Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To limit number of days dd and partner stay with us over christmas

381 replies

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:37

Every year dd and partner stay with us as well as other adult dc .
Dd often declines to say how long she is staying and on previous years she extended the stay from the 23 rd to new year.
Dh is late 60 s and finds this v tiring much as we love her.

So so this year we said in advance we are looking forward to seeing you and as we get tired we are happy to make this 5 nights.

We feel that the previous times when they extended the stay felt too loose and so we did this .

We are worried that she experiences this as rejection.

She wanted to do something on a night that was beyond the 5 nights - we said yes we could meet them but assuming they would be with other s in the area - his parent.

she then replied saying - oh why the drama- you are trying to get rid of us .

for years we have had them for Christmas and been happy to see them , but feel it is reasonable to say we are able to manage five nights ?
my own parents made it clear that a few nights were ok ? I didn’t feel that they were trying to to get rid of me ? It was just natural to want to reclaim yr quiet home after a busy time ? How can i help her , beyond my explanation, understand that we want to see them , and that time limits are not a sign f rejection ?

I know for a fact that when we stay we her she enjoys it but if also glad when we go .. so she would understand.. maybe its the parent / child thing…

OP posts:
JollyGreenSleeves · Today 06:24

She sounds exhausting and with little social awareness. 5 days is plenty. Just be honest with her- that you love her very much but that you’re getting older and 5 days of socialising is exhausting and you need to recharge at that point. Tell her she will understand one day even if she doesn’t now. Then stick to your boundary and if she doesn’t like it, tough.

Mapletree1985 · Today 06:25

Amusing myself imagining how very different the advice would be if this was a parent overstaying their welcome with a child, or, god forbid, a MIL exhausting her DIL's hospitality.

LemonChilliDrop · Today 06:27

Ineffable23 · Yesterday 21:49

You can do whatever you want, but don't be surprised or disappointed if your DD then doesn't plan to spend as much time with you in the future.

Jesus wept!
Why does MN jump to this when a parent wants to put in a boundary?
Its fine to have guests for a known , set period of time , 10 days of constant meals and clearing up is a lot
I like 3 days then peace and quiet before I go back to work, there is nothing wrong with that
Hands out grips

Namechangefordaughterevasion · Today 06:35

DH and I are both 66 and are thrilled whenever our adult DC want to stay with us. The longer the better!

Just be upfront with them about being tired -' you two go ahead and play/eat out/go for a walk. I don't feel to that that. We are going to chill on the sofa for a few hours. ' Ask them to cook a few meals. They are family not visitors. You don't have to change for them.

One of my SILs is like a puppy. He requires constant exercise and entertainment. Luckily he is easily sidetracked by a request to cook a meal, go the the shops or do some light DIY. The other is more relaxed but for some reason LOVES housework. He likes an evening at the pub followed by a late night deep clean of the kitchen.

WhatNoRaisins · Today 06:36

I think the only way forward here is to push back on her controlling behaviour. Insist that you will be going for a coffee with Anne and that you will be having some afternoons reading a book in pyjamas or an early night. Tell her that she needs to go find something to occupy her, I tell my much younger children this sometimes, it's necessary.

She's very lucky that she's found a partner that tolerates her needy behaviour because most adults wouldn't.

PollyBell · Today 06:37

Mapletree1985 · Today 06:25

Amusing myself imagining how very different the advice would be if this was a parent overstaying their welcome with a child, or, god forbid, a MIL exhausting her DIL's hospitality.

And the parent or inlaw dictating you are not allowed to see your friends while I am here it can only be people I have approved

LemonChilliDrop · Today 06:40

ComedyGuns · Yesterday 22:40

This.

But from what you’ve said, your DD strangely seems to want to be treated like a guest, with activities laid on, rather than as an adult child coming home for the Christmas break. The former is relaxing, with everyone rubbing along as usual. The latter sounds exhausting.

