Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you nag your year 8 child to do their homework or leave them to it?

43 replies

Elfie23 · Yesterday 16:38

Just that really! I find I have to constantly remind mine to do their homework but might just stop and let them deal with the consequences!

YABU - don’t remind them!
YANBU - do remind them

OP posts:
mountaingoop · Today 08:55

Lkt32 · Today 08:42

My kid is y7 so I'm trying to find the balance between helping her get used to it without taking on managing it for her.
So far, it's worked quite well that, when she asks to play roblox, I ask her if she's done her homework. I can see on the app what she's been set, so I generally have a good idea of what she's got but trying not to micromanage.

This is where tech is useful. I generally don’t allow gaming on school nights, but we negotiate some gaming time if they agree to do some of the extra optional elements of homework that get tagged onto their usual homework.

StencilCupChair · Today 08:58

This came from MN years ago so we adopted it when they started secondary. Firstly you need to set them up for success so this is having a routine in place that helps them remember which books they need to take to school the next day. This has to be somewhere they have a timetable visible, we used a noticeboard in their room and labelled magazine files with days of the week on.

The noticeboard also had slips of paper where they wrote their homework and pinned it up. Visible to them and visible to us pinned on the day it is due in with the date also on there.

Homework time slot. Every day after school and snack/drink etc they sit and do homework. If there was no homework to do they could watch YouTube on any subject and any topic they were studying at that moment.

Expectations, this is work set by school, not us. Homework to completed to a high standard not just rushed off. This sets them up for all the future years when homework load gets heavier and when they are doing GCSEs. When they don't have homework in year 10 they can make flashcards/mind maps whatever revision aids will help them to succeed. Year 11 there is a wealth of GCSE revision stuff on Youtube that they can watch. If you could see the amount of flashcards needed then starting early is far less stressful.

Make them think beyond year 8, beyond school, so A levels, BTECs etc. Both Dh and I went to uni so they hear a lot of chat about uni days as we all meet up as a large group with uni mates from 30 years ago.

TheChosenTwo · Today 09:03

i will ask if he has any but he’s pretty good at managing it himself, he knows the natural consequences are an hour of detention and he’s keen to avoid that so he tends to come home, chill for an hour and have a snack and then crack on with it once I’ve vacated my office, he’ll come and use my desk and set his laptop up in there.
I’ve done the same with all 3dc, 2 of them would just get it done and one of them would end up in detention once a fortnight or so, her choice.
The more you do the more they will rely on you, I removed the scaffolding to be honest and encouraged them to take ownership of their own workload from when they started senior school, setting the expectation early doors. They can always ask us for help/support and we’ve done so when asked but their homework is their business so other than asking a few times a week if there is any to be done I don’t do more than that.

FatCatSociety · Today 09:08

We have designated Tuesday evenings for homework so ds just accepts he has to do it then. I might remind him it's "homework night." But there's no nagging needed after that.

ToCatchACat · Today 09:08

Hands off from them starting year 7. I was always there to support, they could come to me for a chat and if they asked for advice I would give it but high-school was theirs to manage.

They were responsible for their uniform / any equipment being ready, getting there on time, homework, managing their workload, managing their relationships with classmates and staff etc.

I strongly believe that young people need a safe space to be able to learn responsibility and to mess up occasionally before they get into the real world.

mountaingoop · Today 09:14

@TheChosenTwo I think that’s great if the school has a deterrent like detention, unfortunately if our school tried that half the school would be in for an hour and the school simply wouldn’t have the resourcing for that. Ours get behaviour points and it would take triggers to get to the point parents would be involved (which would be the natural consequence I guess because not much would happen before that).

Our school is the best performing school in the area but I was shocked to learn how many of the students don’t do homework. The demographics of the school are changing year on year and basically parents need to be the consequence as the school is too busy trying to manage misbehaviour than homework. The consequences have to come from us until they learn the importance homework, which did come, my son is GCSE age now and is very much self directed knowing what he needs to put in and why.

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 09:17

Nope i remind them once if they don't do it then they face the consequences from school for not doing it they soon learnt

WhatSymmetry · Today 09:23

Elpheba · Yesterday 18:15

I was thinking about this tonight while helping my dd (y6) with hers. I didn’t have homework until high school so I don’t think it would ever have crossed my mind to sit and do it with parent support- I just got on with it. Whereas she has had it since Y2 and so has grown up with us kind of sitting along side her (or at least in the room) for help/encouragement/general chivvying so I can well see us continuing that at high school next year and beyond, probably until she gets fed up of us 🤣 but I think it’s helpful for them to feel like they’re not alone- or at least I’m telling myself that!

