Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does it really make sense to have "work" be a concept anymore?

51 replies

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:21

So AI and technology generally are drastically reducing opportunities for employment. Not everyone can "learn a trade" or "start a business".

Over on the other side, people are working 40+ hours a week and missing out on time with family, personal development etc.

Looking ahead, this is only going to get worse with even better AI and robotics.
Do we need to massively overhaul the system and maybe stop thinking in terms of "jobs" and "wages"?

OP posts:
migraineosaurus · Yesterday 23:23

What’s your alternative?

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:25

migraineosaurus · Yesterday 23:23

What’s your alternative?

There are no more companies or jobs. Every single person is given 5k a month and in exchange they have to put in 10 hours in the community.

OP posts:
StormKevin · Yesterday 23:26

Please can this thread be deleted for abject stupidity, or at least be taken in a more realistic direction.

Needmorelego · Yesterday 23:27

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:25

There are no more companies or jobs. Every single person is given 5k a month and in exchange they have to put in 10 hours in the community.

This sounds like a plot of dystopian novel.
Those never go well.....

Dragonscaledaisy · Yesterday 23:28

Needmorelego · Yesterday 23:27

This sounds like a plot of dystopian novel.
Those never go well.....

These types of threads are highly entertaining though.

Needmorelego · Yesterday 23:30

Dragonscaledaisy · Yesterday 23:28

These types of threads are highly entertaining though.

I meant the plot of the novel 😂
Always ends up with the characters realising their perfect world isn't what it seems and they have to escape or start a revolution.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Yesterday 23:33

If robots or AI agents are taxed then yes that could be redistributed as a state payment.

There are questions around how society works with fewer workers.

pickywatermelon · Yesterday 23:34

I don’t know where to start 😆

Perhaps we could start with where does food come from?

Who is paying for what the robots and AI produce to be able for them to be taxed?

(I won’t touch the source of the 5K yet)

upskilledotter · Yesterday 23:35

it seems like a reasonable question to me and I’m neither dystopian or a bot - I think the question deserves some thought at least.

Personally I think things may come full circle from pre-industrialisation- a post-industrial and post- consumerist world view

Not saying I agree with either but do think change is inevitable in next 100 years

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:37

pickywatermelon · Yesterday 23:34

I don’t know where to start 😆

Perhaps we could start with where does food come from?

Who is paying for what the robots and AI produce to be able for them to be taxed?

(I won’t touch the source of the 5K yet)

Edited

The food comes from farms. You can work on the farms as part of your 10 hours a week. The farms are owned by the state

OP posts:
unsync · Yesterday 23:41

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:37

The food comes from farms. You can work on the farms as part of your 10 hours a week. The farms are owned by the state

Yes because that worked really well in the USSR and PRC under Mao.

pickywatermelon · Yesterday 23:41

State farms …

Right. Methinks someone is having some fun here.

Enjoy the discussion (!)

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:43

Just because a system didn't work out before doesn't mean we cant use the idea to create a hybrid model

OP posts:
Dragonscaledaisy · Yesterday 23:45

Needmorelego · Yesterday 23:30

I meant the plot of the novel 😂
Always ends up with the characters realising their perfect world isn't what it seems and they have to escape or start a revolution.

Oh - my misunderstanding. It is late. 😂

Needmorelego · Yesterday 23:46

@Lightmare what happens if you don't do your 10 hours?
Do you just lose the money or are you punished in other ways?
£5000 is quite a lot. A couple could live together and not need two lots of £5000 so one could just not bother.
Will all housing be state owned and you have to pay rent out of your £5000?

JLou08 · Yesterday 23:46

Maybe people will have to stop working 40+ hours a week to make more jobs for other people. I think it would have a very positive impact on people's health, especially parents who are working FT and raising children, so effectively 2 full time jobs.

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:48

JLou08 · Yesterday 23:46

Maybe people will have to stop working 40+ hours a week to make more jobs for other people. I think it would have a very positive impact on people's health, especially parents who are working FT and raising children, so effectively 2 full time jobs.

