Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask for help with stocking stuffer for stb DIL

59 replies

WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat · Today 17:05

I have 4 dcs, all boys, ranging in age from 13-22. Every year, in their Santa stocking, they get cologne, chocolate coins, an obligatory orange/tangerine, a toblerone, some sort of novelty game, a toiletry that I know they’d like (ie special shampoo for their particular hair, or a specific face or body wash), maybe something like some wireless earbuds, and (and this is the reason I’m asking), some good quality fancy boxers, which they all love.

Eldest DC has a girlfriend (24yo), whom he has been with for 6.5yrs now -She comes to us every Christmas, and I have always treated her as one of my own, in that she receives a similar amount of gifts, maybe just not to the same value as the boys, but I always make sure that she has lots of presents to open and she is always super appreciative and grateful. We have a fantastic relationship, and my son and her plan on marrying in the next few years. I’m truly happy to be welcoming her into our family.

This will be the first Christmas that I have done a Christmas stocking for her, and I would love to make it all fair and even, however, all the other stocking stuffers are easy to match except for the undies. I don’t want to be presumptuous or embarrass her by buying her undies that she may hate, or would feel awkward to be receiving from her MIL to be.

I know her sizes etc so that’s not an issue, but I wouldn’t like to buy her, say for example Victoria’s Secret stuff in case she thought I was being weird or overstepping. At the same time I don’t want to leave her out as she and my son are working and studying hard, and spend very little on themselves as far as luxuries go. And I’m also aware of the fact that, while new lingerie is a lovely thing to get, it will often be pushed to the back of the queue when you have other financial priorities.

Would it come across as thoughtless to buy her a gift card for a lingerie store, which would allow her to pick what she wanted? Or would it appear more personal and thought out just to buy her some luxurious cute undies/lingerie?

I realise I’m probably overthinking this, I’m in the throes of grief and work acquired PTSD, and every little decision can seem huge and have me second guessing myself right now. Please be kind in your responses, I don’t feel able to fight off whatever criticisms may be thrown at me for this, however welcome genuine help and opinions. Many thanks in advance.

So I suppose the poll is:
YABU- don’t buy her undies, buy a gift card
YANBU - buy her some nice cutesy undies and don’t over think it.

OP posts:
Nonnegotiables · Today 17:07

I think socks are your go to here! I would hate my MIL to buy me underwear but some nice socks are a Christmas classic for a reason!

CleanShirt · Today 17:07

I think it would be odd to buy anything underwear related for her. Maybe some socks instead?

Peridot1 · Today 17:07

What about some nice socks?

Peridot1 · Today 17:07

Snap!

Bacha1910 · Today 17:09

I definitely don't want to pull undies out of a stocking while surrounded by my in-laws on Christmas morning.

Mosaic123 · Today 17:09

Or scarf or gloves? Something cosy and soft. Look at what colour coat she wears and choose appropriately.

ThinkingIsAllowed · Today 17:10

Socks. Definitely do not buy her underwear, that would be very weird

AreYouGoingToBeLong · Today 17:15

Avoid the undies entirely! Good suggestions above of socks, scarf, gloves, hat if she’s a wearer. I don’t think she’d notice/be offended if her stocking isn’t exactly as the boys so you could go completely different.

WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat · Today 17:23

Ok sorry, realise this may be a drip feed, but hat scarf arc won’t work here as we are in anothe Timezone and it’s blazing hot sun here. Socks might work, but again, not often worn in this heat.

Thanks for all your suggestions and help though.

OP posts:
Tiptoethroughthehallway · Today 17:26

Buying her underwear or even a voucher for some is weird.

LastMinuteLara · Today 17:26

What about a nice shortie pj set rather than undies. Or a floaty scarf/pashmina.

Timeforanothernamechange3 · Today 17:41

O God, definitely no undies! My ex's mum did this to me once and ex-boyf and I both found it really weird and embarrassing!

afromom · Today 17:48

I would probably get a couple of cosmetics instead, a nice hand cream, a couple of face masks, or maybe a hair mask? I don’t think she will mind if it’s different to the boys and would probably have been mortified if my mother in law had bought me anything underwear related at 24 (gift card included) that I had to unwrap in front of a room full of men.

if you did want to go for a gift card, maybe one for a coffee shop, or a mug with some hot chocolate in it?

TheFairyCaravan · Today 17:51

My MIL bought me undies twice. Once I had given birth on Christmas Eve, three weeks early, and opened up a camisole and knicker set. Fuck knows what she was thinking. A few years later I got those diamanté g-strings people were wearing above their jeans, only I was a thirty something mum of 2. They never got worn. Honestly don’t do it.

I’ve got 2 DDILs now, one is getting Ugg socks. The other is getting silk scrunchies.

Left · Today 17:54

Do you have a shop like accessorize in your country? Sells things like bags, purses, jewellery, hair accessories? Maybe a voucher for somewhere like that.

Defo not undies. Or any underwear voucher.

IsItSnowing · Today 17:58

I wouldn't buy underwear for someone else unless they specifically requested it and I wouldn't give them a voucher for a lingerie store either. It's just a bit weird to receive for me, even if the intention is nice.
A voucher for a more general type shop like Next or John Lewis or M&S or wherever she shops would be better, I think. She can buy whatever she wants then.

Ritaskitchen · Today 17:58

Really nice hair scrunchie?

Birdie2026 · Today 17:59

Earrings, a lightweight scarf, handcream, hair accessories - anything rather than underwear. Just because your sons get new boxer shorts doesn't mean you have to buy her a pair of knickers, that's going to come across as weird.

WearingBeautifulShoes · Today 18:00

Agree with all the suggestions above, or a make up case, or water bottle, or a photo frame. If you must go for something wearable then I'd say pyjamas.

Velumental · Today 18:00

WhereTheFuckIsMyFuckingCoat · Today 17:23

Ok sorry, realise this may be a drip feed, but hat scarf arc won’t work here as we are in anothe Timezone and it’s blazing hot sun here. Socks might work, but again, not often worn in this heat.

Thanks for all your suggestions and help though.

Hair accessories

RatsCatsandPuppies · Today 18:00

Nonnegotiables · Today 17:07

I think socks are your go to here! I would hate my MIL to buy me underwear but some nice socks are a Christmas classic for a reason!

I agree - I’d go for socks in this situation!

Velumental · Today 18:01

WearingBeautifulShoes · Today 18:00

Agree with all the suggestions above, or a make up case, or water bottle, or a photo frame. If you must go for something wearable then I'd say pyjamas.

Yes! Hot climate so a pair of shorts and t shirt style jammies would be just the thing!

MintChocolate123 · Today 18:01

This is weird. You don’t have to match to this degree! Just leave the undies out.

Dartmoorcheffy · Today 18:02

I think a voucher would be fine in thus scenario, and just explain that to her too.

wishfulthinking25 · Today 18:02

Do not buy her underwear