Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does it really make sense to have "work" be a concept anymore?

51 replies

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:21

So AI and technology generally are drastically reducing opportunities for employment. Not everyone can "learn a trade" or "start a business".

Over on the other side, people are working 40+ hours a week and missing out on time with family, personal development etc.

Looking ahead, this is only going to get worse with even better AI and robotics.
Do we need to massively overhaul the system and maybe stop thinking in terms of "jobs" and "wages"?

OP posts:
Anarchy99 · Today 00:02

Needmorelego · Yesterday 23:59

£5000 is a lot though (would be nice to have....).
What would we be spending it on?
If people are only required to "volunteer" 10 hours a week who is running the leisure activities?

And who looks after them when they are ill and need medical care/pharmacy etc?

And how would the £5k person be obtained? What would people spend it on? And how?

No wonder we have a problem with youth unemployment if kids are being brought up with zero work ethic

Needmorelego · Today 00:04

Anarchy99 · Today 00:02

And who looks after them when they are ill and need medical care/pharmacy etc?

And how would the £5k person be obtained? What would people spend it on? And how?

No wonder we have a problem with youth unemployment if kids are being brought up with zero work ethic

Indeed 🤔

LooksLikeImStuckHere · Today 00:09

5k for 10 hours? Bloody hell, I’m in.

Some work more than 40 hours in jobs that do support the community - teaching, nursing, caring, shop work, refuse, social workers etc. If we only have to do 10 hours work, who will do all that? For example, primary school children would have up to 4 teachers a week.

Anarchy99 · Today 00:18

LooksLikeImStuckHere · Today 00:09

5k for 10 hours? Bloody hell, I’m in.

Some work more than 40 hours in jobs that do support the community - teaching, nursing, caring, shop work, refuse, social workers etc. If we only have to do 10 hours work, who will do all that? For example, primary school children would have up to 4 teachers a week.

And who would pay for the education? And what would be the point of education if all people are going to do is sit on their arses?

I mean, there’s blue sky thinking and utterly batshit!

why do people think it could work and why would anyone want to do this?

Give up your jobs if you are that unhappy. You can opt out of the rat race if you choose to do so. Of course if you want to opt out, you shouldn’t be given money that others are working to earn but that’s okay, right?

Boreded · Today 00:18

StormKevin · Yesterday 23:26

Please can this thread be deleted for abject stupidity, or at least be taken in a more realistic direction.

This!

OrangeBlouse · Today 00:20

it seems like a reasonable question to me and I’m neither dystopian or a bot - I think the question deserves some thought at least.

I thought about it and it’s stupid.

BMW6 · Today 00:28

Who decides where a person lives?
Who decides what work a person does?
Why 5k pm? Based on what?
Who decides on who decides?
How is it maintained/enforced?
What happens to a person who can't work?
What happens to a person who won't work?
Who decides on these rules?

EverybodyLTB · Today 00:30

Where’s the £5k coming from and what’s it getting spent on if everything is state owned? How are we getting the good shit from places like China and Europe, are all the countries of the world doing this? Do we trade in and out? Where is the money coming from to buy out Dyson and The Crown Estate and all of them, to get their land back to the state. How does the state gather up enough funds to compensate them when they don’t have money after Covid and Brexit to do the bins or run A&Es well? How does anyone decide if person A or B can or cannot do the 10 hours. What happens if you do more or less, can the hours be stacked or transferred? What happens when whoever refuses to comply, that isn’t a little bit like the Russian revolution? When the RSPB says we’re not having their wetlands, or the NT says we, the people, can’t turn Beatrix Potter’s house into a gulag, what do we do to make them? I’m fascinated!

ThePeppyOpalScroller · Today 00:31

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:48

We could start with this actually yeah.
Does it really make sense to have one person doing 40 hours anymore? Who decided that should be the working week and why dont we make 20 hours the legal limit

Henry Ford. He decided his workers needed to work enough hours to earn enough to buy his cars, and they also needed enough leisure time to justify buying one of his cars. Sunday was always for prayer so he gave his workers Saturday to drive his cars.

And if you decouple work from money, very bad things happen. Very quickly. Nobody is going to be volunteering to work on state farms for 10 hours a week. There are some jobs that are essential to keep the power grid working and shit flushing away in our toilets. If someone can have an affluent lifestyle by working 10 hours a week on a farm, how much are you going to pay a plumber to unblock a toilet, when he can have a great life on the farm instead?

Unless the 10 hours on the farm just gets you a wooden bench in a workers shed. But then the plumber must be paid a lot more. So who pays the plumber? If most people are just getting rations for 10 hours on a farm, nobody can afford to buy anything the farm produces. So the farm goes broke. So there isn't a farm left to work 10 hours in.

OonaStubbs · Today 00:33

It would be an absolute dystopia.