Agree
The DD sounds controlling
For context
My DS is 27, owns his flat , moved out for Uni back and forth a bit
Coming home for Christmas
We have got a couple things planned but otherwise he will see friends, I go to the gym and lots of walks, some together, some alone
She sounds very rigid and its controlling to kick off if your parents dont meet your demands
Foot down hard @Boomboomi

ednaclouda · Today 06:52

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:51

HeddaGarbled
yes because the partner also comes. And also because we cant get on with our own stuff as you say as they want to do things as a group.
for example in the ten days if i wanted to have a coffee with a friend - they dont like that .

'they dont like it ' if you want to have coffee with a friend well. tough titties she's not there to be entertained by you no wonder youre exhausted strict ground rules and no nonsense from her

Rocknrollstar · Today 06:53

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:46

Because we do thjngs v differently when they are here - we cant just chill - they want to do stuff all the time and its exhausting to us to have a house full for ten days doing meals out, walks , games , without much chill time . Dh has a medical condition .

Set up a rota for cooking and cleaning and let the younger people go off and do stuff while you have a bit of peace and quiet. That said, DHs parents (in their 70s) told us we could no longer stay at all so we just used to visit for the day. That said, I do’t see enough of my DS and family and I would love them to come to stay.

Holdinguphalfthesky · Today 06:54

You have to explain. Face to face probably. That you really enjoy their company, but that you - like dd - also have a life of your own (and how lucky for her that you do, or you might be moving into their flat, installing shelves of your possessions, rearranging their cupboards, and insisting on hanging her childhood Christmas curtains (iykyk) when you come and stay all weekend 2-4 times a month).

It isn’t unreasonable for you to let them do something together while you and or your husband pop out to meet friends, Christmas is a sociable time for many people after all. It IS unreasonable for her to want to control the activities for everyone in the household for the whole holiday. You can tell her that.

violetcuriosity · Today 07:02

My parents are the same age (slightly older) and have serious health conditions and both cry when everyone leaves at Christmas 😢 we could tell them we’re all moving in for December and they’d be so, so happy. We have young kids so I think it’s quite full on but they will sit down and close the door on their living room when they’ve had enough or too tired 😂. We are also quite attuned to their needs though and will take ourselves off to the pub for the afternoon etc and they’ll happily stay at home. I think, if you can, let her stay as long as she wants but make it clear that you’ll both stay home for some of the events x

HAPPILYMARRIEDSINCE2012 · Today 07:03

Have you ever considered that your dd might be neurodiverse?

FirmSnake · Today 07:12

OP how far is she travelling to come and see you? You described 2 hours as nearby, so I assume you are further than that from her.

serenemostly · Today 07:15

I would suggest that you say to your daughter to ask from Father Christmas some empathy and the capacity to consider others rather than ride roughshod over everyone else and their needs!! Seriously though, how to deal with this: In my experience even our adult children sometimes need some guidance on being a considerate human. This is clearly what she needs for Christmas so give it to her. Tell her: Your father is unwell, we can manage ?? days then we need our space back, thank you for being considerate. And please stop worrying about whether she will be hurt - that right there is the problem - it's for her to be concerned about hurting you and her father - don't do her adulting for her or she'll never grow up into a considerate human

Susiehopefull · Today 07:17

nomoreraintoday · Yesterday 21:41

Your DH is late 60s? The way you’re talking I would have expected late 80s! How tiring can it really be?

Why should they entertain adinfinitum with all the extra expenses in their 60s,dd is taking them for granted and abusing their hospitality

User3353821614 · Today 07:18

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:57

Autumnalhibernationisthedream its not the old family home .
She was with us off and on during uni - 4 years as changed courses- then covid time came home to live - them got her job after covid moved in with bf - she is 27 .

Please use “quote” OP. It’s on the bottom
left corner of each post.

knitnerd90 · Today 07:20

I suppose I don’t see why you can’t be clearer about what goes on when she visits instead of going right to cutting the visit short. You both sound a bit difficult to be honest.

