Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fund DC driving lessons yet.

63 replies

toocooltobop · Today 11:41

I’d particularly like responses from London parents though welcome them from everyone far and wide.
DS is 17. In yr12 at 6th form.
We live in an area of London with excellent transport links. Until he leaves school, bus travel is free. Trains / tubes are half price.
He has a Uber account to use if absolutely necessary.
Our area is served by night buses and a 24hr tube line.
I think a couple of his friends are starting driving lessons soon. The vast majority aren’t. That will probably change next year once most are 17 but a significant number won’t be starting lessons even once they turn 17.

Our family car is an ancient 7 seater. We don’t have a drive. We have a parking permit and live in an area where driving is discouraged, partly by charging a lot of money for second etc parking permits.

DS does not have a part time job (tried but non around) so all money comes from us)

Hopefully that provides enough context 😊

DS, naturally, is really keen to learn to drive. We have said no for all the reasons above. It’s just not a necessity where we live. Him not being able to drive does not disadvantage him in any way at the moment.
To his credit, he’s accepted this, hasn’t badgered us about it or got moody about it.
I learnt to drive once I had funds for lessons, a car and insurance. I expect the same for him, though we will likely help him out.

But, I’ve been reading through the NEETS thread and it’s got me thinking. DS will most likely apply for apprenticeships (in who knows what) when he’s finished six form, alongside normal jobs. So, should we rethink the driving thing so he’d got another string to his bow, so to speak? He turns 18 at the start of yr13 so hopefully can pick up some bar work. Maybe we do it then so we can split the cost?

DH and I both admit we’re anxious about him driving because he’s got that teenager invincibility attitude about him! But he’s not an idiot, he’s actually a very lovely boy.

TLDR: AIBU to say no to funding lessons now or should we do it so he’ll gave a license ready for when he enters the world of work?

Thanks!

OP posts:
throughthe · Today 11:48

Yes he needs to be able to drive if he wants to take advantage of opportunities that happen in a place where it's inconvenient to use public transport.

Just book and pay for the lessons and get it over and done with.

RosieandRobin · Today 11:50

If you can afford it I always think learning to drive when in sixth form is a good idea as it gets it out if the way. That way they can drive and when they do get a car they can have a couple of refresher lessons if needed.

However there is no reason why some driving lessons can’t be a Xmas/birthday present and any cash from Xmas etc can go towards this too. Perhaps he could do jobs at home towards this or he volunteers somewhere as he can’t find work and you pay so much towards each lesson per hour he volunteers.

maz210 · Today 11:52

Absolutely not unreasonable, it doesn’t sound like he “needs” to drive yet.

I’m talking from a very different perspective - we live semi rurally - buses are very infrequent and don’t run past 4.30pm. We have a 18 and 19 year old that we’ve therefore had to fund driving lessons for. The way we look at it is that it was our choice to live a bit off the beaten track, so it’s our responsibility to help our teenagers with commuting.

Neither of our teenagers have been able to get a job yet, so we’ve had to fund driving lessons/first car purchase and all insurance. It’s been a strain financially, and I definitely wouldn’t have felt obliged to fund it all if there was no immediate need.

I do believe that driving is an important life skill, and it’s great if you’re able to help your children learn. If I were in your position, I’d probably say that he can start lessons once he’s got a job, and you’ll contribute (if possible) at that point. I’d probably go halves on the lesson costs with him if you’re able to.

WaitingForMojo · Today 11:55

I wish my parents had placed as much emphasis on driving as they did on my a levels. Supported and encouraged it as a necessity, not an optional extra. I ended up an adult who couldn’t drive before finally passing in my thirties. It was horrible and impacted my life far more than any academic result. It’s hard to afford to learn as you get older and have more responsibilities.

My ds is working in a trade (age 19) and most opportunities require a driving licence. It would be very difficult for him now if he couldn’t drive.

Once they pass their test, they always have it. If you can afford to get them there, I would.

Imaginingdragonsagain · Today 11:55

I will pay for each of my dc’s to learn to drive as I think it’s an important life skill. I appreciate your ds won’t need to as he lives in London but he might one day move away, so on balance I probably would. Edited to add that I won’t buy them a car unless they choose a job instead of uni.

RosieandRobin · Today 11:55

especially if he is considering apprenticeships, if a dream job comes up that requires driving there would be no point in applying if you can’t. They won’t wait for you to learn to drive.

Moveoverdarlin · Today 11:58

Yeah I disagree with you. I would get him lessons asap. It’s great you have fantastic transport links but it’s just a great skill to have got done and under your belt.

