Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you nag your year 8 child to do their homework or leave them to it?

43 replies

Elfie23 · Yesterday 16:38

Just that really! I find I have to constantly remind mine to do their homework but might just stop and let them deal with the consequences!

YABU - don’t remind them!
YANBU - do remind them

OP posts:
CurlsLDN · Yesterday 17:05

my sons year 8, our routine is homework Wednesdays and Sundays, that suits schools deadlines for now.

once he’s got in the door and had some time to relax I’ll remind him it’s homework tonight and ask if he wants to do it before or after dinner so he feels he has some control in it all.

then 5-10 mins before it’s time to start I’ll let him know, so he can finish what he’s doing and doesn’t feel he’s having to abruptly abandon his tv show / game / call with his friend.

that seems to work well for us, and he’ll happily get going when it’s time without any nagging or arguments. But appreciate it’s different with different kids.

CurlsLDN · Yesterday 17:07

Sorry I re-read and realised you didn’t ask for our whole evening routine.

so in short answer to your question, yes I remind him, because I feel he’s still young and I’m happy to support him. But I don’t feel like I’m nagging or it’s a pain

mountaingoop · Yesterday 17:48

My eldest I could leave to it, I did no management of his homework in high school, he chooses when he does it, and has never not done it. Always gets excellent for homework in reports. Youngest has AuADHD and to be fair he’s managing it pretty well too, he’s good when he’s in a weekly routine, but if something changes (school holidays, out of sync weekend etc) he will forget so I will prompt him around those times.

If they weren’t managing it I would absolutely step in more, I’m not really a natural consequences kind of parent with school expectations.

ednaclouda · Yesterday 18:12

MY DAD SET OUR DINING TABLE SO I HAD MY BACK TO THE TV AND WOULDNT LET ME TURN ROUND TO BE DISTRACTED tough love
get on with your homework
sorry not shouting

Elpheba · Yesterday 18:15

I was thinking about this tonight while helping my dd (y6) with hers. I didn’t have homework until high school so I don’t think it would ever have crossed my mind to sit and do it with parent support- I just got on with it. Whereas she has had it since Y2 and so has grown up with us kind of sitting along side her (or at least in the room) for help/encouragement/general chivvying so I can well see us continuing that at high school next year and beyond, probably until she gets fed up of us 🤣 but I think it’s helpful for them to feel like they’re not alone- or at least I’m telling myself that!

Belweather · Yesterday 18:15

Completion of homework has always been non-negotiable for us.

House rule was work before play.

By the time they were at high school they were pretty motivated to achieve for their own benefit not because we told them to do it.

SandrenaIsMyBloodType · Yesterday 18:23

I did have to insist it was done. They were supposed to read for 15 mins a night and DD2 was just too excited to play when she got home and making her do homework first didn’t feel appropriate. Playing seemed like a reasonable request.
I found I could make it easier by allowing computer time and garden time first but reading and homework then have to be done without complaining and that’s how tomorrow’s computer time is earned. Any bellyaching today about having to do homework means no computer tomorrow. It worked perfectly for us. Before I introduced that rule she would get so frustrated if the homework was tricky because it was standing in the way of playtime. Afterwards, she just got on with it.
It did help that I felt the amount given was reasonable- 15 minutes reading a night, 10 spellings per week, one times table and maybe a worksheet that could be punted to the weekend.

Everlygreen · Yesterday 18:25

My kids have attended private school since early years and homework has always been part of their daily routine. I know it’s hated on here, but I really believe good habits start early.
My ds is now in secondary school and never has to be reminded or nagged about it. The same goes for tests and exams, he will just get on with it. He will even do an hour each on the weekend of prep without a moan or groan. It has always been something that wasn’t optional. I have a younger child who is following the same too.
Start daily, you will see the benefits later on.

JackGrealishsCalves · Yesterday 18:26

Used to leave ds to it but with questioning on how much he had.
Bit more probing on revision with offers to help

therapymedswhatelse · Yesterday 18:34

In primary I’d encourage, but they would do it independently (unless it was too hard then I’d support and write a note to say that).
By secondary, they were doing it by themselves and taking the consequences if not done or completed to teachers’ satisfaction. They need to learn responsibility. Set your children up for success by making it a routine expectation.

Stompythedinosaur · Yesterday 21:20

I absolutely remind my teen dc They are great kids, but their executive function isn't fully developed, and they benefit for talking through when in between their busy social lives they will get their work done! Once we've made a plan, they are pretty good at sticking to it.

CoodleMoodle · Yesterday 21:35

DD is Y8 and does her homework without me reminding (I do ask sometimes but she's usually on top of it), but that's mostly because she's worried about getting into trouble/detention/negative points. She hates doing it but prefers it to the potential consequences.

