Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask for help with stocking stuffer for stb DIL

56 replies

WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat · Today 17:05

I have 4 dcs, all boys, ranging in age from 13-22. Every year, in their Santa stocking, they get cologne, chocolate coins, an obligatory orange/tangerine, a toblerone, some sort of novelty game, a toiletry that I know they’d like (ie special shampoo for their particular hair, or a specific face or body wash), maybe something like some wireless earbuds, and (and this is the reason I’m asking), some good quality fancy boxers, which they all love.

Eldest DC has a girlfriend (24yo), whom he has been with for 6.5yrs now -She comes to us every Christmas, and I have always treated her as one of my own, in that she receives a similar amount of gifts, maybe just not to the same value as the boys, but I always make sure that she has lots of presents to open and she is always super appreciative and grateful. We have a fantastic relationship, and my son and her plan on marrying in the next few years. I’m truly happy to be welcoming her into our family.

This will be the first Christmas that I have done a Christmas stocking for her, and I would love to make it all fair and even, however, all the other stocking stuffers are easy to match except for the undies. I don’t want to be presumptuous or embarrass her by buying her undies that she may hate, or would feel awkward to be receiving from her MIL to be.

I know her sizes etc so that’s not an issue, but I wouldn’t like to buy her, say for example Victoria’s Secret stuff in case she thought I was being weird or overstepping. At the same time I don’t want to leave her out as she and my son are working and studying hard, and spend very little on themselves as far as luxuries go. And I’m also aware of the fact that, while new lingerie is a lovely thing to get, it will often be pushed to the back of the queue when you have other financial priorities.

Would it come across as thoughtless to buy her a gift card for a lingerie store, which would allow her to pick what she wanted? Or would it appear more personal and thought out just to buy her some luxurious cute undies/lingerie?

I realise I’m probably overthinking this, I’m in the throes of grief and work acquired PTSD, and every little decision can seem huge and have me second guessing myself right now. Please be kind in your responses, I don’t feel able to fight off whatever criticisms may be thrown at me for this, however welcome genuine help and opinions. Many thanks in advance.

So I suppose the poll is:
YABU- don’t buy her undies, buy a gift card
YANBU - buy her some nice cutesy undies and don’t over think it.

OP posts:
KiwiFall · Today 18:03

Nice short and PJ top. Nothing too revealing but maybe silk/satin or a cute cotton print?

Millytante · Today 18:05

Do not (do NOT!) buy lingerie.
Check any of this week’s Guardians, where there is a very good and lengthy article to be found with fab suggestions for stocking fillers, none of which will embarrass anyone.

MabelAnderson · Today 18:06

I put cute knickers in my dds stockings (19 and 21) but they are opened by them first thing together, rather than round the tree with family. I would be happy if my Mil bought me nice knickers, (she has bought me little camisoles) and I would laugh opening them if DH was also opening boxers, but if there is any room for doubt then something else festive like little earrings, or the voucher for a shop to choose her own would be nice too.

Sometimessmiling · Today 18:07

WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat · Today 17:23

Ok sorry, realise this may be a drip feed, but hat scarf arc won’t work here as we are in anothe Timezone and it’s blazing hot sun here. Socks might work, but again, not often worn in this heat.

Thanks for all your suggestions and help though.

A water bottle
Nice cotton socks
A vest top

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 18:07

Socks or t-shirt.

Mamamia35 · Today 18:14

I was coming on to suggest socks. And these are lovely https://www2.hm.com/en_gb/productpage.1320625009.html

Lifelover16 · Today 18:17

A beach cover up?
Hair accessories?

Scarecrowsweeding · Today 18:17

Wrap up some nice hair, skin or makeup products instead. It’s very different a mum buying her sons boxers than her DILs underwear.

Enormouswaterbutt · Today 18:24

My DDs all wear pyjama shorts and I feel that is not as strange as getting her the underwear or a voucher for underwear. Sort of the same, but less weird.

hididdlyho · Today 18:29

Maybe a pair of sunglasses if you're somewhere hot. Or a travel size cosmetic such as a perfume or hand cream if you know the sorts of things she likes.

Houndsahollering · Today 18:29

Do not buy her underwear or a voucher for anywhere that sells exclusively underwear. That is weird and waaayyyy overstepping.

Pyjamas/loungewear maybe.
or a nice T-shirt or something.
But step away from the knickers.

MrsMitford3 · Today 18:29

What about some nice bits from sephora?
this is going in my DIL stocking-she did pick it

https://www.sephora.co.uk/p/rhode-pocket-pair-limited-edition-set?q=rho&q_typ=a&q_cat=product&q_dep=Makeup%2CGift%20Sets

A more generic gift card-like M&S is going in all adult DC stockings as they can buy nice treats or clothing and all love it

OllysArmyRidesAgain · Today 18:29

I don’t even buy my now adult DC pants for their stockings unless they specifically asked for them, I stopped buying their underwear when they left for uni. The stockings are usually fun, low value and amusing
presents I have a DIL and she will be with us on Christmas morning so will have a stocking.

I find clothes very personal.

Shinyandnew1 · Today 18:32

No, you don’t need to match every single item if it means you buying her pants 😂. If socks aren’t good as you live somewhere boiling, then just choose something else as might like.

Nearly50omg · Today 18:35

Don’t buy a gift card for a lingerie shop! That would be VERY weird! Buying sexy underwear for my boyfriend that his mother paid for?!?! 🤢🤢🤢 NO!! Get her some nice soft cozy socks instead 😁

mondaytosunday · Today 18:37

A headband or clips?

LegoPandemic · Today 18:40

Sarong

mittensmitten · Today 18:40

Agree with everyone else socks: falke are really lovely luxe daily ones. At that age I bought a stripey pair in maybe merino. They were amazing. Bridgedale are nice quality for walking but less luxey.

JenRummy · Today 18:47

Ewwe no undies or voucher for any. Think of something else. Well bloody done for being so lovely though… would love a Christmas at your gaff. 🌲

Neighbours23 · Today 18:48

PS I hope you have a gentle and happy Christmas after what sounds like a difficult time.

Blarn · Today 18:49

Socks! Don't do anything underwear related OP!

Maybe a nice silk sleeping mask.

IKillHousePlants · Today 18:49

I think PJ shorts are a good compromise

TheChosenTwo · Today 18:50

Yeah you really don’t need to match every item to this extent! A little shorts and tshirt pyjama set would be nice as an alternative to underwear.

Aquasoap · Today 18:52

Gloves, socks, scarf, mini prosecco. I don't think you can buy underwear.

Flowers