We could start with this actually yeah.
Does it really make sense to have one person doing 40 hours anymore? Who decided that should be the working week and why dont we make 20 hours the legal limit

OP posts:
Anarchy99 · Yesterday 23:49

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:25

There are no more companies or jobs. Every single person is given 5k a month and in exchange they have to put in 10 hours in the community.

And where does the money come from to pay that? Will we have to pay some for healthcare etc? Will people pay for their children to be educated? What would be the point if so?

How will the future be financed? The whole world would have to join in, presumably, otherwise it would just be the people in the UK sitting on their arses whilst their brains rot.

Plus forcing people into community work wouldn’t be reasonable as there would still be people who won’t or can’t do it.

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 23:51

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:48

We could start with this actually yeah.
Does it really make sense to have one person doing 40 hours anymore? Who decided that should be the working week and why dont we make 20 hours the legal limit

Because some of us have a strong work ethic and/or don’t have children.
Again, how would this be paid for? Cutting productive hours in half means either two people doing one job (not ideal) or half the work being done.

Is this one of those ‘think of the maddest economic model’ things?

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:52

Needmorelego · Yesterday 23:46

@Lightmare what happens if you don't do your 10 hours?
Do you just lose the money or are you punished in other ways?
£5000 is quite a lot. A couple could live together and not need two lots of £5000 so one could just not bother.
Will all housing be state owned and you have to pay rent out of your £5000?

I think losing the money is enough punishment.
In terms of rent, there should be a strict formula that sets the amount of rent due aka landlords cant pick a random rent amount to charge. A 2 bed house = £X a month end of story. Location would have no bearing on price so whether you're in a big city or small village, housing costs the same.

OP posts:
EmeraldRoulette · Yesterday 23:52

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:43

Just because a system didn't work out before doesn't mean we cant use the idea to create a hybrid model

Always open to new ideas

How is the 5K being funded?

I would love 5K a month, thanks

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:54

Anarchy99 · Yesterday 23:51

Because some of us have a strong work ethic and/or don’t have children.
Again, how would this be paid for? Cutting productive hours in half means either two people doing one job (not ideal) or half the work being done.

Is this one of those ‘think of the maddest economic model’ things?

I dont have children :-S doesnt mean i want to work 40 hours a week.
Im glad you have a strong work ethic but wouldnt you like to channel that into eg making art or making people in your community feel safe and happy, for example?
Would working 10 hours a week instead of 40 make you feel like you were wasting your work ethic or something? Are you worried you would feel bad aboit yourself if you werent working?

OP posts:
11plusherewego · Yesterday 23:56

Over on the other side, people are working 40+ hours a week and missing out on time with family, personal development etc

What personal development exactly are people missing out on?

Needmorelego · Yesterday 23:59

£5000 is a lot though (would be nice to have....).
What would we be spending it on?
If people are only required to "volunteer" 10 hours a week who is running the leisure activities?

Anarchy99 · Today 00:00

JLou08 · Yesterday 23:46

Maybe people will have to stop working 40+ hours a week to make more jobs for other people. I think it would have a very positive impact on people's health, especially parents who are working FT and raising children, so effectively 2 full time jobs.

So we would all have to give up something which is important to a lot of people just so someone else can do the job as well?

And what about the people whose health would be negatively affected?

We should be trying to stay relevant, yet there are threads on here about having more annual leave, saying that three instances of sick leave per year is hardly anything and now this one.

If you don’t want to work and can finance yourself, give it up. if you don’t want to work but need the money, suck it up.

There are people all over the world trying to stay relevant against the threat of AI etc and yet people on here don’t want jobs but want to sit on their backsides and be paid a standard monthly amount from a magic fund that will continue to fund health and education and pay everyone, despite the entire country being unproductive.

Actually - that’s a point. What about medical staff? Shop staff? (Although of course we would run out of goods in any case). Electricians? Plumbers? What happens without them?