Elfie23 · Yesterday 22:01

Thanks everyone who has responded so far!
I find with my DD one week she’s totally on it and the next week not. She always gets maths homework on a Friday so she remembers that, but other stuff it doesn’t even cross her mind. The school has an app where all homework can be found but I’m sure if I didn’t remind her she wouldn’t do it. Some homework I feel like she just can’t be bothered with as she doesn’t enjoy it or it’s a long piece of homework (science!) and will put it off and put it off until it’s then a panic at the last minute. If I try to remind her during the week I get told I’m ’going on’ or nagging 🤦🏻‍♀️

I feel like leaving her to it but also know how distressed she’ll be if she gets detention and it’ll take forever to peel her off the ceiling … aren’t teenagers great!? 🙈🤣

OP posts:
RebeccaDecember · Yesterday 22:53

Mine isn’t allowed X-Box or gaming until homework is done. Seems to work 😉

Thistimeimeanitforreal · Yesterday 22:58

With mine, it’s set across something like 3 apps so it’s actually really hard to identify what there is and when it’s due. Add in adhd and general aversion to school, and if it wasn’t for me nagging then it would not be done.
DS gets enough negativity around his needs in school as it is, I feel like being on top of homework is something that I can do. Just like making sure he has PE kit on the right day and food tech stuff on the right day.
He has to do the work, but I will sit with him and make sure I have an incentive ready. At the moment it’s heroes chocs, he gets one for doing the work and another one for doing it without complaining.
Although in truth, even in y9 he doesn’t get that much still.
DD managed herself throughout school but she doesn’t have his Sen needs.

Clearinguptheclutter · Yesterday 23:04

Welll my parents nagged me. I eventually motivated myself but not before sixth form don’t think!

y9 boy has to be nagged
y7 boy does it no problem. Is super compliant! (For now…)

Autumnishere1 · Yesterday 23:07

I always have to remind my son to do his homework (year 3) but he never argues and always does it when asked. He has maths, spelling and reading

Belweather · Today 05:43

Elfie23 · Yesterday 22:01

Thanks everyone who has responded so far!
I find with my DD one week she’s totally on it and the next week not. She always gets maths homework on a Friday so she remembers that, but other stuff it doesn’t even cross her mind. The school has an app where all homework can be found but I’m sure if I didn’t remind her she wouldn’t do it. Some homework I feel like she just can’t be bothered with as she doesn’t enjoy it or it’s a long piece of homework (science!) and will put it off and put it off until it’s then a panic at the last minute. If I try to remind her during the week I get told I’m ’going on’ or nagging 🤦🏻‍♀️

I feel like leaving her to it but also know how distressed she’ll be if she gets detention and it’ll take forever to peel her off the ceiling … aren’t teenagers great!? 🙈🤣

Edited

Could you talk with her to put some systems in place to help avoid the last minute and the panic?

One of mine found a whiteboard helpful, listing all her assignments, the date due and the effort required (eg 2 hrs, 4hrs etc) Helped keep the work front and centre.

RancidRuby · Today 06:01

I think this very much depends on the child, their individual needs and personality. In primary school I just made sure they did their reading and timetables rockstars but if they needed a break from it one day I was pretty relaxed, I’m not convinced anything more is beneficial so never pushed it unless they wanted to do it of course. For secondary school, I’d remind in year 7 because it’s a big change for them but by year 8 both of mine just got on with it and mainly managed it themselves. My eldest is in year 11 and set to do very well in her GCSEs and my youngest in year 8 is pretty much self sufficient now too, I just occasionally ask if he’s got much homework as a gentle prompt but that’s all. But like I say, this is very much child dependent, I don’t think it’s necessarily because of my amazing parenting skills. Neither of my kids have any additional needs impacting them either, additionally they want to do well and don’t like being told off at school so all of that plays into it too.

ChimpanzeeThatMonkeyNews · Today 06:36

CurlsLDN · Yesterday 17:07

Sorry I re-read and realised you didn’t ask for our whole evening routine.

so in short answer to your question, yes I remind him, because I feel he’s still young and I’m happy to support him. But I don’t feel like I’m nagging or it’s a pain

Your post was excellent. Don’t apologise, i genuinely got a lot from it, cos it’s always a battle to get my son to do his homework, as well.

lxn889121 · Today 06:46

My son isn't that old yet, but from my own experiences as a teenager - I wish my parents had forced more of a routine. I know I would have disliked it and pushed back, but as an adult, I wasted a lot of opportunities and caused my self far to many problems by just being disorganized and silly when younger.

Like a lot of people though, I didn't have homework until later on, so it isn't like you got to build up a routine during your younger years, where parents would presume it was their role to help. In stead it went from nothing, to homework, and by that point were were teenagers, so I think a lot of parents thought "well, they are old enough to deal with it themselves".

mountaingoop · Today 07:27

It really doesn’t help when the school is chaotic with homework. The only times my youngest has fallen off the ball with it is when subjects just randomly insert homework mid term, maths is very consistent with when it’s given and due and he manages that no problem. They’re not consistent with what they put in our app either.

GaaNeen · Today 07:29

Yes ! Remind and nag and support !

being a parent to a teenage is in part being a PA and coaching them to become their own PA

EndorsingPRActice · Today 08:32

Mine had non negotiable reading daily, just for 10 minutes, but very little other homework at primary. If they had any they did it after breakfast Saturdays, again non negotiable. They knew this and generally just got on with it. I didn't help DS much at all, though would always to ready to discuss anything he was unsure about or help him to research. DD was different and really benefitted from regular basic maths practice so we did that in the car every morning on the way to school, times tables and basic 4 operations. She also needed to practice spellings so did that most days. I think DS somehow absorbed a dictionary and seemed to know how to spell without any effort, he never practised spellings. By secondary I was basically hands off apart from DD's maths. We looked at her maths for an hour or so most weeks and practised it together. She found maths difficult but ended up with a solid 5 at GCSE first time around so it was worth it.

Lkt32 · Today 08:42

My kid is y7 so I'm trying to find the balance between helping her get used to it without taking on managing it for her.
So far, it's worked quite well that, when she asks to play roblox, I ask her if she's done her homework. I can see on the app what she's been set, so I generally have a good idea of what she's got but trying not to micromanage.

Swipe left for the next trending thread