Funkyfoxy · Today 00:34

It's definitely heading that way OP. Banks, post offices, so much is becoming obsolete pretty sharply now and the rise of AI, self service.. jobs will have to change somehow. The future is interesting and it's fair to wonder how it will go

Anarchy99 · Today 00:36

The human race may as well die out in that situation.

OonaStubbs · Today 00:42

What would be the point of living if there was no jobs? How would you stop people turning to drugs and other self-destructive behaviour? How do you manage a population of people that have never worked in a productive sense, have never known anyone who has ever worked and have no cultural memory of having done so? What happens if the economy collapses and suddenly you have millions of people unable to cope because they have never had to fend for themselves but have subsisted sucking from the proverbial governmental teat?

It would be an absolute nightmare world. Like Mad Max but a thousand times worse.

BMW6 · Today 00:42

I vote for OP shovelling shit in sewer works for her 5k pm, while I do some Art to enrich her soul for the same salary

All.in favour say Aye

Anarchy99 · Today 00:45

BMW6 · Today 00:42

I vote for OP shovelling shit in sewer works for her 5k pm, while I do some Art to enrich her soul for the same salary

All.in favour say Aye

Aye

PollyBell · Today 00:47

Ok so when people need an operation, want to use their kettle, buy food, send their kids to school who does all this or related jobs for them while they sit at home posting threads about 'why dont we all just move to Benidorm and let everyone else do jobs around us'

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · Today 01:07

Jobs have always changed. Little call for flint knappers these days, or carders, bodgers, or threshers. And when people were doing those as common forms of work there was a definite lack of coders, nail artists, forensic lab technicians and satellite engineers. People adapt.

The working week has been trending gradually downwards since the Industrial Revolution. From 6 days a week to 5 and half, and then to 5. From 14-hour days to 10 hours, then 8.

There's no magical reason to stop at the current 37-40 hours a week as the standard for what counts as full time. Various trials of 4-day weeks have been going on over recent years, mainly successful. So it's not a stretch to think 4 and a half or 4 days might become the norm in the not-too-distant future, with 30 to 35 hours counting as full time rather than part time. It's unlikely to collapse society and I'm sure most people will find a way to fill the extra 5 hours or so a week.

Ten hours of random volunteering, though, is unlikely to be practical for a very long time. If ever.

LoveItaly · Today 01:10

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:48

We could start with this actually yeah.
Does it really make sense to have one person doing 40 hours anymore? Who decided that should be the working week and why dont we make 20 hours the legal limit

Good luck getting an operation if surgeons only have to do twenty hours a week, for example, or flying anywhere if pilots and cabin crew had done enough for the week going to San Francisco and back.

suki1964 · Today 01:11

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:25

There are no more companies or jobs. Every single person is given 5k a month and in exchange they have to put in 10 hours in the community.

5k a month?

Where's that money coming from?

Im waiting my pension, one that I have fully paid since I left school at 15 . and that will be in todays figures is just over a grand a month

PollyBell · Today 01:14

LoveItaly · Today 01:10

Good luck getting an operation if surgeons only have to do twenty hours a week, for example, or flying anywhere if pilots and cabin crew had done enough for the week going to San Francisco and back.

Maybe they can all work from home like refuse collectors and public toilet cleaners

LoveItaly · Today 01:16

PollyBell · Today 01:14

Maybe they can all work from home like refuse collectors and public toilet cleaners

Good point, I’d not thought of that 😀

Isittimeformynapyet · Today 01:19

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:52

I think losing the money is enough punishment.
In terms of rent, there should be a strict formula that sets the amount of rent due aka landlords cant pick a random rent amount to charge. A 2 bed house = £X a month end of story. Location would have no bearing on price so whether you're in a big city or small village, housing costs the same.

Great. Can I have one of the lovely posh houses with lots of character and no damp please.

Eta. In a nice green area with easy access to a vibrant city with a low crime rate.

LoveItaly · Today 01:31

unsync · Yesterday 23:41

Yes because that worked really well in the USSR and PRC under Mao.

The horrors of what happened under Stalin and Mao are not talked about enough, and should be an important part of history lessons in all schools. How quickly, too, the terrible impact of communism on Eastern European countries has been forgotten, Hungary only became free of it in 1989.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · Today 01:34

Lightmare · Yesterday 23:37

The food comes from farms. You can work on the farms as part of your 10 hours a week. The farms are owned by the state

Some people have absolutely no idea about history, do they?

State owned farms 🤦‍♀️

BooneyBeautiful · Today 01:36

Universal Basic Income has been suggested as the alternative. Once you reach the age of 18, you are given a set amount of money to live on. This also saves money on civil servants processing hundreds of claims. Anything you earn over that set amount is taxed. You also get plenty of spare time to maybe start your own business or do caring commitments. So many people these days are trying to hold down a full-time job whilst also caring for a family member.