees. We have saved up for university living costs separate to their normal savings since all our children were babies. I am confused by the additional loans?

I have a friend in the states and her son is studying medicine at Ox, he is in his 5th year and paying international fees which is still cheaper that in the states for ivy league schools. The schools they looked in the states would have cost them over 70- 100k a year just on fees before living costs so the UK is far cheaper for higher education as a whole. Luckily our children are classed as home fee paying students, we have lived here for 10 years, their father is British and they are dual citizens.

Right, I'll bite. Mother of Scottish students here. Stop quoting the £10k, its misleading. The total costs are horrendous regardless of whether you take loans or not. Scottish loans don't cover the cost of halls. Dundee for example, you can do medicine there but the loan doesn't cover the cost of halls, so straight away you need an additional source of income. I also live in an area where NEETS are on the rise significantly. Why? No universities within a commutable distance and its just not affordable even with a loan to lots of families here.

I work with doctors and many of them are newly through Uni. The highest number I have heard was just short £190k of student debt and climbing due to interest (English trained doctor).

Due to the difference between UK and US wages, my role would pay me twice in the US what it does here. I have worked for American companies for 25+ years now, this is not new. So uni here would feel so much more affordable.

Lots of Americans are still in a position where college loans have left them in huge debt. How do I now this? I work with them. They cant go bankrupt? Why not? You are still left paying the tax on the debt but now you're bankrupt.

The UK needs to make a massive change in its approach to education and funding for all, especially given the challenges we face with health, the environment and technology. It makes no sense to not fund these areas better, to ensure access to education and to help young people enter the workforce.

OP - you are in the 1% of the 1%, please consider yourself lucky. If you are benefitting from the education system of the UK, then I hope you do everything in your power to nurture and encourage others who cant afford uni or college to find work and do the best for themselves.

babyproblems · Yesterday 13:36

It’s not just fees for the uni; it’s housing and food and living.. and often not only for three years. You’ll be spending more than 9k per year and a lot more if it’s London or somewhere pricey