He may go to uni somewhere with fewer transport links. When I was at uni, all of us had cars. So did my DH but admittedly we weren’t in London.

If he’s going for Interviews for apprenticeships it works in his favour if he has a driving licence. It just looks like he’s got his shit together, even if he doesn’t need to own a car for another 5 years. If he doesn’t have a licence and is up against someone who does, he could miss out.

It’s also expensive and like everything else, it’s only going to go up in cost. I would get it done, it’s another massive milestone ticked off the list when preparing your child for the world.

Mary46 · Today 12:01

Hi op I think its money well spent especially for jobs to get around. She paid half we paid half. They 500+ in Dublin so not cheap. My daughter is ask at interviews does she drive just to keep that in mind too. Your right its not easy or cheap

Zanatdy · Today 12:03

Makes sense to learn before uni / full time work.

ChocHotolate · Today 12:05

Watching with interest as I will be in exactly the same position in a couple of years

ItsNotMeEither · Today 12:06

I’m in Australia and just can’t imagine a young person this age not learning to drive. Obviously public transport is different here, but at 17 or 18, either for an apprenticeship or University, not being able to drive would be a big disadvantage.

We paid for lessons for all of ours, they were able to borrow one of our cars for necessary trips, but funding their own car and insurance was completely on them.

Edited to add: Four adult children. Two own cars now and two have never bought a car. They both live in cities with great public transport but, a couple of times a year they hire cars for a day or two. Both use some sort of scheme where they pay online, then get a code and the location of a car nearby. Works really well for them.

As others have said, it’s a question that regularly comes up at interviews, even if a car isn’t required for the job.

araiwa · Today 12:06

It's no good waiting until he needs it as it could then take a year to learn and pass

toocooltobop · Today 12:07

I’ve just had a chat with DH and we’ve decided that we will get him lessons. We’re not getting him a car, that will be down to him once he can afford it. It’s about supporting a necessary qualification and we’ll make sure DS understands this.
He’s going to be speechless when we tell him 😂

OP posts:
BusyGreySnail · Today 12:08

I got a job and paid for my own lessons. My parents had said they'd pay if we (their children) didn't start smoking and I did. So I had to pay myself. My sister did the same and just didn't bother (now in her 40s and without a licence still and is fine).

Obviously that was a punishment of sorts (meant to be a carrot originally of course), but I don't see there is anything wrong in teaching kids if they want it they need to put in the effort and make it happen themselves. In your situation you could go halves, if he got a job to save up.

toocooltobop · Today 12:11

maz210 · Today 11:52

Absolutely not unreasonable, it doesn’t sound like he “needs” to drive yet.

I’m talking from a very different perspective - we live semi rurally - buses are very infrequent and don’t run past 4.30pm. We have a 18 and 19 year old that we’ve therefore had to fund driving lessons for. The way we look at it is that it was our choice to live a bit off the beaten track, so it’s our responsibility to help our teenagers with commuting.

Neither of our teenagers have been able to get a job yet, so we’ve had to fund driving lessons/first car purchase and all insurance. It’s been a strain financially, and I definitely wouldn’t have felt obliged to fund it all if there was no immediate need.

I do believe that driving is an important life skill, and it’s great if you’re able to help your children learn. If I were in your position, I’d probably say that he can start lessons once he’s got a job, and you’ll contribute (if possible) at that point. I’d probably go halves on the lesson costs with him if you’re able to.

If we lived where you live it would be a no brainier. My DH grew up rurally and learning to drive was life changing.

We know quite a few families who Dong have cars. I also know a few people who still don’t have a license now in their 50s. You really can get away with it here.

But, I’ve now reflected on it and realised that he’s going to need all the help we can give him to get on the career ladder and this is part of that.

OP posts:
FrustratedApples · Today 12:16

In my (affluent middle class, non-London city) social circle, only 1 person had driving lessons before the end of school. I learnt at 25 when I needed to as we were moving out of London and it was necessary for work. DH could drive but we didn't have a car when we lived in London.

I would recommend learning & doing your test in London though as some non-London drivers get anxious about London driving.

Squidgoals · Today 12:19

I think it’s a really good idea to start having lessons as soon as you can, while there’s no pressure, and to take your test before it becomes ‘important’, i.e. also while there’s no pressure.

