Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To limit number of days dd and partner stay with us over christmas

269 replies

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:37

Every year dd and partner stay with us as well as other adult dc .
Dd often declines to say how long she is staying and on previous years she extended the stay from the 23 rd to new year.
Dh is late 60 s and finds this v tiring much as we love her.

So so this year we said in advance we are looking forward to seeing you and as we get tired we are happy to make this 5 nights.

We feel that the previous times when they extended the stay felt too loose and so we did this .

We are worried that she experiences this as rejection.

She wanted to do something on a night that was beyond the 5 nights - we said yes we could meet them but assuming they would be with other s in the area - his parent.

she then replied saying - oh why the drama- you are trying to get rid of us .

for years we have had them for Christmas and been happy to see them , but feel it is reasonable to say we are able to manage five nights ?
my own parents made it clear that a few nights were ok ? I didn’t feel that they were trying to to get rid of me ? It was just natural to want to reclaim yr quiet home after a busy time ? How can i help her , beyond my explanation, understand that we want to see them , and that time limits are not a sign f rejection ?

I know for a fact that when we stay we her she enjoys it but if also glad when we go .. so she would understand.. maybe its the parent / child thing…

OP posts:
FreudvsJung · Yesterday 21:39

What it is that makes it hard to have them for an extra few days?

LlynTegid · Yesterday 21:41

It is reasonable given how your DH feels about a guest for a long period. I also think that celebrating for days on end just leads to lethargy and overeating.

nomoreraintoday · Yesterday 21:41

Your DH is late 60s? The way you’re talking I would have expected late 80s! How tiring can it really be?

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · Yesterday 21:42

I think it's entirely reasonable to set a time limit on the length of their stay in advance of it happening. For one thing it makes buying in food and planning meals that much easier.

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:46

Because we do thjngs v differently when they are here - we cant just chill - they want to do stuff all the time and its exhausting to us to have a house full for ten days doing meals out, walks , games , without much chill time . Dh has a medical condition .

OP posts:
HeddaGarbled · Yesterday 21:48

23rd to New Year doesn’t seem all that long to me when it’s your daughter. Why does your husband find them tiring?

If mine stay for a while after Christmas because they’re still off work or can work from (my) home, I don’t feel that I need to spend all my time with them and get on with my own stuff but enjoy having them around.

Is it because her partner is with you as well, you feel you need to entertain them?

Ineffable23 · Yesterday 21:49

You can do whatever you want, but don't be surprised or disappointed if your DD then doesn't plan to spend as much time with you in the future.

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:51

HeddaGarbled
yes because the partner also comes. And also because we cant get on with our own stuff as you say as they want to do things as a group.
for example in the ten days if i wanted to have a coffee with a friend - they dont like that .

OP posts:
Autumn64 · Yesterday 21:51

I don’t think you are being unreasonable but how she takes it depends on your relationship with her. I live close to my parents and if they don’t want to see DC and I on a certain day they just say.
Could you tell her you don’t want to go in group outings and they can just go on their own?

Cadenza12 · Yesterday 21:52

that's a long stay. I'd say 5 nights was actually plenty

HoppityBun · Yesterday 21:53

I think she wants to stay far too long and should understand that you can’t manage this. She’s trying to emotionally blackmail you to get what she wants

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · Yesterday 21:53

Is it her home house if you know what I mean or have you moved since she moved out?

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:54

HeddaGarbled · I have sometimes but they want me to go - to pack stuff in .
We have a very laid back ds who is similar to us - he would happily read for the afternoon , mooch about, he has indicated he feels organised also .

OP posts:
thistimelastweek · Yesterday 21:54

There is no right or wrong answer to this.
But even allowing for different personalities and dynamics, I personally can't imagine telling a child of mine that they couldn't stay as long as they wanted.

AgileOpalLion · Yesterday 21:55

Having people in your home, even family, is hard work.
5 nights is more than generous.
Her declining in the past to specify the length of visit, and then extending it to 10 days, is not on, even if she is your daughter.
She is an adult and you are not responsible for how she manages her feelings. If she interprets it as rejection that's on her. Specifying 5 nights is not drama or rejection. She is pushing back against a perfectly reasonable boundary. Just keep repeating that 5 nights is all you're doing until she gets the message.
Just read that you wouldn't feel able to have a coffee with a friend because your daughter wouldn't like it! WTAF? You need to tell her where to get off.

TheRoyalEyeroll · Yesterday 21:55

nomoreraintoday · Yesterday 21:41

Your DH is late 60s? The way you’re talking I would have expected late 80s! How tiring can it really be?

I agree. But I’m wondering if maybe he has a health problem. I’m also wondering if everyone mucks in to sort out meals and housework or if the OP serves people hand and foot.

Hankunamatata · Yesterday 21:55

Id let them stay as long as they like bit would be setting expectations. Like every other day you will be doing your own thing and on evening you plan on just watching TV and relaxing.

Dutch1e · Yesterday 21:56

Unless they live on the moon, 5 nights is an ample amount of time to stay with family. You don't love a person less just because you need your own space and routine back.

Tell her you're not trying to get rid of her at all, you're just knackered at that point in the year and are planning to come and stay with them for a couple of weeks instead.

Let's see how fast it turns around then!

Boomboomi · Yesterday 21:57

Autumnalhibernationisthedream its not the old family home .
She was with us off and on during uni - 4 years as changed courses- then covid time came home to live - them got her job after covid moved in with bf - she is 27 .

OP posts:
Hiredgun · Yesterday 21:57

Time she learned the very valuable lesson of not outstaying one’s welcome.

Hummusandtoast · Yesterday 22:00

A gentle reminder that hosting and being busy all the time is physically (don’t say emotionally but it’s true) tiring and that it takes it out of both of you. Offer to visit her after the five days as you want to spend time with them but need some downtime too.

Boomboomi · Yesterday 22:01

For those of you who have said thet cant imagine telling a dd she cant stay indefinitely - yes I do feel awful.
As i said - maybe its different personality types - ds is happy to let us do own things- wereas dd likes to do and organise to does not like it if we see other people - she declines to go to the local pub for example- she likes just the family.

OP posts:
TheFormerMrsTruelove · Yesterday 22:02

I know for a fact that when we stay we her she enjoys it but if also glad when we go .. so she would understand.. maybe its the parent / child thing. I think this is it. It just hasn’t occurred to her that you wouldn’t be falling over yourselves to have her there for as long as possible and be desperately sad to see her go. She doesn’t feel like she’s a guest; she’s coming home. Whereas you’re just her parents; she feels it’s quite natural for her to be glad to see the back of you after you’ve stayed with her, even if she did enjoy it, because you are guests at hers, and it’s not your home.

Ask her to think how happy she is to have her house back to herself after everyone has left, and tell her you’re getting older, you value quiet more and as much as you love having her home, you find it really tiring, so she’s welcome to stay until <date> and then she can come back on <date> and you’ll have had a chance to get everything back in order, bedding washed etc and be ready to go again.

I think she might be a bit put out at first. It’s going to come as a shock that she can’t just wander in and out as she pleases.

Boomboomi · Yesterday 22:02

Hummusandtoast

good idea.

OP posts:
sittingonabeach · Yesterday 22:04

Don’t they go and see partner’s family at some point?

Swipe left for the next trending thread