Velvian · Today 07:20

I know that MN hates when you mention ND, but she sounds like she might be Autistic. I think she won't get it unless you explain to her properly.

Tell her that you and her dad are getting older and don't have the energy to do too many organised activities and need a rest from activities.

I think the pyjama day is quite easy to turn around if you frame it as; it is one of your favourite things to do, so you want to that with her .

I think that she will really benefit if you teach her how to relax, rest and take some time out.

Susiehopefull · Today 07:22

violetcuriosity · Today 07:02

My parents are the same age (slightly older) and have serious health conditions and both cry when everyone leaves at Christmas 😢 we could tell them we’re all moving in for December and they’d be so, so happy. We have young kids so I think it’s quite full on but they will sit down and close the door on their living room when they’ve had enough or too tired 😂. We are also quite attuned to their needs though and will take ourselves off to the pub for the afternoon etc and they’ll happily stay at home. I think, if you can, let her stay as long as she wants but make it clear that you’ll both stay home for some of the events x

It's a good job we're all different!
The thought of what you suggested would drive me nuts it's an invasion, and OTT.
Nobody wants a house full for that long surely you can find and fund something else for yourselves FFS.
Just incredible what your expectations are.......

cuddlebear · Today 07:24

Is your DH not DDs father?

It is difficult to understand why he can’t bear being with her for more than a few days tbh.

I think you will cause serious damage to your relationship if you tell her she can’t stay the extra days.

Far better to say you are seeing X friend one Y date and that you will be relaxing rather than constant activities.

Nylonflares · Today 07:25

Namechangefordaughterevasion · Today 06:35

DH and I are both 66 and are thrilled whenever our adult DC want to stay with us. The longer the better!

Just be upfront with them about being tired -' you two go ahead and play/eat out/go for a walk. I don't feel to that that. We are going to chill on the sofa for a few hours. ' Ask them to cook a few meals. They are family not visitors. You don't have to change for them.

One of my SILs is like a puppy. He requires constant exercise and entertainment. Luckily he is easily sidetracked by a request to cook a meal, go the the shops or do some light DIY. The other is more relaxed but for some reason LOVES housework. He likes an evening at the pub followed by a late night deep clean of the kitchen.

This! Be firm but nice, she will get used to it

also, I really hope I get sons or daughters in law who like to do diy or clean 😄

beAsensible1 · Today 07:31

Boomboomi · Yesterday 22:01

For those of you who have said thet cant imagine telling a dd she cant stay indefinitely - yes I do feel awful.
As i said - maybe its different personality types - ds is happy to let us do own things- wereas dd likes to do and organise to does not like it if we see other people - she declines to go to the local pub for example- she likes just the family.

Ok but it’s your house and she isn’t your warden. Stop letting her control your movements. Or be honest and say we want to have an easy going time without too much organised time.

remind her that her DF is ill

Cherrytree86 · Today 07:41

She sounds overbearing, controlling and completely incapable of considering anyone else’s needs, wants or preferences.
putting in some boundaries with a person like this is a good thing.

women don’t NEED to be Martyrs to their offspring in order to maintain a relationship with them!

Cherrytree86 · Today 07:43

cuddlebear · Today 07:24

Is your DH not DDs father?

It is difficult to understand why he can’t bear being with her for more than a few days tbh.

I think you will cause serious damage to your relationship if you tell her she can’t stay the extra days.

Far better to say you are seeing X friend one Y date and that you will be relaxing rather than constant activities.

@cuddlebear

i couldn’t be arsed being around someone for longer than five days who tries to control my movements and stop me interacting with other people…
he is not unreasonable. The daughter however is massively unreasonable.

LaurieFairyCake · Today 07:43

It’s the organising of you I’d be taking issue with. It would just be ‘No, I’m reading today/not playing games/ not going out or going for a walk’

No really would be a complete sentence. My DH is over a decade younger and has long Covid, he can manage one game or one shortish walk a day, that’s it, he gets tired.