Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fund DC driving lessons yet.

65 replies

toocooltobop · Today 11:41

I’d particularly like responses from London parents though welcome them from everyone far and wide.
DS is 17. In yr12 at 6th form.
We live in an area of London with excellent transport links. Until he leaves school, bus travel is free. Trains / tubes are half price.
He has a Uber account to use if absolutely necessary.
Our area is served by night buses and a 24hr tube line.
I think a couple of his friends are starting driving lessons soon. The vast majority aren’t. That will probably change next year once most are 17 but a significant number won’t be starting lessons even once they turn 17.

Our family car is an ancient 7 seater. We don’t have a drive. We have a parking permit and live in an area where driving is discouraged, partly by charging a lot of money for second etc parking permits.

DS does not have a part time job (tried but non around) so all money comes from us)

Hopefully that provides enough context 😊

DS, naturally, is really keen to learn to drive. We have said no for all the reasons above. It’s just not a necessity where we live. Him not being able to drive does not disadvantage him in any way at the moment.
To his credit, he’s accepted this, hasn’t badgered us about it or got moody about it.
I learnt to drive once I had funds for lessons, a car and insurance. I expect the same for him, though we will likely help him out.

But, I’ve been reading through the NEETS thread and it’s got me thinking. DS will most likely apply for apprenticeships (in who knows what) when he’s finished six form, alongside normal jobs. So, should we rethink the driving thing so he’d got another string to his bow, so to speak? He turns 18 at the start of yr13 so hopefully can pick up some bar work. Maybe we do it then so we can split the cost?

DH and I both admit we’re anxious about him driving because he’s got that teenager invincibility attitude about him! But he’s not an idiot, he’s actually a very lovely boy.

TLDR: AIBU to say no to funding lessons now or should we do it so he’ll gave a license ready for when he enters the world of work?

Thanks!

OP posts:
Coeliacsmum · Today 12:32

For employability if you can afford it, I would do now but just with a driving school. I passed at 18 before going to University and then didn't drive till getting a car years later. Still worth it.

Mableandable · Today 12:33

My DC are 21 and 23 and neither of them can drive. Both left for Uni at 18 approx 3 hrs away and use the train. DD now lives in Central London (zone 1) and currently has no need for a car. DS still at Uni. I wasn't overly keen on then learning to drive and then not having access to a car for years after. If however it would improve their employment outcomes of course it is a sensible idea.

Nofeckingway · Today 12:33

I too lived in a city that had excellent transport and many people didn't drive or own a car . But I moved . Found myself a mother of two that couldn't drive which really really restricted me. Double buggy uphill is no joke . I had to live in a place I didn't like in order to walk to work . I had the added expense then if having to learn and it wasn't something that happened quickly .
Both mine were bought lessons and learned to drive as soon as they could . My son did have an advantage going for jobs as he had a drivers licence. And we helped him get a car .
You won't regret it OP . I am sure he will be thrilled 😄

RaininSummer · Today 12:33

It's a good idea to learn though even if you don't get a car because its not needed yet .

tripleginandtonic · Today 12:34

Yabu. Driving is a necessity in life amd the earlier you learn to do it the better if he can drive in London traffic it will stand him in good stead.

toocooltobop · Today 12:35

Whatseatinggilbertsgrape · Today 12:19

No jobs around, in London? He's "tried" so not trying? Ha

You've got a shock coming if you think there will be more apprenticeships around than jobs.

Thanks for your helpful contribution. Sadly it’s where we’re at now, but the snippy comments make it so much better.

OP posts:
stressedoutmumtoday · Today 12:36

Whatseatinggilbertsgrape · Today 12:19

No jobs around, in London? He's "tried" so not trying? Ha

You've got a shock coming if you think there will be more apprenticeships around than jobs.

My son has same problem at 17 (outer London) places that were traditionally Saturday job sorts were happier to hire over 18s on zero hour contracts that didn't have any commitments for studying that meant they would dictate the rota more easily. There was even some investigative journalism about the area around the number of working visas being granted for shop work. It got slightly easier over 18 when legal situation around employment law relaxed but not much, I notice a real difference heading out of London with shop window type signs for part time roles there way they were in my childhood.

Apprenticeships are highly sought after so I think a license will help and it takes ages now to get a test booking

Goodmorningeveryone26 · Today 12:38

I have boys and live in London and will not be paying for them to learn to drive at 17. It’s just not necessary and going male drivers are vastly more likely to be involved in accidents

mamaof4losingmymind · Today 12:39

I had to pay for my own lessons, car and insurance started working at 16 and I always thought I would expect the same from my kids but its such a different time. When i was 16 there was loads off shop work, factory work for 16 year olds. Its just not like that now

Decisionfatiguemum · Today 12:39

Circumstances change quickly at that age. I lived in London age 19 to 35 so didn't learn to drive, and though offered lessons at 17 in the northern city I grew up in (so driving a useful tool!) I was fine getting buses to and from college/school. Lived in London in a very well connected area so didn't need to drive, moved rurally at 35 and had to learn. It took 4 months so not ages, but if you see a job, you can't wait 4 months to apply if it requires driving. Tool him up with the skill now and he's got that ticked off the list for apprenticeships and future work.

keepmeright · Today 12:40

I saw your update and agree driving is a life skill to be gained. Once you have it, it's for life, so might as well do it now 🙂

Iocanepowder · Today 12:43

Whatseatinggilbertsgrape · Today 12:19

No jobs around, in London? He's "tried" so not trying? Ha

You've got a shock coming if you think there will be more apprenticeships around than jobs.