Whatseatinggilbertsgrape · Today 12:19

No jobs around, in London? He's "tried" so not trying? Ha

You've got a shock coming if you think there will be more apprenticeships around than jobs.

foursquares · Today 12:21

toocooltobop · Today 11:41

I’d particularly like responses from London parents though welcome them from everyone far and wide.
DS is 17. In yr12 at 6th form.
We live in an area of London with excellent transport links. Until he leaves school, bus travel is free. Trains / tubes are half price.
He has a Uber account to use if absolutely necessary.
Our area is served by night buses and a 24hr tube line.
I think a couple of his friends are starting driving lessons soon. The vast majority aren’t. That will probably change next year once most are 17 but a significant number won’t be starting lessons even once they turn 17.

Our family car is an ancient 7 seater. We don’t have a drive. We have a parking permit and live in an area where driving is discouraged, partly by charging a lot of money for second etc parking permits.

DS does not have a part time job (tried but non around) so all money comes from us)

Hopefully that provides enough context 😊

DS, naturally, is really keen to learn to drive. We have said no for all the reasons above. It’s just not a necessity where we live. Him not being able to drive does not disadvantage him in any way at the moment.
To his credit, he’s accepted this, hasn’t badgered us about it or got moody about it.
I learnt to drive once I had funds for lessons, a car and insurance. I expect the same for him, though we will likely help him out.

But, I’ve been reading through the NEETS thread and it’s got me thinking. DS will most likely apply for apprenticeships (in who knows what) when he’s finished six form, alongside normal jobs. So, should we rethink the driving thing so he’d got another string to his bow, so to speak? He turns 18 at the start of yr13 so hopefully can pick up some bar work. Maybe we do it then so we can split the cost?

DH and I both admit we’re anxious about him driving because he’s got that teenager invincibility attitude about him! But he’s not an idiot, he’s actually a very lovely boy.

TLDR: AIBU to say no to funding lessons now or should we do it so he’ll gave a license ready for when he enters the world of work?

Thanks!

Does he have a child trust fund or JISA? If so, just use these.

WittySloth · Today 12:22

Paid for my son to have lessons at 17 despite knowing we couldn’t afford insurance and a car and actually he wasn’t even bothered to learn. He passed at 18, didn’t drive at all, and in the summer in his first year at uni got a brilliant summer job with a company relating to his degree and they gave him a van to drive. Wouldn’t have got the job otherwise. One refresher session later and he was on the road driving all summer . Honestly definitely get it over and done you never know when it will be needed

Nighttimenoise · Today 12:23

toocooltobop · Today 12:07

I’ve just had a chat with DH and we’ve decided that we will get him lessons. We’re not getting him a car, that will be down to him once he can afford it. It’s about supporting a necessary qualification and we’ll make sure DS understands this.
He’s going to be speechless when we tell him 😂

I'm so glad, we have to reject young people from our apprenticeship scheme if they can't drive as it's a necessary requirement in order to get to remote sites.

examadmin · Today 12:25

Realistically, even if he passed his theory tomorrow, the earliest he would pass is in 6 months time. If he fails then it is likely to be 12 months or longer. With that in mind, I would start now if you can afford to support him financially as starting around the time he may need a car will be too late. That is the reality of the Post Covid "learning to drive" world. If you said he were set on going to university then that would give him extra years of "during the day time" which is really useful when learning to drive.

We live in a similar situation - London based, 24 hour transport close by and day to day our life is all on public transport. We do have a drive (I know!) and a car, but only use it if we cant get somewhere any other way. Neither of us passed our driving test until our 30s as other things took priority and we had both lived in cities since leaving home for university. Managing driving lessons and tests around stressful jobs plus a 1hr+ commute into zone 1 was horrible. We were fortunate that we only did 3 tests between the 2 of us, and I would certainly support our child to learn to drive (and pass!) once he is old enough just because it will then be ticked off the to do list even if he then doesnt actually buy a car for 15+ years, which is what happened to a lot of our friends who passed as teenagers.

honeylulu · Today 12:28

Glad you've decided to go ahead with the lessons. I'm a huge fan of "getting it done asap" whether you have the current need to drive or not.

My friend is currently trying to learn to drive and it's really difficult and stressful juggling it with a full time job and kids. She hugely regrets not getting it out if the way before she had so many responsibilities and so little time. I learnt at 17-18, didn't drive much during uni years but almost straight after got offered a rurally located job and could just say "yes" bought myself a second hand car and cracked on!

loopsydo · Today 12:29

I passed as a teenager, but didn’t need a car until over a decade later. Buying a car and arranging a few refresher lessons when I needed it only took a few days. Learning to drive (and getting a test!) takes much longer. Better to learn as a teenager and bank the pass even if it’s not needed now.

wildnwilde · Today 12:32

It’s such a skill for life and a job it’s the one thing I did for my kids and bizarrely I don’t drive . It opens so many doors .

Swipe left for the next trending thread