This has clarified something for me, thank you! My DD has just started Year 7 and I’ve been feeling frustrated with having to sit with her as she does her homework, especially as my parents wouldn’t have done anything to remind me about homework or help me (except making sure I had a quiet space for homework). However, I never had homework in primary school while my DD did get homework and was used to one of us sitting with her to help her. No wonder she assumes we’ll do the same at secondary!

It is difficult to know what support to give. She is anxious about getting homework done to avoid negative behaviour points, but often won’t actually do the homework after school or at weekends unless we remind her or almost timetable it in for her. She is on the waiting list for an autism assessment, so I’ve been reading a lot about neurodiverse children needing more support / scaffolding, but at the same time I want her to learn to be independent. It’s a tricky balance.

Scarcityvarcity · Today 09:27

I don't think I ever reminded mine once they were at secondary school. The school were strict so I just let their fear of detentions etc do the work. I think one of them did a lot during break times though.

Scarcityvarcity · Today 09:28

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 09:17

Nope i remind them once if they don't do it then they face the consequences from school for not doing it they soon learnt

Yes, that was my attitude.

FatCatSociety · Today 09:28

FatCatSociety · Today 09:08

We have designated Tuesday evenings for homework so ds just accepts he has to do it then. I might remind him it's "homework night." But there's no nagging needed after that.

I read this as 8 year old not year 8 sorry, haven't got there yet.

lottiegarbanzo · Today 10:40

Neither.

I’m supportive and have conversations about what happens when. So make space for what they need to do but it’s up to them to do it.

Nag is a truly horrible word and one I’d never use, unless referring to a horse-related pub name.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Today 10:51

ednaclouda · Yesterday 18:12

MY DAD SET OUR DINING TABLE SO I HAD MY BACK TO THE TV AND WOULDNT LET ME TURN ROUND TO BE DISTRACTED tough love
get on with your homework
sorry not shouting

Surely the better thing would have been for the TV to be off?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Today 10:53

I do remind mine but I don’t keep track of specific pieces of homework - it’s all on their google classroom.

I just say “have you got homework/ what homework have you got?” Etc

I do help him with revision timetables and hold him to it because he struggles with this - he has ADHD though.

The older one didn’t need any prompting at all from mid primary school (she’s 18 now) but she’s a very different child!

yeah24325r2 · Today 10:56

Yes. The problem is there are NO consequences from school.

mummymeister · Today 11:03

At this age what you are teaching them is time management. wouldnt we all put off the thing we dont like doing until the absolute last minute or rush to finish it because we hate it!

Year 8 is a bit young to be just leaving her to it. Personally we used to sit down with each of ours and help them to make a plan that suited them. One of my DC is an early bird so would get up at 5.30 or 6am and do home work before going to school when the house was quiet and they could potter. they did this at uni and still gets up at this time now in their 30s. One of our other DC couldnt rest until it was done so would work until completion even if that meant staying up late, missing something etc. Its part of their personality.

Your DC is navigating this right now and need you to show how there are many options for managing your time and that perhaps trying different ones will help her find the one that works the best for her.

I am a list maker. everything I need to do today is on a list, i tick off each one as its done and some of it is trivial (check Christmas list, order turkey etc) whilst other is for a bigger project which I then make a sub list for.

In addition you say your DD is on it one week then not others. this is going to be hormonal I am certain. some days I could complete 100 tasks others not one. get her into the habit now of tracking her cycle so she is aware of when the off days are and can plan around them.

OldUserNewNameNow · Today 16:07

Mine is in y7 and needs no reminders. She’s very much on top of whatever needs doing - or she can’t relax (apparently)…and she loves to relax 😜

she went to private for prep and they had loads of HW; the school taught them to be independent from around y3.

Neurodiversitydoctor · Today 16:37

After parents evening in yr 8 I introduced a non negotiable 20 minutes after dinner. It meant changing things up- they got in at 5:15pm and were fed pretty much imeadiately so done by 6. Then 6-6:30 was homework then and only then were they allowed on screens till 8:30. This worked for us but was 10yrs ago....

New posts on this thread. Refresh page