I get your point about potentially an increased chance in London, but I wouldn’t deny is it more difficult these days to find part time work to fit in with full time education.

Pretty sure I read an article in BBC news yesterday about ‘the Saturday job’ no longer being a thing.

Iocanepowder · Today 12:45

Op i would agree with your change of heart to help him with driving lessons now.

I didn’t learn to drive until just after uni and it did impact my ability to get a job.

And yes you live in London, but my impression is that companies are now often choosing to move out of London to lower operating costs. So it is good for your DS to have options for him to remain flexible.

ilovepixie · Today 12:45

Driving is a life skill needed for many jobs. If you can afford it I would get him lessons.

WrylyAmused · Today 12:46

Glad you changed your mind and will get him lessons.

As you say, he doesn't necessarily need a car, but having his license is really important as a life skill as it takes time and can shut him out of opportunities if he needs to take that time to get it, plus his insurance costs will decrease purely by him having held his license for a while, rather than being a new driver, when he comes to insure his own car.

5foot5 · Today 12:46

Our DD didn't really want to start driving at 17 but had changed her mind by 18. We found a driving school that had a special price if you booked a package of ten lessons so bought her that for her 18th birthday present. She did eventually need quite a few more than ten before she passed, which we also paid for.

If you can find something similar could that be his Christmas present?

HScully · Today 12:49

For most driving opens up more opportunities than university. No good going to uni if you cant get to your job.

I work on an industrial estate on the edge of a reasonably large town. Public transport is not great, if we have 2 equal candidates in all other ways, wrongly or rightly the one with the licence would get the job.

TheHouseofBamboo · Today 12:56

I haven't voted because I think you have a point. However I also think driving is an incredibly useful skill for both life and CV.
17 is a perfect window of opportunity before they head off to uni. It's much harder once they are away from home.
My situation is different because we are rural. Every single one of my DCs peers learnt to drive at 17 because there's no public transport. It meant they could take up part time jobs with anti social hours and could have independence.
Friends who grew up in cities and didn't learn found it harder to do in their 20s or later.

As to the fear of your DS behind a wheel. It's terrifying, a taste of the old chestnut that you never stop worrying about your children. Just make sure they get tons of practice and don't give lifts to friends. It's not always the driver who causes accidents it can be the reckless giddy drunken friend.

Elianaye · Today 13:00

We're in London and we'll be paying for DDs to start lessons as soon as they are old enough. I'm not worried about them being in an accident as a teenager as they likely won't get a car for ages (we are in zone 2 and don't even have one). But statistically it's been shown that people tend to need fewer lessons the younger they are, and it's hard fitting in lessons once you have to fit it around work and other commitments. And prices only go up, and the test will have more demands added to it, so if you are going to get a licence anyway it's just easier to get it done and out of the way.

Realistically I don't think it will have much impact on employment prospects from where we are in London (almost nobody we know drives to work, and lots of well-paid adult friends choose not to drive). We are central enough that we can walk to zone 1.

purplemunkey · Today 13:02

Glad to see you’ve decided to go for it. I grew up in London and wasn’t bothered about learning to drive. I had some lessons but stopped for A levels and didn’t pick it up again.

It wasn’t really an issue for a long time - maybe a mild inconvenience coming home from Uni, lugging stuff back on the train, but nothing major. It was only later in life as I started to move further into the suburbs that I realised a car would be helpful and then definitely became a pain once I had DD. I finally got my licence in my late 30s and I can’t tell you how much I wish I’d done it as a late teen. I drive now, but have a lot of anxiety around it which I don’t think I’d have if I’d learned much earlier. My DD is learning at 17 for sure.

NewYearVibes · Today 13:04

I have read that thread. I don't think it applies to London. I have not lived there but when visiting public transport appear to be everywhere. Even if he has a car, can he park it where you live?

I live in Hampshire and it is absolutely necessary to get a car to find work. I can't imagine where DCs can work without a car. But on the other hand, I have a drive that fits two cars and so do most of my neighbours. (Some even three). There are plenty of spaces for DCs cars to park on the street.

ohhelloyou1 · Today 13:04

100% get the lessons and test out of the way. As you and others have said just passing his test doesn’t mean he immediately needs a car. Just getting theory and the test booked in is a mission at the moment so get that all done now 🙂

NewYearVibes · Today 13:07

@purplemunkey I don't think the anxiety changes because you didn't learn young. My mum got a drivers license young but never really driven. She only drove when we lived in New Zealand. She's always very anxious because of it. I think maybe you need a lot of hours behind the wheels when young to feel very natural with it. I got my license at 15 and I drove daily when I was in Auckland, both to school and then to university. I only stopped driving for a few years when I moved to the UK.

BakedAl · Today 13:09

I grew up and went to uni in areas that didnt need public transport. As soon as I got a job though I needed a car so I was glad my parents had paid for lessons at 17. We are doing the same for our ds17.

Nottogetapenny · Today 13:46

My grandson has just turned 17! He had his first driving lesson on his birthday. We gave him money, for some of his lessons and his parents are paying for however many he will need.
It is such a big expense! The lessons are £40.
But like others have said, it’s a good thing to do.